5 ms·
I think the title of the article slightly overstates what is being reported. "Misstated Production Figures" makes it sound as if Tesla lied about what it had pr
by hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
I think the title of the article slightly overstates what is being reported. "Misstated Production Figures" makes it sound as if Tesla lied about what it had produced, as opposed to just giving unrealistically rosy projections.
I can definitely see how Musk's "funding secured" tweet crossed the line into potentially criminal behavior, but honestly, I have a hard time seeing how overly optimistic projections can be criminal if there is even an iota of a possibility that they could be met, no matter how unlikely.
- discodave 8y agoIf they knew they were rosy, or didn't make an honest effort to get them right, then it's intentionally mislaeding the stock market.
- mattigames 8y agoWhat would happen if Bill Gates says "Windows 10 is the best windows ever", is he misleading the stock market? What if he doesn't actually believe its the best Windows? Seems like trying to see a line between optimism and projections an that's idiotic. Seems to me that legally an accusation of misleading the stock market should happen only when putting fake data on official marketing reports or sales reports not about CEO's tweets.
- rpeden 8y ago"Windows 10 is the best Windows ever" isn't a projection, though. People wouldn't rush out to buy MS stock based on a statement like this. I hope not, anyway. "We're going to sell 800 million Windows 10 licenses this quarter" would be a projection. People might buy MS stock based on something like this. Publicly traded companies routinely provide earnings guidance based on production/sales forecasts. And earnings guidance absolutely has an impact on share price. So if a company is knowingly providing unlikely guidance figures, they're also knowingly misleading the market. I'm just speaking generally here. I don't know enough about the Tesla case to comment one way or another.
- wpietri 8y agoExactly. The technical term for things like "best ever" is puffery: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Puffery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Puffery "Best ever" is a subjective statement, and most people would not take it as a neutral statement of carefully researched fact. Official corporate financial projections, on the other hand, are taken very seriously. People expect they might be wrong, but not that they might be fraudulent or negligent with regards to the truth.
- mabbo 8y agoConsider: yesterday Amazon announced quarterly results and projections. It wasn't very rosey: next quarter will see growth, but less than usual. The stock took an immediate 10% hit. Now, what if they had been 'optimistic'? Well, they might have said "yeah we're going to keep hitting growth targets!" And the stock would have done very well today. All those employees holding stock would have seen a nice boost to their bottom line. But it is the responsibility of a publicly traded company to provide such accurate forecasts to the best level they can so that the stockholders- members of the public like you and me- can make decisions based on facts, not hopeful opinions. Amazon had to tell the truth even when it personally cost everyone in the company some net worth. This is just one cost/responsibility that comes with being publicly traded.
- bobthepanda 8y ago"Windows 10 is the best windows ever" is not a statement of fact that has a direct impact on a stock's earnings and price. "We are going to sell and ship ten billion Xbox Ones" does.
- joecool1029 8y ago>What would happen if Bill Gates says "Windows 10 is the best windows ever" That would be considered puffery: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Puffery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Puffery
- dunpeal 8y ago> I have a hard time seeing how overly optimistic projections can be criminal if there is even an iota of a possibility that they could be met, no matter how unlikely. This is a public company, not an Avengers movie trailer. They can't just conjure arbitrarily positive numbers out of thin air. Their statements to investors and potential-investors must be fact based and made in good faith. Otherwise, what's wrong with Musk's tweet? I'm sure there was "an iota of a possibility" that someone crazy enough would buy Tesla at $420. There's "an iota of a possibility" for a lot of far-fetched scenarios, but public companies must be truthful and reasonable in their statements made to the investing public - especially when they err on the side of optimism.
- jklinger410 8y agoReasons not to take your company public.
- sandworm101 8y agoWell, misleading statements to your shareholders can still result in lawsuits. Lawsuits over this stuff regularly happen even within closely-help family companies. If you really want freedom to make up numbers the only thing to do is not have shareholders. Keep the company all within a single individual. But at that point why even bother making official projections.
- rchaud 8y agoYou make it sound like Tesla's hypothetical private investors wouldn't have legal recourse if the CEO missed his production target by 96%.
