8 ms·
Evolved antenna
- elil17 8y agoThey say this is only used rarely. I’m curious why people wouldn’t design every antenna this way
- madengr 8y agoI do a lot of antenna design. There are far too many variables for optimization, and also size/geometry constraints. That's not to say you wouldn't start with a base design and use an optimizer (which could be genetic). There was a company commercializing this exact algorithm several year ago. I don't think it went anywhere.
- londons_explore 8y agoGenetic optimisers don't tend to do well over a few hundred parameters, but stochastic gradient descent does well up to billions of parameters as long as you have sufficient compute and ram. Obviously your fitness function needs to be differentiable with respect to the parameters, which most simulators can't yet do.
- pickdenis 8y agoBecause that would be unnecessary. This is only worth it when there are "unusual radiation patterns" (from the wiki article)
- rtkwe 8y agoBecause most antennas don't have weird enough requirements so standard designs work fine. For stuff down here on Earth we deal with a lot of the same problem so the problem has generally been solved to a reasonable approximation and there's additional constraints like shape and space. Standard designs are also just cheaper because they're made by the thousands and machines exist to make them in massive quantities.
- tomatotomato37 8y agoTalking less about antennas but more about the overall concept, most evolutionary algorithms don't take manufactoring into account at all, so they tend to be a pain to actually build.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- walrus01 8y agoEvolved antennas are good for certain purposes, but for highly directional links, the laws of physics say that there isn't much better than some variation on a human + CAD + Matlab designed parabolic reflector (whether it's center feed, compact cassegrain, elliptical offset feed, etc). Take a look at the dishes used for 71-86 GHz band mmwave links for instance.
- dbcurtis 8y ago"Better" when the goal is a very narrow beam pattern and minimal side- and back-lobes. That isn't always the goal. For instance, putting your entire FCC city-of-license within your grade A signal contour from X miles away at a bearing of B. Or, in one case I am aware of, covering your puny city of license in one direction, and incidentally getting good coverage into the much bigger city off the back of the beam so that your sales department can get some traction selling advertising.
- walrus01 8y agoNot my field, only related to it, but looking at the ERI antenna catalog, they resemble human designed variations on yagi, dipole and log periodic antennas... https://www.eriinc.com/catalog/antennas/ https://www.eriinc.com/catalog/antennas/
- heavenlyblue 8y agoOr using a phased array that can generate practically any shape of the signal.
- dbcurtis 8y agoInteresting to see this antenna here. I heard the creator speak at a local IEEE event a few years ago. Quite remarkable. Nobody would intuit an antenna design like that. Great demonstration of the power of GA. Antenna optimization software has changed antenna design completely. Before wide-spread computer simulation, there was an awful lot of antenna range cut-and-try. Antennas are much better now. Learning to drive the modeling software is still a huge amount of work, but the results are well worth it. An example from the world of amateur radio: the only popular HF tri-band beam to survive from the pre-simulation days is the KT-34 and big brother KT-34XA, originally from KLM. I was talking to Mike Stahl about it (The M in KLM, also one of the M's in M-squared) and he said he spent months going up and down towers at an antenna range. Pretty much all other hand-tuned competitors from that era have fallen by the wayside, the new simulation-verified designs being much better. Mike is a great hands-on antenna designer -- when the Stanford dish was new he designed several feed horns for it.
- mrguyorama 8y agoAnother good example of this is fractal antenna design that allowed significant efficiency/space improvements in mobile phones and allowed one physical antenna to work for multiple frequencies quite well. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractal_antenna https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractal_antenna
- chiph 8y agoOne of my high-school science-fair projects was a fractal high voltage insulator. The idea was that since high voltage follows the surface of an object, why not give it a lot of surface to run out of energy on? I failed of course - the ceramic was too hard to work (I dulled so many saw blades). And I didn't have an oven to bake it at the required temperature profile, nor a high-voltage lab to test my designs. But a cool idea anyway.
- namibj 8y agoYou want a shere/distance/minimize maximum curvature.
- aequitas 8y agoReminds me of an old article about evolutionary circuit design. The computer was tasked with creating a osscilator using physical hardware. It created a really complex and unconventional design that no-one understood, but it worked, only not work outside of the lab. As it turned out the algorithm had designed it in a way that it used the radio noise from the computer it was running on as a source. It had effectively made an antenna.
- gooseyard 8y agomaybe this? https://www.damninteresting.com/on-the-origin-of-circuits/ https://www.damninteresting.com/on-the-origin-of-circuits/ ive re-read that piece dozens of times, the implications are fascinating.
