7 ms·
The Prophets of Cryptocurrency Survey the Boom and Bust
- mrb 8y agoI find it strange that journalists tend to use singular boom and singular bust, and rarely mention that there's been at least 4 major boom/bust cycles, each one bigger than the previous ones. https://i.imgur.com/ZQJfwp3.png https://i.imgur.com/ZQJfwp3.png (Source: http://bitcoin.zorinaq.com/price/ http://bitcoin.zorinaq.com/price/)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- wmf 8y agoBecause they don't remember the previous ones. Most people ignored crypto until a year ago.
- reefoctopus 8y agoMost people still ignore crypto.
- scoot 8y agoI got out after the first bust in your chart. Should have doubled down. Hindsight is 20:20!
- newswriter99 8y agoStory author is Nick Paumgarten. Staff writer at the New Yorker for 13 years. Seems to favour stories on sports talk radio, internet dating, a bit on the WEF (World Economic Forum). His Twitter (grand total of 20 tweets) has a mugshot of a motorcycle. Not what I would consider to be a credible authority on economic theory or cryptocurrencies. I'll take this story like I have most from the New Yorker: cursory homework done by an upper middle class person who was born and raised on the US northeast coast.
- CPLX 8y agoDid you read the article? The entire point of the thing is to talk about crypto from the perspective of someone who doesn’t know much about it at the outset. He investigates it and reports back, as a proxy for the reader.
- FabHK 8y ago> He investigates it and reports back, as a proxy for the reader. And that's enormously valuable. People are often dismissive of The Economist, since many of the writers in its anonymous collective are young Philosophy, politics and economics (PPE) graduates from Oxford, and what do they know. But they're smart, and by virtue of their association with The Economist and its network have access to world class experts, and they can talk to them on and off the record, and synthesise the gist of some development or controversy in an excellent short article.
- xrd 8y agoThe New Yorker, as you say, is probably not the place you would expect to find the greatest journalistic minds writing about crypto. It is, however, a place where you can often find smart writing on things that are verging from obscurity into the mainstream, and I think this article does do a decent job of communicating the perspective of a layperson like the author who is new to the crypto world. Did you read a different motive of the article than that? Or, did you feel that there was something inaccurate about it? I felt like he did not dismiss Lubin's assertions late in the article about the future of crypto when debating Nouriel Roubini. It seemed pretty balanced to me in just reporting their arguments, and not taking sides, which I think is actually quite rare in mainstream journalism when discussing anything crypto! To me, it didn't seem like there were many assertions made that contradicted the bright future or doom of crypto coming from the prophets or naysayers.
- cfontes 8y agoSo many words so little meat... I can't stand articles that read like books.
- Kinnard 8y agoStop reading books that are wordy and not meaty.
- joejerryronnie 8y agoSelecting Fitzgerald was his first mistake.
- extragood 8y ago"More matter with less art."
- mjevans 8y agoHaving the background research discussed can be valuable. However I'm short on finding the salient points and reasons why I should care to read this; it needs something more like a table of contents and a preface summary so that I know where to focus my efforts, at least initially.
- rhacker 8y agoBTC still around $6K, wake me up when it's at 2k or 10k please.
- mythrwy 8y agoHow long are you planning on sleeping? Could be awhile.
- stewfortier 8y ago(Related) I've always gotten a chuckle out of this TechLoaf joke: https://www.techloaf.io/2018/05/29/bitcoin-enthusiast-in-the-office-talking-about-bitcoin-62-34-less/ https://www.techloaf.io/2018/05/29/bitcoin-enthusiast-in-the...
- ppod 8y agoIt's not transforming the world, but too many people who said bitcoin was worthless when the price was $600 are claiming to be prophets because the price is ten times that.
- afdiognionio 8y agoThey were half right. Bitcoin has been a monumental failure in every respect except price. They hit the nail on the head about Bitcoin's technical and economic merits even if they dramatically overestimated the rationality of the market.
- gomox 8y agoThat is absurd. It's working Internet Money that you can use.
- hudon 8y agoThe article compares Cryptocurrency to Religion, roughly speaking. First, there was financial chaos in 2008. Then with a bang, our Lord Satoshi Nakamoto solved the double-spend problem and created Blockchain, and He saw that it was good. Second, you have your prophets: Vitalik who is an "alien sent to help us all" and Joe Lubin who has "seen the light". These are men that have been revealed something about Blockchain that no one else understands, thus them being a "9 out of 10" in terms of how much they understand the Blockchain. You can never truly be a "10 out of 10" because that spot is reserved for our Lord, Satoshi Nakamoto. But Vitalik is a Higher prophet than Joe because of his closer connection to Satoshi, having been so involved with Bitcoin so early. Then you have your priests, there to aid the prophets: Vlad Zamfir, performing the ritual of computational wizardry in the corner of the room as the common folk surround him and praise Satoshi. Emin Gun Sirer interpreting the Holy Whitepaper out loud and vulgarizing its content for the masses. Then you have the Temple: Twitter. Great truths such as "ok can you guys stop trading" are recorded in the Gospels (IRC archives), and propagated and interpreted throughout the Twitter Temple by the priests. Fourthly, you have your warriors, guarding the Temple: Jimmy Song with a cowboy hat, planting his foot on the ground, pointing at the heretics entering the Twitter Temple and charging with religious fervor: "Shitcoin! Scam! Get out of the temple!". All the while, the Blockchain glows mysteriously as our coal plants feed it more and more energy. Perhaps when the Messiah comes, we'll learn that Blockchain was a parody of Humanity all along...
