8 ms·
First people get kicked off their platforms "build your own platforms" Then platforms got kicked off the platform platforms "build your own platform platforms"
by im3w1l 8y ago
First people get kicked off their platforms "build your own platforms"
Then platforms got kicked off the platform platforms "build your own platform platforms"
What reason is there to assume those platform platforms will not get kicked off the platform platform platforms?
These people are not arguing in good faith.
- amputect 8y agoWhat's the alternative to "build your own platforms" though. Are you willing to compel Stripe by threat of force to keep processing credit cards for nazis? Are you willing to completely torpedo freedom of association, as long as the people demanding your company continue associating with them are sufficiently monstrous?
- comex 8y agoNo need to jump to the idea of compulsion. If there were an established social norm that "platform platforms" should make an active attempt to be viewpoint-neutral, chances are that enough of them would voluntarily follow that norm to allow platforms like Gab to continue operating. If the norm isn't established, well, good luck passing a law to force anyone to follow it. Right now, the trend seems to be against such a norm.
- oh_sigh 8y agoAnd - how or why would I care that stripe processed infowars transactions, unless I was actually in the process of buying something from infowars?
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoThe issue isn't whether you in particular care or not. The issue, as I'm reading the parent comment, is that it's beginning to appear that no one is willing to stand up and say "look, it's not that I support this or that view, it's just that, well, if people are going to spout nonsense it might as well be here where can all observe them", because doing so would be so against current social normal it would be irresponsible.
- _iiu1 8y agoWhy should "platform platforms" establish a norm attempting to actively appear "viewpoint neutral"? "come a little closer mouse so that I may better catch you and eat you..." Why on earth should society bend over backwards to aid spoiled deliberate attention-seekers when there are 7 billion other people who are actually trying to resolve problems that need our actual attention. These "malingerers" are using up valuable medical staff's time they could be spending upon actually ill patients!
- comex 8y agoI'm not sure what you mean about medical staff. I'm not suggesting that anyone bend over backwards to aid organizations like Gab, merely that they don't go out of their way to ban them merely because they don't like them. For example, in the case of Stripe and PayPal, there doesn't seem to be any suggestion that Gab falls under any of the normal categories that would cause a financial services platform to ban a merchant – e.g. suspicion of fraud or money laundering, high chargeback rates, high rates of fraud among people giving money, anything like that.
- alexanderwept 8y agoIn America, we accepted that when we decided 'disparate impact' was sufficient basis for establishing civil rights violations. If employers can't use IQ tests because some racial minorities 'underperform' then why not force those same employers to tolerate every view that's legal to own.
- hakfoo 8y agoWhat makes the 'deplatforming' threat viable is that so many critical aspects of an online business are a choice between private-enterprise players. Stripe or Authorize.net. AWS or DigitalOcean. GoDaddy or Namecheap. As you suggest, they have no individual legal obligation to serve a business that may cause bad press/high risk/whatever. But when you can enough of them pointing in the same direction, it creates the chilling effect-- a business that's technically legal but can't get the services they need. It basically creates am unspoken private regulation well beyond the actual law of the state. I tend to think the answer might be non-profit or state-run "service providers of last resort" -- charter-bound to provide service for any legal purpose, no matter how distasteful. Not necessarily cheap or slick, but they won't pull your plug because people complain about your content. Such a provider would defang the deplatforming strategy pretty fast.
- nradov 8y agoI don't want my tax money used for that. Not because I object to the content, but because it's a waste of money and government officials have more important things to focus on.
- pjc50 8y agoAh, state-hosted platforms calling for the extermination of Jews. It's not exactly Radio Free Europe, is it?
- joshuamorton 8y ago> But when you can enough of them pointing in the same direction, it creates the chilling effect-- a business that's technically legal but can't get the services they need. It basically creates am unspoken private regulation well beyond the actual law of the state. Yes, but this is how the free market works. That my $.25 artisanal dog cupcake business can't get the services it needs at the price I can afford doesn't raise complaints. But when we replace dog cupcakes with Nazi chat rooms, suddenly we need the government to step in and subsidize a business which the market has shown is not worth it. In economic terms, the "distaste" of a client is an externality, and there is an increase in price associated with that externality. If the company can't afford it that's just the market at work. So the government providing a platform like this is just the government subsidizing business with negative externalities that the free market was correct tly pricing. It's like subsidies for strip mining or fracking or rhino poaching. But this is something you support in this case. It's odd to me. > I tend to think the answer might be non-profit or state-run "service providers of last resort" -- charter-bound to provide service for any legal purpose, no matter how distasteful. And what if my distateful venture needs redis or windows 10 or a spanner like distributed database, or whatever other service your unflashy system doesn't provide? Then either I can't get off the ground anyway, or you require that the government service maintain feature parity with all the others, neither of which seems viable.
