7 ms·
First private Chinese attempt to send rocket into space fails
- dhruval 8y agoRockets are very hard and failure is very costly. Requires a different mindset from software. All the best to the team.
- baybal2 8y ago>Requires a different mindset from software. All the best to the team. Definitely - it is all about the software team forgetting the accursed word "iteration" There, the software must works right from first compile. The way of writing software "in hopes it works," and reworking it by going from one newly discovered roadblock to another doesn't work. Also, formal verification is genuinely needed here, even more than say in embedded space.
- nicois 8y agoMy naive perspective is not that software engineers should forsake iteration; rather that their tests / simulations have to be "out of this world". After all, the software is still written by taking real world constraints and models and then applying them in software. Anything you are counting on software to do properly should be testable, up to a point, in a virtual environment.
- baybal2 8y ago>rather that their tests / simulations have to be "out of this world". Formal verification far exceeds testing as know to mainstream software development. And in addition to it, some "sanity tests" are preferably to be done just to have an assurance that your are not verifying the wrong thing. I heard of few cases when formally verified software failed despite devs being religiously zealous with it. One on my mind was of oxygen sensor wired to ADC, and ADC was able to measure negative voltage... Thus it was keeping the fuel injector running for the negative amount of time... You can imagine the following sequence of events.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoYou do have simulations in place, so iteration and testing are still very important. Formal verification, when used at all, is still not a substitute for lots of testing.
- baybal2 8y agoAnd so did Alibaba's first attempt at running a satellite business. https://www.straitstimes.com/asia/east-asia/alibaba-reaching-for-the-stars-with-singles-day-satellite https://www.straitstimes.com/asia/east-asia/alibaba-reaching...
- netvarun 8y agoDid it actually fail? Can’t tell from the article (though they quote an expert calling it a gimmick)
- gpm 8y agoIt's worth remembering that SpaceX's first 3 attempts failed as well. Space is hard. It sounds like a lot of things went right with this launch before something failed. So, good for them!
- baybal2 8y agoAnd thing that tend to fail, at least in last few decades do seem to be stupidly simple from first look: somebody forgets to put a bolt in a mission critical assembly, banal programming errors, accelerometers being put upside down, not up to spec critical parts...
- WalterBright 8y ago> accelerometers being put upside down This is a design problem. It should not be possible to install them in the wrong orientation. So many disastrous problems in aerospace result from crossed connections and things installed backwards that a lot of effort is put into making this impossible. For example: 1. having asymmetric bolt patterns 2. having one of the bolts being a different size/thread 3. having a package shape that won't fit any way but the right way 4. have arrows on the package 5. color-coding the ends 6. etc.
- WalterBright 8y agoI earned money in college doing electronic board assembly work. One major source of problems was installing components backwards. We'd try to mitigate this by at least having all the orientations the same, so all the + on the capacitors pointed the same way, the lettering and pin 1 dimple on the ICs always pointed the same way, etc. At least the chip package manufacturers could have slightly offset the pins on one side. But noooo... :-(
- greglindahl 8y agohttp://www.russianspaceweb.com/proton_glonass49.html http://www.russianspaceweb.com/proton_glonass49.html > By July 13, investigators simulated the improper installation of the DUS angular velocity sensors on the actual hardware. As it turned out, it would be very difficult to do but not impossible. To achieve that personnel would need to use procedures and instruments not certified either by the design documentation or the installation instructions. As a result, the plate holding the sensors sustained damage. Yet, when the hardware recovered from the accident was delivered to GKNPTs Khrunichev, it was discovered that the nature of the damage to the plate had almost exactly matched the simulated version.
- EngineerBetter 8y agoThere seem to be a lot of stories with a negative view of China on HN.
- teknologist 8y agoThis is news. Not sure why you think this post constitutes pushing a negative view of China.
- sjburt 8y agoCalling it a failure/setback is pretty harsh and misleading. Getting off the pad at all is a major success for the first launch of a new launch vehicle.
- orbital-decay 8y agoHuh? The mission was a failure. This is the industry terminology, nothing misleading about that.
- scarcely 8y agoCome on, it gets voted to the top because it allows "hackers" to gloat about it under the name of "intellectual curiosity". I bet it brought a smile to your face, didn't it :)
- teknologist 8y agoI don't know what you're talking about but you appear to be expressing insecurity of some kind.
- MarkMc 8y agoI don't see this as negative - I was quite impressed that China has reached the stage where a private company can almost launch a rocket into space.
- crispyporkbites 8y ago
- Symmetry 8y agoIt speaks well of their program that the first two stages worked. Losing a couple of rockets in the first 10 launch attempts is par for the course in developing a new rocket, even for organizations that have been doing this for decades. If a new organization loses a couple more on their first rocket then that's how you learn.