7 ms·
At least a few other detections have been reported by LIGO, and I assume that they, like the first one, are correlated in the data from Hanford WA and Livingsto
by CamperBob2 8y ago
At least a few other detections have been reported by LIGO, and I assume that they, like the first one, are correlated in the data from Hanford WA and Livingston LA.
Doesn't anyone looking to debunk the LIGO results need to first explain what is producing correlated signals at interferometers thousands of miles apart?
Also, are the incidents we're receiving in the US producing similar data at VIRGO in Italy?
If so, then wow, Jackson has a tough case to make.
If not, then why not?
- raverbashing 8y ago> Doesn't anyone looking to debunk the LIGO results need to first explain what is producing correlated signals at interferometers thousands of miles apart? > Also, are the incidents we're receiving in the US producing similar data at VIRGO in Italy? Yes and yes (also there was the optical/GRB confirmation for one of the events) That's why I'm siding on the LIGO side of this The whole article sounds like some "skeptics gone wild" trying to start a car with a banana then saying cars are fake because of it (and that's my behaved way of phrasing it)
- v_lisivka 8y ago> That's why I'm siding on the LIGO side of this Are you sure? Because then you must accept that c≠const, thus Ether exists.
- raverbashing 8y agoI don't remember anything being discussed on that area based on LIGO data
- kryptiskt 8y agoNo, I don't have to accept that, because I already know from my undergraduate physics that light doesn't travel at c in a medium.
- v_lisivka 8y agoLIGO measurements are performed in ultra-high-vacuum[0], so it's not a "speed of light in a medium" it's "speed of light in the vacuum", AKA c. [0]: https://www.ligo.caltech.edu/page/vacuum https://www.ligo.caltech.edu/page/vacuum
- v_lisivka 8y agoAdmins, it looks like I have personal haters. Can you fix this, please?
- gliptic 8y agoThere's a much more reasonable explanation for the downvotes. You're making a very dubious claim without even trying to back it up.
- v_lisivka 8y agoNobody of downvoters asked for anything nor contested my arguments. English is not a my native language and I'm busy right now, so I prefer to be concise. Basically, LIGO is oversized and much more precise version of Michelson-Moorley experiment. What else I need to show you or tell you to convince? Everybody already know role of Michelson-Moorley experiment in development of GR/SR theories. Michelson-Moorley experiment was performed with precision of up to 1E-17 and found nothing, so it was reasonable to post theories assuming that c=const. LIGO performed with precision of 1E-18 and found deviations, so it no longer true unless LIGO is wrong (distance to Alpha Centaur is just 4E16 meters, so it's possible), so it's why I asked "are you sure?".
- kurthr 8y ago
- scott_s 8y agoI'm on LIGO's side on this one, but I disagree that one must be able to offer an alternative explanation in order to claim a result is bogus. That is, I don't need an alternate theory in order to falsify yours. Again, to be clear: I think the LIGO results are probably correct. There's a bunch of corroborating evidence, and from the outside it appears they've been acting is very much good faith. I'm just making an epistemology quibble.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoAgreed: the scientific community is supposed to havea consensus on [Popperian] falsificationism but seem to act like they don't really believe it quite often.
- no_identd 8y ago> the scientific community is supposed to havea consensus on [Popperian] falsificationism You couldn't have it more wrong. See here, with more physics relevant points: http://www.mdpi.com/2073-8994/3/3/611 http://www.mdpi.com/2073-8994/3/3/611 [PDF only] And here with more science relevant points: http://www.mdpi.com/2078-2489/2/4/635/htm http://www.mdpi.com/2078-2489/2/4/635/htm [Different article, mobile friendly]
- CamperBob2 8y agoThat is, I don't need an alternate theory in order to falsify yours. I phrased that poorly: what the critics need to explain is the apparent agreement between the prior model and the observations. It wasn't just a case where someone looked at an oscilloscope screen and said, "Whoa. Look at that. Aliens!" As I understand it, the LIGO results showed good conformance to their predictions. Does that make their position completely bulletproof? No, nothing in science ever is, but it does place Jackson's dispute into the category of "extraordinary claims."
- dnautics 8y agoThe question is as follows:. How frequent are all blips that might be classified as X overall, and from that, what is the expected rate of spurious correlation? To arrive at this one must have access to quite a bit of comprehensive data collected in an unbiased fashion.
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoLet's say you see foot prints outside your house. And they look like deer footprints, and so you say they are. Somebody then shows that a small moose could have left similar tracks. You don't need to state what definitively left those tracks to say that it's premature to declare them deer footprints. In the signal world this is even more true, because with signals this faint everything is going to come down to probabilistic analysis. And so the real question is not binary (gravitational waves or not gravitational waves), but rather the chance that what was detected was caused by gravitational waves. And so anything that could confound those probabilities is as good as a refutation, even without any explanation for what did cause the observed phenomena. I have no opinion on the issue one way or the other, but I do have to say that the large numbers of appeals to authority and ad hominem from the LIGO researchers do not inspire confidence. People tend to resort to these sorts of responses for the lack of a rational refutation. I found a much more informative article on the issue here [1], surprisingly from Forbes. There too, the responses from the LIGO team feel off. For instance they were criticizing the Danish team for using the tutorials LIGO provided on their site alongside the data! I mean...??? Did LIGO ever publish the exact method used to obtain their results? [1] - https://www.forbes.com/sites/startswithabang/2017/06/16/was-it-all-just-noise-independent-analysis-casts-doubt-on-ligos-detections https://www.forbes.com/sites/startswithabang/2017/06/16/was-...
- simion314 8y agoHow is your analogy fit with the fact that there was a case where LIGO had a detection then many telescopes were pointing into that region of sky and "seen" the cause. https://www.newscientist.com/article/2150418-gravitational-waves-have-let-us-see-huge-neutron-stars-colliding/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/2150418-gravitational-w... This is evidence enough for me that LIGO is not detecting noise.
- SiempreViernes 8y agoI think Hossenfelder did a pretty bad jounalistic job in that column, which she defended by pointing out that she is not a journalist. Even reading that it was clear Jackson was probably wrong and had she not been an angry german she would have written that as her conclusion. Also the article you are commenting on directly cites that column by Hossenfelder.
- jobigoud 8y agoIn the general case no, you don't need to present an alternative theory to proove that a given existing theory is flawed or not self consistent or not consistent with observed data.
- CamperBob2 8y agoTrue enough in the general case as you say, but in this specific case, the data in question was (reportedly) a good fit for a pre-existing model. They made a prediction, ran an experiment, observed the predicted effect, drew a conclusion, and got a Nobel for their trouble. So the burden of proof is decisively on the accuser here, I'd think.
- mihaifm 8y agoThey claim it’s noise and pure coincidence. Some trains may have shaken the earth at the exact time the cosmic event happened. At least that’s what I take from the article.