30 ms·
> Google may discontinue any Services or any portion or feature for any reason at any time without liability to Customer for any reason at any time
by chrisseaton 8y ago
> Google may discontinue any Services or any portion or feature for any reason at any time without liability to Customer
for any reason
at any time
- chongli 8y agoBut hey, it's all spelled out in the policy, so don't say we didn't warn you! Caveat emptor, folks.
- 8ytecoder 8y ago>Subject to Section 7.2 Which is the deprecation policy. (I mean I share your frustration with Google's what-appears-to-be-at-least haphazard policy of shutting down services instead of trying to gain traction. But, let's not misrepresent what they say).
- chrisseaton 8y agoI thought that 'subject to 7.2' meant that they can use the escape-hatch there 'substantial economic or material technical burden'? They can list anything under that. I don't think it's wrong - they can deprecate any service they want to do whenever they want, unless people have paid for and signed a contract that says otherwise which I guess people aren't doing. But the policy doesn't really guarantee anything at all does it, due to the reference escape-hatches? It might as well not exist?
- joshuamorton 8y agoThe preceding line is the imprtant part. Which is essentially "Subject to the deprecation policy [which says that Google will give at least 1 year notice before cancelling services], Google may discontinue..." In other words, at any time, google can give you a years notice. (I work at Google, but am not a lawyer and this isn't official in any capacity). Please don't selectively quote things out of context to give a misleading impression.
- chrisseaton 8y agoBut what do these things mean? > commercially reasonable > substantial economic or material technical burden Is one engineer working on an old service to keep it alive commercially reasonable or a substantial burden? I don't know. Do you? In practice this policy lets them shut off anything they want any time they want. Again it's their playground they can do what they want unless they signed a contract saying they'd do something else for you so I don't have a problem with it.
- joshuamorton 8y agoI think you're ascribing an unreasonable amount of bad faith here, and, to rephrase what I had here before, you're approaching this from an engineering perspective, not a legal one. And that's not how those things work. To be clear, that policy is a contract. And those things would be decided by a jury. And if my understanding is correct, the reasonable person standard applies. So you can answer this yourself, do you think a reasonable person would believe that your interpretation is valid? If not, why mention it?
- lovich 8y ago>If not, why mention it? Because it makes more people feel comfortable enough to use your services and pay you, without actually binding you towards any sort of behavior that would cost you money. There's a direct financial incentive here to use legalese to give the semblance of reliability without having to deliver on it
- mempko 8y agoGoogle lost our faith after shutting down countless services.
- housingpost 8y agoI’d say google earned that bad faith this year alone with what they did with maps.
- 8y ago
- uluyol 8y agoNice job cherry picking text. > 7.1 Discontinuance of Services. Subject to Section 7.2, Google may discontinue > any Services or any portion or feature for any reason at any time without > liability to Customer. Let's take a look at Section 7.2: > 7.2 Deprecation Policy. Google will announce if it intends to discontinue or > make backwards incompatible changes to the Services specified at the URL in > the next sentence. Google will use commercially reasonable efforts to continue > to operate those Services versions and features identified at > https://cloud.google.com/terms/deprecation https://cloud.google.com/terms/deprecation without these changes for at least > one year after that announcement, unless (as Google determines in its > reasonable good faith judgment): > > (i) required by law or third party relationship (including if there is a change > in applicable law or relationship), or > > (ii) doing so could create a security risk or substantial economic or material > technical burden. > > The above policy is the "Deprecation Policy." To me that looks like a reasonable deprecation policy.
- Jedi72 8y agoIt's ok I guess but still lets them turn it off if, in their judgement, its an economic burden i.e. costing them money. If they ever do deprecate something people have built on though they're gonna get absolutely crucified. That's probably better protection than any terms of service.
- kuyan 8y ago> It's ok I guess but still lets them turn it off if, in their judgement, its an economic burden i.e. costing them money. If a service Google runs is losing money, what reason would they have to not shut it down?
- lovich 8y agoWith this terms of service, none. Which is why people don't trust them. If I pay you for a service that would take time to migrate off of, and you are making money off me now, I am going to be ripshit if you decide to just turn it off because it's suddenly not making money for you in the short term. Google's done this a lot, and the fact that don't provide concrete time lines in their contract gives even less reason to trust them