14 ms·
What does Stack Overflow want to be when it grows up?
- kapauldo 8y agoA place for people to put other people down for seeking help?
- crdoconnor 8y agoJudging by the number of answers I see which were valid and good answers in 2011 and are horrendously outdated now, it's not just grown up, it's grown long in the tooth.
- dudul 8y agoThat's a really good observation. A lot of very highly ranked answers no longer apply, and still they are very visible due to their score. If the idea is to be the "wikipedia of programming", I wonder if "votes" are enough. Should there be an active initiative to prune stupid/bad questions? Revisit old answers?
- Flimm 8y agoIt's actually worse than that. The accepted answer by the OP is pinned to the top forever (or until OP changes his or her mind, which is often never), no matter how many downvotes the pinned answer collects.
- superflyguy 8y agoPossibly just need to reduce every answer's score a little every month to favour answers which are actively being voted up more recently.
- sureaboutthis 8y agoThen you vote to close the question. It may take a while but, eventually, it will be deleted. Just yesterday, I closed three or four such questions in a brief visit.
- umvi 8y agoThe only questions I've seen constantly outdated are web dev related. More stable technologies like C/C++/python seem to have up to date answers most of the time (purely anecdotal).
- cdoxsey 8y agoLately I've been working with c++ and, at least in my experience, as a developer who's native tongue isn't c++, many of the answers have failed to keep up with the radical changes in the language in the last 10 years. Post-17 C++ is completely different from pre-11 C++. That said there's usually an answer further down the page with a more up to date solution, it's just not the accepted or most popular one.
- umvi 8y agoTrue, but consider your user base. I, for one, maintain legacy C/C++98 code. C++17 answers are not helpful to me because the legacy system does not have a new enough compiler, sysroot, etc for me to take advantage of them. It's not like web development where users' browsers auto-update and you can start immediately using the newest versions of everything. Only our newest projects are using modern C++ (14). I would wager the majority of C++ users "in the field" are using 11 and below and haven't had a good opportunity to switch to 14 or 17 yet. As such, answers that seem outdated to you may be a good fit for the majority. It's sort of like how any native answers automatically float higher than boost answers - why is this? Because most c++ users are not using boost and have no interest in using boost.
- yAnonymous 8y agoTry to update one of those outdated answers and your changes will be removed, because the original author has more internet points. The amount of circle jerking on Stack Overflow is stunning.
- PudgePacket 8y agoI've used stackoverflow for years and have never heard it put like that. "Stack Overflow ultimately has much more in common with Wikipedia than a discussion forum. By this I mean questions and answers on Stack Overflow are not primarily judged by their usefulness to a specific individual, but by how many other programmers that question or answer can potentially help over time." Personally I would have been much more understanding of the process of using stackoverflow if I knew this, and so would many of the people who get stung expecting an answer to their question. In reality the user is contributing their question to the community, not asking a question in the traditional sense. That's my take anyway.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- neuland 8y agoGiven this though, is the question / answer format really suiting the purpose?
- sureaboutthis 8y agoIt did but there aren't enough mods and knowledgeable users to monitor and police the tremendous inflow of off topic questions and answers.
- neuland 8y agoI guess what I'm trying to say is by either adding features or moving to a different model, they could reduce the flow of duplicate/bad questions and lackluster/mismatch answers. One area I wish there were more support in is to aggregate all the knowledge that is split across multiple questions. I think this could be helpful for beginners, but also is extremely specific areas as well. For example, I imagine that a lot of these bad questions come from beginners. So, aggregating answers about common beginner misunderstandings with a library or system into a wiki page. Or, there could be a "getting started" type page that goes over the basic steps and concepts. This is obviously getting into the business of writing docs for projects that either don't have them or don't have good ones, but it seems from the existence of stack overflow that this is actually necessary. Then again, there seems to be tons of questions on projects with really good docs and tutorials. So, maybe you're right and it's just that the people asking bad questions / giving bad answers don't read docs.
