7 ms·
Calling it "screen time" is missing the elephant in the room. The largest part of the problem is that the software we're directly interacting with has been desi
by mindslight 8y ago
Calling it "screen time" is missing the elephant in the room. The largest part of the problem is that the software we're directly interacting with has been designed by companies with interests directly contrary to ours!
Social interaction will inherently set off more chemical rewards, but it is the tuning of the feedback loop (optimizing for micro-interactions) that keeps us glued.
Emacs/mutt/libreoffice/python/kodi have not been adversarily tuned to fire off the reward centers of our brains just enough to keep us returning for more. Whereas on the same exact screen, firefox/chromium are gateways to madness.
- 51lver 8y agoMaybe someday FOSS "veganism" will catch on.
- mindslight 8y agoWith that analogy, I guess web browsers are cheese. I don't think FOSS is even necessary for what I'm talking about (although it seems to be sufficient). Non-networked binary distribution of yore was also (mostly) aligned with the interests of its users.
- marcosdumay 8y ago> Non-networked binary distribution of yore was also (mostly) aligned with the interests of its users. It's much more related to who is paying the bills. Technical concerns do make some difference, but are eclipsed by the money question. Our current problem is that people mostly don't pay for software anymore. So we are left with FOSS and anti-user software.
- mindslight 8y agoThough it's harder to be lucratively anti-user without a channel for telemetry and control. I've long pondered if an economy around Free software could be better implemented. We take it as a forgone conclusion that wide source code availability precludes charging per-instance, but really that's just an assumption. Of course the idea is likely moot in the light of network effects, which seem to be a major underlying factor of the current harsh dichotomy.
- marcosdumay 8y agoI wonder if it's possible to create some Paternon-like project that is inclusive, proportional to use, and does not fall victim to politics or administrative take-overs.
- OpenBSD-reich 8y agoIMO the problem is two pronged: a) hardware changes too much too fast creating a constant hamster wheel of driver hacking which puts GNU, Illumos, and BSD at a disadvantage, and b) that hardware is nowhere near significantly documented enough to make driver writing quick and painless. (a) can be fixed by having platform standards where the interfaces and commands are the same between device brands, but I think the better solution would be to fix (b) by using force of law or taxation to make device manufacturers fully and publicly document their hardware so that there are no "magic" or secret instructions, allowing FOSS hackers the ability to write open drivers. Ideally solution for (b) would be wide enough to include firmware and microcode, and penalty (tax) being both heavy enough (50%-200%) and applied at the customer purchase point of the chain (tax is on the final MSRP of the computer/phone/game-console/microwave/vehicle and not simply on the price of the noncompliant internal component[s]). (b) can be done with a proposition in the State of California and a few million spent on a very convincing ad campaign ("Vote yes on Proposition 42 to take back total control of your computing devices! Don't let advertisers and data leeches control and dictate your life from behind the curtain!"). California because it's home to a big chunk of Big Tech, and because it's a market too big to simply ignore and not sell into.
- mindslight 8y agoI don't disagree with your idea, but unfortunately there is always going to be that churn. Commercial device/app developers have lots of money to invest in robust development and advertisement, to beget the return of more money. Meanwhile, the economic benefits to preserving people's autonomy (/dignity) is spread out amongst those people. Which is why in another comment, I called it a "zero" million dollar idea. The flip side is all of this device churn is all the actually devices left in the wake, available for cheap/free. If software is done right, even last-decade specs are perfectly capable devices good for another decade. Which is what we need, because convincing someone to pave over their current device or spend a lot on a new "weird" one isn't going to happen. Tablets got a foothold by being a new type of device, rather than an immediate replacement.
- chrisweekly 8y agoHere's hoping. See Tristan Harris, "Time Well Spent", Center for Humane Technogy: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_Well_Spent https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_Well_Spent
- VectorLock 8y agoThis is the conclusion that a lot of people on HN seem to be reaching. Now how do we go about filtering out the 'bad screen' while allowing the 'good screen?'
- pesfandiar 8y agoOne good way to distinguish the two is whether or not it's pure consumption/entertainment or production/learning? I realize at times it may not be easy to do (e.g. watching cartoons or playing games that teach children something).
- mindslight 8y agoI mentioned kodi for a reason. I've definitely binged on seasons of shows using kodi (or mplayer), but it feels relatively deliberate. I don't support Netflix et al, so I don't know specifically how many dark patterns they've implemented to "increase engagement" or w/e, but I do know the setup is there. And obviously if you're using Youtube for "TV time", then game over.
- kitsunesoba 8y agoI’ve used Netflix alongside a Plex setup for years now, and if Netflix is employing any dark patterns they certainly aren’t effective on me. My usage of Netflix is just as random and deliberate as my Plex usage, and once I’m done watching an episode or binging on a series for the day I don’t find myself looking for more. YouTube used to be a lot more dangerous with their sidebar recommendations years ago but they changed the algorithm at some point and ever since it’s become very rare that I click on anything there.
