5 ms·
What? If anything, WhatsApp has become a better product since its acquisition. It is currently the simplest, most reliable, ad-free messenger out there, which a
by baby 8y ago
What? If anything, WhatsApp has become a better product since its acquisition. It is currently the simplest, most reliable, ad-free messenger out there, which also supports state of the art end-to-end encryption for its millions of users.
Let's see how they deploy ads. But it would be a shame that WhatsApp shut downs because Facebook cannot monetize the application. If anything, I'm glad they're going this route instead of charging a fee to use the app.
- abhiminator 8y agoAds are a slippery slope. It might begin with text-only ads in 'Status' but I think it's only a matter of time before they spill over into other, more private sections of the application. And I do not trust Facebook Inc. to put privacy over profits [0] given it's trashy record in this space. End-to-end encryption is a valid point, but WhatsApp was not the first to pioneer it. Scale-wise it just got lucky, and Facebook just threw in a bunch of dollars from its coffers to acquire all that. [0] https://techcrunch.com/2018/09/26/whatsapp-founder-brian-acton-says-facebook-used-him-to-get-its-acquisition-past-eu-regulators/ https://techcrunch.com/2018/09/26/whatsapp-founder-brian-act...
- baby 8y agoit does not have to be a slippery slope. Would most people complain of ads in Google or Gmail nowadays?
- f_allwein 8y ago> end-to-end encryption Well, they do collect and use metadata, e.g. chat history: https://www.forbes.com/sites/thomasbrewster/2017/01/22/whatsapp-facebook-backdoor-government-data-request/#79424ada1030 https://www.forbes.com/sites/thomasbrewster/2017/01/22/whats... There's better options regarding privacy, e.g. Signal, which does not collect metadata.
- tinus_hn 8y agoAccording to that article WhatsApp provided almost no data except who was in the group and who was sending messages. There is no way Signal can function without having the same data available.
- majewsky 8y agoSignal was once subpoenaed by the FBI to give up all stored data/metadata relating to a certain account. They responded with the account creation timestamp and the last-connected timestamp, suggesting that they do not store information about group ownerships or contacts. Source: https://www.aclu.org/blog/national-security/secrecy/new-documents-reveal-government-effort-impose-secrecy-encryption https://www.aclu.org/blog/national-security/secrecy/new-docu...
- tinus_hn 8y agoOnce they become big they will be forced to keep that data. It is really difficult to force them to change the client or the protocol but not to force them to keep data they have access to on the server.
- baby 8y agoThis is because Signal works differently for group chat. In WhatsApp, the server delivers your encrypted message to each member of the group. It's an optimization called "server-side fan-out". Check the whitepaper for more deatils: https://www.whatsapp.com/security/WhatsApp-Security-Whitepaper.pdf https://www.whatsapp.com/security/WhatsApp-Security-Whitepap... Interestingly this is also what the Signal libraries implement. So applications making use of them will generally make use of this optimization. For some reason, the Signal application itself was not making use of this optimization. My guess is that it had not updated its code yet when I looked. This might have changed since then. BUT, and that's a big but, as a passive observer (and if Signal kept logs of things) you can still figure out group chat membership by looking at who sent the same kind of message (same length) to who, and at what time. Basic relationship graph stuff.
- move-on-by 8y agoYes, there is a way and it’s already in beta. It’s called sealed-sender and you can read about it in this signal blog post: https://signal.org/blog/sealed-sender/ https://signal.org/blog/sealed-sender/
- techsupporter 8y ago> Let's see how they deploy ads. ... If anything, I'm glad they're going this route instead of charging a fee to use the app. I understand why you hold this view but woe I wish it to be that more people agreed with me and held the opposite. I wish we were fine with paying money instead of "being monetized" and having ads shoved in front of us. I don't want to see how they deploy the ads; I don't want ads, period. By their very nature, ads are a guarantee that I'm going to be tracked, sliced, analyzed, deanonymized, and attention-grabbed any time I crack open that app. I guess I'm turning more and more into the Luddite but I am tired of the ads, tired of the continual chase for my ever-decreasing number of seconds on this planet. I don't even know that letting me pay to not have ads is a) practical (because what's to say the ads aren't being shown in a "hidden" way such that I am still tracked and followed) or b) fair (because what about the other billions of people on the planet for whom money can't be traded for time as they have more of the latter than the former yet still don't deserve to be tracked). But I still don't like ads.
