9 ms·
While iPhone sales remain stagnant, Apple services hit $10B in revenue
- gehsty 8y agoStagnant is not a fair way to describe selling 46.8 million iPhones.
- ekianjo 8y agoStagnant does not mean anything in absolute, it describes a relative trend.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoI'm amazed at how many people in this comment section have taken issue with such an innocuous word.
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoIt's not really innocuous, it is fairly typical for a headline though. It's designed to draw you in. No doubt the use of stable instead of stagnant would produce less clicks.
- nounaut 8y agoStagnant implies it's not growing, not that it's not selling.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sleepychu 8y agosteady, level, imply the same thing but as a positive. I think it's just a matter of perspective whether Apple needs to grow its iPhone sales. That said they must surely decline, the number of people who are going to continue to drop 1k+ on the new iPhone every few years is going to be limited by the resale value of last years phone, a market which (anecodtally) appears is droping precipitously.
- chongli 8y agoStagnant carries a connotation of some dark, oxygen-deprived mire that suffocates fish and smells horrible. It invokes images of death and decay. Not exactly the idea I had in mind when I hear of the sales numbers.
- onion2k 8y agoNot exactly the idea I had in mind when I hear of the sales numbers. The global market size for mobile phones is still growing. If Apple's sales aren't growing at least in line with the size of the market then their market share is shrinking. Selling a lot in a stable market is great. Selling a lot in a growing market is ... less great.
- akvadrako 8y agoWhat market are you talking about? Apple is only in the premium phone market.
- bunderbunder 8y agoIs Apple even looking to ship huge volumes of new units to emerging markets? An alternative strategy would be to preserve their cachet in order to preserve their cachet and remain an aspirational product. Once your brand starts taking on the characteristics of a Veblen good, the rules start to work a bit differently. It hasn't, thus far, been a losing strategy for Mercedes Benz to not have a direct competitor to the Honda Civic.
- gehsty 8y agoNegative connotation, try telling your partner their attractiveness has stagnated if it has stayed the same. A fairer way would be to state the iPhone sales have simply not grown. Do you think Apple should be concerned about the lack of growth?
- Kurtz79 8y agoIf previous sales were about the same numbers, it's a perfectly fair way. Impressive, amazing numbers maybe, but still stagnant, if they didn't improve over the last ones.
- IMTDb 8y agoStagnant has a very negative meaning attached to it. The author could have used words like "constant" (neural) or "steady" (positive). He chose to use "stagnant" and deserves to be called for it.
- xxs 8y agoThe use of stagnant is correct, as for negative the share price affect is immediate as it includes an expected growth.
- Retric 8y agoApple’s P/E of 20.13 does not suggest people expect significant growth. Inflation + 5% returns is a reasonable investment even without increased unit sales.
- Kurtz79 8y agoWhy? Stock price plummeted after the results, and I doubt market analysts were influenced by that specific article. The market clearly agrees on the assessment that the sales are "stagnant", negative connotation included. Which is not surpising since the stocks are priced taking into account potential growth, rather than present results. "Constant" or "steady" I would expect from Apple PR wording... (And I have no beef with Apple, my brother works there and I'm a satisfied customer, for all that matters).
- rickdg 8y agoIt's all about the #donglelife and getting everyone to pay for having an ios app.
- tpetry 8y agoStagnant sales with a much more expensive smartphone, i don‘t think anybody wouldn‘t live to have the same „problem“.
- chvid 8y agoPrice hikes and strong dollar should kill them; but it does not.
- diminish 8y agoMany analysts thought higher average selling prices were possible because of demand inelasticity at the forerunner iPhone. Service revenues would get boosted by lower prices if units sold increase. Cook is doing a fine balance of prices, sales, services. Very successful so far. Yet I'm afraid the only way is down from here.
- homarp 8y agoYou write that it can only goes down, but at the same time you hint that a lower priced devices would boost service revenues. So isn't the next step a "cheaper" iphone ? (or a better second hand market 'certified by' Apple)
- diminish 8y agoYes I think so. Apple Management had better data and tools to make the fine decision. Fact is that smartphone market saturates.
- tguedes 8y agoWhy down? If iPhone sales remain stable, which they should, iPhone customers are extremely loyal; as long as they continue to grow in their Other and Services category, there will be a lot of growth for the company. Plus whatever device that comes out for AR will be interesting. Apple still continues to understand strategy and the technology landscape better than any other company.
