8 ms·
I still wonder how is this legal.
by lostmsu 8y ago
I still wonder how is this legal.
- whalesalad 8y agoHow could it be illegal? If you sold bread in a grocery store and the grocery store decided they preferred their own brand and didn't wanna sell yours anymore... would that be illegal?
- writepub 8y agoWhen the grocery store accounts for 80% of profits, and about 70% of revenues in it's category [1] (mobile app store), it stops being legal, and falls into the category of anti-trust. [1]: https://techcrunch.com/2018/07/16/apples-app-store-revenue-nearly-double-that-of-google-play-in-first-half-of-2018/ https://techcrunch.com/2018/07/16/apples-app-store-revenue-n...
- ryanwaggoner 8y agoYou’re just redefining monopoly to suit your purposes.
- writepub 8y agoHow exactly? What in the definition of the app market is disingenuous. If "browsers" were a market at the time of the Microsoft anti trust ruling, a $70B app store space is very much a market according to prevailing economic theory. You just don't like the truth about Apple, which is understandable, as they're a loved brand. But evil
- tapoxi 8y agoWhat if you moved into a neighborhood that had an exclusive contract with one grocery store (you were kicked out if you bought from elsewhere) and they removed non-store brands?
- dwaite 8y agoSomething similar - my university changed the dorm policy such that, to stay in my room another year, I was required to purchase a meal plan of 20 meals a week at the new buffet-style cafeteria to live there. I moved into an apartment.
- lostmsu 8y agoIt should be if there are 3 grocery stores in the country, and your bread can't be sold by other 2. This is a great case to be a precedent.
- tptacek 8y agoThe great case of the application that abused a platform location feature --- one of the more privacy-sensitive features on the phone --- to do something privacy-invasive?
- lostmsu 8y agoDid not they explicitly tell what's it for? The title also claims other time-tracking apps were removed, so was is the reason? UPD. I see the title was edited, and they have retracted the others apps claim now. The first question still stands though.
- dwaite 8y agoApple's ToS goes beyond asking the user for consent for a privacy or power-impacting feature; the review process is meant to also verify that the access is for an appropriate reason. This similar to how they ban apps that do cryptocurrency mining in the background. With the exception of a few specific Apple apps (Mail is actually the only one I know of now, and I believe it is more that the Mail app is a renderer of the system mail process) and apps which use particular API (such as VOIP and navigation-related location), you cannot have your app run persistently in the background to preserve power and resources. Using these API has always required you actually be an app in these categories. Independent of draining battery and tying up the CPU/memory - it sounds like the primary purpose of this app (tracking your phone usage) broke if you didn't consent to a secondary feature (reporting where you were when you used your phone). Which means the app was fundamentally broken. Which isn't a surprise, because the API doesn't let you make this sort of app.
- saagarjha 8y ago> With the exception of a few specific Apple apps (Mail is actually the only one I know of now, and I believe it is more that the Mail app is a renderer of the system mail process) and apps which use particular API (such as VOIP and navigation-related location), you cannot have your app run persistently in the background to preserve power and resources. Apple has dozens of daemons that run continuously that handle everything from push notifications to fetching calendars to performing backups.
- gagege 8y agoBecause it should be legal for the owner of a store to decide not to sell a product, whatever the reason.
- jasonlotito 8y agoAs Apple's customer, I don't see the "store" as so much a store as the way for me to install and update applications. After all, it shouldn't be legal for the owner of a store to break into my house and either take stuff or leave trash I don't want (something Apple is perfectly willing to do). Apple has chosen to position itself as the only way to install apps, which I feel is generally fine, but as Apple's customer, I have every right to complain to them when they harm my experience with their product by denying me a product I want based purely on business decisions and that don't protect me.
- saagarjha 8y ago> it shouldn't be legal for the owner of a store to break into my house and either take stuff or leave trash I don't want (something Apple is perfectly willing to do). Apple does not remove apps from your device, it stops you from downloading them. So this is still like a store refusing to sell something rather than a storeowner coming to your house and taking things.
- jasonlotito 8y ago> Apple does not remove apps from your device Just because they've never done it doesn't mean they can't. > So this is still like a store refusing to sell something rather than a storeowner coming to your house and taking things. You conveniently ignoring the fact they've still gone and left trash on my device is noticed.
- danmg 8y agoNot when the market is a monopoly.
- scarface74 8y ago
- garysahota93 8y agoI think legality is less the issue and it's more about how ethical this is. Apple is notoriously known for stealing great ideas and integrating them within their ecosystem only to then block others from doing anything remotely similar...