7 ms·
Two major research funders to bar grantees from publishing in hybrid journals
- sonnyblarney 8y agoBravo, this is a huge deal, more to likely follow, it rather seems a secular shift is inevitable at least in some manner. One wonders where this will end and what it will mean for classical publishing. In my experience, incumbent industries are more powerful than we'd imagine, and I'll bet that rather than witnessing classical publishing overturned, we'll just arrive at some kind of new equilibrium.
- jillesvangurp 8y agoAgreed, I hope this helps ends the period of time where research funds were funneled to publishing houses by the billions instead of being used for their intended purpose, which is to do research. The time where they provided a useful service is long over. There are enough reputable open access channels now to be able to stop depending on closed access. I expect the next few years, most universities will stop paying the likes of Elsevier except maybe on a case by case basis for access to older articles outside of the scope of these rules.
- matt4077 8y agoElsevier has revenues of $2.5 billion and profits of around $1 billion. Double that to include other for-profit journals and you're still looking at only $2 billion. While that's certainly a significant sum of money, it is but a small fraction of science expenditures: The US (federal) government alone spends around $150 billion p. a. The fact that the latter has shrunk by about a third over the last decades (in terms of % of GDP) leads to my point: It seems that the issue of publishing is easily grasped and evokes some sort of deep-seated notions of fairness (or lack therefore). In turn, it gets a far larger share of our collective attention and outrage than warranted by the numbers alone. The numbers regarding Elsevier's revenue vs profit also point to another often-neglected fact: being for-profit journals and having the luxury of not having to pay authors or reviewers does not mean that nothing of value is added by Elsevier. That misconception is why it often takes people by surprise to learn that Open Access journals need to collect hefty fees from authors. Even Elsevier's profits may not entirely represent saving to be easily realised. Because nothing says that they manage to capture 100% of the value they are adding. In fact, it's very unlikely that they do, considering nobody has ever managed to pull of such a remarkable feat of capitalism. And the problems of switching to open access journals we have seen ever since the idea came up 10+ years ago illustrate this point rather well: We can collective groan whenever publications in Nature and Science are used as a proxy for research accomplishment. But the insistence of smart people to use them as such, when (trust me here) they have heard arguments against that practice myriad times, points at the fact that such proxies are needed, and that none better have yet emerged. Any expectation of reducing costs by switching to open access should probably be discarded. The benefit to be gained is something different, and the movement's name hints at it. In economic terms, it's the "deadweight loss" of the general public being priced out of this market (and the less-general public that happens to work at a research institute not able to afford every single journal subscription). This is the age-old conundrum of copyright: We'd love to let you read this, and we understand that you can't afford its current price. But if we do, anybody would claim the new, lower, price. And the new price/volume equilibrium would not cover the costs of production. Moving to open access is therefore not much different than suggestions for a "cultural flat-rate" or a tax-funded creative industry. It's going to be interesting how it turns out.
- Vinnl 8y ago> points at the fact that such proxies are needed, and that none better have yet emerged. Yes, I feel that this is the core issue: we keep relying on journal brand names as some sort of proxy for a vague notion of "academic excellence". That is what is driving these prices up disproportionately, and which results in publishers like Elsevier being able to capture so much money merely (or at least primarily) for being the owners of those brand names, rather than for actual value they are adding. This fundamental unfairness is what gets people riled up, and what also feels like an "easy" way to increase funding for research, even if "just" by less than one perfect of US federal spending. (Which still is significant.) Of course, there is also the hope that by lowering the barrier to contribute to the scientific process, we can increase the pace with which we do research.
- FabHK 8y ago> But the insistence of smart people to use them as such, when (trust me here) they have heard arguments against that practice myriad times, points at the fact that such proxies are needed, and that none better have yet emerged. No. It points to a coordination/collective action problem. Everyone knows that they should switch away from Elsevier, and if everyone did, we'd be better off, but every single author, by switching, would incur only the costs, and no benefits. Your argument above neglects this. It is tempting to say that the status quo is optimal, because otherwise it would not be the status quo, but it doesn't fly here. And I find Elsevier etc. above-market returns on equity, and capturing more than 1% of public science expenditure, without adding much, quite scandalous. EDIT to add: Sometimes, the coordination problem can be solved. For example, in 2003, nestor of CS Don Knuth managed to pull everyone from Elsevier's Journal of Algorithms over to a new journal, after writing a bitter letter complaining about their pricing: > In 2003, the entire editorial board of the Journal of Algorithms resigned to start ACM Transactions on Algorithms with a different, lower-priced, not-for-profit publisher, at the suggestion of Journal of Algorithms founder Donald Knuth. The Journal of Algorithms continued under Elsevier with a new editorial board until October 2009, when it was discontinued. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elsevier#Resignation_of_editorial_boards https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elsevier#Resignation_of_editor... https://www-cs-faculty.stanford.edu/~knuth/joalet.pdf https://www-cs-faculty.stanford.edu/~knuth/joalet.pdf
- 8y ago
- rotskoff 8y agoCurrently, for "hybrid" journals, the researcher must pay a publishing fee, typically on the order of $2000-$3000. I have an independent postdoctoral fellowship, which means I have some funding, but not enough for it to make sense to pay. These fees essentially lock me out of open access publishing. Of course, I could simply choose to publish only in open access journals (running the risk of career consequences). I hope changes like this will lead to increasingly prestigious fully open access journals. However, I have found the most practical option to be posting my papers on arXiv.
