4 ms·
YouTube's objection seems to be primarily a business model problem - they assume consent and then provide original content creators with a share of YouTube's pr
by pbhjpbhj 8y ago
YouTube's objection seems to be primarily a business model problem - they assume consent and then provide original content creators with a share of YouTube's profit from that work. It's no surprise that they wouldn't want to have to get permission first.
What stops YouTube from doing cursory scans and then relying on a user agreement to protect themselves from liabilities, like "you agree to pay to us sums sufficient to cover all legal costs including any copyright charges, fines, etc., arising as a result of uploading this work"??
However, the Wikipedia page on the Directive [1] mentions that Art.13 :
>"extends any licenses granted to content hosts to their users, as long as those users are not acting "on a commercial basis".
That would be massive as videos uploaded to YouTube would then be able to be downloaded, and even shared, as works for [personal] non-commercial use. This would be a huge change in favour of the people and against copyright rights holders -- perhaps Wikipedia editors misinterpreted?
The article mentions the "Fair Use Act", what's that a reference too? The para it's in is about EU, and the USA Fair Use Act never survived. We don't have a Fair Use in Europe.
It would really help to know which companies are trying to push this and what specifically they're trying to protect from??
---
[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directive_on_Copyright_in_the_Digital_Single_Market https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directive_on_Copyright_in_the_...