3 ms·
If students can discharge their loans in bankruptcy, then what stops this from becoming standard practice on graduation day? After all, a student has no assets
by chongli 8y ago
If students can discharge their loans in bankruptcy, then what stops this from becoming standard practice on graduation day? After all, a student has no assets to auction off. The education they received cannot be taken away from them.
- curuinor 8y agoyes. just have them do it. student loans are fundamentally unsecured loans because they aren't collateralized. amounts loaned should be comparable to credit cards and other unsecured loans, and support of student enrollments should be through grants and scholarships, not loans.
- rhexs 8y agoWhy should that be stopped? That should be part of the risk the underwriters take into account when making the loan. Of course, the outcome of that would be that a large number of degree programs would no longer offer any meaningful loans, and then students would hopefully not be graduating with 50-100K in debt for a gender studies degree. The only way to have institutions underwrite a loan for a degree that has limited economic value is to make the debt nondischargeable. So, you either have nondischargeable loans for these types of degrees, else you start having the difficult conversation that maybe everyone doesn't actually need to go to college. Obviously, one of those arguments plays well.
- jkaplowitz 8y agoThey were dischargeable in bankruptcy until 10-15 years ago. I don't believe declaring bankruptcy on graduation day was ever a standard practice, nor do I see why reversing the discharge exception would change that. By and large, people intend to repay debts they incur, and they don't want to deal with the 7 to 10 years (not sure of exact duration) of bad credit that results from bankruptcy if they can avoid it. Having difficulty buying or leasing a home or car without paying the total cost up front, inability to get those jobs where a credit check is involved, etc... that will never be standard practice by choice.
- ocschwar 8y agoThey have to go in front of a judge. Do that the day after graduation, and the judge will not be inclined to approve the bankruptcy.
- imtringued 8y agoYour threat model is crazy. Yes people can cheat the government but only at a greater cost to themselves. Working 6 years at a good job to do nothing but repay student debts is still far preferable to being bankrupt and ruining the first 6 years of your career. I'm not sure how bankruptcy works in USA but I doubt it is instantaneous. In Germany you have to liquidate your assets and your income is taken (often everything above minimum wage) to repay your debt and only after 6 years have passed is your debt fully discharged if you cannot cover the whole debt within those 6 years. This means that if your goal is to pay less back than you owe you will have to earn below minimum wage which is far more damaging to your career and well being than just paying the debt without bankruptcy. Even if for some unbelievable reason degrees are now worthless and only give you access to below minimum wage jobs then the demand for them will shrink and therefore the cost per degree will also go down until it is possible to pay them via minimum wage jobs. Different degrees have different rates of ROI. When people declare bankruptcy banks have to increase the interest to cover the loss from bankruptcies. If engineering students have a lower rate of bankruptcies because they earn a lot of money then they will pay less interest on their loans which reduces their debt burden and encourages more people to study this degree. On the other hand if a degree has a 30% bankruptcy rate then the interest will rise which increases the debt burden and discourages people to choose that degree. This is exactly the type of situation that calls for a free market solution.