- bouncycastle 8y agoI think most national currencies are based on religious-like beliefs and mass delusions to some extent. Take the USD for instance. With "in God we trust", and you have your great leaders and "prophets" i.e. founding fathers such as George Washington and Benjamin Franklin printed on the back, governed by a government that is bound to the "commandments" i.e. the Constitution... All the while, the Whitehouse mysteriously glows as the nation's printing press is busy churning out a few more batches of fiat in secret.
- Scoundreller 8y agoBut very few people are holding onto USD bills with the expectation that they'll go up in value, or suddenly have some new use.
- gomox 8y agoAs someone fairly knowledgeable about the Ethereum ecosystem I am pretty impressed by the mostly accurate portrayal of the social intricacies of the scene. I wonder how long this took to research.
- paulpauper 8y agoit's remarkable how stable bitcoin has been recently. It actually has less volatility than even tech stocks. The vast majority of people who trade bitcoin and other currencies seem to have very little (less than 10k or so) , so this is not enough move the price much. The only way bitcoin can go up a lot is if institutions and large funds buy it at once. Otherwise it's just stuck in a really tight trading range.
- joejerryronnie 8y ago> The only way bitcoin can go up a lot is if institutions and large funds buy it at once Or until the crime syndicates and shady government funded entities formulate the next pump and dump scam.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bdcravens 8y agoIt enjoyed previous periods of stability, between bubbles, as well. The profile of ownership hasn't changed that much in the last year, even though there was a ton of price movement a year ago. There just hasn't been much in the way of the news that drives the feeding frenzy.
- latchkey 8y agoThe interesting bit about the stability is the fact that 12,000 new bitcoins enter circulation every week. The miners have to sell in order to pay the power bills (or they are simply holding since the mining has centralized to the bigger players with deep pockets). So, how is the price remaining stable then? The general thought I've seen is that they are selling on private markets and it is the institutions and funds that are buying them up.
- Theodores 8y agoThere are private individuals, a.k.a. 'whales', that have millions of dollars worth of Bitcoin to sell. These people can't sell on the exchanges we hear about because these exchanges do not have buyers on them wanting to buy huge quantities of Bitcoin. You can't just go along to an online exchange and sell millions of dollars worth of Bitcoin, not only is there the problem of finding a buyer but there is also the problem of price. You could find people only wanting to pay a hugely discounted price with the 'market price' falling due to the surplus availability. This is not in the interest of a 'whale' as a big sale could render the rest of the portfolio to be worthless. Instead of trading 'over the counter' these people are 'serviced' by an entirely different breed of traders that attempt to match buyers and sellers. These intermediaries try to get their percentage, however, as soon as buyer meets seller the need for the middle man and his cut is eliminated. These sales also take a long time to organise, so it is more like trying to sell a house than buying some candy at a convenience store. In this sales environment the price is different to the headline price and not as volatile. Much like house sales though there is a huge likelihood that a given sale will not go through. Your stereotypical Bitcoin bore only really dreams of getting the 'Lambo to the moon'. In the bigger scheme of things a fancy sports car isn't really that expensive, it is just a bit of bent tin with a fancy paint job. These greedy dreamers are not currently trading their little coin things, they are in the same boat as the 'whales' that can't sell, they are just 'Holding On for Deal Life', a.k.a. 'HODLing'. They might as well be praying for rain. The price is 'stable' not only due to the problems of large and small 'investors'. There is always the hope that some regulatory approval will come along to make it so that institutions and funds will enter the market. As things currently stand Bitcoin is a 'commodity' whereas every s4itcoin is a 'unregulated security'. So it could be Bitcoin that is undervalued and, when the institutional investors come along, the 'asset' will reach its true value of '50K'. That is the dream and the hope that keeps small time Bitcoin bores HODLing on to their imaginary stores of 'wealth'. This time next year they will obviously be able to pay the deposit on that second hand 'Lambo' proving them to be wealthy. We are sharing this planet with a cargo-cult group of Bitcoin believers that will not let their dreams be shattered. They no longer talk of 'ICO' blockchain things, they have also kind of given up on the general population becoming the 'greater fools' that will buy their imaginary coin things at a huge premium from them. There really is just this belief in Bitcoin getting to be magically approved by financial authorities and them being able to see a return when mythical institutions buy big shortly thereafter.