9 ms·
What happened to Clojure? Was it just a fad, or are people still using it in their day jobs? Are people still hiring Clojure devs? If you write Clojure at work,
by nerdponx 8y ago
What happened to Clojure? Was it just a fad, or are people still using it in their day jobs? Are people still hiring Clojure devs? If you write Clojure at work, are you happy with it?
- jcadam 8y agoNot a fad. Clojure 1.9 was just released. I can only use it on personal projects, as employers hiring for Clojure are few and far between.
- imglorp 8y agoOne datapoint if it helps someone: these guys are full clojure. https://www.relaynetwork.com/careers/ https://www.relaynetwork.com/careers/
- dgritsko 8y agoBarely hanging onto the top 50 at #49 according to the TIOBE index (Java is still #1). Make of that what you will. https://www.tiobe.com/tiobe-index/ https://www.tiobe.com/tiobe-index/
- yen223 8y agoThat index lists Ladder Logic (#45) as being ahead of Bash (#48). Make of that what you will.
- kamaal 8y agoThat's because TIOBE derives metrics from search results. Which means every time some one searches 'Python, the snake', that also gets counted as 'Python, the programming language'. Most people looking for help on the internet are searching: "How do I do X in shell?" No of people looking for help with the word 'Bash' are likely to be lower. That's one reason why TIOBE is sometimes way off the real trends.
- steveklabnik 8y agoI don't like TIOBE, and think it's a pretty bad index, but they search for "$LANG programming", not just $LANG. https://www.tiobe.com/tiobe-index/programming-languages-definition/ https://www.tiobe.com/tiobe-index/programming-languages-defi...
- 200px 8y ago> Which means every time some one searches 'Python, the snake', that also gets counted as 'Python, the programming language'. This is false.
- jcelerier 8y agowell... yeah ? there are entire companies of thousand of electrical engineers working in LL. They just don't come and post about it to hackernews and make PLC projects in github, they do their 9-5 job and that's all. Compare https://www.indeed.com/jobs?q=PLC+engineer https://www.indeed.com/jobs?q=PLC+engineer and https://www.indeed.com/jobs?q=bash+programmer https://www.indeed.com/jobs?q=bash+programmer
- ilikehurdles 8y ago>They just don't come and post about it to hackernews and make PLC projects in github Same logic applies to clojure. I think that's the point he's making. Everyone and their 12 year old nephew rockstar developer has questions about java. I also find that clojure questions nowadays are mainly asked in the clojurians slack organization. Immediate feedback is more attractive than waiting around hoping for an answer in stackoverflow.
- nogridbag 8y agoPersonally I prefer StackOverflow. SO is a wiki and it's likely my question and others' comments and answers will help someone else in the future. With any chat interface, it feels like your question may be lost if it's not immediately answered and it's often hard to follow discussions with multiple people chatting. With SO I will spend time to try and formulate a clear question. In general with slack or any other chat I may feel out the room first as it will be a waste of my time writing a detailed question if no one is around to answer. Perhaps some sort of SO integration into Slack would be the best of both worlds?
- KingMob 8y agoWhile Slack is the most popular forum, there's also Clojureverse.org, which aims to be a more threaded and permanent repository of Clojure discussions and knowledge.
- phaedryx 8y agoWhat I make of it: "I'm quietly being productive with $LANG in my day-to-day job and loving it" doesn't move a language up the ranking.
- cutler 8y agoTIOBE is a joke.
- zmmmmm 8y agoI like the CloudFoundry report [1] better as a reflection of what businesses are actually using rather than search engine metrics (TIOBE) which are overly influenced by controversy and search engine methodologies than actual usage. However it's no prettier a picture, almost no functional languages in the list at all, only Scala making a significant dent (and you can debate whether that is functional or not). Other JVM languages like Groovy are significantly ahead of Clojure in all rankings. [1] https://www.cloudfoundry.org/wp-content/uploads/Developer-Language-Report_FINAL.pdf https://www.cloudfoundry.org/wp-content/uploads/Developer-La...
- vorg 8y ago> Other JVM languages like Groovy are significantly ahead of Clojure in all rankings. Apache Groovy fluctuates on TIOBE a lot. Six months ago it was at the same 50-ish position as Clojure, which is its usual ranking. It's shot up only in the past 6 months, which has also happened a lot in the past and is always followed by a sudden fall -- perhaps someone's gaming the search engine rankings. On Redmonk, Groovy and Clojure have ranked equal-ish for a long time. In the CloudFoundry report, Groovy is at the same very low rank as Others which would include Clojure if present. So Groovy and Clojure are at the same ranking in all rankings I've looked at.
