4 ms·
Equality of opportunities and equality of outcomes are incompatible as long as the source groups differ in any meaningful way, even "just" in preferences, which
by PeterisP 8y ago
Equality of opportunities and equality of outcomes are incompatible as long as the source groups differ in any meaningful way, even "just" in preferences, which is a very big factor in choice of profession. In order to get equality of outcomes, you would need to enforce inequality of opportunities.
- icebraining 8y agoThe problem is distinguishing the two. People (and not just women) feel understandably cross when they come across real obstacles - which may seem very subtle to others - preventing them from choosing a path, and then hear someone else say it's just a result of preferences.
- sharpneli 8y agoIndeed. It is not easy to always distinguish what is due to obstacle and what is due to preference. However if we say that any difference from equal representation is due to obstacle then in reality we will introduce new obstacles in order to get a end result that is different from preferences. There is no silver bullet here. The obstacles must be found and torn down individually. Making obstacles elsewhere will just make things worse for everyone involved.
- kamaal 8y ago>>It is not easy to always distinguish what is due to obstacle and what is due to preference. That's because even without the role of society, a person's preferences are made out of mental outlook they have developed over time. What one person finds to be impossible, the other person might find it to be perfectly easy to do. There is nothing you do to fix that. That largely depends on personal enterprise and what the person wants to do in life. I have seen people throw away perfectly fine opportunities while in position of advantage. I have also seen people run though opportunity famine, move mountains and earth all to create a small opening some where. Ultimately its just on the person. And most importantly You can't fix people against their will.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoIt's more complicated than that even. If women in a 'perfectly equal opportunity' environment, very rarely 'choose' to participate in some fields ... then those fields will probably develop social and institutional dynamics that make it more difficult. The Canadian Navy did a study in the 1990's that showed if there were only a small number of women on a deployed ship, that they had a hard time, but once there was a critical mass (I think like 8% of the ships crew) - then things were easier. So at very low levels of participation of one group, things can get weird. The Army is obviously an extreme version of this, particularly the Combat Arms, but some other entities might be this way. In particular, startup culture might have this problem - there is literally not enough women (at least apparently) today to form a strong critical mass in the culture and so I do think it's harder for them. Of course I'm not implying that there is necessarily 'equal opportunity today in startups, but even if that were the case, there'd be problems. You see a lot of 'clumping' for example: startups led by women have a lot more women working at them, and tend to be focused in slightly different areas. It's why orgs which traditionally have 'almost none' of some groups might have to change a little to accomodate the first few. Literally today in the National Post (Canada) there's an article about the first male midwife in Quebec and the kinds of issues he faces etc..
- andai 8y agoIf a startup has mostly women, is that a problem too?
- sonnyblarney 8y agoThe issue is not 'mostly' it's 'extremely'. Basically when a system is 98% absent of something, it can be hard for some to adapt. I'm not one for quotas but we should be aware of this. A startup with all dudes might have a hard time hiring their first woman. Maybe they might want to hire a few positions at once.
- piva00 8y agoCould be as I have read reports from men in predominantly female fields (as child care services, nursing, etc.) having a feeling of being outsiders and not really included in the workspace. I don't think we have enough data to imply that though.
- sametmax 8y agoBut it's assuming equality of outcome is what's best. Personnaly, i'm glad i can wear big shorts and not small suits. What makes it harder is that some people don't know what they need and just look at the neighbour's plate and require to have the same.
- pron 8y agoEquality of outcome is not about individuals but about statistics over groups (usually groups that have been treated as such by society).
- sametmax 8y agoWomen and men, are groups. It's not a social distinction. It's a biological one. You don't want a doctor to treat exactly men and women alike, because they don't have the same metabolisms. It's not proven it's the right think to do to give exactly the same stuff to men and women in society either. I get why we are currently trying to promote it, as it makes sense morally, espacially with our history, but we are at the risk of ignoring important needs and spending resources to gain doubtful results.
- pron 8y agoFirst of all, it's certainly not in our nature to fly, and yet building airplanes has been both successful and positive; we commonly fight and beat nature when we believe it's in our interest. Second, it is much better to potentially waste resources on what you believe is morally right, rather than save them and do what you believe is morally wrong. In other words, the two sides here are asymmetric, and the burden of proof is not on the side that wants to do what is morally right. Of course, different people can have different moral values; so while I disagree with those who would say that they don't consider fairness a value (or interpret it in a different way), I don't think they're intellectually dishonest. However, I think that those that try to support their position with a "neutral" natural fallacy are intellectually dishonest.
- aiisjustanif 8y ago
- ekianjo 8y agoWhy would you want equality of outcomes anyway? It goes against individual Freedom. As long as opportunities are as equal as they can be, the rest is just the reflection of what individuals want to focus on and achieve. Equality of outcomes will force some people to do what they dont want to, which is undesirable on many levels.
- gizmo686 8y agoBecause outcomes are easy to measure. Oppurtunity isn't. It doesn't help that we have indoctrinated a generation that there is no fundamental difference between any subgroup, so difference in outcome must be evidence of difference in oppurtunity.
- ekianjo 8y agoSure outcomes are easy to measure. So what feminists have to say about the lack of males in nursing? The lack of males in social services? The lack of males in elementary schools? The excess of male suicides vs females? Are they actually complaining about the lack of equality of outcome in such fields, or are they just cherry picking what fits their agenda ? A rhetorical question.
- UncleMeat 8y agoYes. There is ample work in academia on these subjects and real work happening in activists communities on these subjects.
- Dylan16807 8y agoA rhetorical question that says "I don't understand what feminism is".
- dgzl 8y agoNot that I support this idea, but you can think of this as equal opportunity vs equal equity. Some people might be better off naturally, and others might have created something better for themselves, but equal equity means that those who have succeeded should share the benefit.
- arandr0x 8y agoYou don't need equality of outcomes -- you just need neither group, and in fact, no person (even if they do not fit the group norm) to have objectively bad outcomes. For example, in an hypothetical world where women have a massive preference for raising children, and men have a massive preference for looking at spreadsheets entering boring numbers into them, you would want women to look after children, and men to look after spreadsheets, and neither to be more likely than the other to live in poverty, not have enough to eat, commit suicide, be killed by an intimate partner, or die at 50 of alcohol abuse. (I intentionally chose a variety of gender-linked outcomes in our world -- they're not all cases where women have the bad outcome.) Yes, in order to not get some people to be massively likelier to live in poverty or suffer from depression than some others, you need to treat people unequally. I don't think that's a bad thing. If (and I reckon that's a big if) the main reason women are more likely to live in poverty is them making less money than men, and the main reason they make less money is they choose different careers, then it follows that the moral thing to do is to get them to choose masculine careers, by essentially any means possible. I think there's a lot of room for debate at all points of that argument, though. (On the reasons for the inequality -- but also on what the best way to address those reasons is)