- DEADBEEFC0FFEE 8y agoI don't think you described a Luddite.
- user5994461 8y agoYou already pay money for your mobile subscription. The whole point of WhatsApp is free messaging, if it stops being free, there is no point in having it.
- techsupporter 8y agoI pay for many things that go through my mobile and are in addition to my mobile service. Paying is not the issue; ads are the issue.
- kriro 8y agoI think the other two "mainstream" messengers I use (Telegram, KakaoTalk) are as simple or simpler and also ad-free. Kakao also has E2E encryption after a bit of a struggle, Telegram had it for a long time. I think WA is the most widespread but I wouldn't call it the simplest or most reliable. They are all pretty similar imo
- tnova 8y agoAs opposed to the two you mentioned, WhatsApp has e2e by default. Kakaotalk and Telegram force you to use "secret chats" for that which are device to device only and cannot be shared among different devices with the same account.
- BubuIIC 8y agoUh, well, both WhatsApp and Signal are single device only to begin with.
- oarsinsync 8y agoI can continue an encrypted chat in Signal from my desktop. I don't think I can do that in Telegram.
- def_true_false 8y agoTelegram secret chats don't sync across devices and aren't supported in the official desktop client, which makes them pretty much useless.
- diazon 8y agoA better product? I don't like most of the things they've added, like statuses, stickers, or invite links.
- nindalf 8y agoPerhaps you take the basic features for granted. For example, it works well on a wide variety of devices, especially those with low specs. What about audio quality, which has gradually improved to the point where people I know don't make "normal" calls anymore. What about latency on awful connections. Often when I'm in a place with poor reception, Whatsapp works when other apps don't. All of these aren't build-and-you're-done kind of features. You need to invest continuously to make sure you don't regress. And the flipside is that people will look at your app and say "what have you done for me lately? What features have you added?"
- diazon 8y agoI am afraid I don't know much about call quality as I don't make calls through WA, but WA has always worked well on devices with low specs, and adding more features will only make it worse, not better.
- Aeolun 8y agoI don’t know, but didn’t whatsapp subscribe to the idea that if you build something well the first time around you won’t need to keep supporting it. Which was the reason they could scale to their current userbase with some 50 people.
- baby 8y agoI have no idea what are these things, and I've never heard of them eventhough I use whatsApp daily. Please.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y ago> I'm glad they're going this route instead of charging a fee to use the app. Why is this an either/or situation? Why not give users the option to pay if they so choose?
- michaelt 8y agoEven if you can pay to remove ads, you can't pay to restore privacy. So long as you've got a non-paying friend, Facebook will hoover up your phone number and chat history and social graph from their end instead.
- user5994461 8y agoYou woudln't pay $100 a year for whatsapp, would you? Because that's how much advertising can earn.
- briandear 8y agoiMessage is far easier and reliable and it even falls back to SMS if your recipient doesn’t have iOS. It also doesn’t give your data to Facebook.
- rakoo 8y agoIt also isn't available outside iOS, so it's not even in the same league.
- tpush 8y agoWhat is easier or more reliable about iMessage? Consider that large portions of the world (among them Germany with its extremely old population) use WhatsApp pretty much exclusively; they don't seem to have a problem using it. Whereas something like iMessage would be a complete nonstarter with its semi-iOS exclusivity.
- baby 8y agoCan you explain to me how to get iMessage on an Android phone?
- emiliobumachar 8y agoThey won't shut it down after paying billions (10?) for it. If they do, an alternative could rise. Imagine paying billions again. Running costs are very cheap in comparison.