- sevensor 8y agoThere's a reason that conventional design uses models that abstract away the particulars -- in this case the evolved solution isn't robust to process variation in the FPGA. It's really easy for optimization to exploit irrelevant details to give you designs that aren't very useful. I'm no skeptic when it comes to EAs -- I did my dissertation using them, and I've subsequently written one of my own -- but you have to have realistic expectations for them. They get a lot less magical when you look at them up close.
- scrooched_moose 8y agoAre you aware of anyone who has recreated the process, except with a large pool of different FPGAs from different manufacturers and running designs on a random one each time? I'd imagine with even a moderate pool (~10?) the variation falls away and you're left with a robust design, although the process will take significantly longer.
- dnautics 8y agoapparently it is not possible because contemporary FPGAs do not give you low-level access to modify the floorplan.
- adfm 8y agoIf you’re interested in generative design beyond antenna construction, check out what Autodesk has been doing: https://www.autodesk.com/solutions/generative-design https://www.autodesk.com/solutions/generative-design
- joe_the_user 8y agoTook a few clicks to find the referenced paper as PDF, So here it is: https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Greg_Hornby/publication/226096470_An_Evolved_Antenna_for_Deployment_on_Nasa's_Space_Technology_5_Mission/links/5447e2fb0cf2d62c30526293/An-Evolved-Antenna-for-Deployment-on-Nasas-Space-Technology-5-Mission.pdf https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Greg_Hornby/publication...
- rc_kas 8y agoI <3 NASA
- auslander 8y agoAnd then there is phased arrays, a computer-controlled array of antennas which creates a beam of radio waves that can be electronically steered to point in different directions without moving the antennas. Pure math (matrix of delays per element). Go crazy :) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phased_array https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phased_array
- taneq 8y agoThe same thing is used in ultrasounds (except with sound) which is how they can "scan" without having any moving parts. Super cool.
- tabtab 8y agoSkipper: "Professor, why did our rescue radio fail?" Professor: "Hmmm, it looks like somebody straightened out the antenna. It had an unusual shape for a reason." Skipper: "Giillligan?! Do you know anything about this antenna?" Gilligan: "Uh, I'm sorry guys, the antenna looked all bent up, so I straightened it. See how nice it looks now?" (They both bop Gilligan on the noggin.)
- dnautics 8y agonot in the article (or the linked): Over the lifetime of the spacecraft, Did it perform as well or better than the conventional? Does anyone know?
- stefs 8y ago> This sophisticated procedure evolutionary algorithms are anything but sophisticated. i love them, but sophisticated they are not.
- crimsonalucard 8y agoThe results are sophisticated.
- heavenlyblue 8y agoEvolutionary algorithms are just a variation of pseudo-random search.
- k__ 8y agoSophisticated is (also) a synonym of convulted.
- crimsonalucard 8y agoAll of us are products of evolution. Either you are sophisticated or convoluted. Choose.
- nomel 8y agoI accidentally "evolved" a microwave antenna in my microwave oven, once. I put some hematite sand on the top of a glass plate that was suspended about 5 inches from the bottom of the microwave oven. I wanted to see what kind of pattern the standing waves would heat the hematite to (this microwave didn't have an RF stirring fan). Instead of some standing wave pattern, I ended up with a fractal like antenna that grew from a molten blob in the middle. The initial molten blob extended into arms of molten material, with each arm necessarily extending in the direction that maximized RF absorption, causing additional material to melt. It grew brighter and brighter as it extended, reached some peak, then some of the arms shorted and it dimmed. Then the plate shattered from the heat. I wrote some software that converted the picture into antenna elements for some free antenna simulation package I found at the time, but it couldn't support enough elements to get close to the shape of the antenna and would just crash beyond 10 or so. I'm not sure how useful of an antenna it would be, since it was maximized to generate heat, but it was a neat kitchen experiment.
- bradenb 8y agoI would love to see pictures or a video of this in action!
- tabtab 8y agoSounds like a Star Trek episode: a creature evolving to avoid weapons, morphing into something unstoppable.
- nomel 8y agoI don't have a video, and I can't find the original picture, but here's a very low resolution version: https://pbs.twimg.com/profile_images/378800000340843432/c1f1f74b9f2e4951fad9fbefef55467c.png https://pbs.twimg.com/profile_images/378800000340843432/c1f1...
- chris_va 8y agoProbably worth revisiting with Q-learning