- tribaal 8y agoWe are a mostly Clojure shop and are very happy with it. It's very expressive, functional, and allows you to tap into the Java ecosystem if you need to. Might not be as hyped today as it was some years ago, but the language itself is still a joy to use. Edit: SWE at exoscale.com here. We're hiring, also for full remote positions!
- catbodi 8y agoDang thats some expensive cloud pricing. Your cheapest plan offers 512MB of RAM for 5 Euros a month. There's well over 5 competitors who can get you quadruple that amount of RAM and maybe even double the storage for half that price per month. This is due to renting out space at datacenters, no? I'm no hosting expert.
- pyritschard 8y agoHey, Exoscale CTO here, Thanks for looking into the service. We're certainly not the cheapest in terms of pricing but I would also warn against using RAM prices as the sole way to gauge a service. To drive low prices a lot of VPS providers tend to have a very liberal way of playing with overcommit, which we don't do. The same goes for CPU. Our instances should be considered to higher-end families such as the C3 and here you'll see we're playing in the same field in terms of prices.
- tribaal 8y agoIt's due to us offering some guarantees on what you get, and therefore not over provisioning our hardware :) Many of our clients choose us for performance (IOPS, memory guarantees, etc...), and our geographic and legal situation (no connection to 5 eyes countries, strong privacy laws).
- calgoo 8y agoThat 512mb server can cost several thousands at enterprise datacenters so its not that bad. It all comes down to who their customer base is.
- swah 8y agoWhile other posters comment that "Clojure still works", IIRC the "promise" was that Clojure/Lisp would be much, much more productive, and that claim I feel like must been disproved in daily work, otherwise Clojure would still a main topic around here. Reminds me of the classic Erann Gatt post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2308370 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2308370 (I loved to play with Elisp, Clojure, Lua, Factor, Ion, Ioke and hope dynamic languages become fashionable again someday...)
- lukev 8y agoIt is (sadly) not clear at all that programming language popularity (or rather, "online buzz" around a language which is all you can measure) correlates strongly with productivity.
- KingMob 8y agoI can only speak for myself, but I'm definitely much, much more productive using Clojure. I think its absence from HN is more reflective of a less-than-stellar onboarding experience for newcomers, and HN's general neophilia.
- empthought 8y agoI think individual developers are most likely to become much, much more productive when using Clojure/Lisp vs. Java, C#, and the like, but software development teams are unlikely to experience the same benefits. And it's not even because Clojure is bad for teams, it's because teams often form because there are nontechnical stakeholders, and suddenly an individual contributor's code-writing productivity is a much smaller factor when compared to the communication practices and other parts of the development process outside of writing code.
- StreamBright 8y agoIf there is one think about humanity that is worth to note is that the shittier alternative always wins. This is true from money through computer architectures to programming languages.
- jimbokun 8y ago"hope dynamic languages become fashionable again someday..." Python, Javascript and Ruby are very dynamic.
- jakebasile 8y agoThe industry can rip Clojure from my cold, dead hands. It's still used in smaller teams at a lot of places including some of the BigCos. It's a simple joy to use and it is a damn shame it's not more popular than it is, but I don't think it is a fad.
- mecameron 8y agoWe've been using Clojure for 3 years and ClojureScript for 1.5 years. We're actively converting more of our legacy codebase to Clojure/Script. It's been a great choice for us and even the skeptics have become converts over time. I think it's a joy to work with and allows us to reason about our problems and solve them better than many alternatives.
- z3t4 8y agoIt's interesting that in the current state of software development, a programming language that have been stable for not even a year might be considered obsolete.
- KingMob 8y agoA perennial problem in Clojure is libraries that reach a mostly "done" state tend to look inactive to outsiders, because the language is so stable there's almost no maintenance work. So inevitably, someone will ask "Is lib foo still being used? The last commit was over 8 months ago" and then people have to chime in, "yes, it's still in heavy use".
- nerdponx 8y agoSeveral languages have this problem, e.g. Common Lisp. It would be nice if developers of libraries like this at least updated their copyright annually, as an indicator that they and the project are still alive.
- imhoguy 8y agoDamn, you have just brought me an idea for next weekend project. Copyright-year updater which submits PRs to GH projects :) In Clojure of course!
- Jach 8y agoWho is the indicator for though? Wouldn't users of that language quickly come to expect that inactive is not necessarily dead or useless? (Especially with Common Lisp, stuff decades old is still useful.) And I find outsiders unlikely to care that much, it's just a nit random passerbys will make when they think they need to comment on something, rather than actually informing a serious decision. It's also kind of pointless to "update the copyright year" for individual works tied to your name, since the copyright lasts x years after your death. If anonymous/pseudonymous, then it's like 95 years after initial publication date, and you can't just extend that arbitrarily by updating the base year and nothing else every year..