- k__ 8y agoWhen I wrote my bachelor thesis about democratic methods in online communities, I found out that all these crowd-sourced sites had one major problem. When they start, senior players in their field of work laugh at them because they don't have much content. So they try to get as much as possible, trying to get as many new creators on board as they can. Later, when they have grown enough, the senior players in the field laugh at them because they have mostly garbage content. So they try to increase the quality of their content. The problem here is, now they accumulated a vast mass of creators who love the site, but only a fraction of them creates quality content. They unleash a task force of moderators on them that kick out the low-quality creators, which improves quality, but bad for the morale of the whole community. Wikipedia did this and Stackexchange does this too. I think, instead of alienating existing creators by deleting their content, they should simply make high quality content more visible.
- debacle 8y agoBeing a community manager is a thankless, unrelenting assault on your confidence and emotional and social stability. The social Internet's linchpin has almost always (since as long as I can remember) been that it requires a certain kind of person to be an unpaid community manager (by any name), and nearly every site you visit (wikipedia, stackoverflow, reddit, etc) makes use of these nonployees.
- crdoconnor 8y agoThis is similar to almost all unpaid positions which require dirty work and give you a bit of power. The people who do them end up being people who volunteer to be "paid" with the opportunity to go on a power trip. I've not had experience of it myself, but I've heard from some people who have worked at high profile charities that a similar thing happens there.
- k__ 8y agoSure, but mostly policy is the problem here. Instead of "Hunt down bad content and delete it!" they should use "Hunt down good content and promote it!" Why not create a premium version of the product that features only chosen content? Creators can do what they always did and maybe they're even motivated to become "premium creators".
- faitswulff 8y agoI found the conclusion rather disappointing: > What should Stack Overflow be when it grows up? Whatever we make it, together. It's more of a historical overview than a vision for the future.
- superflyguy 8y agoI got bored of scrolling through it. I know it's just someone's blog but I'm always a little surprised when grown-ups use stupid little cartoons and memes.
- PunchTornado 8y agoMemes can convey powerful messages just as much as words.
- superflyguy 8y agoIn theory perhaps, yes. In this case, however, just "I'm a kidult".
- pg_bot 8y agoThat's appropriate considering Jeff hasn't worked there for more than half the life of the company. Stack Overflow is a piece of software that I would consider complete. I hope their future is just more of the same. Sure there will be small improvements to be made over time, but the radical days of product changes are far behind. I'm going to guess that in 10 years the site will still be recognizable to anyone who uses it today.
- codinghorror 8y agoEntirely possible .. but I desperately hope that the /ask page is reworked from the ground up to be a much more engaging sort of dynamic tutorial. Most of the friction from people colliding with the SO system is on that page, and it hasn't materially changed since 2011.
- jmuguy 8y agoOn any given day when I'm being really productive I try to go back and count the number of tabs I have open on SO. I certainly enjoy watching my rep go up from the one time I answered a VueJS question when it was still kind of new but really I don't think I could do my job without the site. The amount of negativity that gets thrown towards it is really ridiculous.
- gonational 8y agoI’m gonna catch some flak for this... Listening to Jeff try to describe what stack overflow is and the “fundamental misunderstanding” by all of us millions of unwashed masses is amazing. It’s also a bit like listening to a muskox describe why it decided to grow long hair after so much time in the snow; IOW, a complete and total lack of understanding of emergence and a rewriting of history at the behest of Jeff’s enormous ego. This is what happens when you raise massive amounts of money for what is a simple question and answer site and you have to find some kind of philosophically transcendent exclamation of what it is that you have created. Instead of saying “we created yahoo answers for programmers, but with a better interface”, you come up with something like “We’ve created a valuable resource for the future of the planet and all the programmers hereafter”. Stack overflow is and always was a question and answer site. To attempt to take credit for the following value of search results containing stack overflow questions that have already been answered that sound like what you’re asking is to take credit for search engines and to take credit for your users’ hard work. That last bit doesn’t surprise me at all, given that Jeff’s post ends with an insulting meme that implies we are a dumb mob.
