4 ms·
My understanding is that a lot of this abrasiveness on interview day (third interview for me as well) is mainly about judging response and culture fit. I found
by tracker1 8y ago
My understanding is that a lot of this abrasiveness on interview day (third interview for me as well) is mainly about judging response and culture fit. I found out a lot more a few months after my own similar experience with Amazon. I think MS's lot drops are far more egregious though.
The keys are not to let it phase you, stay positive and ask clarifying questions to give clear answers. It's often far more about personality than you may think.
- Aeolun 8y agoWhy would I have reason to be abrasive? Am I expecting people in the company to act like that on a daily basis? Honestly, I just need to know that they can code to the level expected, work together, and aren’t completely looney.
- tracker1 8y agoLOL, I'm not saying I agree with the practice. That said, many of the most impressive programmers I've met were less than typical in terms of personality. Being able to work with all types, including when a person is having a bad or rough day is important. There are times when you've been working 16-18 hour days for a few days and can get cranky. I've worked with all types of personalities. The only ones that ever really bugged me were the excessively arrogant. Some types just grate on you. It's how you deal with and interact that is important. Can you get along with people that are different? Different backgrounds, personalities, cold, super-warm, etc. The culture fit is incredibly important for good or bad. One person can make a team very toxic very quickly.
- rorykoehler 8y ago>working 16-18 hour days I hope not. If so management need to be replaced
- sethammons 8y agoIf that is regular, yeah. I took it as that happens for a few days in a row irregularly. If once or twice a year, one finds oneself (and, presumably their team) in an unusual crunch or fighting fires for a couple of days, that does not strike me as unreasonable.
- watwut 8y ago> Being able to work with all types, including when a person is having a bad or rough day is important. Inability to work with all types here is primary displayed by the "less than typical" personalities through. Not by someone who decides that he does not want to answer insults with "please may I have another one, sir". I understand importance of not being overly sensitive, but so should be valued ability to control yourself and not be abrasive in the first place. Otherwise being asshole becomes competitive advantage in that company. I don't mean to say that less then pleasant people should not be in team, but that criticising them and refusing to accept that behavior should be standard and accepted responses by other people. Including leaving the room or directly defending themselves. > There are times when you've been working 16-18 hour days for a few days and can get cranky. That is planning and organizational failure. Also self-awarness failure. No one is effective at 18 hours a day and demanding that collegues tiptoe around you or and spend effort on your crankiness instead of work is a.) unfair b.) ineffective. If others can't tell you about you mistakes or question you or just have to deal with abrasiveness because you are cranky after sleep deprivation, then it is your fault and you are slowing others down.
- rahimnathwani 8y ago"Why would I have reason to be abrasive?" Interviews are mostly (~80%) about evaluating the candidate for fit. They almost always have a time limit. The interviewers job is sometimes made harder by a candidate who answers a question different from the one asked, or who rambles unnecessarily, or who continues talking after the interviewer is satisfied with the answer to a particular question. In these situations, the interviewer needs to quickly cut off the candidate and move to a different line of enquiry in order to collect enough useful signal during the allotted time. This can come across as abrasive to some people, particularly if it happens multiple times during a single interview. And the impression can be compounded if they feel the interviewer cut them off as they were saying something which would have increased their odds of success.
- specialist 8y ago"Interviews are mostly (~80%) about evaluating the candidate for fit." Interviews in our industry are the chaotic mutant hybrid of "Guess what I'm thinking!" and fraternal hazing rituals. I've been interviewed a few times by self-declared bar raisers. Not impressed. One raiser dismissed outright all my work on grammars, saying the tool (ANTLR) did all the work. Awkward pause. Has he never written a parser? Is he making a joke? Oh. He's serious. Unfortunately, I eventually sarcastically replied "Ya, and the compiler writes all my code for me." I'm not a CS researcher. Our pithy jobs are client/server CRUD apps with some glue. Cut a string from here, paste it over there. Do some validation. Make sure the concurrency scales. Not rocket science. Stop treating me like an initiate. I've been doing this longer than most.
- indogooner 8y agoI don't know if you are referring to Amazon bar raisers but most of them are Dev Managers who don't write code on day-to-day basis. And this is a common problem where they don't understand the technical depth of the problem a candidate has worked but still have most weightage in debrief even on technical strengths.
- mrhappyunhappy 8y ago“Culture fit”. I’m sorry, isn’t this just a term for whether they like or dislike you personally? Sounds like a form of discrimination.
- williamdclt 8y agoIt is a tern for wheter they like or dislike you personally, but I certainely wouldn't call it discrimination. Plus, it's critically important that employees enjoy working together.
- vasco 8y agoIf you ran a company wouldn't you enjoy to work with people you personally liked?
- matz1 8y agoyes, like ability to code in nodejs is also a form of discrimination.
- danpalmer 8y agoThe term “culture fit” sounds very vague, but at many companies there are clearly defined criteria, you just don’t know them. For example, a company may practice test driven development (TDD), and may evaluate for a candidates ability and desire to use TDD as part of their engineering culture fit. TDD is not necessarily better than alternatives, and a candidate may not necessarily be better because they can do it. It might mean passing on better candidates who don’t prefer TDD. Culture fit can cover many different aspects, and most are not about being past a “good enough” bar, but rather valuing the same things as the company. To “fail” a culture fit interview is arguably a good thing as otherwise the candidate may have found working at the company unfulfilling, uninteresting or difficult.
- sifoobar 8y agoMy favorite cultural fit failure was trying to opt out of the weekly mandatory surfing lessons, barely got my wet suit off before I was called to a Friday morning meeting with the founders and told to grab my stuff and leave quietly. No more startups for me, thank you very much.