- 8y ago
- abc_lisper 8y agoYes, we are using it at a BigCo. I am extremely happy with Clojure. I wouldn't think Clojure is a fad, it never was that popular.
- pixelperfect 8y agoClojure is still around and a great language for experienced devs. But the experience for newcomers is much less attractive than for other languages, which is preventing growth. Also, the largest Clojure community is the Slack channel, which is hidden from the rest of the world.
- jakebasile 8y agoI really wish the community would move away from using Slack. It's completely opaque to most people and anything past the last couple days gets lost to the ether. Yes, I know you can find it on some archiving site, but it's non-intuitive. Wish they'd move to Discord or Matrix or... pretty much anything else.
- tosh 8y agoAccording to the JVM Ecosystem report/survey Clojure is the 2nd main language on the JVM (after Java): https://snyk.io/blog/jvm-ecosystem-report-2018 https://snyk.io/blog/jvm-ecosystem-report-2018 ClojureScript also seems to gain traction. Quite impressive when you consider that Clojure is a language/ecosystem not driven/backed by one of the larger tech companies.
- cutler 8y agoSee my earlier post in response to yogothos. On jobs boards Scala adoption is orders of magnitude higher than Clojure.
- Dirlewanger 8y agoCircleCI uses ClojureScript last I read.
- shady-lady 8y agothink they stopped: https://www.reddit.com/r/Clojure/comments/9ho97m/is_circleci_still_using_cljs_saw_a_few_react/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Clojure/comments/9ho97m/is_circleci...
- smoe 8y agoThat link only refers to the frontend where they used to have ClojureScript. Judging from their backend job postings they seem to use Clojure and Go. .
- hellofunk 8y agoThe cancellation of a few major Clojure conferances hasn’t helped. I’m guessing it speaks to demand. I used Clojure for a long time, professionally. Not much any more. Main issue is that the language is not very readable (a pain point mentioned in these slides) and very hard to find people to work in it. Also more than any other language Clojure is very sensitive to typos in your code. A misspelled keyword results in nil accidentally flowing through your app. It was frustrating to spend time on scaffolding everywhere to catch these things.
- kamaal 8y ago>>A misspelled keyword results in nil accidentally flowing through your app. Some dynamic languages, worked around this issue in the 90's. Perl for example, if you use 'use strict; use warnings' will catch most of these misadventures. Having said that, only the most novice programmers make these kind of mistakes. Like the absolute beginners, in the first day or two of exposure to programming. As a rule almost any shop these days write unit test cases, so that should flush out these kind of bugs. EDIT: Why the downvotes? People seriously work with programmers whose biggest incompetence at work is typos? Or you think writing unit test cases is bad?
- StreamBright 8y agoThey just disagree without explaining why. Anyways, I sometimes have typos in my Clojure code, but once I follow through with your mental model and just reproduce the problem in REPL it is easy to find these sort of bugs.
- kamaal 8y agoI'm not sure, but if people have problems, as bad as things like hiring programmers who struggle with indenting code, making typos in variable names, write functions hundreds of lines long, can't modularize code, write 3 nested for loops, or write nested if's where '&&' suffices. Then you are having far bigger problems related to project management, hiring and overall direction in which you are running your team/company. Clojure as a tool doesn't aim to fix these kind of problems. And it can be argued no tool will fix these problems.
- mayneack 8y agoWe're still using Clojure at Factual and are hiring. https://www.factual.com/company/careers/?gh_src=1pt2v8 https://www.factual.com/company/careers/?gh_src=1pt2v8
- yogthos 8y agoClojure use has been growing steadily, and lots of companies are hiring. In a recent JVM survery of 10K people Clojure came in as the second most used language after Java https://snyk.io/blog/jvm-ecosystem-report-2018 https://snyk.io/blog/jvm-ecosystem-report-2018 My team has been working with Clojure for the past 8 years, and we're extremely happy with it.
- cutler 8y agoThese stats look highly suspect with Clojure:Scala = 1.6. Here in London the jobs boards Angel.co and Indeed.com have Scala:Clojure at 3.6 and 19.6 respectively.
- yogthos 8y agoIt's one of the most comprehensive surveys to date. Meanwhile, the job numbers can relate to many factors. For example, there could be more turn around for Scala jobs.
- cutler 8y agoThe survey opens with: "Welcome to the largest survey ever of Java developers ... The survey was conducted by publishing its availability to the Java community at large (via social media primarily), to Java User Groups around the world, including the Virtual JUG, and to subscribers of Java Magazine, the Java bimonthly publication from Oracle Corp." So the sample is heavily biased and doesn't include the population of JVM users who have never touched Java.
