5 ms·
I was about to say that launching so far from the equator sounds very fuel-inefficient, but it turns out that their launchpad's latitude (39 degrees south) is n
by kibwen 8y ago
I was about to say that launching so far from the equator sounds very fuel-inefficient, but it turns out that their launchpad's latitude (39 degrees south) is nearer the equator than Russia's primary launch site, the Baikonur Cosmodrome (45 degrees north). For reference, Cape Canaveral is 28 degrees north.
- MPSimmons 8y agoFor what it's worth, this specific launch was polar, I believe. But yes, for equatorial launches, it will take a lot more dV to flatten it out. I do like their little kick stage on top that finalizes payload delivery, though. That will be useful for this sort of thing.
- taneq 8y agoIf you think about it, the added starting velocity from launching on the equator is nice but is still only ~6% of the total velocity required to get into low Earth orbit. (0.0625 = 1.5 / 24 given orbital period in LEO is ~90 minutes and rotation period is 24 hours). Even at 45 degrees latitude you're only losing 0.707*6=4.4% of your target velocity.
- masklinn 8y agoThe problem is not the starting velocity (which is indeed minor, and not an issue for LEO launches) it's the inclination burns you need to reach GTO/GEO. With roughly equivalent rockets, there's a 30~40% difference in payload mass between Kourou (5°N) and Baikonur (45°N): Proton can launch 23t to LEO and 7t to GTO while Ariane 5 can send 21t to LEO and 10t to GTO.
- taneq 8y agoThat makes sense, I hadn't really thought about it in this context but I guess geostationary orbits kind of have to be equatorial.
- mikeash 8y agoPercentage of velocity is highly misleading. The rocket equation is nasty, and a small increase in velocity means a large increase in fuel requirements, or a large decrease in payload capacity.
- masklinn 8y agoTBF Baikonur is known to be a fairly bad location from an efficiency perspective if you're trying for GTO/GEO: using pretty much the same rocket, you can send 6~7t to GTO from Baikonur while you can send 10 from Kourou (on 5N). That's why as time went on, China kept building their new launch facilities more and more southernly (Jiuquan was built on 40N in the 50s, the recently opened Wenchang sits on 19N).
- sandworm101 8y agoIt gets worse than that. The russian site also has to not fly over chinese territory, further increasing their minimum inclination. Chinese dont want thier stinking rockets falling on china. (Literally. Russian rockets use some nasty stuff that groups like SpaceX have stayed far away from.)
- calcifer 8y ago> Russian rockets use some nasty stuff Do you have a source for that? What sort of "stuff"?
- rsynnott 8y agoThey probably mean hydrazine. The Russian Proton rocket uses it, though it’s being discontinued. This isn’t a uniquely Russian oddity, by the way; the European Ariane IV and US Titan IV were still in use into the last decade.
- baybal2 8y agoUDMH is not hydrazine, and is said to be worse as it doesn't biodegrade as readily as hydrazine. UDMH, hydrazine, and MMH are all very different beasts.
- masklinn 8y agoUDMH and MMH are both hydrazine derivatives, classified as hydrazines, and either picked or mixed (Aerozine 50 is a 50/50 mix of hydrazine and UDMH) depending on the specific chemical and performance tradeoffs you want to make. UDMH, hydrazine and MMH are slightly different beasts.
- walrus01 8y agoIf you're launching into sun-synchronous and highly inclined or polar orbits, you want to be as far north or south as possible. They're not going for low inclination orbits, but rather the opposite, if you look at the ground track of an Iridium satellite, that's a perfect example of a polar orbit. Spire is one of their customers, that's earth observation, perfect use case example for polar orbit. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polar_orbit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polar_orbit To avoid dropping the first stage on a populated area if you're launching into a polar orbit, you also need a very empty area of land or an ocean under your flightpath. For example Israel has a domestic satellite launch capability (they're one of the few countries that launches LEO stuff westbound, to retrograde orbits) because they both can't drop first stages on the eastern neigbours, and can't launch heading north or south.
- tjpnz 8y agoThis has always bothered me especially given their plans to send a rover to the moon. Launching from Tokelau, Niue or the Cook Islands would make more longterm sense.