- kevinherron 8y agoThis post was written by Jeff Atwood, not Joel...
- dgritsko 8y agoOn the subject of fundamental misunderstandings, you do realize that Jeff Atwood wrote this post and not Joel Spolsky, right?
- gonational 8y agoOops, thanks - corrected. Also makes my deleted last paragraph’s speculation a little bit irrelevant, nominally, while also remaining entirely relevant.
- michaelbuckbee 8y agoIDK, Jeff (edited) explicitly calls out that they were lucky and the they do not deserve all the credit for SO. "I am honored and humbled by the public utility that Stack Overflow has unlocked for a whole generation of programmers. But I didn't do that. You did, when you contributed a well researched question to Stack Overflow. You did, when you contributed a succinct and clear answer to Stack Overflow." You did, when you edited a question or answer on Stack Overflow to make it better.
- melling 8y agoBefore I did a couple of rage quits on StackOverFlow, I wanted it to be the definitive place for learning any computer topic from the beginning through advanced topic, especially esoteric topics. You could easily build the ultimate learning guide given enough questions, linking, etc. I spent quite a bit of time on elisp questions. For example: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/2170528/writing-hello-world-in-emacs https://stackoverflow.com/questions/2170528/writing-hello-wo... I think I had close to 200 questions at one point.
- codinghorror 8y agoIt's not a bad idea, but speculative questions (will anyone really ask this?) lead down the path of the "documentation" effort which was hugely risky and eventually got pulled. https://stackoverflow.com/documentation https://stackoverflow.com/documentation
- melling 8y agoNo one wants to read documentation. You want to throwdown enough breadcrumbs from hello world to any topic you might wish to know to get things done in a language. More of a cookbook.
- manigandham 8y agoThere are definitely problems with outdated content. SO + Google seems to be particularly bad at finding accurate answers without cross-referencing several different posts all linking to each other, combined with forced immutability and the difficulty of some changes. Some other sites like Quora have a full question "merge" feature which SO needs, it would cut down the duplicates and allow a single question thread to become more useful.
- fabian2k 8y agoSO has a "merge questions" feature, but it's rarely used. It is only available to elected moderators, and it's quite dangerous because it's not reversible without assistance from SE staff. One major problem is that merging two very similar questions that are about the same concept would still end up with answers that seem out of place because they address a slightly different version of the question. Most cases should be solved by closing as duplicate, as that will create a link to the canonical answer. Anonymous users will also be automatically redirected to the canonical answer if there are no answers present on the duplicate.
- manigandham 8y agoThat never seems to work well in practice. Most of the time, there are existing answers and "closing as duplicate" leaves up all of them as a separate question thread that just confuses everyone. The links between them and the duplicate message are not intuitive and easily overlooked, leading to an expectation of unfinished answers. Quora meanwhile has completely reversibility, and allows the community to do it. It's caused some problems but overall has cleaned up many common and repetitive questions.
- jrochkind1 8y agoOne challenge not discussed here is when an accepted and highly voted answer _used_ to be a good answer, but no longer is in later versions of whatever software/platform/library is discussed. This is also something that gets worse over time, like the uniqueness problem. I think it's worse than the uniqueness problem, multiple duplicate _good_ questions/answers don't actually harm, misguide, or delay anyone looking for an answer; one _wrong_ one does. And of course, if you try to ask a question again because you think the old one might be outdated (if you were _sure_, you wouldn't have to ask probably), it'll likely get closed as a duplicate. :)
- manigandham 8y agoRemove the entire concept of "accepted" answers and let votes decay or be withdrawn, along with scoring the rankings using time as an additional input. Quora has recently introduced secondary voting mechanisms where answers will randomly have a "is it still relevant" toggle for users to continue providing signal beyond the initial vote.