- 8y ago
- hacker_9 8y agoI mean sure 'Stagnant' means that there was no growth, but it also implies that this is a bad thing, which in this case it obviously isn't. Clickbait title.
- cm2187 8y agoHow high do you think they can go in term of prices? And do you think they will sell many £1000 smartphones in a recession? Stagnant volumes is not an imminent problem but the share price is a forward looking metric.
- alexis_fr 8y agoA $600 mass phone in 2007 was difficult to imagine. And 2008 was the recession.
- cm2187 8y agoYeah, but that's the point of the market saturation. Apple (or Google for ads) achieved a phenomenal growth despite the recession because they were taking over a market. But now that the market is saturated, there won't be a growth in volume to offset difficult economic conditions.
- pdpi 8y agoI’d argue that £1000 phones are less affected by a recession than £400 phones
- cm2187 8y agoI think that classifies them as luxury products, which historically tend to be pro-cyclical.
- ForHackernews 8y agoiPhones might be a Veblen good. They could probably release a $5000 or $10,000 model and there would be a market for it. Plenty of people buy $50,000 watches.
- howlingfantods 8y agoThe average sales priced for an iPhone increased nearly 30% from $618 to $793. Services now account for 16% of revenue. Apple is gradually shifting from a device maker to an ecosystem company that consumers pay a premium initial fee to enter and pay an additional recurring free to use.
- jillesvangurp 8y agoAn ecosystem requires a user-base. Shrinking volumes means less users. Short term raised ASPs mean of course they don't suffer in terms of revenue. However, that may be a short term effect.
- diminish 8y agoYet services would be better if units sold gets increased. So cheaper models are a must. So it's so far an excellent strategy milking the high end keeping the units sold not fall.
- howlingfantods 8y agoServices might be better, but I suspect that budget conscious consumers would also spend less on services, compared to customers willing to spend $1200 on an iPhone XS. I imagine their FP&A team has done pretty thorough analysis that the extra sales from fewer products at higher margins will offset the incremental increase in revenue from more (potentially lower value) services subscribers.
- decasteve 8y agoThis is also true if people keep their devices longer — which seems to be the case from what I’ve been seeing. The low end now seems to be previous generations phones like 7/8.
- bunderbunder 8y ago> Yet services would be better if units sold gets increased. I'm not sure that follows. Apple's a very different company in many ways. Notably, by being dominant in a relatively deep-pocketed userbase, they don't need to worry about the "our profit margin is near zero and likely to shrink further so we have to grow just to stay alive" red queen's race that so many other tech companies find themselves in.
- beerlord 8y agoApple takes a 30% commission on any revenue passing through the store, and 15% on subscriptions. These fees are exorbitant - they are merely ringing a credit card, transmitting a few megabytes of data, and performing a basic examination of the app itself. The oligopolistic position that they hold is their main point of value.
- Cthulhu_ 8y agoNot entirely true. Stores are also the first point of contact for support and warranty. I know Apple resellers nearby also offer (free) courses to get acquainted with apple devices and applications.
- ericcholis 8y agobeerlord is referring to the app store
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoWhich still has terrible search. It’s nice that it’s a bit prettier than it used to be. But it still has terrible search. I wouldn’t mind the 30% if the store made it easy to find relevant apps. But it utterly fails at useful high quality discovery.
- gehsty 8y agoIts also ironic apple are suing Qualcom regarding licensing fees which are paid as a percentage of the hardware cost, as they believe that this means Qualcom profit from apples innovation unfairly, you could argue that Apples policy is the same with the App Store - why do they get a percentage? They add no extra value for high value transactions, surely a low fixed fee would be more aligned with apples values :)
- bunnycorn 8y agoBecause most of the R&D that Qualcomm does (and as a fabless, IP is their real business) ends up on Android phones, while Apple pays the biggest slice. Therefore, they are getting their chips from Intel. Apple doesn't have anything to do with Qualcomm anymore, they get the package from Intel. Qualcomm can battle Intel in court if they want. Good luck for them...
- GeekyBear 8y agoGiven that Samsung just reported a 33% drop in smartphone sales from the same quarter last year, Apple reporting a .4% increase in their smartphone sales vs the same quarter last year sounds pretty good. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/2018/10/31/samsung-reports-record-profit-despite-smartphone-sales-slump/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/2018/10/31/samsung-re... https://www.anandtech.com/show/13540/apple-announces-q4-fy-2018-earnings-revenue-up-sales-not https://www.anandtech.com/show/13540/apple-announces-q4-fy-2...
