4 ms·
Long time mediators are familiar with this. When you drill down attention to smaller and smaller time resolution, eventually you notice that attention flickers.
by nabla9 8y ago
Long time mediators are familiar with this. When you drill down attention to smaller and smaller time resolution, eventually you notice that attention flickers.
Buddhist Abhidhamma sutra describes this phenomenon. Smallest flicker of consciousness is called ceta.
I think 250 ms is closer to vithi (kind of small molecule of mind- moments), than ceta.
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/abhidharma/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/abhidharma/
> We have seen that the Abhidharma’s analysis of sentient experience reveals that what we perceive as a temporally extended, uninterrupted flow of phenomena is, in fact, a rapidly occurring sequence of causally connected consciousness moments or cittas
...
> The Sarvāstivādins use the term “moment” (kṣaṇa) in a highly technical sense as the smallest, definite unit of time that cannot be subdivided, the length of which came to be equated with the duration of mental events as the briefest conceivable entities. There is no Sarvāstivādin consensus on the length of a moment, but the texts indicate figures between 0.13 and 13 milliseconds in modern terms
(My personal subjective estimate is something like to 40 ms)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jchanimal 8y agoSimilar to the time distance of an Elvis style slapback vocal echo. Less than ~40ms and it’s not perceived as a distinct sound, more than ~120 ms and it starts to sound obvious like a reggae dub echo. Same sound perception time constants show up all over audio recording.
- jerf 8y agoI did not know exactly what Elvis-style slapback echo is, so here's the fruit of my moments of poking around: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FuStmPbG528 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FuStmPbG528 About 1:30 long.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bsder 8y agoIt's generically echo or delay. Normally, it's called slapback when it's used for "rockabilly" (yes, basically sounding like Elvis--specifically his guitarist Scotty Moore). People emulating Brian Setzer is the more modern thing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-PY4CSScCKY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-PY4CSScCKY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EW54TX4Pwl8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EW54TX4Pwl8
- dharma1 8y agoWhen playing software instruments with latency, most people say the threshold for percieving the latency is between 10-30ms
- bsder 8y ago> When playing software instruments with latency, most people say the threshold for percieving the latency is between 10-30ms I really challenge the lower end of this. Sound travels about a foot per millisecond. Bands regularly play at 10ft distances. The problem is that 10ms latency on a digital audio workstation generally isn't if you start measuring with an oscilloscope.
- panic 8y agoThere’s a huge difference between the feedback loop of playing an instrument and the one-way experience of listening to a band, though.
- klank 8y agoBands typically are using in-ear or floor monitors. Main PA latency won't affect their playing because it's not what they're paying attention to.
- xelxebar 8y agoOh wow! I just recently stumbled on this in my personal meditation practice. I noticed that it's almost like there's a game loop that periodically hits the CartesianSelfAssertion function. Or something. Everyone I've tried to talk to so far has just given blank stares, so it's kind to nice to run across someone with similar experience. Thanks for sharing.
- Baeocystin 8y agoI've always felt it more akin to garbage collection triggered by hitting a resource limit. (not being sarcastic)
- xelxebar 8y agoWould you mind elaborating a bit? This is something I've recently been trying to get more intimately familiar with and new metaphors are a really helpful rubric.
- Baeocystin 8y agoWith the caveat that I think stretching the metaphor too much further would exceed its utility, my point is only that awareness is not a smooth process, but occurs in fits and starts, slightly delayed from actual reality- it takes time for a brain to assemble meaning from its sensorium. Different parts of the brain can work semi-independently, while other parts are strictly single-use. And 'resetting' one's mental machinery after this kind of interference takes a measurable amount of time, much like the triggering of garbage collection. The Stroop Effect is a good demonstration of this kind of cognitive collision. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EGpzftQf8oI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EGpzftQf8oI https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stroop_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stroop_effect
- justinpombrio 8y ago> I noticed that it's almost like there's a game loop that periodically hits the CartesianSelfAssertion function. Or something. Could you go into a bit more detail? What does CartesianSelfAssertion feel like? How often is it called---on the order of 40ms per OP, or less frequently? Do you notice this only during/after meditation?
- zeta0134 8y agoDoes anyone else notice the length of a moment changing? I especially notice a difference if something causes me to trigger an adrenaline rush; I noticed it a lot when playing DDR and similar, since the physical motion would trigger adrenaline, and then the tempo of whatever I was playing would appear to slow. It was like ... to use a game developer's terms, like my perception was suddenly running at a higher framerate. Of course as a musician this meant the music felt "wrong" somehow after that. "Why is it so slow? Was this song always this easy?" and relatedly, "Why is it harder to move my legs quickly?" etc. This persisted for maybe 20 minutes and then returned to normal gradually. Once I pieced together the criteria, I started to notice that sort of tempo... kind of a "beat" in everything that I do. I feel it especially when I'm visually analyzing a scene, as it's the speed at which I can control my eyes darting about a room. If I'm tired that slows down considerably. The brain is just... so fascinating.
- trentmb 8y ago> Does anyone else notice the length of a moment changing? Sure- a couple beers makes a couple hours feel like a couple minutes.
- justinpombrio 8y ago> My personal subjective estimate is something like to 40 ms This is fascinating. I'm waiting for the time in my meditation practice when I start to notice it. Could you (or anyone else who experiences individual moments) go into a bit more detail about what you experience? Do the moments tend to all be from the same sensory modality (e.g. vision), or are they mixed? If you can tell, does any moment combine more than one sensory modality? How often are there moments of thinking (e.g. narration or a visually imagined scenario), or does thinking tend to end the experience? How isolated do the moments feel: are they like isolated snapshots, or is it like a movie running slow where you can tell that there are frames but they partially blend together?
- certmd 8y agoCannot strongly recommend enough "The Mind Illuminated" by John Yates. https://www.amazon.com/Mind-Illuminated-Meditation-Integrating-Mindfulness/dp/1501156985/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1541648654&sr=1-1&keywords=the+mind+illuminated https://www.amazon.com/Mind-Illuminated-Meditation-Integrati... It's been discussed on HN before (it's how I found it a few years ago) and breaks down meditation in a systematic way while relating the phenomena described in Buddhist texts to current psychological principles. This "moments of consciousness model" of the mind is discussed at length and a short answer to you question is yes, different sensory moments are integrated in "binding moments".
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- justinpombrio 8y agoYeah, I own it. "Binding moments" is why I asked that question :-). I'm partly wondering if peoples' experience matches the book's description, and partly looking for more detail about what the actual experience is like than the book provides. Would second the recommendation though: it's a great book.
- damontal 8y agoHow do you know what 40 ms feels like as opposed to say 60?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Nomentatus 8y agoIf you're used to noticing the dots-and-dashes from flicking your eyes past a 60hz (non-incandescent, say LED) light (each about 17ns apart), - something that happens to most of us many times per day - 40 vs 60 is a pretty obvious difference, and 17ns an obvious measure for comparison.
- Daishiman 8y agoIt's always mind-blowing to hear the precision and scientific rigor of the ancient Buddhist monks from two millennia ago and how they managed to create what is ultimately technology to observe the phenomena that comprise consciousness to the smallest perceivable level.