12 ms·
I think it is reasonably easy to prevent people from dating subordinates in the workplace. Up front, you explain that the policy is one word: don't. If it ever
by wpietri 8y ago
I think it is reasonably easy to prevent people from dating subordinates in the workplace. Up front, you explain that the policy is one word: don't. If it ever happens, you fire the higher-level person promptly. No excuses, no second chances.
Bosses should know not to have sexual or romantic relationships with people who work for them. We all know how one has to be careful what one says to one's boss. And we all no how hard it can be to say no to a boss or boss's boss about anything. It puts the junior person in an impossible situation.
But it's just as bad from the employer's perspective. Suddenly two people who are supposed to be putting the company's interests first have a strong conflict of interest. And when the relationship ends (as most do) you have a whole different set of unnecessary potential conflicts in the workplace.
- conradfr 8y agoAt some point people will only hire people of their own gender or different sexual orientation to avoid any problem down the line and it would be a loss for everybody.
- kevincrane 8y agoIs that really easier than just not sexually harassing people?
- sievebrain 8y agoThis Rubin story isn't about sexual harassment. Some woman dated him and then decided she was "coerced" (how?) into doing something she late regretted. Given the modern notion some women have developed that they can change their mind about whether an act was consensual at any time, even retroactively, it's not at all clear Rubin did anything wrong beyond adultery. After all have only this woman's word for it.
- thereare5lights 8y agoI sincerely hope you are not in any positions of power.
- kevincrane 8y ago> Some woman dated him and then decided she was "coerced" (how?) into doing something she late regretted. Given the modern notion some women have developed that they can change their mind about whether an act was consensual at any time jesus. With all due respect dude, this is incredibly retrogressive and I suggest you reevaluate your personal views on that.
- lawnchair_larry 8y agoDid you miss the part that covered the fact that she was consensually having an affair with him for years, and the trip where she decided it was time to break up is only when it became “pressure”? I suggest you be less naive.
- icebraining 8y agoHiring people of only one sex is illegal in the US. See the Hooters lawsuit, who had to settle for millions for only hiring women.
- klank 8y agoI believe that policy will work for mid-level and lower-level employee where the reporting structure is their power. However, for people like Rubin, the reporting structure isn't their power but their overall sway with the organization. In those cases it's not as easy to make a clear delineation along organizational boundaries.
- gowld 8y agoSomeone at that level can afford to pay for a matchmaking service and has plenty of willing strangers to date, and doesn't ned to go foraging among the staff.
- klank 8y agoSure, I'm not meaning to be an apologist for people in Rubin's position. Only meaning to say that a focus on organizational lines is not appropriate for somebody like that. The article itself points this out several times as if it should make a difference, however, I'd disagree. The power imbalance is too extreme, even for people not in the direct organizational chain.
- bwilliams18 8y agoIt's really not, when you're at that level (which I think is easy enough to define) you don't sleep with anyone in the company. At this point you should be a mature enough adult to be able to handle this, if you're not, you probably shouldn't be in a leadership role. If you're so enamored with someone then you leave. The workplace is a place for work, not a place to find a date. Do people date people they work with? Of course – and that's fine, but the second it gets in the way of the work it's a problem and needs to be handled, rarely can it be handled any other way than having one person leave.
- ummonk 8y agoRight. Even Travis Kalanick understood this.
- 8y ago
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoI don't think the issue is that simple with senior execs. The article brings up Page and Brin dating Google employees. Pretty much the entire Alphabet employee base are subordinates of those 2.
- dougmccune 8y agoIsn’t it pretty simple to just say that Page and Brin shouldn’t have ever dated anyone in the entire organization?
- lixtra 8y agoBut why? The fact that they date someone in their organization becomes only problematic if they coerce their partner into something using their position. Or if the partner accuses them of such. Ruling out theses intra company relationships is like saying that you cannot date a physically weaker partner because you are in a better position to physically force him int things he doesn’t want.
- wpietri 8y agoIt's a problem whether or not there's explicit coercion, because the subordinate will always have a reasonable suspicion of retaliation. But how do you plan to prove that no explicit coercion took place? Should they just video-record all of their interactions so that an impartial review board can regularly review goings on to make sure no harm is happening? Or is instead your plan to place a burden on the junior person to report? If that's the case, you should do a little research on what percentage of problems are reported, which of those reports are taken seriously, and which of the seriously-taken reports see appropriate action. In those numbers you'll find your answer as to why it won't work.
