12 ms·
Citus Data Donates 1% of Equity to PostgreSQL Organizations
- mistrial9 8y agocongrats to this ! Brewster at Archive.org has been making some persuasive points in public, recently, about non-profit org models, FOSS and sustainable finance models.
- citilife 8y agoDoes anyone know what Citus Data is valued at? I'm curious what this is "worth" to the PostgreSQL organizations? Although, to me it seems more like a gesture than anything else - I am curious.
- Fnoord 8y agoApparently others have done this as well: "Building a Movement of Corporate Philanthropy We want to change the world through inspiring early–stage corporate philanthropy. Pledge 1% is an easy way to leverage a portion of your future success to support nonprofits in your community. It’s a small commitment today that can make a huge impact tomorrow. The sooner you start, the easier it is–so join your fellow founders by making a pledge today!" [1] In the list are companies like Atlassian, Salesforce, and Yelp. The pledge is either 1% of equity, time, product, or profit. [1] https://pledge1percent.org https://pledge1percent.org
- the_duke 8y agoThis is not philanthropy, this is a company financially supporting the essential foundation upon which their product is built.
- dymk 8y agoWhat's the difference?
- singlow 8y agoThe investor expects a tangible direct benefit from the investment. A philanthropist expects only the benefit of humanity as a whole, and maybe her own good feelings; or if you are cynical, prestige.
- Fnoord 8y agoMethinks you are confusing altruism with philanthropy/charity. Either way, it is more than that due to PostgreSQL's software license. Because of that, we all (potentially) benefit. And it is a commitment. A (somewhat) stable source. More so if more companies commit to such a pledge.
- antirez 8y agoPotentially Citus may be worth a lot, so this is in no way just a symbolic gesture. IMHO it could be the start of something very right happening more often. It was funded for 13M so far btw (crunchbase data).
- pbiggar 8y agoTheir last round was 9.5m, so I'd say their valuation was probably $50m (postmoney) at the time. That was 3 years ago though, so it has likely gone up quite a bit.
- jtchang 8y agoGood on them. When done in a transparent and public manner this could be a good thing. One thing to always watch out for is how incentives align. One possible scenario to think about is if this 1% equity now tilt any sort of balance in the postgresql organization regarding decision making? I.e. if a decision adversely affects Citus but is better for the community.
- koolba 8y agoIf the history of the core committee and contributors till now is any indication of their objectivity and community focus, I’m not worried about that in the slightest.
- anarazel 8y agoSee https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18296064 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18296064
- jakobegger 8y agoThe PostgreSQL community consists of a large number of companies that all contribute large amounts of time and money towards PostgreSQL. A single donation (even if it's big) is not going to shift the balance in a significant manner.
- ccleve 8y agoIf they had made a cash donation, it would have been an unambiguously good thing. Equity, however, creates a conflict of interest. If the non-profit Postgres organizations make money when Citus makes money, then they have an incentive to favor Citus over other companies. Let's say there's a Citus competitor. The competitor implements a feature a bit differently than Citus. Does Postgres support both organizations equally? Or if there's a technical decision to be made, and it involves making one company's code incompatible with base Postgres, who do you think will win? It's a free market, and the parties involved are perfectly free to make this arrangement, but it generates potential problems.
- anarazel 8y agoDisclaimer: I used to work for Citus and have options. > Equity, however, creates a conflict of interest. If the non-profit Postgres organizations make money when Citus makes money, then they have an incentive to favor Citus over other companies. > Let's say there's a Citus competitor. The competitor implements a feature a bit differently than Citus. Does Postgres support both organizations equally? Or if there's a technical decision to be made, and it involves making one company's code incompatible with base Postgres, who do you think will win? Note that none of the non-profits have technical decision making power. That's in the end the decision of the committers (and potentially the core team if there's irreconcilable conflicts). Both groups work for a variety of companies.
- hamandcheese 8y ago> Let's say there's a Citus competitor. The competitor implements a feature a bit differently than Citus. Does Postgres support both organizations equally? Well, maybe the competing company could also become a major donor.
- cowmix 8y agoMy ISP.. long ago.. fixed a few key thing in Postgres95 which fixed a few keys things (see slide 19 -- https://www.pgcon.org/2007/schedule/attachments/30-great_steps.pdf https://www.pgcon.org/2007/schedule/attachments/30-great_ste...). From that point on, we never had to touch the core again. The Postgresql community is awesome.