- joering2 8y agoThe probably wouldn’t bother going into many years of legal battle knowing they are cutting the branch of three they sitting on. With public company all you have to do is conplain to SEC in hopes to i.e. remove CEO from his duties and get going with someone else in charge. Clearly there is huge advantage of getting access to hundreds of millions of dolars in capital to spend, but that’s usually where advantages ends.
- pvg 8y agocan be criminal if there is even an iota of a possibility that they could be met That would make all sorts of pump & dump scams perfectly fine and they aren't.
- greglindahl 8y agoThe SEC thing was civil, not criminal.
- thinkloop 8y agoIf there is a 1 in 3 chance or better of achieving the goal, it's probably legit, if it's 1 in 100, probably illegal. Something around there.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Someone 8y ago“Overly optimistic”, by definition, is asking for trouble. I’m not a lawyer, but I think even just optimistic projections should be avoided at all costs in earnings forecasts. They may be fine, if accompanied with a zillion “if all stars align” phrases, but it’s a minefield best avoided. https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2012/11/08/giving-good-guidance-what-every-public-company-should-know/ https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2012/11/08/giving-good-guida... (near the end, after a zillion warnings to be careful): ”Viewed with hindsight, overly optimistic guidance can result in financial cost to the company and its directors and officers.”
- rchaud 8y ago> I’m not a lawyer, but I think Tesla has a lawyer, probably several, that know exactly how far company officers can go regarding making public projections. They can't do much if the CEO loves headlines and says whatever it takes to stay in them.
- AndrewBissell 8y agoTesla's General Counsel is Elon Musk's divorce attorney. The SEC settlement contained some not-very-subtle digs at his qualifications to keep Tesla/Musk within the bounds of securities regulations.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- elif 8y ago"secured" is a vague word in itself. there are degrees of security, everything from "This bank account is secured by FDIC insurance" to "This touchdown secured his Heisman bid" to "You are secured to this lava helicopter by a piece of yarn"
- macintux 8y agoThere's no interpretation of the phrase "funding secured" in the SEC-regulated world which includes "I've had conversations with an investor who didn't immediately say no to the idea".
- GenericsMotors 8y agoWhat other interpretation can "funding secured" possibly have other than "we've got to funding to go ahead with this"?
- alehul 8y agoYou're almost certainly right that the part about this being a "criminal probe" seems wrong, but there are possible legal issues from a civil perspective. While it's not enforced that tightly by the SEC, it's common knowledge in banking that, for instance in the process of an IPO (or in the offering of any security to the public, i.e. quarterly reports), you should always show pessimism in your outlook. Take Snap's S-1 [1], for an example-- I linked to the Risk Factors section, and you can see a huge amount of bullet points of everything that could possibly go wrong for Snap, even going into how Google could raise prices on cloud storage and screw them over. While, again, I totally agree with you it isn't criminal, Tesla could be in trouble if they gave very idealistic estimates. [1] https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1564408/000119312517029199/d270216ds1.htm#rom270216_2 https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1564408/000119312517...
- matwood 8y agoYou call it pessimism, I call it outlining risks that could materially change the financial outlook of the business. People routinely underestimate risk and overestimate rewards.
- davedx 8y agoIt's also worth keeping in mind the WSJ has a very bad track record for climate change denial. See, for example, https://www.theguardian.com/environment/climate-consensus-97-per-cent/2018/jun/11/the-wall-street-journal-keeps-peddling-big-oil-propaganda https://www.theguardian.com/environment/climate-consensus-97... This article is highly questionable given their history.
- tanderson92 8y agoThat article is the WSJ Opinion page which is very different from their reporting.
- davedx 8y agoReally? https://www.mediamatters.org/blog/2015/08/11/its-not-just-the-editorial-page-study-finds-wsj/204855 https://www.mediamatters.org/blog/2015/08/11/its-not-just-th... You can downvote me if you want. It doesn't stop the WSJ being a highly objectionable source for anything related to climate change.
- tanderson92 8y agoI didn't downvote you. It remains the case that citing problems exclusive to its Opinion page, as you did in your first post, is a poor way of critiquing the news reporting section.
- OscarCunningham 8y agoHis settlement with the SEC over his "funding secured" tweet required Tesla to put in place a system to monitor Musk's tweeting. Given that, the SEC is less likely to give leeway for further over-optimistic tweets.