7 ms·
The article doesn't seem to have any substance, it's just an article about one person's opinionated tweet. The team is joining DeepMind/Alphabet, and it appear
by crazygringo 8y ago
The article doesn't seem to have any substance, it's just an article about one person's opinionated tweet.
The team is joining DeepMind/Alphabet, and it appears DeepMind promised that health data would never be joined to your Google account.
And there's zero evidence that they are joined or that they would be joined. As far as I can tell, fearmongering like this would suggest that Alphabet couldn't ever deal with health care info, which feels silly... There are plenty of very strong laws enforcing health care privacy (e.g. HIPAA in the US), so this really just feels like FUD.
- AlexandrB 8y agoThe specific language was: > [data] "will never be linked or associated with Google accounts, products or services" Streams is plainly a Google product and is probably using deep learning models trained on this data. Morever, patients were never given the option to opt-out of this data collection at all.
- crazygringo 8y agoI can't tell what you're trying to say... What is trained on what data? The point is that health care data will never be linked to your "Google account", e.g. your Gmail/YouTube/etc. or other Google services -- AdSense can't show you ads based on a hospital visit. DeepMind is part of Alphabet, like Google is part of Alphabet. DeepMind can do its thing without ever touching Google accounts or Google data.
- mayankkaizen 8y ago"DeepMind can do its thing without ever touching Google accounts or Google data." May be it is the case at present. But I see zero probability that it will always be the case.
- je42 8y agoHealth products need to be designed with privacy as a core pillar. Just pumped everything to the cloud and then figuring out - was nice a couple of years ago. Thankfully the laws are catching up and hopefully companies like Google will not only start to comply with them but actually follow the underlying spirit of these laws.
- alehul 8y agoHow can you say zero probability? I understand a hyperbole, but let's make a fair estimate. Assuming hyperbole: why do you believe that, over time, there is a low probability "DeepMind can do its thing without ever touching Google accounts or Google data?" What factors will contribute to that?
- kodablah 8y ago>>> "will never be linked or associated with Google [...] products [...]" >> is [...] a Google product > I can't tell what you're trying to say... Surely it's clear...said it wouldn't be associated w/ Google products and became a Google product. You can bring up nuance or twist words or whatever, but it's clear that at the least they misled.
- andybak 8y ago> [data] "will never be linked or associated with Google accounts, products or services" was true at the time but surely what people care about is data flowing between the medical app and existing Google services? i.e. what the wording could be revised and still keep to the original intended meaning. Whether you think the company separation was critical to trust is a rather different question to whether they have broken the intent of their original promise. If you don't trust Google then you presumably also had suspicions about the previous arrangement.
- eiaoa 8y ago>> [data] "will never be linked or associated with Google accounts, products or services" > was true at the time but surely what people care about is data flowing between the medical app and existing Google services? I would think people would care about the data flowing to any Google service. An understanding that it only applied to existing services like you're claiming would be meaningless. A hyperbolic example of this is Google/Deepmind would still be compliant if they came out with a brand new service, Google Privacy Destroyer 1.0, that puts all these people's private health data up for sale on the dark web.
- andybak 8y agoI didn't mean that. At the time the medical company was separate from Google. Therefore the statement was intended to communicate the key point - we're not using your data for other stuff. This is the spirit of the declaration and the part that we should probably care most about. The statement unfortunately has a secondary implied promise which Google has broken. But my point is that if we don't trust Google to keep the data separate then the initial promise was meaningless. And if we do then not much has changed. If Google wanted to do bad things then they would have kept the companies separate to keep their promise superficially. The wording was poorly thought out but unless you think the reorganisation is going to materially change Google's behaviour then I don't see it as hugely significant.
- PunchTornado 8y ago> [data] "will never be linked or associated with Google accounts, products or services" it doesn't say your google account or product. it is in general google products. It seems to me that they are breaking this promise.
