3 ms·
It isn't delusion, because it could be true, it's just irrelevant. For all you know you're just a brain in a jar hooked up to simulated input, there's no way to
by AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y ago
It isn't delusion, because it could be true, it's just irrelevant. For all you know you're just a brain in a jar hooked up to simulated input, there's no way to prove otherwise. We have no choice but to accept that our senses provide us some approximation of reality.
- bluntfang 8y agoThat's all fine and dandy, but I think that, as a human cohabitating with other humans, we should do our best to look out for each other and try not to trigger people into psychotic states. When someone near you is experiencing an anxiety attack, it's not very helpful to tell them what they're experiencing shouldn't cause them anxiety.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sideshowb 8y agoUsername checks out, I wouldn't go into mental health work if I were you ;) Is it coincidence that some of the world's most famous philosophers went mad?
- dkersten 8y ago> Is it coincidence that some of the world's most famous philosophers went mad? Yes. Some of <insert anything> went mad, that doesn't prove causation at all.
- sideshowb 8y agoThere is of course a plausible mechanism involved though, which is one of the ways we deduce causation from correlation.
- rocqua 8y agoIf the brain in a vat gets perfectly simulated input, then indeed, there is no way to tell. Same thing if we live in a computer simulation. However, if such a surrounding simulation 'errors' that can be noticed. Moreover, there is the rather pressing issue of 'being turned off'. Its a difficult (semantic?) discussion of whether you can notice your world being deleted, but the thought of unpredictable all-encompassing extinction isn't quite comforting. A better reason not to care, is the idea that there is nothing you can do about it. However, if we are being simulated, there is probably some observer who might react to our actions. Moreover, if we are in a computer simulation we might be able to trigger some 'bug'. So even that line of reasoning isn't clear cut. In the end, life does seem to be easier when you accept reality. Even more so because any way we have to influence the 'outside' is so infeasible as to be useless.
- nradov 8y agoIn theory some extremely high energy particle physics experiments ought to be impossible to properly simulate, and so if those experiments produce anomalous data then that could expose a "glitch in the matrix".
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoHow would you determine the difference between anomalous data as a result of the simulation and anomalous data as an indication that your model of physics is simply incomplete? After all, you don't have data from a real reality to compare to.
- Filligree 8y agoIndeed, there's no guarantee that the real world follows the same laws of physics whatsoever. For all we know, it might allow hypercomputation.