- StreamBright 8y agoI regularly use Clojure at work, even though I am usually a sole contributor because other people are not willing to use anything other than Python, Go, Java. The primitives for doing concurrent and parallel programming is just so nice that I can't think of living without it. Go has similar solutions though. The biggest advantage is to have a concise small code base that does exactly you want without dancing around language related boilerplate.
- tombert 8y agoI work for one of the big "brand name" companies (I don't want to say which, but it's on the "companies using Clojure page"), and on my team we try and start all new projects to use Clojure. Frankly, I love it. After the "zen" of lisp clicked for me, Clojure gave me an OS/2-style "Better Java Than Java". Suddenly I was able to compose standard JVM library stuff in a more-natural and easy way than I could in vanilla Java, I was able to easily define relatively-well-optimized persistent data structures, and I could quickly provide new semantics to the language as I saw fit. Also, the Clojure REPL provides an amazing level of increased productivity. Do I miss the Hindley-Milner type system from my last job? A bit, but surprisingly it doesn't bother me as much as I thought with Clojure. I don't know if Clojure was just a fad, but I think that it'll always have a loyal fanbase, like mosts Lisps.
- sunshinerag 8y agoCare to mention what is the language you used in your last job that you are comparing clojure with.
- tombert 8y agoI was using F#, and before that Haskell, and before that Scala.
- anon1253 8y agoWe've been using a full Clojure stack (front-end + backend) in production for nearly 4 years and very happy with it (6-8 people full time). But that is very much anecdotal. I guess one thing to note is that the language is very stable, there are very few (if any) breaking changes and a 4 year old library will "just work" most of the time. Even more amazing is that it's trivial to port 40 year old ideas from (Common)Lisp if you're so inclined, or interface with a known good Java implementation. To me that is a big plus, personally I wouldn't even want a ton of extra features in Clojure ... the language is fine and libraries fill in the rest. It does give the impression that not a lot of happening and that it might be fading or boring, but in a lot of settings boring is actually a good thing. The amount of times some NodeJS or Python thing changed from underneath me and I needed to rework an entire codepath or build infrastructure just because the language changed their mind on how things should be done are gladly behind me with Clojure!
- jimbokun 8y ago"...personally I wouldn't even want a ton of extra features in Clojure ... the language is fine and libraries fill in the rest." And for anything else there's macros.
- joseakle 8y agoWe use Clojure at Nubank. We’re actively hiring Clojure devs or we can teach those who don’t know it yet. https://nubank.workable.com https://nubank.workable.com We’re very happy with it.
- ljosa 8y agoWe're using it happily at Yieldbot. We're an ad network, and the core matching technology (which finds relevant ads based on the contents of the page and decides which one to show and how much to bid) is all Clojure. All the data science stuff is Clojure (it's been great with Spark and pretty good with Storm). The data pipeline is all Clojure now. The central database for ad campaigns and such is Datomic. The APIs for the frontends are moving to Clojure. ClojureScript never caught on for the front-end work. There are some substantial services for which Elixir was chosen instead of Clojure.
- Naomarik 8y agoMy feeling (and personal experience) is that the state Clojure is in now is so solid there's not a lot to talk about. Every time I take a peek at the JS ecosystem there's a new flavor or build tool. I've been making a living using Clojure for a few years now as a solo dev and I don't feel the language is lacking in anything I would care much about. I started with reagent not knowing anything about react or having any Clojure experience and was immediately productive. I was able to augment part of a webapp I had in production in no time due instant feedback loops from the REPL and figwheel. The language is being iterated on but it has already been in such a state in that I'm not keeping up with what's new because I'm able to solve any problem I need to already. I'm extremely happy with it. I have a lot of interests other than programming and I feel that Clojure allows me to deliver complex projects on time without driving me insane or having to keep up with new trends.
- eigenhombre 8y agoI've been doing Clojure professionally happily for five years. My company/team in Chicago uses Clojure and is hiring (onsite). https://hire.withgoogle.com/public/jobs/opploanscom/view/P_AAAAAADAAFvGt7ggWHI2Qh https://hire.withgoogle.com/public/jobs/opploanscom/view/P_A...
- quantisan 8y agoWe use Clojure for the whole backend, Python for machine learning, and JS for frontend at Motiva AI. It's the fourth company that I worked at (UK and US) with Clojure as one of the main languages. I'd say hiring Clojure devs has been one of the best perks for working with Clojure. Consistently high quality people that I've had the honour to work with. At Motiva, we've dabbled in other languages like Haskell, Scala, Rust, Go, etc. but Clojure has been what sticks for us on the backend team https://github.com/Motiva-AI https://github.com/Motiva-AI. We are a fully distributed remote team and we are hiring. Drop me an email.