11 ms·
How a Massive Ad Fraud Scheme Exploited Android Phones to Steal Millions
- 0xmohit 8y ago> This means a significant portion of the millions of Android phone owners who downloaded these apps were secretly tracked as they scrolled and clicked inside the application. By copying actual user behavior in the apps, the fraudsters were able to generate fake traffic that bypassed major fraud detection systems. So the fraudsters essentially did what Google is best at -- tracking and making 'use' of the information.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jaclaz 8y agoI seems to me that - besides the specific fraud scheme in the article - there is something else to be worried about. From the article: >The revelation of this scheme shows just how deeply fraud is embedded in the digital advertising ecosystem, the vast sums being stolen from brands, and the overall failure of the industry to stop it. And, more relevant: >Pixalate’s latest analysis of in-app fraud found that 23% of all ad impressions in mobile apps are in some way fraudulent. Now, if the numbers are correct and 23% of ad impressions is fraudulent, it should mean that either: 1) the firms/brands/whatever that are paying for these ads cannot measure with a sufficient degree of accuracy the results of these ads 2) they perfectly know that more than 1/5 of their ads expense is having "null" results but overall they are ok to spend the 100% price for less than 80% "real" impressions If the first hypothesis is true there is some incompetence around, if the second, it's business as usual. I believe more likely the #2 to be true, and since the companies/brands/etc. insist on it, this 20-25% "surcharge" is a "standard" of sorts. So,hypothetically , if these frauds would be completely eradicated and the companies would continue to invest the same amount of money in ads, we are doomed to see 20-25% more ads than we do now.
- idunno246 8y agoIt’s defintiely 2. But ads are priced on value to the advertiser. If someone reduced fraud to 0% they would just charge 20% more, and that money goes from fraudsters to advertisers, not more ads. This exists already, networks that filter out fraud better can charge higher rates.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> they perfectly know that more than 1/5 of their ads expense is having "null" results but overall they are ok to spend the 100% price for less than 80% "real" impressions Don't ad companies charge fees as a function of spend? The chumps in this chain are (a) shareholders and (b) the managers hiring the agencies. (Counterfactual: if this spend is that useless, it should be possible to start a competitor that focuses on high-ROI advertising.)
- ucaetano 8y ago> Counterfactual: if this spend is that useless, it should be possible to start a competitor that focuses on high-ROI advertising. Exactly! And that's where online ads, user tracking, online-to-offline came in. The whole reason why it gained so much traction in the past 20 years is that it began to offer better tracking and results than other forms of advertising. If Google (or Facebook, or anyone else) stands still and lets fraudsters abuse their ad networks, the return on their ads will drop, opening space for their competitors. So controlling ad-serving quality is a competitive advantage.
- michaelbuckbee 8y agoI'm always curious how exactly the fraud detection happens. Is Pixalate doing network analysis? App Analysis? Could I do the same thing myself with wireshark on my home network?
- z3t4 8y agoBasically all "spyware" traffic is encrypted, you can however see which IP's users of your network connects to (and some meta-data such as domain name, protocol and hand-shakes) using for example Wireshark or tcpdump. My guess is that the fraud is detected by monitoring the traffic on the ad server, see that a "impression" is registered from their test phone's IP, and by looking at the phone they affirm that no ad was displayed.
- sdossick 8y agoIt is functionally trivial to rotate IPs from the "test phones". There are shady brokers who will sell you Residential IP-based proxy servers (hacked home machines which will proxy your calls and make them appear to come from homes all around the world).
- z3t4 8y agoI mean in an audit, the test person can install the app on a device he/she has physical access to. And conclude that his/her phone was registered on the ad agency logs, yet no ad where shown. The fraudsters could however make it so the phone only sends fake impressions after a certain amount of engagement, so that audit/test person would have to play "my little pony" eg the child game - for one week ...
- cf498 8y agoQuite alot of it is done be measuring the rate of clicks vs views and simple statistics. If people actually click on the ad, its a red flag and likely fraud.
