17 ms·
Suicide increasing among American workers
- rhacker 8y agoYesterday we found out we're not having sex. Today we find out suicide is increasing. I wonder if the two are linked.
- dv_dt 8y agoYes, they're both driven by economic inequality and a nation built for profits over people.
- patrickaljord 8y agoSuicide rate is much higher in more socialist countries: http://worldpopulationreview.com/countries/suicide-rate-by-country/ http://worldpopulationreview.com/countries/suicide-rate-by-c... This includes France, Finland and Sweden is just right next to the US with much lower inequalities.
- tim333 8y agoYour linked list has socialist Venezuela at #148 with 3.7 suicides /100k and now capitalist Lithuania at #1 with 31.9 /100k so the link seems unproven.
- DanBC 8y agoIt's very difficult to compare suicide rates across countries. This is because they use different definitions. Your link doesn't say where they're getting their data and how they've fixed this problem.
- dv_dt 8y agoThere are multiple factors correlated with sucicide, but notable is that the US rate has increased 30% during a time of decrease in suicide rate of other nations: https://www.usnews.com/news/best-countries/articles/2018-07-02/why-are-suicide-rates-rising-in-the-us-while-falling-in-most-of-europe https://www.usnews.com/news/best-countries/articles/2018-07-... This one lists Belgium, Finland, France as higher rates than the US. But other research also notes differences in rates of various races, I guess whites commit suicide at a observerably higher rate too.
- patrickaljord 8y agoThis link of yours links suicide rate to social welfare spending, this is unlikely given that France, Finland and Belgium and specially Japan offer free healthcare and have much higher suicide rates. In fact, if you take out suicide by gun in the US, you get much lower suicide rates and it is a fact that guns make suicide easier and more likely.
- dv_dt 8y agoThe article hypothesizes suicide increases because of reduction in social welfare spending as well as social support. And notes some correlations, and calls for deeper study. Suicide by guns don't count because?
- patrickaljord 8y agoSuicide by guns counts, it just diminishes even more the inequality cause because if you take out suicide by guns then suicide rates are even much lower than in these other countries with less inequalities and free healthcare but no suicide by guns.
- dv_dt 8y agoI think that's a huge unknown assumption that if there were no gun, the victim would simply not commit suicide. There might be some dissuasion, but we have no way to gauge it - and pegging it at everyone in that group would be saved if only we took away guns seems like an assumption at one extreme end.
- sam0x17 8y agoNot to complicate things more, but social welfare spending != efficient social welfare spending, leading to more potentially contrary (in both directions) trends.
- diogenescynic 8y agoIt’s almost like there could be multiple contributing factors and there’s not a simple explanation.
- jahaja 8y agoHow much is hidden by the US drug epidemic?
- diogenescynic 8y agoAgree, while not exactly the same I’d add up overdoses and compare both groups.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- phkahler 8y agoI wonder if anyone knows how many opioid deaths are deliberate. The suicide rate could actually be much higher if this turns out to be a thing and is not included in the stats.
- tsumnia 8y agoMy biggest concern is are we following a similar trend to Japan (low sex rate, high suicide)? While I am no means an expert, the overall theme that I've seen describe the phenomena in Japan is that they have just "stopped caring" about all the social pressures. I wonder if Western culture is starting to have the same effect where the "rules of society" are just becoming so convoluted that people are "opting out". I'm looking at this more from the birth rate speculation, but not having a family to go home to at night and stressful work environments may have a connection.
- watwut 8y ago> I'm looking at this more from the birth rate speculation, but not having a family to go home to at night and stressful work environments may have a connection. There is. Having high stress competitive work prevents you to go to familly (because you are working overtime) and makes you loose it (whether formally or you just looses relationship). Conversely, having familly often prevents ones career and limits job opportunities. But, I don't think western rules are convoluted. It is more that economy sux and tends to be winner takes all.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoProbably, and I can make an educated guess how: modern society eschews the value of human relationships in favor of status and wealth seeking. People find they are not happy, so they search for a path to happiness and our culture tells them that it is through being wealthy, famous, and successful. They search for a path to those things and find that it often involves long hours, greed, and psychopathic behavior. Human relationships are a risk, and risks are to be minimized. They put this knowledge into practice and find that it doesn't work. My own theory of how depression works is that it involves an inescapable realization that your model of reality is broken and can't be used to make predictions that allow you to effect the change you want to see in your life. You wanted to be happy, society gave you a bad model to work from, and the mind's reaction to discovering that this model doesn't work is depression.
- plainOldText 8y agoA very insightful comment. I have no idea to what extent your hypotheses describe reality, but the elegance of your line of reasoning deems this path worthy of further investigation.
