7 ms·
The problem lies in what's semi-advanced to one is critical or basic to many others. Apple has been known to hide (aka. make subtle) basic operations. How often
by karmakaze 8y ago
The problem lies in what's semi-advanced to one is critical or basic to many others. Apple has been known to hide (aka. make subtle) basic operations. How often have you wanted to load a page in 'desktop mode' in mobile Safari? It's there, just invisibly so. The UI does not teach in the name of clean/minimal design which is Apple's way: form over function.
Edit: it's the equivalent to not putting keyboard shortcut keystrokes into pull down menus.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 8y agoTheres a lot of armchair design going on here. Obviously there is some sort of balance between showing the user too many options or not enough and making the important stuff obvious without cluttering the UI. I imagine if Apple had gone too far in the other direction (which they would never do IMO) that people would complain there are too many options. There is definitely room for improvement though. There are some regressions that are too obvious. The recent regression that comes to mind is forcing the end user to go through extra taps to switch the camera between front and back during a FaceTime call when previously it was a one-button click
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoThat change is infuriating. Showing something/someone else on a FT call may be a minority pastime, but it's not exactly a super-obscure use-case. I seriously doubt there was a groundswell of users complaining they could swap cameras with a single tap. The other annoying change was putting the End Call button in a panel the bottom right. Regular users have muscle memory, and suddenly they have to relearn one of the main features. Changes like these are superficial tinkering and make work for the sake of appearances rather than considered, focused development.
- biofunsf 8y agoPersonally, I use the "Request Desktop Mode" features lots! I also moved it so it's the very first option listed for quick access. But I wouldn't do that on my grandma's phone... While 'desktop mode' is super useful the HN crowd, I don't think most users would benefit from it. A non-technical user is probably only minimally aware that mobile and desktop sites might have different features at all. And even when you do use it, it might not have the desired affect. I might have been browsing around on "mobile.site.com" for a while and repeating my request with a desktop User-Agent is still going to get me the mobile version. (this happens to me on m.facebook.com) To fix this I have to know how to modify the URL to point to the non-mobile-only version...easy for this crowd, but not for the average user. Certain CSS @media queries also don't seem to be affected by "Desktop Mode". (It only changes the User-Agent I believe?) So in other situations, it won't work no matter what and that's pretty frustrating/confusing/inconsistent if you don't know the details. Even if I do succeed, a desktop webpage on mobile can be a pain with all the zooming and zooming out needed. Sometimes desktop sites don't even work properly on mobile browsers! Now...we understand the constraints, but all these details come together to make it a pretty confusing feature for the average user. I think most users wouldn't get value from this so it's obscure by default...but for the technical types that love this, it's not too hard to figure out how to move this feature to a place where it's convenient to access. Overall I think the current design is a pretty good balance all things considered. (though I do wish the ability to move the desktop mode button to the 1st slot was more obvious. Definitely took me a while to figure this out)
- nighthawk454 8y ago> I also moved it so it's the very first option listed for quick access It took me a second to realize that "Request Desktop Site" is available in the Share Sheet. I use it by long-pressing the refresh button.
- biofunsf 8y agohah I only discovered that long-press option just a couple months ago! Long pressing there also gives me a "request without ad blockers" button which I've found super useful as well. A bit weird this option isn't in the Share Sheet like desktop mode is... also isn't it weird that this is called the "Share Sheet" but has lots of buttons for non-sharing related things?
- Bud 8y ago"Form over function" is not "Apple's way". Apple's way is function, period, paragraph. And often, what "function" means is, don't bury the user under 200 options they will never use. Make choices. Be willing to say "no" to having every single option front and center. Added to this is the obvious point that with a touch interface on a small screen, you cannot make everything obvious. It's impossible.
- Green_man 8y agois that what putting usb ports on the back of an iMac is? function, period, paragraph, and publication?
- coldtea 8y ago>is that what putting usb ports on the back of an iMac is? Yes, why not? Tons of PC laptops had it that way as well, even industrial-style all-function PCs.