- thijser 8y agoThis is Mathijs from AppBrain. The app mentioned at the start of the article used Admob and Adcolony it seems: https://www.appbrain.com/app/emoji-switcher-root/com.stevenschoen.emojiswitcher https://www.appbrain.com/app/emoji-switcher-root/com.stevens... and was taken down on October 2nd. Another app implied in this scheme used 15 ad networks (including Admob, Facebook Audience Network and Twitter's Mopub) and was just taken down 6 days ago: https://www.appbrain.com/app/wheel-of-surprise-eggs/com.thomsandapps.wheelofsurpriseeggs https://www.appbrain.com/app/wheel-of-surprise-eggs/com.thom...
- thijser 8y agoWe updated our SDK signatures and now have a public page that shows stats about apps that contain this malware: https://www.appbrain.com/stats/libraries/details/techsnab-code/techsnab-behavior-capture-code https://www.appbrain.com/stats/libraries/details/techsnab-co... If you want to check your own device if you have any apps that contain the code used by this botnet, the latest release of our AppBrain Ad Detector app will scan for it. It's available on Google Play here: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.appspot.swisscodemonkeys.detector https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.appspot.sw...
- tareqak 8y agoGoogle's blog about it: https://security.googleblog.com/2018/10/google-tackles-new-ad-fraud-scheme.html https://security.googleblog.com/2018/10/google-tackles-new-a...
- gcb0 8y agoa security blog you can only read after enabling javascript for a dozen domains. Nice one google.
- elejo 8y agoAdding ?m=1 to Blogger blogs usually works. https://security.googleblog.com/2018/10/google-tackles-new-ad-fraud-scheme.html?m=1 https://security.googleblog.com/2018/10/google-tackles-new-a...
- John_KZ 8y agoHow silly of you to assume one can deliver 2kb of text without running thousands of lines of blackbox-javascript on your device and contacting dozens of servers. Besides, do you have anything to hide? Not running JS would suggest so, and possible help identify you online as the one guy that doen't run JS from your IP range. Welcome to the future.
- gcb0 8y agopeople here can't understand sarcasm :) I had a laugh, then got sad. but upvoted you anyway.
- charmides 8y agoDidn't this type of fraud require massive domain expertise?
- gcb0 8y ago1. record all network interaction going out of your MRAID adapter, from your few, actual users. 2. replace timestamp and userIDs fields on the network requests you will replay with Math.random() 3. Profit! Seems pretty simple and banal to me.
- stordoff 8y ago> userIDs fields on the network requests you will replay with Math.random() Isn't this _why_ you'd need domain expertise? Random User IDs would be detectable - a French user suddenly clicking on English ads and following East Coast time would be a red flag.
- gcb0 8y agothe beauty is that everyone want to do re-attribution, so they can buy cheap and sell expensive. if I send a bid to google with a random browser id, it will assign a new user on the spot (we wont be lucky to match a valid user as in your example) and all goes on normally.
- z3t4 8y agoI have mixed feelings about the ad market. Automated ads is a very nice business model, compared to trying to get users to pay for your content. Running ads basically automates your whole sales organization, you do not even need a sales organization. On the other hand, I forget what's the term in game theory, but it's a lose-lose game, where the one with the most ads wins, not necessary the one with the best product. - Forcing competitors to also spend money on ads. And because it's fully automated - it's easy money for bad actors.
- rayvy 8y agoAs someone who works monitoring ad network traffic at a large ad-tech company (not FAANG, but just below), let me just say: everyone does fraud. Some don't need as much of it (e.g., Google), but quite literally saying "there's fraud in my online traffic" is like saying "there's tomato sauce in my spaghetti". It's quite literally such a normal thing that I've become immune to even getting roused by it (and remember, again, I work to find ad-fraud daily). Does this make it right? No, absolutely not. But is this ever going to change, absolutely not. Too many people are making too much money from this. Just you try to tell an L2 that they can't hit their Q4 Revenue OKR because "we're doing something really immoral by allowing fraud". Don't make me laugh XD
- da02 8y agoWhat kind of fraud does Google do?
