3 ms·
I can only skim a nearly 300 page book but I get the impression that the basic point is that, done right, computers can be an amazing tool to allow a child's na
by joe_the_user 8y ago
I can only skim a nearly 300 page book but I get the impression that the basic point is that, done right, computers can be an amazing tool to allow a child's natural impulses to play and exploration to grow and flourish.
Seems reasonable enough. So what went wrong to the point that today, primary advice to parents wanting to encourage growth in their kids is to remove the computer completely?
This also is connected in my mind to the period where learning to program was connected to basic literacy but now just avoiding the computer until one is old enough to handle it is closer to a road to basic literacy.
Is there a different way we can take this.
- amatecha 8y agoI think the suggestion to remove the kids' computer arises out of the expected likelihood that the kids will just load up Facebook, YouTube, Twitch etc. and install Steam, and never engage with anything other than those activities. When I was a kid and I spent hours on the computer, none of that stuff existed, and it was difficult _not_ to learn interesting things because the primitive nature of the computers forced me to figure out a lot of non-obvious things. I wanted to play computer games too, but sometimes I had to figure out pretty advanced troubleshooting processes to even launch a game (for example).
- ryrobes 8y agoSame. Had a Commodore 64 hooked up to a CRT in the living room. Thinking back - "a programming language as an 'operating system'" is actually still very cool idea for those reasons you mention above. Hell, even moving foward - in the 90s using DOS - you had to be somewhat computer literate to get anything to run well (esp games those days which bundled their own hw drivers, etc). HIMEM.SYS, different system boot files per application, etc. In some ways things are much better now... in some ways they are far far inferior. This mini-dichotomy reminds me of Rich Hickey's "Simple and Easy" talk. Much in favor of more Alan Kay, Bret Victor, Doug Engelbart type ideas coming to market as opposed to being "locked" (somewhat) in academia.
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoWhat went wrong is that these systems were designed by extremely smart CS PhDs who massively overestimated the abilities of the average human. Papert, Kay, etc, are all world-class smart, capable, and inventive people. They designed these systems in their own image, probably with a more or less conscious desire to build something they would have wanted in their own childhoods. An average human with average abilities doesn't have the cognitive horsepower or the creativity to get much from these systems. They can play with them in a fairly superficial way, but only a relatively small proportion - I'd guess less than 25% - will get excited by the ability to imagine and build their own systems. Without that excitement there's no motivation, and without the motivation any kind of programming becomes an exercise in pointlessness. So - you can move a pointer around and draw lines? By typing words? Cute. But so what? Why should I care? The real challenge - much harder than designing computer software - is working out political and educational strategies that reach the (nominal) 75% who don't find that kind of problem solving particularly interesting. I've literally just been reading Kay's mini-book on the history of Smalltalk. Here's a quote on literacy: "Literacy, for example, is being able to fluently read and follow the 50 page argument in Paine's Common Sense and being able (and happy) to fluently write a critique or defense of it. Another kind of 20th century literacy is being able to hear about a new fatal contagious incurable disease and instantly know that a disastrous exponential relationship holds and early action is of the highest priority. Another kind of literacy would take citizens to their personal computers where they can fluently and without pain build a systems simulation of the disease to use as a comparison against further information." This sounds perfect, but I think the experience of almost everyone who has been to school knows that a fair proportion of their age cohort not only can't think at this level, but has absolutely no interest in being able to. You might - possibly - be able to do something about this with a historically unique social engineering program supported by a media campaign that made abstract skills appear desirable and heroic. (A version of this happened during the Cold War, kind of.) But even then, it's not obvious from history just how far you could take that. Either way, technology on its own is never going to be a solution. It may support policy, but it's never going to be powerful enough to enlighten the surrounding culture. What actually happens is that economic and political pressures steer technology towards offering simple - often poor, but understandable - solutions to common problems. Worse wins out over better, and over time the possibilities shrink instead of expanding.
- err4nt 8y agoI've not finished the book yet, but I'm partway through it. I can share an anecdote from my own adult experience. I have played around with coding (HTML/CSS/game modding/etc) a little bit for many years, but I will admit I knew very little of "programming" until after I was an adult, after college. I learned programming through learning JavaScript, and once I got a tiny foothold on the language I went through and did a number of explorations: - string formatting (outputting song lyrics that contain predictable patterns, usually kids songs) - calculating simple math problems like restaurant tip split between friends, or final % abv of a mixed drink of two liquids with different volumes and different %abv - using randomness to generate simple things like images or natural language based on a variety of inputs - producing sound via web audio APIs and reaffirming music theory (notes, harmony, scales, musical instruments like theremin and piano) - creating very basic games with a simple event loop - creating very basic turn-based games like hangman - recreating a number of dead-simple mobile apps: reminder list, memo pad, clock, etc As I learned to program, I basically went through each aspect of education I had learned as a child and teenager and not only reaffirmed and brushed up what I thought I knew, codifying it into executable code I could demonstrate and show to others - but I expanded what I knew by harnessing language + math together in an interactive environment. Personally, I see the computer as an AMAZING tool for thinking, but that's only if you're the one writing the software. Computers for kids are as good an idea as literacy, and numeracy - it's like the next level of literacy where your thoughts come alive. However, just like how literacy is a huge benefit to any child, reading trash literature is bad. I think we need to stop lumping all computer use into one category. Perhaps there's little benefit to some uses of a computer, like using software written by others, or using it for little more than a television set…but computers as a tool for mind-expansion are unbeatable with any other tool we have. We need to teach kids how to be COMPUTER users, not SOFTWARE users. It's when you are the person writing the software that you're fully using the power of the machine.