4 ms·
I agree with Andy. It's not up to the company to protect civil rights through limiting the use of their product -- that's the job of the government. If Amazon
by jedberg 8y ago
I agree with Andy. It's not up to the company to protect civil rights through limiting the use of their product -- that's the job of the government. If Amazon stopped allowing law enforcement to use their products, someone else would literally just resell their products, because there is no way you can enforce every use, and you've just kicked the can down the road.
If Amazon really wanted to take a stand on this, they would use their massive size and lobbying power to lobby the government to put in new rules and laws about the use of facial recognition technology.
Not only would that help everyone at once, but it would also protect their profit margins because then every company has to play by the same rules, thus allowing them to justify the expense to their shareholders. It's a win all around.
- hellcow 8y agoIt's the responsibility of all of us to protect civil rights.
- jedberg 8y agoLike I said in my post, I think they should, but not through banning use of their product. They should be protecting civil rights through lobbying.
- jjulius 8y agoSo you think they should protect civil rights through lobbying while simultaneously profiting off of the erosion of civil rights? What about leading by example?
- jedberg 8y agoTelling Amazon to lead by example is about as fair as telling Warren Buffet to "just pay more taxes then" when he complains that rich people don't pay enough taxes. It doesn't work when only one player does it. That's why Amazon should lobby, and that's why Buffet spends his time lobbying while simultaneously employing accountants to reduce his tax bill.
- Larrikin 8y agoWhy is the argument that they must profit off it while legal while also lobbying against it? Why can't they lobby against it and not profit from the erosion of our civil rights?
- drankula3 8y agoLarge corporations have a Board of Directors composed of people voted into the position by shareholders. This means that large corporations need for the most part to do what shareholders want, or else they will be voted out. There's also a matter of business competition. If Amazon stops worrying about profits, leverage, and expansion, that leaves areas that competitors can move in _within their domain_. This is why it seems all the big organizations behave sociopathicly: it's required to be on top. Laws are designed to create limits on corporations to explicitly express how big businesses can behave, and it's not the businesses fault that those laws haven't been keeping up with the times.
- smogcutter 8y agoKant would like a word with you about moral imperatives. If you think something is unethical, then facilitating it for a profit is also unethical. If you don't think it's unethical, fine, but you don't get to have it both ways.
- jedberg 8y agoI don't think using facial recognition is inherently unethical. I think what you do with it may be unethical. That's why government regulations would be much more effective here.
- throwaway4job 8y agoThat is an absurdly stupid argument. Makes sense that a god-awful world-worsening piece of shit like you would make it. Good people should look at you and know, instantly, that they're on the wrong side of history if they agree with you for even a half a second.
- PKop 8y agoWhat about the civil rights of American citizens who don't want their votes and social services diluted by illegal immigrants unlawfully entering into the country? No, illegal immigrants voting directly is not what I mean. But their children vote. Just so happens the fastest demographic growth especially in the lower border states is the same as those which are immigrating illegally. They vote 70% for liberal policies and politicians. Is this fair to American citizens who may ideologically oppose these voters but can't illegally import their own votes to keep pace?
- bognition 8y agoAre you suggesting that it’s not fair for individuals to vote who have a constitutional right to vote? Instead of attacking the constitution I’d suggest critiquing the parties (and their policies) in power.
- PKop 8y agoWhy do you want to cite the legality of 2nd generation voters voting, but not cit the illegality of their parents coming here? It's not fair to embrace law breaking when the consequences disenfranchise 1 party, 1 ideology, along w/ the pressure it applies to wages and social services demands. I'm quite simply stating, it is unfair to turn your back on law breaking that may benefit some people (and of course certainly benefits the immigrant) while harming others, who happen to be citizens the law is designed to protect. Can you articulate to me why you think we even have a law against illegal immigration, before you dismiss my point of view out of hand?
- jedberg 8y ago> it is unfair to turn your back on law breaking that may benefit some people (and of course certainly benefits the immigrant) while harming others Who exactly is harmed by someone coming to this country? They don't qualify for any benefits paid for by tax dollars. They do however pay taxes. So in fact they are a net positive to anyone who is already here. I'm curious how you think they harm a citizen just by being here.
- bootlooped 8y ago> It's not up to the company to protect civil rights through limiting the use of their product -- that's the job of the government. People and companies have a responsibility to behave ethically, whether the law specifies that or not.
- nlarew 8y agoIs there anything inherently unethical about facial recognition technology or does the concern lie in the potential for misuse and profiling by law enforcement? AFAIK Rekognition just takes in a face and spits out an ID that you can use to identify an already known face. This doesn't seem inherently bad to me. Any misuse or profiling in this case is designed, managed, and implemented by law enforcement and the moral responsibility lies with those who create the policy, not a tool that they use to enforce it.
- hcg 8y agoFirst off, I disagree. Any scientist should be aware of what they are building. Second, they actively market to law enforcement.
- nlarew 8y agoFair enough if you disagree! Regarding actively marketing to law enforcement, is there any law enforcement use case that is not unethical? For example, if a facial recognition system is set up to only alert on faces that are listed in the Interpol Most Wanted list is that system unethical? It seems that there's a moral line between identifying faces and profiling/targeting people arbitrarily. It's impossible for Amazon to know how any given customer will use its products before they actually use them so the only reasonable ethical expectation is for Amazon to outline improper uses in its TOS and go from there. EDIT: What if the above facial recognition system doesn't use automated software but instead relies on humans reviewing video feeds and trying to determine if a face matches one on the list? Does that change anything?
- jryle70 8y agoSo marketing to law enforcement is unethical? What about all the database vendors that sell to law enforcement -- Oracle, Microsoft, or Postgres? Can't you see the nuances in that? Law enforcement is the tool designed by the society to maintain the law. That inevitably lead to conflict with civil rights and abuse of power. A healthy democracy needs to protect human rights while giving the law enforcement the tools they need to effectively do their job. Constitution, legal framework, and freedom of expression are essential.
- drak0n1c 8y agoRegulatory capture of facial recognition technology might be a successful tactic - it certainly worked in Oracle's favor with government certified databases.
- femto113 8y agoTopf and Sons made ovens, it was the government that decided what to do with them. Amazon deserves no cover on this: when the buyer uses your products for evil and you know this it is evil to continue to sell them. If they want to stand up at an all hands and make the argument that what ICE is doing isn't evil fine, that's their privilege, but they can't just wave their hands and say its not their problem. And if they did try to make that argument I'll bet a good portion of those 500,000 employees would be disgusted.
- bradleyjg 8y agoWhat about when one of your employees does something unethical and you continue to pay his salary, or have you gone on a tax strike?
- drb91 8y ago> It's not up to the company to protect civil rights through limiting the use of their product -- that's the job of the government. ...and the employees, and the members of the board, and shareholders.