7 ms·
Let's put aside the "Facebook is evil and therefore everything they do is evil" tangents for a minute since if you're in that boat then its hard to have a usefu
by Spivak 8y ago
Let's put aside the "Facebook is evil and therefore everything they do is evil" tangents for a minute since if you're in that boat then its hard to have a useful discussion about this specific feature. And I want to talk about the details of Dating.
Facebook is exactly the right company to pull this off in a way that actually changes the 'industry'. I really want this to be successful and as good as I hope it can be.
* Dating apps live and die by their userbase so we're already doing pretty good there.
* Using the social graph for matches is brilliant since its actually how people IRL do it and you have a built in endorsement system with mutual friends. Having what amounts to an audit trail of "I know this guy, he's cool" gives me a lot more confidence that I'm not getting into trouble.
* More than any other dating platform they have the tools to combat bots and fakes at scale.
* Strongly connecting dating with IRL identity is basically mandatory for safety.
* Facebook has huge potential to make dating safer by knowing when you're together detecting suspicious activity. Integrating their crisis response system would be a game changer.
* Dating apps necessarily collect a lot of user information, there isn't much way around it, and for all their faults Facebook has way more experience than anyone else in protecting it.
* Good on them for removing picture messages, I can't say I'm ever happy to receive unsolicited dick pics.
- jordigh 8y agoSo, can we also have a useful discussion about the evils of this?
- rhacker 8y agoI think the idea was for this thread to exclude that - but launch a new, separate thread if you want.
- LiterallyDoge 8y agoYou don't need to expressly define all cases in an `else` block.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- AJ007 8y agoWell I’m not sure about all of that stuff, but Facebook is definitely going to be able to monetize the ad inventory a lot better than Match Group. Dating app behavior doesn’t look much different to me than people obsessively viewing a Facebook or Instagram feed.
- eksemplar 8y agoAre you sure facebook is the right app though? They obviously have a large user base, but is facebook really being used anymore? This is anecdotal, but everyone in my social circle is considering quitting facebook. They stick around for the same reason I am, because events are planned on facebook, because everyone is there. No one really uses the wall though, and messenger completely died when it started forcing you to use it on mobile and people simply started using other message services because half their friends wouldn't respond until they were at computers. That's not to say facebook the company is struggling. The wall has moved to instagram and a lot of people obviously use watsapp, but facebook itself is almost exclusively a better meetup. Maybe this is different in the US, and it's certainly anecdotal, but it's the story I hear everywhere. The user base is big, like you've said, and that means facebook has better potential than almost everyone else, I'll agree with you there, at least in theory. I just don't think Facebook is really a company with enough vision to disrupt online dating. If they were, they probably wouldn't still be trying to push facebook as their core product, and certainly not at the expense of their new apps that people actually like. I mean, it feels like the world is moving on, and Facebook isn't realising it, maybe because of their company name, but it just feels like they don't have the or any vision anymore.
- forkLding 8y agoFacebook is still being used, the majority of users are between 18 to 44 as can be seen on statista thru google search. However there is basically no young people. Having this dating feature kind of matches with their adult demographic who likely can pay. After all fb is dying with no young people signing up in North America, its gotta find a way out. Note that around the world but not North America and Europe there are still many young people signing up for FB.
- searine 8y ago> the majority of users are between 18 to 44 Yes but what kind of people? The only young people I see on facebook are married couples and kids. Not exactly the prime dating demographic.
- yandie 8y agoI agree on most of the points you raised except this one: > * More than any other dating platform they have the tools to combat bots and fakes at scale. I'm not sure this is true. Bots and fakes are still a huge issue on Facebook. They might have more money to pour into the finding the solution, but doesn't mean they have a good one yet
- sfilargi 8y agoFive out of your seven arguments are directly or indirectly linked to safety. This post right here is something Dating App entrepreneurs should take a note of.
- sfilargi 8y ago> Good on them for removing picture messages, I can't say I'm ever happy to receive unsolicited dick pics. Why? Unsolicited dick pics is the easiest way to weed out the creeps.
