7 ms·
Crystal City really has so much going for it: 1. As you point out, right next to Pentagon and federal government. 2. Good transportation: right on the Metro an
by hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
Crystal City really has so much going for it:
1. As you point out, right next to Pentagon and federal government.
2. Good transportation: right on the Metro and literally across the street from National Airport.
3. If you're going to have 2 headquarters, having them be on opposite coasts makes sense.
4. And I think another one that is pretty unique to Crystal City is that Amazon and their employees definitely want to be in a downtown, urban environment. However, most of the other cities on the list were either extremely crowded downtown, available sites were actually more out in the 'burbs, or the cities were far down in what a lot of people would consider "2nd tier" (or 3rd tier) cities. Crystal City is basically an urban suburb of DC that you could easily see having a great "vibe" for an HQ2, but still has room for Amazon to build out.
- tomohawk 8y ago> 2. Good transportation Surely, you jest. Yeah, it's on a metro line, but hardly anyone lives near a metro line. That area is consistently rated as the #1 or #2 worst traffic in the country for years.
- CalRobert 8y agoSounds like good transportation with terrible urban planning.
- CamperBob2 8y agoYes, it's always inconvenient and disillusioning when people refuse to live where "urban planners" think they should live.
- mikeash 8y agoDemand for Metro-convenient housing is enormous. Builders are having trouble keeping up.
- CalRobert 8y agoThat would make sense if urban planners were the ones telling people not to live near transit stations, but it's generally existing residents opposing new housing. Though, perhaps to your point, I also am not a fan of almost all planning. The nicest places to live, walk, etc. tend to be ones that arose before planning was widespread. Of course, they existed before the car, too.
- totablebanjo 8y agoWhat are you talking about that no one lives near a metro line? It’ll be on the same line as Shaw which is one of the most desirable neighborhoods for 20/30 somethings in DC right now.
- tomohawk 8y agoMetro serves a tiny fraction of N. VA. Sure, if you're in DC and commuting out, it's probably ok, but people don't tend to stay in DC very long. Once they have kids and realize there is no hope of reasonable public education there, they move.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoYour comment about "nobody lives near a metro line" though - I mean, come on! With the orange line and silver line extension there are lots of places in NoVa near the metro. Yes, the car traffic is horrible, but the car traffic is horrible in SF, LA, Boston, NY, Austin... As another commenter pointed out, there is actually a ton of empty real estate in Crystal City itself and no doubt a ton of it will be built up as apartments/condos now.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- empath75 8y agoInside the beltway is very different from outside the beltway.
- totablebanjo 8y agoI mean, Crystal City is pretty soulless, but a bunch of AMZN cash will make that millenial ready in no time. Also, some nyt writer that’d never been there called it the Brooklyn of DC which was hilarious.
- plaidfuji 8y agoLol @ the notion that Amazon cash will give a city “soul”
- samstave 8y agoPeople who think amzn cash will bring soul, also think....
- mortenjorck 8y agoI think the poster above meant to be a little facetious. I tend to read “millennial ready” as building out a supply of tiny, $2000/mo studios with loads of flashy amenities and terrible quality construction.
- mindslight 8y agoDon't forget the cookie cutter restaurants, properly styled and stippled to create an illusion of not just being yet another bland chain.
- JBlue42 8y agoEdison bulbs, wood, microbrews, and board games on hand. See you at trivia night!
- dvtrn 8y agoI just involuntarily started grinding my teeth reading this entire comment chain, having escaped one such of those kinds of cities in Central Texas. /walks away from the keyboard to avoid ranting about why I got the ever loving hell out of Austin yet again.
- ttul 8y agoAnd to its credit, Crystal City is actually pretty rad. It’s full of highly educated people who can’t say where they work or what they do. But they do have good taste in restaurants.
- rhino369 8y agoMy biggest complaint about crystal city is that the restaurants are pretty bad. One one's above the Crystal City Shops are mostly chains you find wherever business hotels. And the ones on 23rd street are just mostly bad. If I were going to work in HQ2, I'd live in Del Ray, though its more single-family focused. But it has some nice local restaurants.
- rdtsc 8y agoI don't know. Compared to other areas around the country maybe. But with NoVA there are just better places. I remember going there twice maybe and just never had a reason to go back Crystal City. Tons of empty office space for sure though. I think proximity to DC itself is probably the main selling point.