- rc_kas 8y agoI think its harder than that. Some anwers are just timeless. Others should decay.
- tobr 8y agoIf they’re timeless they should continue to get votes, no? Even if everyone stops voting in a thread all the votes would decay at the same rate, so the timeless answer would stay at top.
- Piskvorrr 8y agoI can confirm this: I'm getting votes from stuff I have written in the Permian, Triasic and Jurassic periods, respectively.
- manigandham 8y ago
- pixelmonkey 8y agoMight be good enough to be remembered as the site that killed Experts-Exchange.
- EADGBE 8y agoI'm still getting a bit of a humble brag out of this. But thanks for the shout out, for all my contributions on SO. It's amazing, I really feel like an indispensable cog now. /s However, keeping Documentation[1] would have really accelerated the progression of SO. But whatever... I don't run it. This really isn't all for ourselves though; the Stack Exchange community is more impressive to me. I really enjoy the Parenting, Money and Music SE's. [1] https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/354217/sunsetting-documentation https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/354217/sunsetting-d...
- 0x445442 8y agoI think the need for, or at least the level of reliance on, a site like Stack Overflow is an example of how utterly messed up the "profession" is compared to other engineering and non-engineering professions.
- badosu 8y agoThat's not a fair comparison, the level of diversity in ways to solve or diagnose a problem are much bigger in the software engineering world. Where in a typical engineering profession you would have a somewhat defined checklist on how to diagnose an issue and a proven method to fix it, in software engineering you have a million possibilities: "- Did you check x? - Was this nth specific step for this specific framework followed? etc.." It's messy because the problem space can't be as easily enumerated.
- zrobotics 8y agoI don't know, software is far more dynamic than many other engineering fields. Even a first edition of The Art of Electronics is chick full of useful information, the only truly dated stuff is anything involving microcontrollers (so, software). Even the sections on digital logic ICs are still useful, they still see some use. Software has always had the problem of information being outdated before the books even reach retailers. However, this is one of my big frustrations with SO. There are so, so many c++ questions with accepted answers that are now 'wrong' due to changes in the language. That, and the fanatical insistence to close questions that are opinion based closes off a lot of questions more experienced programmers will have.
- rcxdude 8y agoI think other engineering professions could be substantially improved by a greater participation of their members in such sites. The amount of public communication and advice availible for profession electronics development, for example, is far lower than that for software (There's a glut of hobby-level stuff, but beyond the basics it gets much worse).
- Flimm 8y agoI like this blog post, this is the vision of Stack Overflow that I bought into when I started posting. However, it's hard not to read this blog post as a diplomatic pushback to the current efforts of SO leaders to make it more welcoming. Jeff Atwood says that SO is "supposed to involve a healthy kind of minor [...] anxiety". This section in particular stands out to me: > This is why I cringe so hard I practically turn myself inside out when people on Twitter mention that they have pointed their students at Stack Overflow. What you'd want for a beginner or a student in the field of programming is almost the exact opposite of what Stack Overflow does at every turn: > * one on one mentoring * real time collaborative screen sharing * live chat * theory and background courses * starter tasks and exercises > These are all very fine and good things, but Stack Overflow does NONE of them, by design. If this were on the official SO blog, I would be very surprised.
- codinghorror 8y ago> not to read this blog post as a diplomatic pushback to the current efforts of SO leaders to make it more welcoming Not at all, at least, that is not my intent. I do feel like the key items articulated there (SO as wiki, duplicate danger, competitive system of peer review, for practicing programmers) are not well understood by outsiders and peripheral members of the community, though. Note that the Stack Overflow tour (which was and is quite good!) that explains what Stack Overflow is was perma-demoted to the footer... well, that used to be true, but actually I just checked now and it's gone altogether? The word "tour" doesn't appear on the SO homepage in incognito mode, at all. You can visit "help" (which is in the footer) and then, and only then, will it appear as a topbar. https://stackoverflow.com/tour https://stackoverflow.com/tour
- skohan 8y agoI feel like Stack Overflow has gotten less useful to me as a programmer over the years, and these days I more often find the answers I need on a forum geared toward whatever technology I have a question about. I have a hard time telling whether this reflects a change in developer culture online over the years, or a change in the types of questions I tend to ask as I have become a more experienced programmer.