- Green_man 8y agowell, older laptops had top mounted hinges that allowed for a lot of I/O real estate on the back. that allowed them to work well on a tight desk, with power, usb hub, whatever coming out the back. for a portable machine, i think most accessible things should be on the sides, and the newer hinges on most laptops that are mounted to the back of the chassis mean that back mounted ports aren't an option. the obvious function first choice is side mounted ports, with a bottom dock with power redundancy and everything else. best of both worlds. i don't know if older laptops are the relevant comparison point to a new imac all in one desktop though. I understand why they are on the back, but its clearly not a function first decision (putting them on the front would be way more functional.
- Bud 8y agoWhere would you suggest the ports be located on a desktop computer whose sides are not thick enough to accommodate any ports? Perhaps they should be located in the middle of the screen? ;)
- pasta 8y agoOr clearing the cache in Safari. The only options I know is to go to the settings and then find the Safari app. This is not so nice when you only want to reload the page while clearing the cached files. Could have been something like a long press or double tap on the refresh button.
- userbinator 8y agoEdit: it's the equivalent to not putting keyboard shortcut keystrokes into pull down menus This reminds me that several versions ago, Windows stopped underlining the shortcut keys to the menu items by default --- taking away the only affordance to discovering that the keyboard can be used to more quickly activate the menus. I learned by accident long ago ("what's the Alt key for?"), and have used it since. In contrast, I remember trying to operate a Mac the same way but gave up experimenting with the Alt key and such to try to get the menus to show (I know about the shortcuts, but they are not easily discoverable/explorable in the same way that menus are) --- and only later found out that trying to operate the menus on a Mac from the keyboard is... not very intuitive and disabled by default (why!?!?): https://superuser.com/questions/117549/use-the-keyboard-to-activate-the-menu-bar https://superuser.com/questions/117549/use-the-keyboard-to-a... https://superuser.com/questions/504111/how-to-select-file-menu-in-mac-just-like-alt-f-in-windows https://superuser.com/questions/504111/how-to-select-file-me... (I'm not sure if the above even apply to pre-OS X --- when I discovered the function of Alt and the underlined keys in Windows, it was the Windows 3.1 era.)
- rangibaby 8y agoSteve Jobs was heavily against hidden functionality (sorry there is a word for it I can't remember off the top of my head). It's why Macs had one-button mice for so long. It wasn't until the third major revision of the OS that iPhones got copy+paste!
- reitanqild 8y ago> Steve Jobs was heavily against hidden functionality (sorry there is a word for it I can't remember off the top of my head). It's why Macs had one-button mice for so long. That doesn't make sense at all to me: The right click button on a mouse is visible. The Mac way of hiding it behind the ctrl key was non-discoverable and non-obvious to me.
- bb88 8y agoOr under pull down menus... or context menus... or... Force touch just seems like a different form of right mouse clicking.
- submeta 8y agoI know a few people who - even after trying - can't make "force touch" work properly. I love it and try to show them. But they can't seem to make the effort to learn it.
- eridius 8y ago
- em500 8y ago> How often have you wanted to load a page in 'desktop mode' in mobile Safari? It's there, just invisibly so. Not a single time in the past 5 years or so. What's your point?
- coldtea 8y ago>The problem lies in what's semi-advanced to one is critical or basic to many others. Well, that's not a dictum to design UIs by. This way everything becomes "critical". At some point you just use statistics, and if something is critical to fewer people, you can give it lower priority anyway than what most want to use everyday.
- Ntrails 8y agosorry to off topic - but how do you get safari to force desktop? I've been hacking URLS
- dave84 8y agoPress the share button at the bottom (or next to the address bar in landscape/iPad), then scroll along the list of options at the bottom and you'll see "Request Desktop Site."
- Ntrails 8y agoCool, thanks!
- tim333 8y agoI think the trick they are referring to is to go to the site then hold the refresh icon and a menu saying "Request Desktop Site" pops up. I thought cool, I'll try it with the nyt - It'll be like the original iPhone demo again but no - it goes to a pay screen. Mercury Browser kind of worked though which is an app that "can spoof the UserAgent string to trick websites into thinking the browser is a desktop browser."