- aylmao 8y agoMaybe the'll weed themselves out if the feature is not there ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- alexandre_m 8y agoI'm sure FB has the technical ability to automatically detect dick pics with IR. They should let that in, blurry it and flag it. Then you decide what to do with it, like blocking the sender.... or share the picture to his own wall :)
- searine 8y agoTo play devils advocate : >Dating apps live and die by their userbase so we're already doing pretty good there. The only people on facebook are boomers arguing about politics. Dating is all about exclusivity and compartmentalization. Nobody wants to date in the same place they get happy birthday messages from their grandma. >Using the social graph for matches is brilliant Nobody wants to see their friend of friends on a dating site. Tinder tried this already and it bombed. The current meta for dating apps is to exclude anyone in your contacts or friendlists. >More than any other dating platform they have the tools to combat bots and fakes at scale. This is largely self-policing. Bots are in neither sides best interest so they get reported and removed quickly. >Facebook has huge potential to make dating safer by knowing when you're together detecting suspicious activity I barely want facebook to know my name, let alone when and where I'm on a first date. This, again, is largely self-policing. Meet in public places. Make sure your date passes the sniff-test. Yes there are bad actors out there, but there is also personal responsibility. As for picture messages and data. I don't trust any company and its probably best to keep data from being centralized as best as possible. But that's just my opinion.
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y ago> Nobody wants to see their friend of friends on a dating site. Tinder tried this already and it bombed. The current meta for dating apps is to exclude anyone in your contacts or friendlists. If you exclude your contacts and friend lists and exclude friend of friends, who does that leave? Friends of friends of friends? Complete strangers? I wonder what proportion of couples knew each other directly or indirectly before they got together: "Oh, you know Jack! Yeah, he's by father’s brother’s nephew’s cousin’s former roommate!" Obviously I have no hard data, but it's not too difficult to imagine that couples come together with all sorts of varying prior knowledge of each other's existence. That the current meta is this, doesn't mean that is the most successful strategy for all people at all times. I think dating apps suffer from the public health policy vs. individualised medicine paradox: what might be good policy for people en masse might be terrible advice for any particular individual.
- searine 8y ago
- sandworm101 8y ago>> Dating apps live and die by their userbase No. Dating "apps" live and die by their customers. The bulk of the dating app industry is powered by bots, false accounts and professional "trainers". Some are real, but the majority of the industry is a scam.
- wild_preference 8y agoI don't understand. Bots aren't that big of a deal, and it's not unlike encountering a woman who doesn't want to meet up: you find out very quickly and you move on. Until bots are going on dates and sleeping with you, I don't see how online dating is "powered by bots." You glaze over them the same way you ignore a spam post on a forum.
- sandworm101 8y agohttps://www.scambusters.org/chatbot.html https://www.scambusters.org/chatbot.html >>“Chatbots” — computer programs that use artificial intelligence to strike up conversations with dating site users — enable scammers to “talk” with multiple potential victims at once. They’re particularly active on the Tinder dating app, which employs users’ locations and Facebook profiles to try to link them with nearby online romance seekers. The big takeaway from the Ashley Madison hack was that nobody was actually having any affairs. All those men were paying for a dream. There were next to zero real women on the site. It was all bots and fake accounts. And that company, ironically a Canadian company, was being called a potential pre-IPO unicorn.
- wild_preference 8y agoI'm not sure what you're trying to prove. That article even enumerates the trivial ways in which you can detect these scams. Is email "powered by bots" because spam/phishing/scams happen there, too? Seems like a worthless distinction to me. What about in real life when someone scams you by asking for bus money but they didn't actually need it for the bus? Hell, maybe you even have to mess up a few times before you learn. So what? It's pretty easy to evaluate the utility of a dating service: are you actually meeting people? That's not something bots can fake, yet. Have you actually used Tinder and found yourself talking to a bot enough times for it to challenge your entire objective? Because I have a very hard time believing that just like I doubt you've fallen for an adultfriendfinder "girls in your area" advertisement more than once. Some live, human women on dating apps even ask you to Venmo them some money. Well, you unmatch with them and move on. No dating app can give you an unending consecutive succession of mates that will blossom into an in-person meet-up and then a relationship. Real life can't give you that, either. You already have to deal with the interactions that fizzle out, whether it's someone who never even responded to you, a chat bot that drops you an adultfriendfinder link, or someone you ended up not clicking with after all. That's life.
- cbhl 8y agoI disagree with your assertion that "Strongly connecting dating with IRL identity is basically mandatory for safety." Strongly connecting anything with your IRL identity is a recipe for doxxing and stalking. I think Facebook's biggest challenge with their dating platform will be convincing women that they will both get good matches and be able to stay safe on the platform.
- wild_preference 8y agoSex workers have a screening process that demands your IRL identity for safety. Turns out doxxing/stalking can always happen, but knowing someone's identity still makes you safer. For one, it gives you recourse. In Facebook's case, it also gives people social proof and precisely helps avoid the sort of troglodyte that's going to stalk you. When I see that I have mutual friends with someone on Tinder, I certainly have asked my mutual friend about that person just like you would do when dating through your existing friends, like that woman you met at your friend's dinner party. Also, most dating in human history has happened through immediate social channels where you know someone's identity. I don't see what alternative you're proposing except blind dating with strangers with zero social proof. Yeah, women aren't going to do that for safety concerns.
