8 ms·
To Err Is Human: Mistakes and slips in skydiving and other disciplines
- imatworkhandle 8y agoI get this mag. Never would I think Id see a link to it here.
- brownbat 8y agoWith nod to Norman’s “The Design of Everyday Things,” including the chapter “Human Error? No, Bad Design.” For reference, an article he also wrote with that title, discussing design and human error in major transportation accidents: https://www.jnd.org/dn.mss/human_error_no_bad.html https://www.jnd.org/dn.mss/human_error_no_bad.html
- djmips 8y agoIt seems that having a checklist like in aviation (that was also applied to surgery and other areas) could be useful to alleviate some of these slips. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8862273 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8862273
- lostconfused 8y agoPoint and call https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/pointing-and-calling-japan-trains https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/pointing-and-calling-j... Someone linked this article in a thread related to worker safety or hazards. There always seems to be ways to improve safety or reduce failure rate. But the problem is lack of incentive or motivation to make those improvements. After reading the actual article. The point and call aims to eliminate the "slip" error. By keeping the human awareness focused and engaged in the activity.
- mnw21cam 8y agoI recently went around the USS Midway museum. It struck me that the guy in charge of the catapult would point at each person in turn waiting for an OK, before making a very clear signal to launch. Not quite point and call, mainly because the deck would be too noisy for the call bit, but it worked.
- Steve44 8y agoOne of the changes to surgery was moving from a "did we remove the 5 swabs we put in" type of question to saying how many were removed and writing that down next to how many were put in. A couple of years ago I changed how our work checked the tyre pressures on company vehicles. It used to be a sheet with the tyre pressure stated at the top then a checklist of if each tyre was OK. I changed it to the checker having to write down each individual pressure. This had two positive effects. Firstly it helped ensure they actually took the measurement and secondly we could identify slow punctures better.
- FabHK 8y agoThere's a great book by Atul Gawande, The Checklist Manifesto, that talks about this transfer of best practices from aviation to surgery (including checklists and CRM). Informative and entertaining read. I think it's extremely important, because the case of aviation shows that highly trained professionals make mistakes all the time. Now, bad mistakes in aviation are very visible (hard to ignore a crashed passenger jet). However, bad mistakes in surgery result may result in the death of one person that was sick already. So, it's very easy to "overlook" them. I feel much more comfortable in a hospital that uses checklists and CRM.
- hudibras 8y agoHaving never heard of a "CYPRES fire," just spent 10 minutes googling it and then watching terrifying skydiving videos, like this one (no injuries or deaths, just scary): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DAZXF1UZ1Yg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DAZXF1UZ1Yg
- kweks 8y agoBy far the most 'well known' AAD videos. The human mind is amazing in its ability to adapt to new environments. To a non-skydiver, the most important thing to do when you skydive is to open your parachute. However it's stupidly easy as a jumper to forget completely about your altitude because you're concentrating on something else. Hard to believe that you're able to easily ignore 'certain death' after a few times - but that's the case. According to CYPRES documentation, they've had thousands of fires - so in theory - saved thousands of lives - including the ones in this video. Pretty impressive.
- dotancohen 8y agoNot every CYPRES fire is another life saved: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MmOiyrsCRNA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MmOiyrsCRNA I'm being cynical. The occasional misfire is worth every life saved. I suppose that AAD systems are like airbags. An occasional false positive is better than even a single false negative.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> However it's stupidly easy as a jumper to forget completely about your altitude because you're concentrating on something else. When you're falling? What else is there to concentrate on, than how frigging high you are?
- JoeDaDude 8y agoOlder jumpers at my drop zone used to tell the legend of the South African Three Way. Seems that in the early days of RW, three jumpers were jumping all day long trying to get the first 3-way formation in South Africa. They succeeded, as proven by the position their bodies were in when they found them.
- blablablerg 8y agoThe theory in this article is based on "Human Error" by James Reason.
- kweks 8y agoI skydive and BASE; from my (limited) experience, the disciplines have a risk of 'built in' complacency. Take skydiving, for example. As a beginner, you're keenly aware that every time you toss yourself out of a plane, you're committing suicide, and every time, the parachute saves your life. Quite quickly, it can be easy to equate "wearing a parachute" to "nothing will go wrong". A skydive rig is an incredible feat of engineering. Each fold and stitch has a history, a reason and a purpose. It's a thing of beauty. However, in a skydive rig, half the system is a black box: You're not allowed to touch or handle the reserve part. This can foster a complacency, or a shift of responsibility: It doesn't matter if my pack was terrible, I've got my reserve.. Checklists do exist: In theory you'll check your AAD (Automatic Activation Device - it basically fires your reserve if you haven't opened by a certain altitude), your pins (reserve and main), your handles (pilot chute / main handle, cut-away handle, reserve handle), straps (leg straps, chest strap), ring system (RSL and three ring system), and then your own gear (helmet, goggles, alti). However, expectation of performance (IE, every time you've worn your chute it's worked, leads to complacency), peer pressure (it's totally 'not cool' for experienced jumpers to ask for a gear check) - rushing - and the 'laid back' environment of dropzones erode the seriousness of the task and the importance of stringent checking.
- WalterBright 8y ago> it's totally 'not cool' for experienced jumpers to ask for a gear check Wow. What I'd do after I check my gear, is ask a buddy to check mine and I check his. With a checklist.
- yubiox 8y agoYou are going to be the only one of 20 people on the plane doing this, for jump after jump, no matter how experienced you become? I wish there was a way to test this. I don't believe you. In reality, most new jumpers will ask for a gear check for the first few jumps after finishing the training and then stop. There really isn't a need for a checklist, it isn't hard to remember what to check. The problem is that people are either too lazy, too embarrassed, too complacent, or just too stupid to do the checks (and practice emergency procedures). Recently, at 10,000 feet up (on the way to 13,000) I asked a 15 jump beginner in a friendly way if she was going to check her handles and practice emergency procedures. She answered that she already did. I sat behind her and watched all the way up, and she had not done these things in the plane which is common safety procedure. I then said, no, I mean in the plane. She ignored me and then went on to jump without checking anything. This is actually pretty common. People don't like to be told what to do.
- clueless123 8y agoOne way to mitigate slips are mnemonics.. in grain them into the students when they are learning, and they will get stuck with them for life. I have one for pretty much everything I do.
- jobigoud 8y agoGreat tip. I wonder if exaggerated gestures and pointing with the finger, like the Japanese railway operators do would help. I'm going to start doing this myself during my checks (beginner paraglider).
- clueless123 8y agoThat is exactly how we do them.. you say the word and point to the item with the hand you will be using. Ex: When landing the plane: GUMPS (gas, undercarriage, mixture,prop,seatbelts ) say them all while pointing to each item.