3 ms·
The author Russ Roberts runs the EconTalk and is a well respected economist/journalist/thinker in the field, definitely worth reading for a fair assessment. Th
by joe_the_user 8y ago
The author Russ Roberts runs the EconTalk and is a well respected economist/journalist/thinker in the field, definitely worth reading for a fair assessment.
The thing one needs to understand about economics is that it's field where analysis and advocacy have never been separate. It's not just Marx and von Mises that were strong advocates of policy. Smith, Ricardo and Keynes had the favored policy and thus favored world view.
So being a respected economic commentator by itself isn't by itself a testament to objectivity.
The article is worth a glance but others here have to pointed to the serious methodological problems - following individuals falls victim to regression to mean, some poor can become wealth and some wealthy can become poor says nothing about the average gulf between the groups. Even more, if we have a society where the whole population is divided between wealthy and poor randomly, with each having a 1% of becoming wealthy and otherwise barely surviving, we might have a fair society but it would also be an extremely dysfunctional society (but know such fairness really could exist, so we're just left with the income inequality).
- joe_the_user 8y agoFurther, One might say there's a complex debate that goes between economists, where the arguments are framed as "how do we measure this policy's impact on equity, well-being and etc" but where each debater has their own emphasis and measure of these things. One pole might be a grim state socialism while another pole might be a Nietzsche/Harry-Lime view that "the goal of a society is to produce five great men and if the majority must be destitute for this, so be it". It's easy to say "we should be in the middle" but the reality talk of middles essentially involves where each debater wants to claim the "Overton Window" is located and so incrementally move it.