8 ms·
Not to get too off topic, but higher birth rates equal more economic growth, or at least the potential for it. That is, what's currently being passed off as an
by chiefalchemist 8y ago
Not to get too off topic, but higher birth rates equal more economic growth, or at least the potential for it.
That is, what's currently being passed off as an immigration issue - in the USA, and Europe (e.g., Germany) - is ultimately an economic growth issue. With "native" births flat (or less), growth has to come from somewhere. The quick and simple solution is immigration. But, obviously, that's coming with baggage, at least for the proles. The economic elites continue to cash in.
Put another way, no one wants to be the next Japan. Capable but ultimately stagnant.
Note: Yes, I'm generalizing but the bottom line is, immigration in many countries is often a proxy for economic growth.
- adverbly 8y agoWhat is wrong with people in Japan? I understand that the entity of the country is of lower standing relative to other countries due to population stagnation, but for the individual, who cares about your country's global standing if your country's members are better off on average?
- soared 8y agoOp is talking about growth, not current standing. Japan looks good now, but that will change in the future without growth.
- criveros 8y agoThey are not better off. Have you worked or even been there? Their culture is horrible? People are literally worked to death and sexism and xenophobia is rampant. The summers suck as it's too damn hot, to the point it sucks going out.
- screye 8y ago> What is wrong with people in Japan? The OP is referring to their declining birth rates, paired with general xenophobia and anti immigrant sentiment. As the average population gets older, they are faced with a smaller and smaller tax paying population and an increasing tax dependent population. This will eventually lead to the death of retirement funds and an aging country that can't afford to have retirees. Higher average age also makes old people the main voting bloc and forces the country to prioritize funding towards younger populations needs, as they have increasing lower representation. The country's general productivity will also drop as even if older people come out of retirement, they can't match the efficiency and vigor of a young work force. It is an all out impending disaster.
- fromthestart 8y ago>paired with general xenophobia and anti immigrant sentiment. It is increasingly infuriating to watch people stall any debate by slandering those with legitimate concerns over immigration as xenophobes. One can be wary of, for example, the increased infrastructural strain of, say, large numbers of uneducated third worlders entering a country suddenly, without being hostile to or fearful of their culture.
- d1zzy 8y agoIf, that concern (of large uneducated immigrants) is paired in the same sentence or paragraph (or at least article) with a suggestion of how to increase immigration of highly skilled/educated people. Because if it just stops at "we should stop immigration because of these potential social problems", then you are (willingly or not) selecting arguments to match your narrative and that can be seen as pushing an agenda that goes beyond simply trying to cope with the potential problems expressed at face value. Hence why articles that describe issues that seem reasonable on the face, can be interpreted as pushing xenophobia.
- fromthestart 8y ago>then you are (willingly or not) selecting arguments to match your narrative and that can be seen as pushing an agenda If I lean towards one side of an issue (e.g. unchecked immigration policies are a net negative to first world societies) then the onus is not on me to present both sides. That does not make me a xenophobe. >can be interpreted as pushing xenophobia Only when there is social pressure to interpret things in such a way. No matter how you slice it, automatically associating anti immigration sentiment with xenophobia is dishonest conflation.
- lovich 8y ago>No matter how you slice it, automatically associating anti immigration sentiment with xenophobia is dishonest conflation. That is correct, unless the group in question is saying "we don't want immigrants because they are intrinsically worse then us". In Japan's case, lookat the example of ethnic Koreans changing their names to hide the fact, despite south korea being an industralized economy on par with Japan in terms of technology and prosperity. It is difficult to see a reason why they would discriminate against Koreans for any reason based on actual performance of their people and seems to show that it is in fact xenophobia
- Leary 8y agoPopulation decline also places a lot of pressure on young people for elder support.
- snowwrestler 8y ago> higher birth rates equal more economic growth The empirical data doesn't support this. The nations with the strongest economies are also the nations with among the lowest birth rates, and it has been that way for decades. To highlight one specific example, China's birth rate fell even as its economy took off over the past 30 years. And they did not experience high rates of immigration either.
- buboard 8y agoMaybe it is "periods with higher birth rates", such as the baby boom. standard disclaimers about correlation not correlating with causation apply both ways.