- danShumway 8y agoThe problem is, even if Google is following the spirit of the policy, how do we know whatever policy they introduce now won't be changed in the future? So the new promise is "Patient data remains under our NHS partners' strict control, and all decisions about its use will continue to lie with them." Except I can think of at least two or three good reasons off the top of my head why Google could renege on that without breaking the spirit of their promise too. Maybe Google decides that the information will be more secure on their servers, and the original point was to make it more secure anyway, right? Yes, Google's original promise was kinda arbitrary and over-strict. But the way you build trust is you keep promises, even if they're arbitrary. When Google says they're not going to do something, they should not do it. Otherwise, nobody will trust them in the future when they say they're not going to do other things. Nobody wants to live in a world where we have to second guess what the intent is behind everything a company promises and are only able to hold them to that. If Google can't keep its promises, then it shouldn't have made any promises in the first place. It should have just given a milk-toast answer like, "we care about privacy", which would have communicated exactly the same information without deceiving customers into thinking that there was an actual line in the sand somewhere.
- Loughla 8y ago>Nobody wants to live in a world where we have to second guess what the intent is behind everything a company promises and are only able to hold them to that. How is this not the world we already live in? Every agreement, obligation, promise, or contract I've read from my major tech 'partners' professionally and personally has had a clause that they can change it at any time with no prior notification.
- danShumway 8y agoYou're right, that is crummy, and it is something that annoys me. That being said, at least they include the clause. If this promise had been phrased as, "we won't link with Google products, but we might in the future", I would honestly feel a bit more charitable towards them. It wasn't. DeepMind went out of its way to describe this not just as a temporary promise, but as a legal one.[0] In their words, "...data will never be connected to Google accounts or services, or used for any commercial purposes like advertising or insurance. Doing so would be completely impossible under our NHS contracts and the law". That is a full step beyond the crappy TOS that most companies use, and statements like that were given to ease consumer concerns and make it easier for DeepMind to form deep relationships with hospitals. One other thing to note outside of legal obligations or technicalities is that even if you don't think Google did anything different from the companies you're talking about, companies who do 180s on their TOS still lose trust. The trust loss is separate from the legality. I don't know if you can go to Google and say, "legally, you shouldn't be allowed to link your product," I'm not a lawyer. I do know that we as consumers and engineers should instinctively distrust any future promises that Google makes about privacy. If what they're doing is legal, I'm still going to call them out for being untrustworthy and dishonest. Their earlier statements are still lies. [0]: https://twitter.com/MalcolmMoore/status/1062394654702927873 https://twitter.com/MalcolmMoore/status/1062394654702927873
- DannyBee 8y agoStreams is a Deepmind product, moving to Google Health. It's not like it was an existing Google product that the data is being moved to. If Google Health was part of Alphabet but not Google, would you argue it was "plainly not a Google product"? Or is that still a Google product? (FWIW: I actually expect the article gets it wrong and that Google Health will be/is a separate LLC under Alphabet but not Google)
- danShumway 8y ago> Streams is a Deepmind product, moving to Google Health. So now it's a Google product. And when they said [data] "will never be linked or associated with Google accounts, products or services", that was a lie. Seems very straightforward to me. > If Google Health was part of Alphabet but not Google, would you argue it was "plainly not a Google product"? It has Google in the name. I don't understand this claim. It's a Google product. From the official blog post that Streams released yesterday[0]: "We’re excited to announce that the team behind Streams—our mobile app that supports doctors and nurses to deliver faster, better care to patients—will be joining Google." They're not joining Alphabet; they're joining Google. I mean, I guess linking to Google is technically different than literally being consumed by Google? [0]: https://deepmind.com/blog/scaling-streams-google/ https://deepmind.com/blog/scaling-streams-google/
- DannyBee 8y ago"It has Google in the name. I don't understand this claim." Just because something has Google in the name does not mean it is part of the same legal entity as the rest of Google. This is already the case in various situations. Your view seems to be "branding" is what makes it a Google product, and that seems wrong. Branding has no effect on anything material at all. If Google called it "Alphabet Chrome" but it reported into the Google entity, would it suddenly remove privacy concerns around chrome? As I asked, and you never answered, would you suddenly no longer call it a Google product? What really matters is what entities it is part of and what walls/agreements/etc exist between the entities, etc.
- 8y ago
- Lapalata 8y agoGoogle is taking over everything and has the mindset of the most evil big brother you could imagine. And yet you hope they will just nicely make sure no correlation is done between you and your health data ? I don't get how people still try to defend Google. When you see what Google is doing with our data, they should be prohibited from accessing any health information on us. Google has just proven themselves to be one of the most data-angry and unethical company of the moment.