- Insanity 8y agoI feel the same way. Questions I have are more specialized to the domain I'm working in rather than general programming questions. No longer of the kind "X in language Y". Most of the questions about the system that I'd have nowadays can also be answered by colleagues over slack with the domain knowledge.
- Someone1234 8y agoThe way SO is moderated encourages out of date information. For example, if you find a question from 2015, with all out of date answers, if you ask it again today it will be flagged as duplicate with a link to the 2015 answers and no further discussion is allowed. The older SO gets the worse the content gets. They're trying to make a "Wiki site" but in a Q&A format, it doesn't work and doesn't make sense. Until they realize that their moderation policies are going to keep driving away questions that would warrant modern/fresh answers. For example try searching SO but set your Google to only show content from the last 12 months, the results are simply low quality with half mod-dead. Most of the good content is from two years ago or more, back before the site switched from Q&A to "confused Wiki-site."
- codinghorror 8y agoPer the wiki comparison, there's an edit button on every answer and question -- it works even if you're not logged in. Try it! I'm starting to think that calling the edit button "improve this answer" and "improve this question" was a mistake..
- ndnxhs 8y ago
- kauffj 8y agoStackOverflow being a wiki is at substantial odds with the way answers are selected. If StackOverflow is a wiki, then the best answer to a question should be determined by the community, not the asker, and needs to be able to evolve and change over time. However, StackOverflow simultaneously insists questions can't be duplicated while making answer selection immutable and controlled by the asker. This results in a suboptimal experience. Here is an example question highlighting this: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/884177/how-can-i-determine-what-font-a-browser-is-actually-using-to-render-some-text https://stackoverflow.com/questions/884177/how-can-i-determi... I currently have the best answer to the question "How can I determine what font a browser is actually using to render some text?". The answer I gave was the best answer in 2010. Things have changed a lot since then, and my answer is no longer the best one on that page. _But no one can change the best answer, which is insane!_ As a result, you see best answers to old questions being turned into community wikis edited to include better answers in the thread, rather than those answers being selected.
- coldtea 8y ago>If StackOverflow is a wiki, then the best answer to a question should be determined by the community, not the asker. You're thinking of wikipedia. A wiki doesn't determine what the "best content" in it is. It's just a collaborative way to edit text together.
- mademechuckle 8y agolol "You're thinking of" I dont know what they were thinking.. but in any wiki I have used anyone can make corrections and there is a shared responsibility to keep it up to date.. it seems to me that the statement is therefor valid - the basics of what is or is not a good answer is set by the asker not the community, which is how ticketing / Q&A systems work NOT wikis IMHO.