- chrisseaton 8y agoI don't know what field you're in, but in my field, nobody pays to publish, and everyone just puts pre-prints on their websites and everyone seems totally happy with that. Is pre-prints on websites or arXiv not an option for you for some reason?
- Vinnl 8y agoThe final sentence of GP's comment actually mentioned arXiv being most practical.
- chrisseaton 8y agoYes I meant with a pre-print - it sounded like they meant putting them on arXiv instead of trying to publish in a journal at all?
- UncleMeat 8y agoArxiv is not open to all fields.
- Vinnl 8y agoI was responding to a comment asking whether arXiv was an option in response to someone saying arXiv was most practical, so I'm sure that person's field is welcomed on arXiv.
- 8y ago
- Vinnl 8y agoWellcome and the Gates Foundation have long been on the forefront of the transition to Open Access, and it's good (and luckily unsurprising) to see them join the front ranks here as well. Note that the original consortium has already expanded from the initial 11 as well Wikipedia currently lists 14.
- buboard 8y agoSo , they 'll switch some of their major journals to open-access-only and everyone will publish there. The publishing fee remains, and honestly i don't see the progress to better peer review, like for example, publishing of the reviews along with the manuscript
- Vinnl 8y agoThe main reason for this is that the goal of Plan S is not to improve the peer review system; its goal is to make more research openly accessible, and to limit the costs of doing so (it also involves a cap on publishing fees, though an exact amount has not been specified, and apparently Wellcome will not adhere to that part of the plan).
- buboard 8y agoscihub does that already tbh. And arxiv/biorxiv
- Vinnl 8y agoSure, but Sci-Hub is not a sustainable long-term solution, still relies on the traditional paywalled publishing system, and doesn't legally make works available under an open license. arXiv and other preprint servers are limited in their reach. We're certainly not in Open Access utopia yet, and anything that brings that closer should be commended, in my opinion, not criticised for not achieving other goals such as improving the system of peer review.
- buboard 8y agoI don't know. Open access has been advocated for 15+ years, but scihub has the most impact in everyday work. At this point i think we should push for governmental intervention that retroactively abolishes the copyrights for all existing publicly-funded works or otherwise mandates the creation of publicly-accessible copies.
- 8y ago
- Vinnl 8y agoI just read Wellcome's announcement [1], which has this interesting bit: > We will no longer cover the cost of OA publishing in subscription journals (‘hybrid OA’). We previously supported this model, but no longer believe that it supports a transition to full OA. Whereas Plan S, IIRC, explicitly stated that research funded by them could not be published in hybrid journals, Wellcome merely states that they will not cover the cost - implying that well-resourced researchers are still allowed to use other funds to publish there? Another interesting part of their OA policy is that they require organisations they fund to commit to DORA, i.e. to work towards not judging researchers on the names of the journals they publish in, but on the inherent quality of their work. In my opinion, this is the largest problem that is currently holding back the transition to open access and many other problems in science. (Disclaimer: I work on a project that hopes to solve this problem as well.) [1] https://wellcome.ac.uk/news/wellcome-updating-its-open-access-policy?utm_source=twitterShare https://wellcome.ac.uk/news/wellcome-updating-its-open-acces...
- sergiosgc 8y agoFor academia outsiders, like me: DORA is the San francisco Declaration on Research Assessment [https://sfdora.org/ https://sfdora.org/]
- stonewhite 8y agoI have a couple questions due to lack of background and/or perspective in these matters: - What is the new business model that is forced upon these scientific journals? - Also, would this move influence the quality of content in the published papers?
- Vinnl 8y ago- There is no new business model enforced; that's up to the journals to figure out. However, the currently dominant model is an author-pays model, where authors pay a publishing fee ("Article Processing Charges", APCs) rather than readers paying a subscription fee. These funders explicitly free up funds to pay those fees, although this plan does include a stipulation to put a cap on those fees, since they tend to rise uncontrollably. (Although according to this article, Wellcome Trust will not be applying this cap, but will keep an eye on these fees itself.) - There is nothing in these plans that should affect the quality of the content. Open Access journals can maintain exactly the same system of peer review as their subscription-based equivalents.
- richvn123 8y agoFor folks reading this, note that the main thrust of the article isn't quite accurate. Neither Wellcome nor Gates are 'barring' their grantees from publishing in hybrid journals. Wellcome isn't paying OA publishing fees, but it won't stop its grantees publishing in hybrid journals if they could pay the fees another way. It also will support up to 2022 transitional 'read and publish' arrangements that some hybrid journals are striking with institutions. Finally, one can still publish behind a paywall (e.g. in a wholly-subscription or hybrid journal) if one is allowed to distribute the accepted version of the manuscript online at PubMedCentral immediately, under a liberal (CC-BY) publishing license. Meanwhile, Gates Foundation hasn't actually announced what its specific policy as regards hybrid journals will be yet. COI/Disclaimer: I'm a reporter at Nature magazine and wrote this piece on today's announcement: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-07300-5 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-07300-5