5 ms·
Dear Microsoft, As a vocal critic of the Linux Desktop, your horrifically misguided attempts to "improve" Windows since Windows 10 have so degraded the experie
by AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y ago
Dear Microsoft,
As a vocal critic of the Linux Desktop, your horrifically misguided attempts to "improve" Windows since Windows 10 have so degraded the experience of using it that I am now only 2 reasons[0] away from switching anyway, so at least I don't have to pay for the privilege of using crappy software.
I would ask you kindly to cease your endeavors to kill off the Windows Desktop and personal computing in general, but having dealt with you I know that it is your policy to ignore user feedback.
[0] 1. I hate package managers as an application installation paradigm, and 2. GPU drivers still perform worse for my card, if you must know.
- craftyguy 8y ago> GPU drivers still perform worse for my card Which GPU?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agonVidia GTX 1080ti In addition to the performance degradation, nVidia and the kernel maintainers don't currently get along so I'd also have to deal with that.
- craftyguy 8y agoAh, yes. nvidia is a thorn. In other news, the AMD and Intel drivers are as good as, if not better, than their windows counterparts!
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoShame their hardware isn't as good. Especially Intel's.
- Karunamon 8y agoLegitimately asking; does AMD still do that thing where they unceremoniously drop support for an older card on newer kernels - so you do a apt-get upgrade at some point and reboot to a black screen, and your options are either never upgrade your kernel or get a new GPU?
- wbond 8y agoThis, unfortunately is not as true as I wish it was. I bought an RX 560 and tried to install Ubuntu 18.04. It could not propery drive my 4k display that uses DP 1.2 MST. That display has been working fine with a few different cards on Mac and Windows since 2014 when I bought it. I even tried the AMD pro drivers. Granted, the open source nvidia drivers couldn’t do it with a 1030 on 18.04 either, but the proprietary ones had no issue. edit: I should note, the RX 560 runs fanless up to 60c on Windows, but the fans always spin on Linux.
- craftyguy 8y agoI have no problems running my RX 580 with the amdgpu driver and recent versions of Mesa.. If I had to guess, Ubuntu 18.04 has some archaic versions of both the kernel and userspace drivers.
- wbond 8y agoDo you have a 4K display that requires DP 1.2 MST? I tried the latest proprietary amdgpu-pro drivers also. I even bought the RX 560 because some other Linux users assured me the AMD Linux drivers were excellent. My post here is to help other people so they can make a more informed choice in the future.
- mjevans 8y agoIt seems that support existed in KDE/Plasma workspaces in late 2014. https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=MTg2NTY https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=MTg2NTY Though if you follow the DP MST keyword there's still some corner cases being polished... https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=search&q=DP%20MST https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=search&q=DP%20MST https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=DRM-Misc-Next-4.21-1 https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=DRM-Misc... The Mesa drivers Ubuntu (and Debian, and many other distros) provide CAN be rather old. As you mentioned Ubuntu, follow the directions here to have a stack that's as updated as possible. https://github.com/ValveSoftware/Proton/wiki/Requirements https://github.com/ValveSoftware/Proton/wiki/Requirements I also tend to like checking Arhc Linux support page, but it doesn't seem to be helpful for this issue: https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Radeon https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Radeon
- jcelerier 8y ago> 1. I hate package managers as an application installation paradigm wat so you prefer go to vlc.com for vlc, 7-zip.com for 7-zip, update them by hand or add custom system services constantly running for every program to install themselves, etc etc instead of a `pacman -S 7z vlc krita libreoffice [every other software you need]`
- wvenable 8y agoIn open source world, this is fine. In the closed source world, this is one step closer towards walled garden. Just the other day, I could not install something because my Windows 10 was set to "install only from store" and I had go in and turn that off. How long before that's no longer even an option?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoYes. I like having software that is up to date and delivered direct from the developer. I like having portable applications that don't even need installation. I like being able to put applications on different disks. I like being able to have multiple versions of an application. There is not a single package manager in existence for Linux that gives me these things.
- pritambaral 8y agoSounds like AppImages would satisfy all your requirements.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoYeah, they do actually. I really like AppImage, it's a shame they aren't really embraced at all by the community. Good luck getting them to show up with icons in your file manager (even Nitrux, which supposedly embraces AppImages, can't seem to do it).
- rkeene2 8y agoAppFS is a package manager for Linux that exists and solves all these problems, except the "putting them on different disks", which it doesn't prevent you from doing but it doesn't really make any sense either. http://appfs.rkeene.org/ http://appfs.rkeene.org/
- ashrk 8y agoRe: [0], what about them do you hate? For my part, I've discovered since switching to Mac that I don't like having system packages managed alongside user packages. It's one thing when I'm all-in on handling everything from the kernel up (it was fine back when I used Gentoo, for example) but the middle ground of massive meta-packages and such mingled with user-installed individual packages on e.g. Ubuntu is a train wreck. MacOS w/ homebrew's great. I can delete the entire directory with my brew installed crap in it and the system's unaffected. System upgrades are separate from my stuff. That plus the occasional drag+drop installed program cover my needs nicely, and better than everything's-a-bespoke-GUI-installer on Windows.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoLots of things. They're basically the same walled garden you get from Apple, Google, or Microsoft, only with a different gardener. They're also ludicrously inflexible in that they don't allow multiple versions of the same application to be installed, install applications to different disks, or often even get timely updates when a developer makes a change. I agree that "installers" are not a good paradigm either, but a lot of Windows software can be had in portable (or at least non-installer) form.
