7 ms·
If you are stable and not in immediate danger, you should absolutely take a Lyft to the hospital instead of an ambulance. Ambulances are very expensive and shou
by modeless 8y ago
If you are stable and not in immediate danger, you should absolutely take a Lyft to the hospital instead of an ambulance. Ambulances are very expensive and should be reserved for people who actually need them. What if there's a car accident and someone is bleeding out and the ambulance is delayed because it was busy transporting some guy who wanted an ambulance ride for his stable back injury?
- chrisseaton 8y agoIn the UK we have two tiers of ambulance for this purpose. One kind only turns up with basically just a van and ambulance drivers. The other kind turns up with paramedics and full kit.
- willyt 8y agoAlso Paramedics on motorbikes and in cars. Paramedic on a bike gets there quickly and triages/delivers critical care, cars and ambulances are stood down or dispatched as needed.
- michaelt 8y agoBike paramedics stop the time-to-help-arriving clock, which is a KPI for health service administrators. As they can't transport people to hospital and they don't carry strong painkillers they're basically useless if you've got, say, a broken arm.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- PJDK 8y agoIt's a particularly key KPI if you happen to be having a heart attack, which is why the bikes carry defibrillators.
- mschuster91 8y ago> Ambulances are very expensive and should be reserved for people who actually need them. Lol what? It's the job of the state to provide adequate resources (for example, the law in Germany requires that emergency personnel be at your location in 10min tops, on average). Telling people to use an Uber/Lyft/cab due to cost concerns or not enough ambulances being available is bad. Demand proper emergency services funding from your politicians! Obviously: when all you got is a small cut on your finger, fine, take public transport or whatever. But for a back injury?! No way in hell I'd risk my chance in public transport or taxi.
- c22 8y agoLol, in the US ambulances are often run by private companies and the bill is delivered to the patient. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_medical_services_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_medical_services_in_...
- eknkc 8y agoHoly shit. Forget Uber, you better be able to walk to Canada or something.
- slavik81 8y agoIt is not cheap to take an ambulance in Canada. In my province, they cost $250-$400 per trip. You do not call an ambulance unless you actually need medical attention at the scene or en route to the hospital.
- cavanasm 8y agoIn the US, an ambulance trip can cost thousands. Also, if after being treated / examined, your insurance decides you didn't need the ambulance, they often won't cover it.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoMuch better than the alternative where everyone pays and sometimes poor people use them /s
- mijamo 8y agoThe US will always amaze me. If you don't have enough ambulances to cover the interventions then just buy more ambulances. And what kind of ambulances should be used should be up to medical professionals, not yourself. It is fairly common in many countries for hospitals to use regular taxis instead of usual ambulances when they know it will be fine, but it should not be your call as a patient. I guess in the US the incentive of the hospital is just to bill you as much as possible so it makes things different. In many places the incentives of the hospital are just to keep you in good health and do not overspend their budget ...
- modeless 8y ago> If you don't have enough ambulances to cover the interventions then just buy more ambulances There are enough ambulances to cover legitimate needs. Why then waste money by using ambulances to transport people who would be just fine in a Lyft? That money could be better spent on actual patient care. No matter how much money you're willing to spend on healthcare, using it efficiently is always better than wasting it. > what kind of ambulances should be used should be up to medical professionals, not yourself Having medical professionals decide whether an ambulance is appropriate, instead of patients, is one of the main things the article is slamming Tesla for doing.
- xg15 8y ago> Having medical professionals decide whether an ambulance is appropriate, instead of patients, is one of the main things the article is slamming Tesla for doing. Medical professionals who are under orders to ignore their medical judgement and always treat patients as lightly as possible. Also, deciding for yourself not to take an ambulance is one thing (even if questionable). Being forbidden by your employer to call 911 is something completely different.
- blattimwind 8y ago> Having medical professionals decide whether an ambulance is appropriate, instead of patients, is one of the main things the article is slamming Tesla for doing. TFA says Tesla managers made a policy to not involve emergency services. They are not entitled to make either a policy or a decision in this regard. In other countries making such a policy is flat out illegal, telling subordinates to not involve emergency services is illegal and following such directions from superiors is illegal as well.
- hrktb 8y agoSelf evaluation of one’s situation is not ideal though. I remember the “funny” story of the guy who accidentaly stabbed himself in the chest with a nail gun and drove to the hospital thinking “that’s a pretty f*cked up day” It makes for a nice tale, but those people are real, and for every drama queen going to ER for a papercut there is people in serious condition waiting for a Lyft that decides to drive a better client first or stays stuck in the trafic.
