5 ms·
Why is insider trading a different category than other forms of speech? Why is paying someone to murder someone a different category than other forms of speech
by pessimizer 8y ago
Why is insider trading a different category than other forms of speech?
Why is paying someone to murder someone a different category than other forms of speech?
Why are intentionally deceptive drug advertisements a different category than other forms of speech?
Why is pointing a gun at someone and telling them to do something a different category than other types of speech?
I'm going to claim that it's because these forms of speech enable types of coordination and coercion that corrupt processes and structures that we deem essential for the operation of society. So, pragmatic reasons.
Placing limits on the payments, direct or indirect (a dollar I spend is a dollar a candidate doesn't have to spend), that can be made to aid people in gaining a position that places them in charge of allocating public resources, that's something that very few people seriously argue against. What they argue about is what those limits should be.
You can make an argument that payments to candidates and government officials should be allowed, but making absolutist arguments that something is speech and therefore must be permitted isn't serious. Payments to a television station to run an ad that you financed the production of is surely less worthy of being called speech than calling in a bomb threat is - at least the bomb threat is using your mouth to say a thing. Speech, instead, is what we define to be speech. If it's to encompass all expression, you might as well call selling cigarettes without a tax stamp speech.
- k_sh 8y ago> Why is insider trading a different category than other forms of speech? The speech isn't illegal - the act of trading based on insider information is. This works in a similar manner to bomb-making plans being legal to disseminate, but making a bomb being very illegal. > Why is paying someone to murder someone a different category than other forms of speech? This is solicitation to commit a crime, which is a specific exception to the 1A. > Why are intentionally deceptive drug advertisements a different category than other forms of speech? This is a false statement of fact, which is a specific exception to the 1A. > Why is pointing a gun at someone and telling them to do something a different category than other types of speech? Pointing a gun isn't speech, it's coercion.
- Dylan16807 8y ago> The speech isn't illegal - the act of trading based on insider information is. The act of paying for something. That's not a very helpful distinction to make when the proposal is not being able to pay for certain ads. > This is a false statement of fact, which is a specific exception to the 1A. Political ads are deceptive all the time. And what does "specific exception" mean? Specified by what?
- JdeBP 8y agoHerewith the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, wherein one will find no specific exceptions actually made. * https://www.archives.gov/founding-docs/bill-of-rights-transcript#toc-amendment-i https://www.archives.gov/founding-docs/bill-of-rights-transc... Enjoy.
- manigandham 8y agoThat's not how this works. The constitution and amendments are the foundation. There are centuries of supreme court rulings and further legal precedent that determine the modern framework. Free speech does have certain restrictions, which you can easily read about here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_free_speech_exceptions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_free_speech_exce...
- JdeBP 8y agoActually, it is how it works. You are confusing case law with what k_sh actually claimed, which was specific exceptions. There do exist U.S. constitutional provisions with specific exceptions, such as the 5th Amendment. The 1st Amendment is not one of them. Indeed, it is famous for being neither specific nor having clear exceptions. Contrast with the Basic Law of Germany article 5, that has already come up in this discussion, which outlines specific exceptions in paragraph 2. (For another example, see article 8.)
- manigandham 8y agoIncorrect. What is being discussed are the applicable rules to citizens today, and the cumulative legislation states that there are exceptions. We do not follow only the constitution and bill of rights, otherwise what do you think the thousands of other laws are doing exactly? Real exceptions exist, regardless of whether they are written in the original amendment text or in rulings afterward.