- lixtra 8y ago> But how do you plan to prove that no explicit coercion took place? How do you do that on regular dates? Do you record them? What’s the difference? Proving is always difficult. You just have to take contextual evidence. > Or is instead your plan to place a burden on the junior person to report? Of course the burden of proof is on the accuser. The fact that two people are in a relationship is not a proof. But creepy comments about polyamorism is good evidence. And yes, the superior is in a weaker position if accused of coercion. So the higher level partner should take a higher risk if the case is brought to court.
- simonsarris 8y ago> I think it is reasonably easy to prevent people from dating subordinates in the workplace. Up front, you explain that the policy is one word: don't. If it ever happens, you fire the higher-level person promptly. No excuses, no second chances. This is completely absurd. How many current great relationships would have never existed under such a rule? (Bill and Melinda Gates is the obvious go-to example, or Barack and Michelle Obama, but there are no doubt millions.)
- untog 8y ago> Barack and Michelle Obama I actually don't think that's true. They met through work, but didn't start dating until her summer term in the job ended.
- pitt1980 8y agoOther way around, she was his mentor as a summer associate "Robinson met Barack Obama when they were among the few African Americans at their law firm, Sidley Austin LLP (she has sometimes said only two, although others have noted ut there were others in different departments).[55] She was assigned to mentor him while he was a summer associate.[56] Their relationship started with a business lunch and then a community organization meeting where he first impressed her.[57]" https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michelle_Obama https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michelle_Obama
- Brockenstein 8y ago>This is completely absurd. How many current great relationships would have never existed under such a rule? How many great relationships/working relationships wouldn't be ruined because of that rule? How many people wouldn't have lives and careers ruined because of that rule? Frankly if you love someone that damn much, move to a different job and avoid the potential conflicts that are involved. Good luck arguing that a boss absolutely needs the option to date a subordinate because what if a serious relationship never happens? I mean it's nice if you can pull examples out of the air when it worked out for two people. But for everyone else? What's the ratio of happy couples to victims do you need to tilt scales to one side or the other?
- 8y ago
- miles 8y ago> I think it is reasonably easy to prevent people from dating subordinates in the workplace. Up front, you explain that the policy is one word: don't. If it ever happens, you fire the higher-level person promptly. No excuses, no second chances. In such a world, the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation would likely not exist: Office Romance: How Bill Met Melinda https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/features/office-romance-how-bill-met-melinda-855292.html https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/fe... The first time Bill Gates asked Melinda Gates out on a date, she turned him down https://www.businessinsider.com/melinda-gates-turned-bill-gates-down-2015-3 https://www.businessinsider.com/melinda-gates-turned-bill-ga...
- mikestew 8y agoIn such a world, the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation would likely not exist: We can cure malaria without having millions of women sexually harassed at work.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoYour statement implies Melinda Gates as sexually assaulted at work by Bill, which is wrong. Or more directly, your response does not speak to the argument.
- mikestew 8y agoYour statement implies Melinda Gates as sexually assaulted at work by Bill, which is wrong. sigh It implies no such thing except under the most uncharitable of interpretations. Here, I'll spell it out: one exception with a positive outcome does not offset the millions of women who have been harassed by their boss. IOW, "hey, baby, we could be the next Billinda!", just no.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoYou're digging yourself a hole by once again presuming that people who are involved in office romances are mostly likely to be in situations of sexual coercion. This is not remotely the case. Most office romances are just two people dating - and that's it. It's the possibility that something might go awry that's problematic, not the situation itself. Gates is not 'one example' - it's the norm. Wherever you work, there are surely people dating/married to one another, it's almost normative.
- sonnyblarney 8y ago" Up front, you explain that the policy is one word: don't. If it ever happens, you fire the higher-level person promptly. No excuses, no second chances." In the real world, it's not that easy. Things happen. Also, it's probably illegal, or it wouldn't hold up in court. VP of Customer Service falls in love with one of the help-desk assistants, they get married, VP gets fired - that's a lawsuit.
- tptacek 8y agoNo contract any VP of Customer Service is going to have will insulate them from being fired for cause, which is what would be happening if they violated a basic HR handbook rule about dating subordinates. And that's assuming the "VP of Customer Service" has a negotiated contract in the first place. Most employees, even managers, don't have negotiated contracts; they have the default handbook contract, which I guarantee you restates and maintains the US default, which is termination at will.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoTermination at will doesn't cover things that violates people's rights, and a whole host of other things. You can't fire someone because they are black, or gay, or Mormon, or get sick - and probably not because they fall in love with each other either.
- nradov 8y agoMost US employers absolutely can legally fire an employee because of who they fall in love with, as long as the action isn't based on a policy which disproportionately impacts a protected class.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoMaybe you're right, but I'm doubtful. I wonder how it would hold up in a big supreme court challenge (or maybe it has already ... I'm not an expert)
- yongjik 8y agoSure, because zero-tolerance policies work so well in practice.. While we're at it, why don't we also tell teenagers about sex? One word: Don't. Problem solved.