- ttul 8y agoAbsolutely. Government is a huge customer for AWS. Being literally walking distance to the Pentagon is valuable.
- snowwrestler 8y agoAnother major advantage of Crystal City is that it is full of empty real estate. It was built up to house major federal agencies and their contractors, but all the agencies have moved out, and so have most of the contractors. The Patent and Trademark Office had 5 huge buildings; they moved to Alexandria. The Dept of Defense is moving a lot of its employees to Fort Belvoir, and the contractors are following. It's really kind of crazy to have such a major business district so deep in a major metropolitan area, with such low average occupancy.
- Animats 8y agoI knew the USPTO had moved out. Those buildings are half a century old. Does Amazon plan to tear down and rebuild?
- snowwrestler 8y agoI wish I knew what Amazon was going to do! I do believe they have said they want some folks working out of HQ2 in 2019, so that means using existing buildings, at least at first. The USPTO buildings have a lot going for them: pretty close to Metro, dedicated parking garages, and a great view out over the airport. I had occasion to work in one of them in 2011 and it was in fine shape. But even if Amazon does choose Crystal City, it doesn't necessarily mean they'll go after those USPTO buildings specifically. There are plenty of empty floors and buildings in CC to choose from.
- ghaff 8y ago> However, most of the other cities on the list were either extremely crowded downtown, available sites were actually more out in the 'burbs, or the cities were far down in what a lot of people would consider "2nd tier" (or 3rd tier) cities. Yeah, in Boston for example (where Amazon is actually doing some fairly heavy building and hiring in the Seaport anyway), the proposed HQ2 site was Suffolk Downs. That's not out in the burbs exactly but it is adjacent to old working class towns a little ways north. It's not what your typical techie would consider being in Boston. I think Raleigh was somewhere out in industrial parks a decent way outside the city with no transit. Etc. We'll see if this story pans out but the DC area always had to seen as a leading contender. Yes, it's probably a bit pricey but one wonders how much latitude Amazon would have had anyway to pick a cheap location and provide much lower compensation than HQ1 to reflect that. Even if the area doesn't check all the boxes, it checks a lot of them--including the fact that there's a ton of local tech talent and DC is, if not everyone's idea of a dream location to live and work, is at least considered tolerable by many.
- solatic 8y agoIt's debatable whether Metro will be able to handle another few tens of thousands of daily commuters going through the downtown core to get to Crystal City. The system's already crammed up at rush hour and nobody has the budget for capital improvements to start to put more tracks through Gallery Place, Metro Center, and L'Enfant Plaza. It would be interesting though, if Amazon was prepared to invest in capital improvements for Metro...
- bobthepanda 8y agoJudging from Seattle's experience, Amazon is not really prepared to do anything other than garner support from the business community and support a token streetcar. And Metro's capital needs are probably much bigger than Seattle's and are politically more complicated due to three jurisdictions that are frenemies in the best of times.
- mikeash 8y agoMore like twelve jurisdictions. The various counties and cities also get involved. It’s quite Fun.
- bobthepanda 8y agoI was just talking about the board. It's worth noting that Seattle and DC have vastly different representations on their boards. In DC this is two representatives picked by the governments of DC, VA, MD, and the feds each, and in some cases not even appointed by elected officials. In Seattle, this is a board consisting almost entirely of elected officials of counties and municipalities. Seattle's method works because the responsibility of elected officials is quite clear and their voting records are transparent, whereas a diffuse chain of responsibility via appointment is not.
- Fomite 8y ago"It would be interesting though, if Amazon was prepared to invest in capital improvements for Metro..." Narrator: Amazon wasn't.
- 8y ago
- nova22033 8y ago> Good transportation: right on the Metro Found the guy who doesn't live in or around DC...
- Fomite 8y agoI lived in DC and rather liked the Metro...
- PopeDotNinja 8y agoI love how easy it is to get to National on the Metro. I took public transit to Dulles once, and that was notably less easy.
- mikeash 8y agoDulles will be connected to Metro in 2020.
- gammarator 8y agoIt will still take forever to get there...
- JPKab 8y agoI lived in Crystal City for a few years. Perfect place for it.