- wvenable 8y ago> Sex workers have a screening process that demands your IRL identity for safety. This is one-way only though. I'm sure sex workers do not want their IRL identity out in the world.
- mathur 8y agoWhile this is "true", this is already happening. In the vast majority of cases, your match's Facebook profile will both be there and have some public information. Also, a huge amount of the lack of safety from potentially fake profiles can be addressed more systematically and in a more scalable way.
- aylmao 8y agoI don't see as much negative behaviour from people in Facebook, as I do in online platforms which are anonymous. Maybe it's just my friends aren't a meaningful sample of people, or maybe it's that-- since you connect with your friends and a lot of people you know IRL, it's less common that these are people you'd hurt with impunity.
- thoughtexplorer 8y agoMost of your points are about safety and that's a concern many have. I'm curious though, do we know how big of a problem it actually is? What's the probability of an online date being unsafe vs a bar date? How much of it is rational vs irrational fear. Is it more likely you'll get hurt driving on the way to the date?
- jliptzin 8y ago> * Facebook has huge potential to make dating safer by knowing when you're together detecting suspicious activity. Integrating their crisis response system would be a game changer. I didn't realize online dating is so unsafe that this would be a "game changer." Online dating is already safer than (for example) meeting some random person at a bar or party, assuming you first meet the person in public which is an obvious thing to do. Presumably you've exchanged phone numbers or have some kind of identity of the person you're going out with, should you go missing, people know who to look for. I suppose the contact info they're giving you could be faked, and they could be using Tor the entire time, but I'd say someone nefarious like that is far more likely to be picking up drunk people at bars who aren't even paying attention and not even thinking in that direction.
- bobthepanda 8y ago> Online dating is already safer than (for example) meeting some random person at a bar or party, assuming you first meet the person in public which is an obvious thing to do. This is not necessarily true. I've been harassed by people who I've talked to online who have never even progressed to the meeting stage (we talk a little bit, I determine I'm not interested, a meeting never happens). They'll create fake accounts, message from their friends' accounts, etc. because some people don't know how to take no for an answer. People are a lot more willing to harass behind anonymity than to stalk people in person, because the bar and the resulting consequences are so much lower. Plus it's a lot easier to screen people in person than it is to assess potentially fake profiles. That being said, I don't think that Facebook dating is the answer to this.
- lechiffre10 8y agoDating apps are more directed towards younger generations ( Millennials, Generation Z) and if you look at recent use those generations seem to be dropping Facebook.
- kareemsabri 8y agoFacebook already has a dating app, it's Instagram.
- rspeer 8y agoI can't really imagine setting up a date with someone on the social network used by my parents and theirs.
- hellbanner 8y agoDidn't Facebook apps used to include dating apps that would use your social graph?
- gowld 8y ago> * Dating apps necessarily collect a lot of user information, there isn't much way around it, and for all their faults Facebook has way more experience than anyone else in protecting it. Isn't Facebook famous for NOT protecting it? How is any other dating company worse?
- 121789 8y agoFB has a few other things it can bring to the table, too. Assuming reasonable user engagement on the platform: -They can match people with similar interests, or similar friend groups (or test the hypothesis that opposites attract). -They can recommend good places for (individual or group) dates (with advertisers offering discounts). -They could remind you when your anniversary or your SO has a birthday coming up and recommend gifts and locations. -Also, it's actually one area where advertisers and FB users can actually be aligned. If you're just looking for casual dates, you could be recommended new clothes, grooming services, bed sheets (haha), or other things. If you're in a relationship, they could recommend occasional gifts that your SO might like, or restaurants. Plus, they have a ton of experience with combatting harassment. The more I talk about this, the more I think they have a good shot of getting this to work.
- alexandre_m 8y ago"They could remind you when your anniversary or your SO has a birthday coming up and recommend gifts and locations." I don't see how that's a relevant capability for dating. You're not supposed to be dating lots of people at the same time, so you should be able to keep track. Furthermore, these dates should not last more than mere weeks in practice, otherwise you can be sure someone is sitting in your seat. Let's be honest, if your date hasn't let you know about her upcoming birthday, then it means you're not invited.
- 121789 8y agoIt’s relevant because the whole point of the service, clearly stated, is long-term relationships. My point is that not only can they help you out with the initial matchmaking, but they could also help you maintain your relationship. Other products like tinder/bumble/etc are standalone and have to maximize engagement even after their initial matchmaking, but FB does not.
- masonic 8y agothey have the tools to combat bots You mean they have tools to combat bots that they don't bother using on their main site?