- bun_at_work 8y agoAnd what exactly is Google doing with our data? And how does that apply in this context? Are you conflating Google and their parent: Alphabet? Also, comparing Google to Big Brother is disingenuous at best. Google isn't trying to control or limit what people think. They are merely trying to allow advertisers to target audiences precisely. I hate advertising, for sure. But the anti-Google fear-mongering and hate based on nothing substantial and leveraging an inaccurate view of what Google does is harmful for everyone involved.
- math_and_stuff 8y ago> Google isn't trying to control or limit what people think. I think proactive censorship for authoritarian governments (e.g., China) falls into this category.
- wafflesraccoon 8y agoIs that really Google's fault or China's for creating the policy? Google is forced to follow the local laws in the countries that it operates in.
- KirinDave 8y agoIt's true, but they're not actually forced to operate in China for any reason other than a desire to compete with unrestrained Chinese companies, and a desire to drive growth. So the relevant product groups and leadership are, at least to some degree, implicated in deciding to go along with rules they knew would be morally objectionable from the start. That said, Chinese folks are imo quite right to cry "hypocrisy" on the degree of moral outrage US citizens level at Western nations given how many ways western nations police dissidents and stifle anti-government speech.
- ancorevard 8y ago"fearmongering like this would suggest that Alphabet couldn't ever deal with health care info" I think that would be a good start.
- ionised 8y agoAlphabet should never be dealing with healthcare info, correct.
- aylmao 8y ago> The team is joining DeepMind/Alphabet, and it appears DeepMind promised that health data would never be joined to your Google account. Ah, good to hear! Companies always keep their promises after all, especially when it is around user-data sharing and it's all left to good faith instead of a written, actionable contract. /s Throwback to Facebook and WhatsApp anyone?
- bagacrap 8y agoI really don't see the connection between Facebook and Google. Track record on privacy is totally different between the two. No matter how many times I hear about cambridge analytica, my opinion of google will be unaffected.
- aylmao 8y agoI once heard a Google employee mention this himself, specifically after the Google+ breach coverup came to light: "Honestly, I don't think it was the right thing to do but it definitely was the better business move. And announcing the deprecation today definitely tries to cover it up. We just have a better PR team." I'm not claiming one is better than the other and that's not a discussion to have today, but I agree with him 100%. Google, after all, invented the business does have a hell of a PR team.
- reaperducer 8y agoThe PR department is ready to crank out another "We can do better. We'll learn from this" SV non-apology.
- thanatropism 8y agoFUD is disinformation with a commercial agenda. Unless you're suggesting that the rest of FAANG is playing dirty tricks at a guerilla level...
- aaavl2821 8y agoFrom what I can tell the substance is in the latter half of the article: > Streams began as a collaboration with the Royal Free Hospital in London to assist in the management of acute kidney injury. > However, it emerged that neither the health trust nor DeepMind had informed patients about the vast amount of data it had been using. > DeepMind Health went on to work with Moorfields Eye Hospital, with machine-learning algorithms scouring images of eyes for signs of conditions such as macular degeneration. > In July 2017, the UK's Information Commissioner ruled the UK hospital trust involved in the initial Streams trial had broken UK privacy law for failing to tell patients about the way their data was being used. Still not super clear what happened but it appears that google simply failed to tell patients about how it was using their data, which seems to be a violation of UK privacy law. I'm sure to some people this does not seem super concerning, and to others seems very concerning. In my opinion this is a mistake that should just not be made. The data privacy cultures in tech and healthcare are so incredibly different. Personal healthcare data is regulated arguably too heavily, while in tech it seems that privacy doesn't exist. It seems quite irresponsible to me that such a high profile company as google, that already has a reputation for lax privacy practices, would mess up such a seemingly simple compliance issue. It suggests they simply either dont care, are negligent, or think they can get away with whatever they want That said, the reporting on this seems to be egregiously sensationalist and fearmongering, and potentially factually incorrect. My initial reaction to that kind of language is to recoil and it makes me side with google rather than the reporter, although upon further consideration it seems clear to me that google / both google and the journalist are in the wrong. But i am probably in the minority and other people may respond to this kind of journalism. If it takes this level of aggressive journalism to raise public awareness of privacy concerns in healthcare, then maybe i support it...
- hammock 8y agoNo need to go to the bottom of the article, it's in the second sentence. >Streams...hit headlines for gathering data on 1.6 million patients without informing them.
- hammock 8y agoRegardless, it says "gather[ed] data on 1.6 million patients without informing them."