- slivym 8y agoI think we should attach an important health warning. Samsung release their S9 in March 2018, whereas Apple released the iPhone X in November. So this quarter is the drop from Samsung's first full quarter of their new flagship sales to one year later. Apple's quarter is the drop from the last full quarter before their new flagship to a quarter where they released a new flagship.
- GeekyBear 8y agoBoth companies have a similar release schedule every year, which is why we compare to the same quarter a year ago. Unfortunately for Samsung, falling smartphone sales figures have been an ongoing problem. >Samsung’s mobile phone sales have been taking a hit this year. It’s a downward trend that started during last year’s holiday quarter and has persisted throughout 2018. Both IDC and Strategy Analytics report that Samsung’s smartphone sales have dipped around 13 percent in the recent quarter. That follows a 10 percent decline in Q2, a 2 percent drop in Q1, and a 4 percent dip in Q4 2017. It’s a clear sign that Samsung’s Galaxy Note 9 and Galaxy S9 devices haven’t been competitive at the high-end https://www.theverge.com/2018/11/2/18055094/samsung-smartphone-sales-decline-2018-report https://www.theverge.com/2018/11/2/18055094/samsung-smartpho...
- slivym 8y agoI don't think that it's fair to say that Apple's release schedule has been similar between now and the previous year. Last year the iPhone X was announced in September and released in November/December (by region) and it was arguably the biggest upgrade Apple made since the iPhone 4. So it's fairly obvious that Q3 2017 was an almost uniquely low year. Compare that to Q3 2018 where Apple announced AND shipped the iPhone Xs in September. I don't disagree that there's a larger trend going on, I'm just saying that this isn't a particularly good data point because there are other underlying factors.
- mirekrusin 8y agostagnant /ˈstaɡnənt/ – showing no activity. so they're selling 0 iphones? really?
- abrowne 8y agoWiktionary says > 1. Lacking freshness, motion, or flow; decaying through stillness. > 2. (figuratively) Without progress or change; stale; inactive. A stagnant pond isn't empty, the water just isn't moving or changing. Same with sales numbers here.
- mark_l_watson 8y agoApple services definitely are on an upward trajectory for quality and breadth. Two years ago I thought Siri was a bit of a joke because the voice recognition and accuracy/usefulness of results was not there for me. Different now: about 4 months ago I deinstalled the Google Assistant from my iPhone and now just use Siri. Siri is still not as good but there is the privacy issue. Siri is good enough for me. I still prefer Google for the Play Music + commercial free YouTube bundled service, and also GCP is my favorite cloud service.
- wycy 8y agoOut of curiosity, what do you use Siri for that it can be good enough? I use Siri almost exclusively for reminders (e.g., "remind me at x PM to do y" or "remind me when I get home to do z"), and even with this limited use case I often end up with baffling reminders in the future (my favorite reminder is to "make farts"--I never did remember what it was supposed to be.) Beyond reminders I've yet to find a compelling, reliable use case.
- browsercoin 8y agoIt's amazing that I would be having a random discussion and to check a fact, I would ask Google because Google Search Engine. Google reads the answer in a natural human like way. It works well. Countless dinner arguments arbitrated by Google via Google Voice by a simple ask. Shit saves marriages I bet. "wtf you mean the Mongol Empire didn't last long? hold up, lets ask Google about the Crimean Khnate that still kicked ass up till the 17th century" "i dont fucking believe you, i want a divorce" "...ey google what year did Crimean Khanate close" During the 16th and 17th centuries, the Crimean Khanate was an important center of the slave trade. In 1774, it was released as a nationally independent state, following the Russo-Turkish Treaty of Küçük Kaynarca, and formally annexed by the Russian Empire in 1783, becoming the Taurida Governorate "thank you Google for saving our marriage" Your welcome. --goes to work the next morning, sees divorce lawyer ads--
- ryanwaggoner 8y agoYour marriage is very different than mine. Not just because of what you argue about, but because you think the injection of a fact provided by a robot in the cloud is what’s missing from the path to de-escalation.
- jaxtellerSoA 8y agoMaybe if the price of an iPhone wasn't MORE than buying a decent a laptop then their sales wouldn't be stagnant.