- aidos 8y agoIt’s curious how there seem to be 2 schools of thought in this thread; always with the ambulance or ambulance only when required. I’m not totally sure why it’s created such a huge disagreement. Obviously there are some injuries which totally don’t need an ambulance, and some which do, and then a big grey space in the middle where it’s harder to tell. Unfortunately, in some places (like here in the UK), there aren’t the resources to err on the side of caution as much as in other places (by the sounds of some commenters). Being able to have an ambulance arrive within 10 minutes for any situation sounds like a wonderful luxury if you have infinite resources to burn. I personally was impressed they dispatched an ambulance when we delivered our baby at home (on the bedroom floor!). But I also felt a bit like it was a resource that might have been wasted.
- screye 8y agoYou are getting it wrong. There is only one claim, ie. "Ambulance when required". The point of contention is who decides what required means. Tesla has a perverse cost saving incentive to recommend the cheaper option. The person in shock is no position to make a rational decision. It is medical practitioner's responsibility to put his practice before his employer and decide what is a medically appropriate response. The emergency service has an incentive to be deployed regardless of severity. The comments section in general, agrees that a severed finger and crushed hand are sufficiently severe injuries to warrant an ambulance. It seems pretty.obvious to me that lay-managers and CEOs should not be the ones deciding emergency policy. That is what trained practitioners are for and the expectation is that they will hold the org to a certain regulatory safety standard.
- pvaldes 8y agoAre sufficiently severe injuries to warrant a physician, not an ambulance. And the cheaper option for Tesla would be not to hire a team of full-fledged doctors waiting in a room 365 days/year for taking care of any injured worker.
- andrepd 8y agoOne would think that, in the wealthiest country in human history, the answer to the question "what if there's an accident and the ambulance is delayed because it was busy" would be "get more ambulances". Amazing.
- vbuwivbiu 8y agoalso, why not have official mini-ambulance 'carbulances' for just such lower-risk injuries ? They could be Teslas
- zaroth 8y agoMaybe you could hail them with an app and they would show up fast and give you a quick lift to the hospital.
- camtarn 8y agoThe UK does this with rapid responder vehicles - ordinary cars outfitted with blue lights and a limited amount of first aid kit. Some NHS regions also use motorcycles, which would be very good for getting through traffic jams to an accident.
- dnautics 8y agoSounds like it would be a great entrepreneurial opportunity to start an ambulance company that delivers lower costs by increasing the supply.
- neolefty 8y ago
- _Codemonkeyism 8y agoGood look getting a Lyft driver to take you if you bleed.
- tobyhinloopen 8y ago🇺🇸 greatest country of the world people. Well you won’t get rich by giving away healthcare or ambulances apparently
- sctb 8y agoPlease don't troll here, it's not a troll site. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- pvaldes 8y agoThis is common sense, and standard practice. There is not need to use an ambulance for everything and is not even advisable always. Ambulance drivers are customed to drive fast and ignore any red light; they have accidents also. To expose yourself to an increase in the probability of having a car crash because you had a minor injury, or one that is stable and can not really benefit of the specialised services provided by the ambulance, is stupid. Each case is different and must be treated individually.
- tomatotomato37 8y agoBoth options are stupid when you consider the third option: Have a coworker with a vehicle already at the location bring them to the hospital, instead of going into shock on the factory floor as the ambulance/taxi driver makes the trip over there. Actually the Lyft is the stupidest idea here, you combine the disadvantages of ambulances with those of personal transport, with none of the pluses
- tomjakubowski 8y agoIf I'm about to die from shock, I'll take the ambulance responding to an emergency over a random coworker untrained in transporting a dying person driving me to the hospital in their regular car without any lights or sirens.
- athenot 8y agoAmbulances are also used for medical transport. If you as a patient drive yourself to an outpatient cardiology office to get some diagnostics and feel perfectly found but severe blockage is found, the staff will call an ambulance and have you transported to the nearest ED. Even if you are asymptomatic. Fun fact: this will also happen if the ED is within walking distance. There have been cases where an MA was wheeling a seeminly OK patient from a cardiology office to the ED and the patient collapsed in the hallway. That's why it's against protocol. Yes ambulances are insanely expensive (that's another problem). But availability issues are handled by the 911 dispatcher.
- Aeolun 8y agoAm I crazy, or are dispatchers generally able to tell what needs an ambulance and what doesn’t?
- conanbatt 8y agoYou are crazy. Dispatchers cant make complex clinical decisions, even if they were doctors.