5 ms·
Amazon Execs Addressed Concerns About Rekognition/ICE at All-Hands Meeting
- vorpalhex 8y ago> we feel really great and really strongly about the value that Amazon Rekognition is providing our customers of all sizes and all types of industries in law enforcement Translation: "We are making so much money that we have entirely sold our ethics and will continue doing whatever makes us more money."
- ergothus 8y agoWhat is it about executive-speak? I entered the Google announcement about changes in their sexual harassment with a bad feeling because it started with a very executive-sounding statement that actually left me surprised with what followed. If language creates this negative reaction, isn't that the opposite of the desired result? Or am I just particularly skeptical?
- kopo 8y agoExecutive speak is designed for minimal fallout. But it has other deeper value in maintaining power structures and internal org stability. Any deviations and rumblings from within the hierarchy become very easy to identify if they don't use the same language.
- CobrastanJorji 8y agoI mean, yeah. Amazon's been doing that for a long time. Back in the day, Amazon was very fond of repeating over and over that customer trust and customer loyalty was the very most important thing. Customers absolutely had to know that if they ordered something on Amazon, the right product would arrive on time. A data leak would be seen as an existential crisis. Shipping the wrong product was a customer service emergency. Then Amazon found out how much money it could make from being a third party marketplace and mostly just giving up on quality control. Now nobody has nearly the confidence that the thing they're buying is a real thing. Is that USB-C cable gonna work with your phone? Who knows? Amazon doesn't. But they'll be happy to sell it to you. Turns out that whole "customer first" thing was more of a temporary tactic more than it was any sort of moral grounding. It was a great tactic. It got Amazon to #1 from an era where nobody trusted eCommerce. But they dropped it once they didn't need it. Remember, Amazon's the place that kicked a political organization off of their cloud with no notice because Senator Lieberman placed a quick phone call to Jeff Bezos and suggested it'd help him win GovCloud if he did.
- notyourwork 8y agoThis generalization is a bit over dramatic. Not everyone has problems just because hackernews has articles about mixed lots and other quality concerns. If it was as bad as you say they would not be pulling in the amount of revenue they are.
- Nacraile 8y agoThey haven't sold their ethics because they didn't have those ethics in the first place, and haven't ever seriously tried to pretend otherwise. Amazon is pretty transparently in business to make money, with little regard for anything else. The closest thing they have to ethics is "Customer Obsession", but even that is explicitly justified as a means to maximize long-term profit. I really don't know how this response surprised any of their employees (as a previous employee, it certainly does not surprise me). Those who can't abide it oughtn't work there; this isn't something that is going to be changed from the inside.
- nartz 8y agoDisagree. The technology is out there, if its not amazon, its going to be someone else.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- smurfysmurf 8y agoI watched the all hands today. I just want to comment on the journalism here. For one, whoever this employee is that email buzz feed news is taken as representative to general feelings for all of Amazon employees which is ridiculous. Also the article makes this assertion "Though the company-wide Q&A was not meant to only address concerns about Amazon’s facial recognition deals with law enforcement, it was a major topic on employees’ minds.", which it has no data to back up. One question at the tail end of a 90 minute all hand does not make it a major topic.
- fizwhiz 8y agolooks like you have an ex-Googler working at your company.
- FiloSottile 8y agoSo you are here to tell us that employees don't actually care as much as reported about the ethics implications of their work, and that leadership didn't actually meaningfully address the topic. ... is that meant to be a comment in defence of the company?
- smurfysmurf 8y agoThe comment is not really addressing the topic at hand, just how the article here makes bigger claims than it actually has data to prove.
- FiloSottile 8y agoNot addressing the topic at hand, preferring to discuss technical points is precisely the industry tend that concerns me.
- writepub 8y ago> trend that concerns me. No one cares about what trends concern any one person.
- 8y ago
- saagarjha 8y ago> “I don’t think Amazon leadership addressed the concerns brought up in the question, and I don’t think a Q&A session at an all-hands meeting is enough or suitable for addressing the concerns appropriately,” an Amazon employee, who requested anonymity, told BuzzFeed News in an email. The response given by Jassy during the all-hands meeting doesn't really answer the underlying question, which is "how are you going to stop this technology from being abused". It starts off with "oh, but look at all the good it can do; of course we can't just stop" and then just drops the issue and says "the ToS will fix it".
- thrower123 8y agoIt's bizarre how many people pick ICE as their hill to die on.
- bootlooped 8y agoIt shouldn't be that surprising given the family separation fiasco.
- throwaway4job 8y agoYah, but most of the awful things that ICE does (stealing children on purpose, deporting legal citizens through carelessness) happen to non-white people; and you're responding to somebody who cannot even _imagine_ having empathy for non-whites.
- bradleyjg 8y agoICE != CPB I'd expect people so fired up about this issue to at least understand the basic facts.
- craftyguy 8y agoBoth of them are under "Homeland Security", and their 'mission' often overlaps, sooo perhaps it's more accurate to say 'homeland security.'
- ryandrake 8y agoI dunno, it kind of makes sense. Besides the IRS they probably have the most negative brand association in all of the US government. Their activities, especially recently, make them pretty easy to characterize as the bad guys. It’s not that crazy.
- hcg 8y agoICE is as good an example of the police state as anything else.