- zimablue 8y agoThis is such a common thing that you're doing. There are four levels of power (kind of) => government, employer, social, individual. Whenever you're in an argument, assume that the other side is advocating for the top level to enforce something so you can call them oppresive, and claim that you're advocating for the bottom level (and that that level should be free to do as it likes). Nothing in this article mentions passing a law and he even mentions several times that it's within their rights. It's therefore clearly discussing level 3 and 4 (trying to effect cultural change at the level of the individual. For you to weigh in as if he's arguing for passing an insane freedom of speech is disingenuous.
- jasode 8y ago>Nothing in this article mentions passing a law [...] For you to weigh in as if he's arguing for passing an insane freedom of speech is disingenuous. I think you've inadvertently overlooked how the 3 parent replies above you were discussing hypotheticals. In other words, each reply tried to elaborate what the alternate universes of free/censored speech might look like: - evrydayhustling's hypothetical: "What would it look like for an "anti-deplatforming" initiative to succeed? [...]" - im3w1l's hypothetical: "What reason is there to assume those platform platforms will not get kicked off the platform [...]" - amputect's hypothetical: "What's the alternative to "build your own platforms" though. Are you willing to compel Stripe by threat of force [...]" Commenters can bring up hypothetical laws or attempt to predict hypothetical outcomes even though the article itself doesn't mention creating a new law. (It's also possible that the middle reply in the chain of hypotheticals by im3w1l was misinterpreted as a call for a government law even though he doesn't explicitly state it. Sometimes people read between the lines and misconstrue the commenter's intent. It does seem like im3w1l's statement of "These people are not arguing in good faith" is implying that the mechanisms of the free market and free association wouldn't work for marginalized ideas. Therefore, it's not unreasonable to assume that the alternate universe he's thinking of that would work would be a government law that prevents de-platforming.)
- atq2119 8y agoI agree with you, but your four levels really need to be refined by a fifth level, corporate power. That is, power that is wielded over you by corporations even though they're not your employer because you essentially have to do business with them (Visa and MasterCard come to mind - they're essential infrastructure to the point where it really should just be a function of government, but isn't for historical reasons)
- OpenBSD-reich 8y agoFreedom of [dis]association has already been torpedoed. If political leanings were protected tomorrow like sexuality and sexual orientation are protected today, it'd significantly reduce the deplatforming. Joyent couldn't deplatform for politics anymore than christian* bakers couldn't refuse gays their cake! Interestingly, political opinion is not something protected in progressive-pushed instruments (take the Creative Covenant's CoC for example). If the right got smart, it'd modify the legal devices of civil and sexual rights to include political rights, or at least strip legal liability protection from political deplatformers (moderate a little -> then moderate in totality). *I'm a fedora tipping Atheist.
- drewbuschhorn 8y agoMakes you wonder why they haven't, despite controlling all three branches of government.
- KozmoNau7 8y agoBut they don't want that. They want to silence opposing viewpoints, not protect them.
- ryanlol 8y ago>What reason is there to assume those platform platforms will not get kicked off the platform platform platforms? Why should we assume that until someone gets kicked off the platform pltaform platforms? Platform platforms intended exclusively for uses commonly considered undesirable have been successful in the past, see namecentral.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- evrydayhustling 8y agoYou are mistaking "good faith" for satisfying others' entitlement The spirit of your complaint here is "there should be a reasonably easy path for me to widely distribute my message without getting the rug pulled out from under me". There is exactly one way to distribute your message, and whether it is easy or hard is up to you. That is: satisfy the requirements of every platform you build on top of, and fill in the rest by creating your own infrastructure and audience. I believe in common spaces, and like I said I am glad that if you drill down far enough you will find distributed* protocols that aren't opinionated about your content. Feel free to start there and build an ecosystem and audience - that is how the world discovers who wants to participate in a particular kind of dialogue. The * is that of course central censorship exists at the Telecom and government levels. I (directly) support distributed private protocols to ensure that people can choose to find the information they want as easily as possible. But doing so emphatically doesn't and shouldn't guarantee you an audience.
- logifail 8y ago>> satisfy the requirements of every platform you build on top of This sounds simple, until you realise the requirements aren't well-defined, or that the definitions can be changed arbitrarily (and retroactively) by the platforms.
- evrydayhustling 8y agoNo argument, and it wasn't meant to sound simple -- just depends on how deeply you are aligned with the goals of the platform. I agree from painful experience that platforms can be capricious and even disingenuous. But that's also part of how they adapt to a changing world and business. Still boils down to: nobody said it would be easy (to get others' attention).
- logifail 8y ago"We're shuttering our API" (which kills your business model) is very concerning if you're the business that's just been torpedoed. "We don't want your sort on our platform because reasons" ought to be concerning at a much wider level (and not just to the sort that apparently aren't wanted on the platform).