- twic 8y agoOn Tue, 22 Oct 1996, Julian Assange wrote: > Does anyone know what is happening with the delegation of the > postgres domains? Indirect.com was going to hand them over, > but as yet has not. Not a name i was expecting to see! He seems to have made a few commits to psql: http://mat.caminos.upm.es/~iht/pased2011/ http://mat.caminos.upm.es/~iht/pased2011/
- rrix2 8y agoAssange used to be involved in FOSS, even writing and maintaining tools like surfraw[1] [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surfraw https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surfraw
- bch 8y agoAlso has his fingers in NetBSD, though mostly in fortune(1) files, iirc. https://queue.acm.org/blogposting.cfm?id=27326 https://queue.acm.org/blogposting.cfm?id=27326
- jopsen 8y agoWow, people are quick to suggest this could somehow comprise postgres independence.. I think 1% percent donations like this is fantastic. In this it also seems to make business sense for Citus to ensure postgres is well funded :) Still a good example to follow.
- garyclarke27 8y agoWell done Citus, comendable and inspiring. I’m betting most of my wealth and my new company on Postgres, if it succeeds, I hope to emulate you. Postgres is an incredible data platform, that just gets better and better every year with more functionality AND better performance (unlike most software where more features = slower) AND consistent rock solid reliability AND the best documentation of any product I have seen.
- unclefoo 8y agocan you elaborate more about your company ?
- garyclarke27 8y agoWe’re building - a new commerce automation platform - a unified ERP/CRM/CMS.
- unixhero 8y agoHi Odoo guy! I'm a huge fan of your product. It's powering all my startups.
- growlist 8y agoI love Postgres! I've barely scratched the surface compared to you and I found Postgres a pleasure to use when building a solution around it recently, so I'd say even at the basic use/novice end of things it's superior to say SQL Server or (gulp) Oracle, which are the other databases I've had experience of. I use Python to orchestrate and read SQL scripts from disk which I then write my dynamic variables into, and then pump that into Postgres with psycopg2, and the whole thing's been running perfectly for a couple of years now. Probably a hacky way to do things but it's all offline so I have the luxury of not worrying about security.
- Bucephalus355 8y agoFun fact: Ingres was the brainchild of the brilliant Professor Michael Stonebraker. After the company went under after being beaten by Oracle in the RDBMS marketplace, he open-sourced the DB as a shot against Larry Ellison. Hence it’s name, “Post-Ingres”, or Postgres. Also, I believe his version of SQL was called QUEL, and we would have been using that term today had Ingres won out.
- tomcam 8y agoI remember Ingres but was too stupid to make the connection when Postgres came out. That is awesome.
- wu_tang_chris 8y ago> too stupid being a little bit hard on yourself there
- vmlinuz 8y agoWe used Ingres on HP-UX for our database class when I was at university in the late 90's - and now the vast majority of my current colleagues are quite a lot younger than I am, and they don't know why I keep doing double-takes when they're talking about k8s/nginx ingress...
- singlow 8y agoYour history got me interested so I looked it up on Wikipedia. Based on the info there, POSTGRES or Post-Ingres was a new project that he started after Ingres, and based on its concepts, but not using the Ingres code. PostgreSQL is based on the POSTGRES code which was licensed BSD from the outset.
- sitharus 8y agoThere's a timeline on Wikipedia that has all the relationships, it's interesting how related everything is. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/22/RDBMS_timeline.svg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/22/RDBMS_ti...
- shady-lady 8y agoI like the idea of DB as a managed service but in effect this surely means that 3rd party has access to the data?
- quickthrower2 8y agoCash (profit share?) would be better no? Equity can't be spent now.
- sbr464 8y agoGreat news! I have a friend that works at Pledge 1%, A company that is based on this idea, I always thought it was a cool concept, maybe doing something like this (or similar) for Open Source would be interesting. https://pledge1percent.org https://pledge1percent.org
- jaxn 8y agoI love working with Citus (I'm a customer). Everyone I have interacted with there has been very helpful and supportive. Almost surprisingly so. This seems right in line with their core values. At least how the company values are practiced since I have no idea if they have "core values" or how they are worded. Well done!
- iKevinShah 8y agoI can confirm this. I was trying out their product as an option and still they were super helpful (shout out to Sai if you're here) and everyone else too.. Also their slack page is decently active and helpful
- serveradminblog 8y agoAre they generous or this is just to avoid Server Side Public License from PostgreSQL ?
- justinclift 8y agoWhy would a Server Side Public License be needed?
- Tostino 8y agoWhat do you mean? How would this have anything to do with changing the license?
- tr33house 8y agoThis is awesome but it would've been nice to see 10%, something like a tithe for the company's building blocks