- munificent 8y agoShould we not have higher expectations for rich senior executives than we do your average teenager?
- yongjik 8y agoI'm not objecting to holding executives at higher standard. I'm objecting to zero-tolerance policies at workplace (or anywhere), which is (in a way) the opposite of holding people at higher standard: it's basically saying "I don't trust you to have common sense, so here are the rules and you will follow them unquestionably." It's a pain in the ass for those who have common sense, and unmitigated disaster for those who don't.
- chrisbennet 8y agoEveryone thinks they have common sense but it all goes out the window when romance is involved. When you decide to date a close coworker, you are setting her (and it’s always her) to lose her job or feel uncomfortable enough that she needs to leave, if it doesn’t work out. Many men don’t even consider that ‘cause hormones.
- PaulRivers 8y agoNo, theen who don't consider it get laid while the men who do consider don't get anywhere. You'll notice these themes are always repetively "sex bad!" with no "sex good" elements ever.
- TallGuyShort 8y agoOh - do a lot of rich senior executives display a greater degree of sexual restraint than high school students?
- nradov 8y agoIn a modern matrix organization with shifting project assignments it's not always clear who is a subordinate. Some employees may have formal or informal "dotted line" responsibilities to multiple managers, all of whom can impact their career.
- Mtinie 8y agoIf the organization structure is so complex it isn’t clear, then all the more reason for senior-level leaders to abstain from intimate relationships with people they work with, at any level within the org.
- dcole2929 8y agoThe problem is that is an infinitely arbitrarily moving goalpost. The issue isn't even clear with in the specifics of Rubin's situation. If someone directly reports to you then the answer is obviously no. But from the article it seems like some of these relationships which were inappropriate were with people who were only tangentially in his chain of command. And some not at all. What happens when you start at the same level but are promoted to different levels? If you're responsible for making your company Billions of dollars a year the way Andy Rubin is you can easily argue he shouldn't be able to date anyone in that company at all without there being an unacceptable power dynamic. But as someone worth close to a billion dollars that's probably true of any relationship he's in. Google has literally millions of employees, is it ok to say he can't date any of them? That's why I said it's a tricky issue with no good answers. It's easy to say people should know this or know that but the fact is different people know and believe different things. You have to have a codified policy. And if you can't codify a policy that works in every case then you don't have a good one.
- munificent 8y ago> What happens when you start at the same level but are promoted to different levels? If through promotion or re-org one partner ends up in the subtree of the other, either end the relationship or find a new position for one of the two people. > If you're responsible for making your company Billions of dollars a year the way Andy Rubin is you can easily argue he shouldn't be able to date anyone in that company at all without there being an unacceptable power dynamic. So be it! Being in charge of thousands of people and billions of dollars is an incredible responsibility. That kind of responsibility requires discipline and sacrifice. If you want the freedom to fuck anyone you want in the org chart, don't try to climb to the top of the org chart. > Google has literally millions of employees, is it ok to say he can't date any of them? Thousands, not millions. And, yes, that's totally OK. Any executive who doesn't like that can spend some of the millions of dollars making themselves feel better. Seriously, if you're worth +$100M and you can't find a date outside of the office, you've got bigger problems than the org chart. > You have to have a codified policy. Google has a codified policy, which every employee signs that they agree to. It says you can't date people when there is a reporting chain between them. There are seven billion people on Earth. Executives can find someone outside of their reporting structure to fall in love with. This isn't hard. The only problem here is that the kind of people who want to be in charge of thousands of people and billions of dollars are often also the kind of people who want lots of power and to have the rules not apply to them.
- majani 8y agoWomen are have a strong, natural attraction to leaders, so this rule won't stick in a practical sense.
- harshaw 8y agoErr... what? I think this deserves a down vote (which I don't have)
- bsder 8y ago> I think it is reasonably easy to prevent people from dating subordinates in the workplace. I think you are terribly naiive. Why does someone have the drive to climb these corporate power structures in the first place? What's the point of power if it's not being (ab)used? If you want to accomplish something, you're better off starting a company rather than climbing one.
- ericjang 8y agoFiring the more senior person automatically is an interesting idea. Are there any companies that do this in a way that doesn't add excessive legal liabilities to the company?
- killjoywashere 8y ago> I think it is reasonably easy to prevent people from dating subordinates in the workplace Even the military struggles with this. It's not easy.
- Twisell 8y agoUsually law/policy that strictly forbid someone to date somebody which is deemed inferior in any way haven’t turned out to be good idea throughout human history...