- rv-de 8y agoWhere does the sex come in?
- prawn 8y agoPart of (some) human relationships. Being ignored at the expense of working towards success or building a brand towards status.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoIt's worse than that, it's active avoidance of human relationships because they're a liability. Not just because they create dependencies but because in order to form connections we need to make ourselves vulnerable.
- DoreenMichele 8y ago
- monksy 8y agoI would imagine that it gets excerbated when people can't afford to have kids and are required to get a double income just to survive.
- draw_down 8y agoImmiserated people tend to have less sex and kill themselves more, so, sure.
- zanybear 8y agoThere is an interesting discussion on this topic in the last Sam Harris podcast, based on established connection between depression and suicide and the current political context in US. https://samharris.org/podcasts/142-addiction-depression-meaningful-life/ https://samharris.org/podcasts/142-addiction-depression-mean...
- hour_glass 8y agoHow are they making these categories of workers? > Farmers, Ranchers, and Other Occupational Managers category (a sub-group of the Management major group) > Agricultural Workers category (a sub-group of the Farming, Fishing, and Forestry major group) Farmers aren't in the Farming major group? I'd like to see a little more detail here
- Pete_D 8y agoThe full report (https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/67/wr/mm6745a1.htm?s_cid=mm6745a1_w https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/67/wr/mm6745a1.htm?s_cid=mm...) says they're using the Standard Occupational Classification system (https://www.bls.gov/soc/ https://www.bls.gov/soc/). You can read the full definitions at https://www.bls.gov/soc/2010/2010_major_groups.htm; https://www.bls.gov/soc/2010/2010_major_groups.htm; farm managers are at 11-9013, agricultural workers are under 45-2000. The distinction in this case seems to be whether or not someone working on a farm is mostly a manager or mostly a laborer.
- nperez 8y agoFarm workers are classified as agricultural workers. farm managers / owners are classified separately. There was a whole redacted study because of managers being accidentally lumped in with workers. https://newfoodeconomy.org/farmer-suicide-crisis-cdc-study/ https://newfoodeconomy.org/farmer-suicide-crisis-cdc-study/
- jrowley 8y agoQuick PSA: If you are contemplating suicide you should reach out to professionals for help. You are not alone in this struggle and deserve to be happy and live a fruitful life. What do you have to lose by talking with a professional?
- bananamuffin 8y agomoney
- izzydata 8y agoMoney seems irrelevant in this scenario, but there are plenty of free services that will assist you. I also doubt friends and family will charge you to talk to them.
- bradenb 8y agoI don't think it's irrelevant. Sure, you can get immediate free support, but long-term help is not cheap.
- NTDF9 8y agoThis. America is not a society where anything happens without money. In eastern countries, there are easy to go community centers like temples, churches, local social organizations, festivals etc., all for free. Just go in. There is always someone to reach out to. There are always welcoming people.
- olivermarks 8y agoThe Arts, Design, Entertainment, Sports, and Media group features for both men and women. I wonder if 'hustle culture' has anything to do with this... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18381605 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18381605 Separately this is a huge HR problem that just isn't addressed properly in the USA. If the suicides are due to work pressures that employer has a direct responsibility for that situation. Echoing what others have said here, if you are contemplating suicide talk to people about it. Don't suffer in isolation. Get out of your bubble of despair and try to see your life in perspective - get help that's what we are all here for, each other...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tathougies 8y agoLack of religion: https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/atheism-has-a-suicide-problem_us_5a2a902ee4b022ec613b812b https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/atheism-has-a-suicide-p...
- kasperni 8y agoSeriously, that article is a joke... You get three atheists in a room together and it won’t be long before there is some minor issue that divides them.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bvxvbxbxb 8y agoLet's not overlook the role of psychopathic / sociopathic women driving men to suicide purposefully, like my step-sister did to her first husband, simply because they enjoy it.
- glbrew 8y agoOn that note also the role of non psychopathic /sociopathic women driving men to suicide non-purposefully which I have seen too.
- b_tterc_p 8y agoThat story may be true, but even if it is, your belief that it is common enough to merit being a meaningful driver of increasing suicide rates is a heavy indication that your views are wildly off base.
- hellbanner 8y agoGee, I wonder if this has anything to do with the pay discrepancy between CEOs, investors and us wage slaves.
- jjoonathan 8y agoNah, can't be! A rising tide floats all boats, doncha know?
- Broken_Hippo 8y agoIf only the ones at the bottom didn't have holes...
- awakeasleep 8y agoThats not a hole, it's a shareholder value tunnel!
