6 ms·
The UI circle is complete
- joelesler 16y agoWhat? That we are back to icons? The icons never left from OSX.
- pohl 16y agoThat's what I thought too: "what? icons within rectangles!?" But maybe the intended parallel is Program Manager's [1] MDI[2] interface. Maybe the author thinks Lion and Ubuntu are re-invinting MDI? [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Program_Manager http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Program_Manager [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_document_interface http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_document_interface
- Macha 16y agoThe main way of launching applications in Program manager was a program containing a grid of applications. Replacing the Applications menu with a dedicated grid of applications for Ubuntu, Applications folder with dedicated grid of applications for OS X. Which is basically what Program Manager was. (Yes, I know plenty of people probably do this ad hoc with their desktop anyway, but you were _supposed_ to use the proper methods)
- nlawalker 16y agoBack to screens full of icons for applications. Since Win95's Start Menu (I'm sure there are perhaps earlier examples in other desktop environments, but Windows is what I'm familiar with), users have been encouraged to keep documents on the desktop, and keep application shortcuts filed away in the Start menu or on the Quick Launch bar or other similar launcher. OSX and various Linux desktops are organized in the same way: you can put application shortcuts on the desktop, but the desktop is better for documents. Why did this happen? A)Even for non-tech-savvy people, the idea of a "file" makes perfect sense if you think about a document, B)Someone realized that opening a document in an application made for that kind of document should be a first class action, and shouldn't necessarily require you to first open the application and then use the application to open the document, and C)When you start putting documents on a desktop, putting "applications" alongside them using the same visual representation (a clickable icon) can be confusing. The result was a more literal "desktop," complete with your click-to-open documents laying around. Tools (applications) were put away in the desk drawers, so to speak. The widespread usage of iOS has put apps front and center again, both figuratively and literally - users have again become accustomed to seeing grids of icons for their applications instead of their documents. This is reflected in the Ubuntu and OSX screenshots.
- anigbrowl 16y agousers have been encouraged to keep documents on the desktop Almost every piece of windows software I can remember installing has asked me if I wanted to create a desktop icon for the application. I have a whopping...2 documents there. This hasn't required any special effort on my part, many applications default to saving in the user or (later) 'My documents' folders. I typically open documents from the file manager or via a 'Recent' menu, but prefer to launch the app if I starting a new document, and can't say I've noticed an irresistible trend for doing things the other way - if you ask me, it depends on the person rather than being driven by the OS.
- Macha 16y agoAlmost every piece of Windows software tries to add itself to the quick launch too. It's more about self-promotion than following best practices. "Hey, look at me, I'm here! Use me, tell all your friends"
- devmonk 16y agoWhat about... The Original Mac: http://www.old-computers.com/MUSEUM/computer.asp?c=271 http://www.old-computers.com/MUSEUM/computer.asp?c=271 The Xerox Star 8010: http://lowendmac.com/wale/07/the-roots-of-the-mac-os.html http://lowendmac.com/wale/07/the-roots-of-the-mac-os.html
- ThomPete 16y agoEvery GUI is a descendent of the Xerox Star
- adamesque 16y agoBoth the Win 3.x example and the Ubuntu example suffer from the same (presumed) failure: application organization imposed by the OS vendor. I can find things on my messy desk because I made the mess. If someone else arranged my desk for me, suddenly I have to understand their mental model before I can locate anything. Which is why I can never, ever find what I'm looking for in Windows' Start menu. Even if the categories seem obvious, they never map 100% to my way of thinking. (If those categories in the Ubuntu example are user-defined, then they're OK by me.) …and let's please not even get into how confusing and redundant the Dock looks in the otherwise nice Lion example.
- StavrosK 16y agoTry launchy, search beats categorisation any time.
- sudont 16y agoOnly for people who memorize application names. I bet you feel fine in front of a CLI, too. (Not a knock against, I like Launchy as well.) Do some time as a tech support, and eventually you'll get a request to help them with "this application, you know, the blue one. With the pictures and stuff?"
- StavrosK 16y agoThat's true, but are these people likely to have so many programs in the start menu anyway?
- NathanKP 16y agoPersonally I think that Spotlight style search launchers are the best way to launch applications. If the search launcher is designed halfway well, with learning about which applications you use most often it only takes a few keypresses to bring up the applications you need. Of course with touch devices it is probably more convenient to swipe to the application icon you want and touch it, but on the PC I find it much easier to click the search icon, type the app name and press enter.
- semanticist 16y agoIf you can remember the name of the application without prompting. I'll frequently have to troll through my /Applications directory looking for something that does X that I know I installed ages ago and will recognise when I see it. It's important to have multiple useful ways to get to your applications. My unprompted recall, in general, is quite weak, but someone else might have vision issues that makes distinguishing icons apart difficult. For this kind of basic functionality, I think that having several high-quality approaches is best.
- Groxx 16y agoA good reason to include meta info about applications, so it can be pulled up after name matches. Personally, I've almost quit using the Windows start menu. I hit win-key and start typing. Utterly pathetically slow and inaccurate compared to using something like QuickSilver or Alfred, but I can still get places much more quickly than using a mouse when I'm programming.
- anigbrowl 16y agoNo it isn't. I still want a Conetree godammit: http://www.infovis.net/imagenes/T1_N173_A1014_ConeTreeInteractionsV5N2MarzoAbril98p11.jpg http://www.infovis.net/imagenes/T1_N173_A1014_ConeTreeIntera...
- maxxxxx 16y agoIt's interesting that UI's started out program-oriented, then document-oriented, and now going back to program-oriented.
- viraptor 16y agoUbuntu decided to go that way for some reason, but I think that vanilla Gnome tries to continue on the document-oriented path. gnome-shell searches documents by default, includes Beagle (or whatever the native tool was called) and lately the Zeitgeist project. We'll see what they plan to do with Unity...
- glhaynes 16y agoI agree! Very interesting. I remember when "document-centric" was all the rage in UIs (often went hand-in-hand with the term "object-oriented"... right around Windows 95/OpenDoc/Workplace Shell timeframe) and I would think that it seemed odd, because most users I knew had nearly no real concept of document/folder hierarchies. You'd ask a user where their document is and they'd answer — just like they do today — "It's in Word."
- avk 16y agoFor inspiration: things that reject this same old paradigm: http://www.amazon.com/Beyond-Desktop-Metaphor-Integrated-Environments/dp/026211304X/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1288128575&sr=8-1 http://www.amazon.com/Beyond-Desktop-Metaphor-Integrated-Env...
- jessriedel 16y agoNo arrange by penis?
- wallflower 16y agoBrings back memories of DESQview http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DESQview http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DESQview
- petercooper 16y agoI remember when the screenshots of Windows 95 first came out in the magazines and people's reactions. With the people I knew, at least, was an almost universal hatred of the Start menu which I put down to it merely being "new." In retrospect, it was a pretty stupid idea UI wise that, sadly, so many others copied (IMHO, of course).