- wott 8y agoThe dark pattern is series themselves. 1. They are massively produced and have replaced many other programs. There is always new content available, you can spend your life watching 3 new episodes an evening. 2. They are in fact not series any more, but serials. Each episode of a series has an independent storyline and comes to a conclusion; episodes can mostly be watched in random order, you can miss a broadcast, it doesn't matter, you can watch a later episodes without any problem. Serials are a single long storyline split in episodes: you can't miss one, let alone two episodes, otherwise you're lost; and they can use cliffhangers! and of course they do. The hooking is much much bigger for serials than for series, you always end up begging for more. Even when it starts as a series, they quickly inject enough serials elements to turn it into a serial in disguise.
- jimison 8y ago> Emacs/mutt/libreoffice/python/kodi have not been adversarily tuned to fire off the reward centers of our brains Indeed, some of those could desperately use a little polish to stop firing off the pain centers of our brains. :\
- faitswulff 8y agoGIMP comes to mind...
- Aeolos 8y agoGimp 2.10 is really rather pleasant to use. Some pains remain, but it's (very slowly) getting there.
- HoppyHaus 8y agoGimp as a whole becomes ten times better once you enable single window mode.
- 4ad 8y agoGimp having multiple windows is its best feature. Luckily, Photoshop on macOS (but not Windows) also has multiple windows mode (though it's emulated, they aren't really operating system windows, so not as nice as Gimp).
- Cursuviam 8y agoI always thought the name was supposed to evoke how masochistic it is.
- derefr 8y agoYep. The concept of "screen time" conflates such disparate things as "reading a book on an iPad" and "playing Candy Crush." In this instance, the medium is not the message. Books, movies, etc. don't suddenly become more addictive just because they're on glowing rectangles. The glowing rectangles enable additional, potentially-addictive experiences that weren't possible without them—but you as a parent have complete ability to disable these experiences. A glowing rectangle that can "only" function as a library, encyclopedia, movie theatre, radio, and (if you like) chatroom, is still a useful possession, but likely not an addictive one.
- woolvalley 8y agoLike TV ads targeted to children 20 years ago to buy into the beanie baby craze?
- Nasrudith 8y agoIronically it was the adults who were susceptible - they were just plush toys to kids. Which I suppose ironically rhymes with social media and deception.
- drb91 8y agoSeriously, I enjoy my beanie babies the same as I did 20 years ago. They’re a lot of fun to throw around! I just never expected anything more.
- avip 8y agoThat's a racoon maybe. The elephant is that said "screen time" comes au-lieu of parents attention.
- pokemongoaway 8y agoI don't totally agree about the evil company idea, but it is totally true that useful programs like vim or editors could be reimagined for better throughput!
- DoreenMichele 8y agoThe largest part of the problem is that the software we're directly interacting with has been designed by companies with interests directly contrary to ours! I have two adult sons. They were online as early as ages 2 and 5. I beg to differ and all that. If kids are being ignored and not getting their needs adequately met, etc, then what happens online can have a huge adverse impact on them. But I don't think this is a problem we solve by trying to "fix software." This is a problem we solve by trying to fix social fabric.
- mindslight 8y agoYou're right of course, but not exclusively - both are necessary. IMHO the era your sons were growing up, the concern was properly contextualizing online interpersonal interactions, which were completely invisible to parents by default. Now we're dealing with websites/apps that have been explicitly designed to addict mature adults, playing people as pawns against one another. I'm familiar with the idea of "Rat Park" [0], but I think even if we can be absolutely sure kids' needs are being met it would be naive to rely on it. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rat_Park https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rat_Park
- qubax 8y ago> Whereas on the same exact screen, firefox/chromium are gateways to madness. Oh my god, what hyperbole. This is like the cringey hyperbole equating rock 'n roll with devil music back in the 50s. Things will be fine. Every older generation thinks the newer generation is "mad". It's not the end of the world. Is hacker news mostly grandparents now? Just worried about every new technology? So many comments here feel like my grandparents talking. It's so sad how old and scared HN has gotten. HN isn't supposed to be like it.
- jplayer01 8y agoThe medium is the message. Go read a book or some studies about attention. It's not mindless fear-mongering.
- parasubvert 8y agoI have read the studies. The science is early and tenuous. I also remember what it was like to be a metalhead in the 80s. This is still mostly mindless fear mongering. Sometimes it also is about parents who have had problems parenting kids that slipped into addictive behavior patterns, and blaming the thing rather than just engaging with human nature. I have two kids, they use screens (with some reasonable limits), and they’re doing fine, but we need to be watchful and actively engaged in their screen use to ensure they know how to to put it down. Some kids needed extreme interventions, I get that. But addictive things aren’t bad things necessarily, they can be very good things in moderation. The world is a big place with more to do than screens. I don’t understand why thy extremes some rich SV families have had to implement is now some kind of “consensus”. The hell there is consensus. The screen also offers a rich world of its own and ample opportunity for personal advancement. Children need to learn how to manage it for their own ends. Thankfully both of my kiddos seem to be able to put the screen down after a bit and go outside to play.
- parasubvert 8y agoIt is a great case study in groupthink. Fear also is driving a lot of behavior lately generally. Reminds me of the 80s satanic cult scares. I don’t think all of HN is like this, it’s more about who was attracted to the headline.