- inetknght 8y ago> They're also ludicrously inflexible in that they don't allow multiple versions of the same application to be installed They actually do allow multiple versions of the same application to be installed. It's just difficult to get it to work. The package itself will install to (for example) /usr/bin. A new version of the package will have the same file names, so they get overwritten. Most well-built packages will allow you to override the installation path though. This is perfect in case you want to install to your home directory (instead of globally) or some versioned directory. For example you can relocate RPM installations given an example.rpm file: rpm -i --relocate=/=/home/myuser example.rpm
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but won't all of the dependencies also need to be installed to the same prefix? So I could end up with half the OS on there for one application?
- forrest92 8y ago> As a vocal critic of the Linux Desktop well, go on then, elaborate...
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoToo off topic for this thread, also past experience has shown that all that will happen is a bunch of evangelists will come out of the woodwork to tell me variations of: you're using the wrong distro, you're using the wrong hardware, or your workflow is wrong and you should change how you do things.
- ashrk 8y agoNot the OP but my most recent attempt to ditch Windows on my gaming desktop ~6 months ago was tripped up when I discovered that core software like file managers and such still crash or wig out constantly (it's always been that way, I simply used to put up with stuff like that, just hoped that had changed since I'd been away) and generally basic interactions (e.g. drag & drop) are still inconsistent and buggy. This on Ubuntu which is allegedly relatively polished. Tried KDE and Gnome both (Gnome's performance was also terrible, incidentally). And all of it looked pretty bad. I'm a fan of (though not insistent upon using) "ugly" old school interfaces, so it's not that it wasn't "flat" or "beautiful" enough or whatever the current trend is, just lacking consistency and the result of a whole bunch of small, poorly-chosen defaults adding up to a big stew of gross. I could overlook that if it weren't also crash-prone and janky as hell, but it is. So I'm still stuck on Mac for anything serious, and my gaming desktop sits in storage because I can't be bothered these days to screw with either Windows post-10 or Linux. Sigh. FWIW my favorite desktop I've ever used, as far as core software, stability, desktop UI/X, compared to its contemporaries, was BeOS.
- russdpale 8y agoIf you want to love windows again, find the Eurpean LTSB version, it is incredible. No app store, no cortana, none of that shit. As for linux, I went through a bunch until I found my love for fedora. It still requires some tinkering, but for the most part everything works.
- 8y ago
- howard941 8y agoConsider FreeBSD and its ports model. You'll be building your own ports from sources but you needn't touch another package someone else built, if you don't want to.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoNo. I have no desire to have my primary means of installing software be to compile from source. That's retarded. Literally retarded, in that it is a backward concept from the before-times.
- howard941 8y agoAt some point aren't you going to have to choose between software requiring shared libraries and take the package-complexity or source build-hit, or have everything statically linked and take the program size hit?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoOnly if I insist on doing things the way UNIXs do, which is what is keeping me on Windows. If Linux had a stable and consistent base system that was comprised of the most commonly used libraries, then developers would only have to statically link or include their own copy of less common libraries. I'm totally ok with that. And let's be real for a minute, the program size hit is negligible. You can get a 1TB SSD for under $200. The largest part of almost any program that's in any way large are its assets, not its code.
- fredsanford 8y agoYou're wrong, tiresome and ignorant. Windows allows multiple instances of the same app to work via the WinSxS mechanism which keeps copies of basically every DLL ever installed, including system DLLs. So it is basically keeping duplicates of everything, regardless. This includes some executables as well. [1] Before WinSxS you could achieve the same effect by keeping copies of the DLL dependencies in the app directory beside the executable. Windows would then choose the DLLs from the app current directory before looking at system directories and the path. [2] Linux gives you the same choices and a couple more options. Work with the system package manager [1]. Link dynamically and keep copies of differing DLLs in a different prefix and... take a size hit. [2] Link statically and take a size hit. Link dynamically and build everything yourself, minimizing your dependencies. You can't do the last two with Windows, for the most part because you do not have source code. So, which of those options do you choose? You cannot have your cake and eat it too.
- ryan-c 8y agoWhy don't you like package managers?
- Wowfunhappy 8y ago> I hate package managers as an application installation paradigm Flatpak has you covered, or at least, it's getting there pretty fast. You'll still need to manage debs for base system stuff but you can install most gui apps as flatpaks now.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoIf only it did. For one, its absolutely a package manager. You need a special tool to manage flatpaks. Also, flatpak has a lot of problems in my opinion, not the least of which is that it has no mechanism for installing to a different disk without creating an entirely new "installation", which in its terminology means a completely new dependency chain too. The "portals" idea is a pretty good one though, on the whole.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoIt's still a package manager, and it still has dependencies, but the dependency chain is "flat" such that it's always comprehensible and you'll never be stuck modifying large parts of your system to update one program. I see it as similar to Windows's Visual C++ and DirectX runtimes in that regard. I hear you on installing to different disks, though. Appimages are also an option, but I've found they have a tendency to not actually work between different distros and system versions.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoUnfortunately that's a problem with they way Linux is structured, or rather it's lack of structure. There's no consistent base system that can be relied upon like you have with other platforms. The community seems unwilling to deal with this issue, some outright deny that it is an issue. One thing that would be interesting would be to use flatpak "runtimes" to provide a target base system for AppImages, but I don't think that level of cooperation is actually possible within the Linux community.
- Spivak 8y ago