- janesvilleseo 8y agoIt’s not that they do it. It’s that they allow it. Not outright, but they don’t go out of their way to suppress/stop it anymore more than anybody else.
- canadapups 8y agoWhen it comes to email spam or fake email accounts, Google not only allows it, they enable it. One scammer can setup thousands of gmail accounts and google doesn't blink an eye. Gmail also allows "scammer+1@gmail.com" and "scammer+2@gmail" to be the same account. I've reported obvious gmail abuse to Google through their channels, but nothing. Same scammer keeps coming back with new email accounts.
- lucasmullens 8y agoCan't spam detection check if it's the same email with a +1? Seems pretty straightforward. There's no scarcity in available email addresses. If your security depends on people not being able to register new emails, you've already lost.
- 1024core 8y agoHow do these "bots" work? Is there like a big room with lots of Android phones hooked up to some automated robotic finger for tapping and scrolling? Or are they using VMs to run some Android emulator and do everything in software?
- notyourday 8y agoBased on the article it seems to be pure software emulating interaction between the apps and i guess the APIs.
- nneonneo 8y agoA simple ad system shows an ad in an app or page, and when you click on it, sends a request off to the ad server which causes some ad credit (money) to change hands - the advertised company gets charged for a click, intermediaries get a cut, and the app or site owner gets their share. Unsurprisingly, a site owner is heavily incentivized to click on their own ads, or have others click on them, in order to pay themselves. To avoid this the ad server will want to check that the click came from a real human. They can check by IP (e.g. clicks coming from AWS boxes are probably fraud, excessively fast clicks are rejected, etc.); by user activity (monitoring mouse clicks, keyboard entries, dwell time, and a host of other factors); and by statistical measures (is the ad statistically likely to be clicked on by the source, based on e.g. language, prior ad preferences, etc.) The news article makes it sound like the bot owners are gathering usage data to simulate real human behavior, which they can then pass off as being real human inputs prior to clicking an ad. Of course, one wonders why they don’t just instruct these millions of phones to click on ads directly (e.g. in the background), which would give them access to a huge legitimate pool of IP addresses.
- Jach 8y agoFrom the article, here's the list of apps/websites so far: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1BMJAHOASdeOOYgomSva9URZnPZ4ZdPbnyxdpqQH9KgI/edit?usp=sharing https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1BMJAHOASdeOOYgomSva9...
- homero 8y agoI don't get why they spoof other apps. They have many real users/traffic to hide fake ads into. Hiding the ad is another story.
- monochromatic 8y agoI wonder how plausible something like this is on Apple’s App Store.
- iamaelephant 8y agoGosh I don't know who to feel worse for, the brands who will do anything to stick their bullshit into my eyeballs or the shitty ad networks that enable it.
- rustcharm 8y ago700,000 apps were removed for fraud? This probably means most of the free apps you see are shady ad-scams!
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- BLKNSLVR 8y agoSo, to summarise online advertising: 1. It has been a vector for viruses / malware / cryptocoin mining 2. It tracks users activities on the internet without their knowledge to form a picture of their 'online personality' 3. It can invade a users privacy by keeping records of personal and / or intimate details of their online activities 4. It often uses more bandwidth than the content of the site it's on 5. auto-play videos 6. unexpected audio 7. As per rayvy's comment "everyone does fraud" As the Joker said "this town needs an enema". Given that "all the smartest people in the world work for advertising" it's a remarkable collective of all kinds of failure. And yet it continues to make a shit-ton of money because it's pretty much the only game in town. What's the alternative? Word-of-mouth? That requires a product that's good and useful both now and into the future; not a fad. The growth-rate can also be glacial for a long initial phase, which needs commitment and passion from it's developers and management over the long term. I can't see any revolution on the horizon though. It's going to take an impossibly sized critical mass of society to protest, and given the number of people still on Facebook... 'Brands' aren't going to stop advertising for fear of competitors getting more eyeballs. I'm going to start an advertising company called Raypenpillidge Sleepwell. Footnote: Point #3 is separate to point #2 because tracking and privacy invasion should be considered separately - tracking could be done more openly with user consent which would mean the level of privacy invasion could be chosen by the user.
