4 ms·
Two related observations. One, that [obsessively] lining things up is supposed to be an early indicator for autism @ c.2yo. Two, Thomas The Tank Engine (child
by pbhjpbhj 8y ago
Two related observations.
One, that [obsessively] lining things up is supposed to be an early indicator for autism @ c.2yo.
Two, Thomas The Tank Engine (children's books, cartoon featuring living trains with their faces on their boilers) is supposedly beloved of those [boys] on the autistic spectrum.
The latter is weird to me as it's pretty orthogonal to anything to do with trains AFAICT. The trains might be coincidence and the structure of the stories with the strict roles and narrow characters might be the appealling part?
- taurath 8y agoOr the anthropomorphising of the trains helps them empathize - the faces themselves are very singular and simple without subtlety that they might not pick up with human faces.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoI wonder if the affinity for "Thomas" has decreased then as they moved from static scenes with fixed expressions done with stop motion models (IIRC) to animated characters.
- Amorymeltzer 8y agoTo the second point, maybe, but I would think it's similar to nerds/geeks and a lot of scifi or fantasy books/movies/tv. A lot of any given story might work just as well in Victorian or Edwardian England, but throw a spaceship or a wizard in there and we'll watch it.
- lbriner 8y agoI would be interested in whether it has anything to do with faces on trains or just the fact they were trains. Also, compared to other train programs like Ivor the Engine (from the UK), the trains were real models, not cartoonised. I think the bright solid colours helped too, there is perhaps something soothing about simplicity and trains offer excitement with less of the unknown than road transport.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoIvor the Engine is very similar to Thomas IMO, but I saw them both in books first. Solid colours, may be a factor, train livery often is quite bold too. But I don't think kids need to have experienced train travel to have the effect, and real trains aren't so simple; road travel is far more commonplace for most and so is not unknown?
- PhasmaFelis 8y agoNot sure why this got downvoted; I was going to say something similar. A lot of autistic kids like trains. We tend to like trucks, construction equipment, and machines in general, anything that's orderly and has a lot of information available about it; trains are a quintessential nerd interest (see: model train hobbyists, trainspotters), so there's a whole community out there to tap into. I would guess that Thomas the Tank Engine intersects trains and children's TV in a particular way that resonates with a lot of kids who began with an interest in either.
- itronitron 8y agoTrains move very smoothly through space, unlike people or animals, so that may be what captures their attention.
- Markoff 8y agoso if my child just creates mess and like watching peppa the pig it should be fine?
- liveoneggs 8y agodon't worry- that's another disorder