- irrational 8y agoThere must be some point where that reverses. If China's population dropped to 1 million people I would assume it would no longer have one of the strongest economies. The question is, where is the reversal point between 1 billion and 1 million?
- jpatokal 8y agoChina has been enjoying the "demographic dividend" of having lots of young working-age people without retired parents or children to support. It's now in a race against time to get rich before the ratio reverses and the country's demographics turns into an accelerated version of Japan or Korea.
- snowwrestler 8y agoIf their population dropped from 1b to 1m immediately, right now, then yes that would be a disaster. But imagine that their population falls slowly, as automation increases their per-capita productivity. Imagine a future China with 1 million people, but the average person can produce 1,000x the economic value that the average person can today.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoI'd call China an outlier. (1) It's size isn't comparable to any other. (2) It's not a First World'er in the same "mature" way USA or Germany, is. (3) It's growth is driven by all the counties it serves. Regardless of what happens internally, the world economy is the driver. (4) Again, Japan is - at least in the eyes of USA and German politicians, economists, etc. the most likely fear-driver.
- nostromo 8y agoWith the next wave of automation, we're going to need far fewer seasonal farm workers, fewer cab drivers, fewer truck drivers, etc. etc. What today may be a modest economic gain from unskilled worker immigration could quickly become a huge burden when many of these jobs go away.
- maxander 8y agoIf you're not limited by bulk unskilled labor you're limited by talented, skilled labor. A bunch of skilled labor is coming from elite families that have had expensive educations and white-collar jobs for generations, but a not inconsiderable portion is coming from skilled immigrants and the second- or third-generation upwardly mobile children of unskilled immigrants.
- specialist 8y agoI'm trying to articulate something, please humor me: Lowering coordination and transactional costs are factors too. Gig & sharing economy leading to better allocation of capital & labor, leading to less stuff & work overall, leading to less economic activity (production & consumption, as currently measured). For example, it's looking like we're going to have fewer cars per capita. A virtuous cycle of less inventory, greater density (less land for parking and roads), more mass transit, fewer miles traveled, and so on. Unless that paradox where cheaper makes consumption rise kicks in. So many variables, trends and countertrends, technology colliding with policy... It's hard to figure out what's going on, much less guess what's next.
- jessaustin 8y agoIt's amusing how much what people (even economists) think is "right" and "true" is biased by what's going on while they're alive. Back when kings had divine rights, mercantilism reigned. After that, before many nations had gone through the demographic transition, and still while many material resources are still easily exploitable, everything has been "growth growth growth". In future, economists will confidently tell us how wrong their predecessors were about that...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gdubs 8y agoI think it was in Bill McKibben's book "Eaarth" that I was surprised to learn that back in the 1970's, after the "Limits of Growth" was published, polls showed that people were generally OK with moving towards an economic system that prioritized sustainability over growth. (Unthinkable in today's political climate.) In our current system, growth == prosperity, generally. But, if you believe Climate Science – then, well, this model is unsustainable. It needs tweaks at minimum (carbon tax, etc), and a total reimagining at best (e.g., Star Trek, The Next Generation.) That said, I find Stewart Brand's argument compelling that a collapsing population can spell environmental disaster, because in a strained economy, protecting the environment is the last thing on people's minds. They will burn the cheapest, most accessible sources of energy available. But perhaps the real story is income inequality. The working class is told the economy most keep growing for their benefit – yet, since the 1970s, wages have been relatively flat. America, in particular, has seen enormous growth over the past half-century (even if it has slowed in recent decades) – yet that money has concentrated itself into a very small number of pockets.
- whatshisface 8y agoClimate science? That doesn't limit growth. We'll cook the earth by continuing our same rate of emissions without adding a single person, and if we switch to something like solar we can have as many people as we want without any climate change.
- Animats 8y agoIn our current system, growth == prosperity, generally. Read Piketty's "Capital in the Twenty-First Century", which everyone interested in serious money has already read. One of his points is that prosperity for the little guy comes almost entirely from growth. In the absence of growth, money tends to flow toward those who already have it, in the form of rents. ("Rent", in the economic sense, includes any passive asset which generates revenue.)
