4 ms·
I don't think it's fair to blame Twitter. When I first started using the internet (forums, usenet, mailinglists and so on) there where hateful speech, angry mob
by mrweasel 8y ago
I don't think it's fair to blame Twitter. When I first started using the internet (forums, usenet, mailinglists and so on) there where hateful speech, angry mobs, and just plain idiots.
The problem is that some people have come to expect that everywhere they go is a safe-spaces, where ass holes don't exists or can be swiftly dealt with.
Sure, Twitter needs to have a way to deal with things that are just plain illegal, and for the health of the platform they may need to add some additional policing. But let's face it, it's not the average internet user who are using Twitter.
The issues facing Twitter isn't that people are leaving because it's a hostile place. People leaving are either bots or realising that Twitter isn't good place it interact with friends and family. Honestly, most people don't need Twitter, but the media, which is full of Twitter power users, seem to think that it's THE platform. We need to look at Twitter more as a supplement to LinkedIn and not as a Facebook competitor.
- izacus 8y ago> The problem is that some people have come to expect that everywhere they go is a safe-spaces, where ass holes don't exists or can be swiftly dealt with. That's such a strange thing to say - isn't that a very reasonable expectation? Even in the outside world, the expectation is that you won't be dealing with assholes every minute of your life when you participate somewhere. And the thing about modern internet is that it's really really hard to find ANY place where you don't have to deal with them. Even HN isn't immune to deliberate trolling and personal attacks.
- zapzupnz 8y agoThough I'll say it's much more civil than, say, reddit. So even if HN isn't immune, it's nice to find a place where the majority of discussion is on-topic and not just endless ad hominem attacks. Granted, HN is rather specific in its userbase.
- mrweasel 8y ago> That's such a strange thing to say - isn't that a very reasonable expectation? Even in the outside world, the expectation is that you won't be dealing with assholes every minute of your life when you participate somewhere. That depends, I can't go into a ghetto area or a bar and say what ever I want and not expect people to react, regardless of how right I may be. I'm sure that this is an unpopular opinion but posting on Twitter is actively seeking out the ass holes and loud idiots.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoSo you're saying Twitter is a ghetto? I can't say I'd disagree with that. But how do we start a social media site that isn't?
- moate 8y agoBy your very nature, you can't. As you reach a certain size, it becomes nearly impossible to moderate due to the volume of material. Also, what to moderate will always be a fight. If you have a 10 million users, and 3,000,000 of them say that something is offensive, and 3,000,000 of them say that it is not and needs to be left, you're in a real pickle. If you listen to either side, you're possible siding with a minority opinion. Even if you're siding with a minority, you're going to upset millions of people. And no matter what your stance, you're taking a stance (with either action or inaction). What is the morally correct choice? It's the trolley problem every time a group gets offended (or counter-offended, or counter-counter-offended or...) Is it supposed to be a truly democratic state of majority, or a civil environment? What is the goal? None of these questions have "right" answers, just opinions. So what if you feel that your opinion is opposed by most of your users, who do you listen to?
- sheepmullet 8y ago> Even in the outside world, the expectation is that you won't be dealing with assholes every minute of your life when you participate somewhere. It depends on how you define assholes - there are people who disagree with you everywhere.
- jmfayard 8y agoI'm simple enough to think it's better to be in a compassionate place than in a toxic one. True, Twitter and Facebook are not the first places when discussion tends to be angry and ugly. Old internet had plenty of that too. But it was also much more fragmented, it was quite easy to leave the toxic places and move to the nicer corners of the internet. 10-15 years ago they were hundreds of "social" products. But they almost all died (even Google could not keep up) due to an intense darwinian pressure. Only the angriest have survived, those that optimized like psychopaths for user engagement.
- duckerude 8y agoPeople I know from other websites almost always seem to express noticeably worse opinions on Twitter, probably because it's so hard to fit nuance into a tweet. I use more abrasive websites, but Twitter still feels uniquely terrible somehow.