3 ms·
I wonder when this will spread to other industries? Say someone doesn't pay their newspaper bill. Maybe contact their water company and ask them to shut off t
by jrockway 8y ago
I wonder when this will spread to other industries? Say someone doesn't pay their newspaper bill. Maybe contact their water company and ask them to shut off their water, to encourage them to pay. It's worth a try, right?
I get why content rights owners go to the ISP to get at the ISP's customers who are doing things they don't like. I don't get why ISPs play along. It's extra work, and it makes the customer hate the ISP for being the bearer of bad news.
- usefulcat 8y agoIn this particular case, the answer is rather obvious--the ISP is a content rights owner. Vertical integration FTW!
- jedberg 8y agoThe ISPs are common carries, so they have to play along with the rights owners. A better analogy would be getting USPS to stop coming to your house when the content creators find out you've been mailing pressed DVDs from your house. The difference of course is that you could switch to UPS or FedEx. For 72% of the country, you can't switch ISPs.
- aerotwelve 8y agoI believe the obligation to play along with rights holders comes from the DMCA's safe harbor provision, (which limits an ISP's liability for copyright infringement that occurs over their network provided they cooperate with takedown notices), not from the property of being common carriers. Especially since FCC has ruled cable internet providers are no longer Title II services.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- autoexec 8y agoThe DMCA forces ISPs to play along to some extent. It means ISPs have to have a process that includes termination for repeat offenders. The specifics are pretty vague and AT&T is being very aggressive but believe me ISPs don't want to have to play internet police for media conglomerates. They have to spend substantial amounts of time and money handling massive volumes of DMCA notices without compensation and risk pissing off and losing customers over unproven allegations of illegal activity. It's not a good position to be in.
- adventured 8y ago> Say someone doesn't pay their newspaper bill. Maybe contact their water company and ask them to shut off their water, to encourage them to pay. It's worth a try, right? I can do better than that. Where I live in the US, if you don't pay your water bill, the government can take your home in a forced forfeiture. They put it up for auction to pay for the water bill. If that water bill is for $800 and the home has $300,000 of equity, doesn't matter, they'll steal it just the same. The benefit of having a lot of guns behind you and the legal right to use deadly force to steal property.