- tweezy 8y agoIt's times like these I wish I could afford a boat!
- tryptophan 8y agoDid I just walk into reddit by accident? Comments like this do not belong on HN.
- manfredo 8y agoInterestingly the states with the lowest suicide rates (Connecticut, Massachusetts, California, New York, and other relatively wealthy blue states) also have some of the highest income inequality [1]. Another counterintuitive thing about suicide in the US is that demographics that tend to earn less (e.g. young people, Blacks) tens to commit suicide at lower rates than wealthy demographics (Whites, Asians, older people). Pointing to income inequality as cause of a high suicide rate does not seem particularly convincing. 1. https://www.zippia.com/advice/states-highest-lowest-income-inequality/ https://www.zippia.com/advice/states-highest-lowest-income-i...
- millenialdev 8y agoWhoa, Men kill themselves many times more than women. I thought this number would be closer.
- twalla 8y agopersonal opinion alert: western society seems to preach that the inherent value of men is zero and all value comes from success and accomplishments whereas women are inherently valuable due to their ability to raise children. combine failure to meet the expectations levied upon them by society with a quaker/protestant belief system where all shortcomings boil down to "you didnt work hard enough" plus a culture where showing weakness or seeking help isn't believed to be a masculine trait and it becomes surprising that the discrepancy isn't greater.
- ericmcer 8y agoYeah this is my exact line of thinking. We are all trying to find meaning and purpose in life and the ability to give birth is inherently valuable. Men feel the need to create value through work/skill so if you fail totally in that area....
- hnmonkey 8y agoWhere is it preached in western society that the inherent value of men is zero? Men can raise children too and last I heard it usually takes a man to help create that child also.
- ericmcer 8y agoCreating 500 new humans takes 500 women and 1-2 men, most men are totally superfluous for procreation, thus us needing to define our value in other ways. Granted that isn't great for genetic diversity :(
- goldfeld 8y agoIt's simple, generally it's more common in men that they don't ask for help, don't reconcile with their own true feelings, don't allow for their own full self expression, don't hug, don't cry, don't share emotions with naked confidentiality, and macho culture preys on any signs of weakness, to their own detriment. This carries on to the kinds of hobbies, interests and all that puts men further away from a simple emotional comfort than women. It took me two decades before it didn't feel awkward hugging my brother in earnest, and I consider myself a very sensitive person, so take that for what you will. Maybe it just takes longer for boys to become emotionally mature men. It varies culturally a lot for men and women by city and country, of course.
- prawn 8y agoI know we're collectively no fans of anecdata but I get a strong feeling that attitudes to typical work are changing, that jobs are making more people miserable. I get asked a lot by people seeking to do something different; I guess they're bombarded by successful side hustle stories and never by "I love my 9-5 day job, it's so rewarding" stories.
- diogenescynic 8y ago>I know we're collectively no fans of anecdata but I get a strong feeling that attitudes to typical work are changing, that jobs are making more people miserable I tend to agree. My parents have completely different stories about their experiences with work 40 years ago. Much less stress, better pay, more mentorship, less competition, and lower demands generally. I’m sure part of that’s nostalgia, but nearly everyone I talk to seems to be miserable at their job anymore. There are rarely people who say they enjoy their job and want to do that exact thing until they retire.
- hopefulengineer 8y agoOlder family friend made $30/hr in the 60-70s with pension and benefits working in a meat packing plant with a high school education. Same job today pays $15/hr with no benefits thanks to illegal immigration. There's a reason people like the Koch brothers spend millions in support of illegal immigration, they wanted to drive down the labor cost for jobs like the above. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vf-k6qOfXz0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vf-k6qOfXz0 Offshoring and illegal immigration has killed low skill jobs and given billion dollar multinational corporations the ability to demand whatever they want from workers because they have unlimited labor supply. This doesn't just effect low skill labor either, it forces more people to go to college and take on debt which then drives down the wages of high skill work as well. It's a scam and the american people should be angry
- octonion 8y agoThe root cause is the destruction of unions and worker's rights. It has nothing to do with legal or illegal immigration.
- hollaur 8y agoThey should do a study on suicide among all workers who are forced to use Slack. #notkidding
- throwaway1116 8y agoThey should contact their local computer user protection services immediately! [1] [1] https://theasocial.github.io/articles/computing/slack.html https://theasocial.github.io/articles/computing/slack.html
- marmot777 8y agoI’d like to mention as someone who’s mother committed suicide when I was a young child that if you choose to take your life you’re harming your family and friends In ways they’ll never fully recover from. So I request people think about that before making a decision to go through with commmiting suicide.