- pjc50 8y agoI'm always confused whether people mean growth per capita or not. Because trivially the economy grows with more people, but are they more productive?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoThere are potentially economies of scale. If you operate a restaurant or auto repair shop and the local population doubles, you have twice as many customers and the same fixed costs. But a major thing that matters is "size of the economy" (not per capita) vs. "government expenses" (proportional to number of retirees). If you increased the population by importing a slew of retirees, that would be highly counterproductive. If you increased it by adding a lot of young working people, you raise the per-capita productivity because then a higher percentage of the population is productive workers.
- scottlocklin 8y agoThey mean the more people kind. Like, China has less GDP/capita than South Korea, but is a much more powerful and capable country. Economists who think of this sort of thing, of course, are basically frauds. They never mention 'externalities' like the country descending into a vicious civil war because you imported new people who aren't compatible with the ones who were there before. MUH GDP
- gaius 8y agoThis is exactly the case in the UK. GDP goes up so the country is richer, but GDP/capita goes down, so everyone in the country is poorer. Well, not everyone, the fatcats always do well.
- apostacy 8y ago> Put another way, no one wants to be the next Japan. Capable but ultimately stagnant. Huh? I would LOVE to be the next Japan, as opposed to the next South Africa, Israel, India, Philippines, or Brazil. Because with the massive demographic changes caused by immigration into Europe, they are ensuring unending ethnic conflict. The best they can hope for is that the different people can carve out their own enclaves and leave each other alone, only having small wars flare up occasionally. The problems that Japan is facing are a BLESSING compared to the rest of the 1st world. Nobody talks about the upsides of Japan's population decline. Japan is going to experience a major redistribution of wealth, as fewer people inherit more things. Land that was locked up for centuries is going to be sold to new people. Housing will become more affordable. Already, the chronic crowding is becoming less of a problem, as Japan has essentially "finished" their major infrastructure, and there are no new plans to build any new train lines or anything like that. Something like 30% of our jobs are going to be eliminated in the next 20 years as self driving vehicles are rolled out. Even if immigration were cut to 0, we are still facing a work crisis regardless. Does any nation really need any more unskilled or semi-skilled labor to grow? Check out this new Japanese drywalling robot: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n_sUJtl1V8A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n_sUJtl1V8A The Japanese are embracing this as an opportunity to improve automation and benefit from the challenge. Countries like Italy and Hungry are rolling out programs to offer financial incentives to people that have more children: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-36297177 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-36297177 These are very solvable problems, but many governments are only making things worse.
- thaumasiotes 8y ago> Because with the massive demographic changes caused by immigration into Europe, they are ensuring unending ethnic conflict. Ethnic conflict doesn't have to be unending. Often one side wins.
- Tsubasachan 8y agoI agree with this. Immigration from low skilled people who don't speak the language is simple not an economic boon for developed nations. Western Europe doesn't have Foxconn jobs, agriculture is heavily mechanised and you need to train for 4 years to become a basic nurse.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> That is, what's currently being passed off as an immigration issue - in the USA, and Europe (e.g., Germany) - is ultimately an economic growth issue. With "native" births flat (or less), growth has to come from somewhere. What the article is pointing out is that "somewhere" is not going to be able to sustainably make population donations anymore, as those countries industrialize too and their fertility rates fall as well -- which is already happening. We may need to start looking at policies to get the domestic fertility rate back to the population replacement rate: Free childcare, more generous dependent child tax deductions, etc.
- nitwit005 8y ago> Not to get too off topic, but higher birth rates equal more economic growth, or at least the potential for it. This kind of thinking is just seems like an attempt to optimize a metric. Say I add 10 million people to a country, each of whom make a dollar a day. We could say the country's GDP has grown, but in reality I'd say the country's poverty problem has simply swelled.
- dogsh1t 8y agoCorrect. Goodhart's Law.
- jfoutz 8y agoThere is a great gulf between adequate and finesse. I think you would be surprised at how quickly people can become adequate, and developing fineness seems statistical. Not everyone can become amazing, but some will. And the more that have the chance, the more frequently it will happen.
- lottin 8y agoEconomic growth is irrelevant. It has no effect on the standards of living. What does have an effect on standards of living is economic growth per capita.
- 0xfaded 8y agoExcept when systemic wealth transfers exist from the younger to older generations.