- FiloSottile 8y agoPeople with emphathy or ethics can get jumpy about ripping children away from their families. I wish I could still find it bizarre that some people don't.
- jedberg 8y agoI agree with Andy. It's not up to the company to protect civil rights through limiting the use of their product -- that's the job of the government. If Amazon stopped allowing law enforcement to use their products, someone else would literally just resell their products, because there is no way you can enforce every use, and you've just kicked the can down the road. If Amazon really wanted to take a stand on this, they would use their massive size and lobbying power to lobby the government to put in new rules and laws about the use of facial recognition technology. Not only would that help everyone at once, but it would also protect their profit margins because then every company has to play by the same rules, thus allowing them to justify the expense to their shareholders. It's a win all around.
- hellcow 8y agoIt's the responsibility of all of us to protect civil rights.
- jedberg 8y agoLike I said in my post, I think they should, but not through banning use of their product. They should be protecting civil rights through lobbying.
- jjulius 8y agoSo you think they should protect civil rights through lobbying while simultaneously profiting off of the erosion of civil rights? What about leading by example?
- jedberg 8y agoTelling Amazon to lead by example is about as fair as telling Warren Buffet to "just pay more taxes then" when he complains that rich people don't pay enough taxes. It doesn't work when only one player does it. That's why Amazon should lobby, and that's why Buffet spends his time lobbying while simultaneously employing accountants to reduce his tax bill.
- function_seven 8y agoWho's the marketing genius that chose to spell it with a "k"? That just screams authoritarian dystopia to me.
- CobrastanJorji 8y ago"Let's call it 'Cloud Vision.' Oh, shit, somebody took that? Fuck, that was my big idea. Okay, no worries, we'll call it 'Image Recognition.' What, IBM has it AND it's a generic term? 'Cloud Sight'? No? Shoot, the meeting is in 10 minutes. Let's just go with Recognition, but, like, make it different. eRecognition? No, recognitionly? No. Re:cognition, like thinking! Yeah, now we're cooking! Josh, we're naming it Re:cognition!" 10 minutes later, Josh gets his kerning wrong in PhotoShop, and Re:cognition becomes rekognition.
- arthurcolle 8y agoI just searched for Rekognition and found it interesting that two days ago BI wrote this post: https://www.businessinsider.com/amazon-workers-confront-jeff-bezos-facial-recognition-software-2018-11 https://www.businessinsider.com/amazon-workers-confront-jeff... > ... preparing to confront Jeff Bezos Sounds like that went quite swimmingly.
- writepub 8y agoIf the intersectionalists had it their way, they'd ban Amazon from selling any and all services to all agencies and people whose politics they disagree with. They're yearning to stop serving Republicans and conservatives - almost 50% of the population. That's OK, just as long as these intersectionalists are the first to go when revenue declines from their extremist philosophy stops supporting Amazon jobs. I think they should take their activism to it's logical conclusion and start cannibalizing both revenues and operations with their manufactured outrage and activism - only then will this reach fever pitch and force management to openly call this group's hypocrisy out. We really need center of the aisle, common sense to be popular again in this country
- tomjakubowski 8y ago"Intersectionalist" isn't synonymous with "leftist" or whatever you're trying to say. It's hard for me to see how intersectionality is relevant to the subject of Amazon's work with ICE.
- writepub 8y agoIt's VERY relevant - regular Amazonian employees do not care about selling to US law enforcement - the agencies that protect and allow Amazon to thrive and exist. This whole anti law enforcement narrative has been popularized by inter sectionalism - in whose heads law enforcement is full of majority race, privileged individuals oppressing the minorities.
- hcg 8y ago> He added that he thought it was the government’s responsibility to help specify regulations around the technology. That's true but it doesn't absolve them of responsibility. They are choosing their actions willingly, and with full knowledge of the potential consequences. This sort of behavior is inexcusable. It's just wrong.
- Sleaker 8y ago> There is no way to hold leadership responsible in comparison to, say, a letter or email from HR to all employees where a statement is written and more concrete Wouldn't the answer be to just leave your job? Don't support the company if you don't like what they are doing...
- callalex 8y agoWhile I don't want to back up this terrible buzzfeed tabloid article, your argument holds absolutely no water. If the answer to all company injustices was to "just leave your job" why do we need any worker protections/wage regulations? In the real world many, many, many people don't have that option.
- bootlooped 8y agoWorking within systems to change behavior you don't like isn't an invalid approach. In the public sphere we often do it by protesting and voting, not by moving out of the state or country.
- tbyehl 8y agoI don't get why everyone is so riled about Amazon's service. At this stage, the tools to do it are widely available and have been simplified to the point that building a rudimentary facial recognition system is a novice programmer project. It's too late to put this technology genie back in the bottle. Legislation would be our only salvation.
- oliverx0 8y agoI for one think Andy's response is articulate and well explained. The technology does have a lot of potential to do good, and it seems that everyone is focusing on the bad side of it. "Rekognition is actively been used to help stop human trafficking, to reunite missing kids with parents for educational applications, for security and multi-factor authentication to prevent theft." Can it be used for evil? Yes. Should Amazon do its best to prevent it? Sure. But at the end of the day that is the responsibility of the government.
- bitrrrate 8y agoWhat a non-issue. Snore...