2 ms·
While Kliff's work seems good, the title has the "Helping X, one Y at a time" problem. The actually state of affairs is that arbitrary hospital bills are a pro
by joe_the_user 8y ago
While Kliff's work seems good, the title has the "Helping X, one Y at a time" problem.
The actually state of affairs is that arbitrary hospital bills are a problem that won't be solved one hospital at a time but rather are going require regulation, not just on all hospitals but of health care broadly.
- tialaramex 8y agoThe one Y at a time approach brings _transparency_ as mentioned in the title. Once there's transparency the conversation is more likely to be about the facts because that's what everybody can see. When you don't have transparency what happens is that everybody can bring their own anecdotes, maybe baseless, and you can watch as a group "wins the argument" based on claims _you_ know are spurious, because even though their position is unsupportable on the facts, nobody had those facts. So, you're right that Kliff's work doesn't itself fix the problem, but what it does is document the problem unmistakeably so that this thread has fewer people saying "I don't think that can be right, my friend's sister knew someone who worked in an ER and they never charge that much". Back in technology the Certificate Transparency system doesn't itself solve any problems per se. But it delivers transparency, and that has allowed clean-ups to happen in years that would undoubtedly have taken decades to complete without transparency. It still requires a Will in the right place to solve the problem, for example CT's effectiveness is in good part dependant on Mozilla. Would Google step up to the plate and do the same job if Mozilla didn't exist? Maybe, or maybe for political reasons as a for-profit they would fail. Certainly Symantec's leadership believed that going over our heads to Google management would get them what they wanted, but unless what they wanted was "Get out of this business" that does not seem to have worked. But the good news is that for healthcare Americans can vote to put that Will in place in your country.