- 2sk21 8y agoHalf serious suggestion: Could we somehow enable individuals themselves conduct auctions to allow advertisers to access? Imagine being able to say: "I will accept 10 ads today - you guys figure out what you want to show me".
- pavel_lishin 8y agoAssuming we erect such a system, what's my incentive to not use an ad blocker anyway? I don't want to see ten ads a day, I want to see zero.
- 2sk21 8y ago
- makecheck 8y agoI’m kind of amazed how much money can be tied up in things that are not well understood by the vast majority of people who fund those things. Ad networks. Various products from financial institutions. Cryptocurrencies. Heck, even app stores (as a developer, if your app was sold to somebody and Apple/Google’s system was simply broken and somehow they made their cut but you didn’t, how would you even know?). At a certain point, it sure seems that people rely on popularity as proof of proper functionality (i.e. “lots of people seem to use this just fine” = “nothing can go wrong”). In reality, we should be expecting a lot more: asking harder questions, demanding more proof of activities, expecting extremely reliable support, etc. And frankly, a lot of these things should have open-source implementations to make it even easier to ensure that they work the way they claim to.
- cwkoss 8y agoIs Ad fraud a pro-social 'crime'? Every ad viewed by a bot is one less attempt at adversarially influencing a human against their will.
- archi42 8y agoWhile this point of view is a neat idea and part of me really likes it, I'm afraid those people just want to make as much cash as possible. Also, if they make 750M$, that's 750M$ they deprived other parts of society of (e.g. app developers who could have had about 5000 more employees).
- wiradikusuma 8y agoTL;DR: Some company acquires apps to track those apps' users' activities so that the company can simulate the activities in a farm of bot-controlled ad-enabled phones? 1. Why don't they just show the ads to real users? 2. If the real users don't really get to see the ads, isn't this a win for everyone (except advertisers)? (I'm not saying I agree with their practices, but just trying to think how they rationalize their moral decisions).
- puranjay 8y agoIt's ironic that one of the top comments on this page is a bot account pitching a "work from home" opportunity
- mellow-lake-day 8y agoThat article is an example of outstanding journalism. It probably required tremendous amounts of writing ability, knowing the subject matter, spending hours and hours of research, being familiar with the industry, etc. Doesn't see this much these days. Too bad a lot of journalism died in 2008/2009 when journalists lost their jobs and newspapers were either bought by big players or simply went out of business.
- mschuster91 8y agoWell, it's Buzzfeed. They have the relative unique business model with their listicles and other clickbait crap financing their high-quality investigative journalism.
- dvirsky 8y agoWhat I find a bit weird is that they don't split the brands of the main Buzzfeed stuff and the more serious journalism.
- mschuster91 8y agoIMHO it makes sense for Buzzfeed - the quality stuff makes readers go to the website, and then the reader can be led to the stuff like "21 Unintentionally Hilarious Knock-Off Halloween Costumes That Are Just MAYBE Better Than The Real Thing" in the "Read On" section.
- pentae 8y agoI bet BuzzFeed has a lot of really skilled digital ad guys on staff, maybe the Author is an expert in the field already.
- John_KZ 8y agoWow, it's like the way I move my mouse isn't a legit Turing test. What a shocker. The real problem is using stupid methods to identify real users. This adversarial run is reaching it's end state, and you can't tell apart humans from machines there.
- philipodonnell 8y ago> More than 15 additional websites involved in the scheme reused the same TrackMyShows.tv SSL certificate Anyone shed light on this? How does one website use another website's SSL cert?
- detaro 8y agoAt least the one example they link is delivered over HTTP. If you request HTTPS instead, the server presents the certificate for TrackMyShows.tv.
- philipodonnell 8y ago> If you request HTTPS instead, the server presents the certificate for TrackMyShows.tv But will it successfully connect?
- detaro 8y agoNo.