- Ajedi32 8y agoSolutions to this problem have been suggested multiple times[1][2][3][4] by the community and, unfortunately, were mostly ignored. [1]: https://meta.stackoverflow.com/q/326095/1157054 https://meta.stackoverflow.com/q/326095/1157054 [2]: https://meta.stackoverflow.com/q/283456/1157054 https://meta.stackoverflow.com/q/283456/1157054 [3]: https://meta.stackoverflow.com/q/272651/1157054 https://meta.stackoverflow.com/q/272651/1157054 [4]: https://meta.stackoverflow.com/q/253752/1157054 https://meta.stackoverflow.com/q/253752/1157054
- cletus 8y agoWow, time flies (for both the age of SO and how long since Jeff was involved). So I'm onboard with the concept of SO as Wikipedia. Fine. Weirdly I see no mention of some of the bigger problems (as I see them). And what's weird about these problems is they were completely foreseeable by anyone who paid the tiniest bit of attention to Wikipedia. 1. TMS (Toxic Moderator Syndrome). You have askers, answerers and moderators. All have their purpose but they are not equal. - People who ask questions mainly derive value from SO by getting answers to their problems and this is how it should be (and the karma system reflects this). - People who answer questions. This is where most of the value is derived from. - Moderators. While cleaning up the site has value it should be recognized that this is a utility function. The karma system reflects this but any system like this seems to attract a certain kind of personality who embodies the principle that "those who can, do; those who can't, moderate". Look at any highly ranked answer (or question) and you'll see a litany of questionable edits (which eventually rob the answerer of any karma when that question or answer gets 30+ edits and goes "community"). I don't have a problem with this kind of pedantry. What I do have a problem with is closing of using questions because of a culture that has decided completely on its own what qualifies as acceptable content for the site. Anyone who has used SO more than a few times will have come across useful questions that don't have mathematically provable correct answers and are closed as off-topic. It's like the SO mods feared flamewars that never happened and in the process created an equally bad (if not worse) situation. 2. Accepted answers that are wrong (or were right but are now wrong). Why can't these be edited? 3. What to do with all that VC money. This never made sense to me but this was in the era where some (VCs mainly it seems) thought that Q&A sites like Quora were going to be the next unicorns (I never did and still don't). This has led to side businesses like SO recruiting, which I never thought was going to go anywhere because if you say contributions to the site were a useful signal in hiring (which I'll accept as valid), last I looked at this (a few years ago) only some ~25,000 with non-trivial amounts of karma. That's not a sufficient market and pales in comparison to, say, Github repos as a signal. 4. How to handle stale information. I still see no solution to this. I really do wonder what went into Jeff bailing 2 years in (assuming he wasn't pushed out). Joel still seems to be plugging away, which is a bit weird given he's done much better out of, say, Trello. There's honestly nothing magic about SO. It's just fairly simple software with a clean UI that came about at a time where the alternative was the giant trash heap that was and is EE. Don't get me wrong, it's definitely useful.
- forrest92 8y ago> Stack Overflow is a wiki first This is such an out of touch statement it's hilarious. Stackoverflow is a wiki in the same way my dog is a heater.
- gonational 8y agoLiterally fell out of my my chair and out the office window; had to be rescued. +1 thank you for this comment.
- sjapkee 8y agoThis is the world's most famous vim exit guide. It has already fulfilled its mission.
- marcosdumay 8y agoIt also has the most authoritative answer about parsing HTML with regular expressions in a question that isn't about parsing HTML in any general way.
- toddh 8y agoSorry, I'm going to have to close that post as off topic.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- wool_gather 8y agoThanks for writing this, Jeff! I was very cheered to see a gentle but firm defense of SO's mission -- and of the users who make it happen -- this morning. Doubly so given [the latest nonsense-bomb that SO corp decided to drop][0] on those users this week. [0]:https://medium.com/@cellio/dear-stack-overflow-we-need-to-talk-13bf3f90204f https://medium.com/@cellio/dear-stack-overflow-we-need-to-ta...
- ufmace 8y agoQuick summary of that Medium post for everyone - Some unknown people accused a SE site of... something on Twitter. People got mad about it. A SE employee weighed in in support of the tweeter. Some other people claim the accusation of whatever it is is nonsense. And I don't have the slightest idea what happened or whose side to take.
- wool_gather 8y ago> And I don't have the slightest idea what happened or whose side to take Unfortunately most of those involved are at least a little bit right, and I'm not sure that we SE users who are upset have concerns that make any sense out of context. :) They don't have anything directly to do with the original tweet. I probably shouldn't even have linked the article.
- ianamartin 8y agoThe thing I think will be most interesting to understand in retrospect is how much of a filter the SO community has been in terms of blocking and shaping the generation of programmers who've started out since it has become the go-to site for help. University degrees act as a filter to a certain extent. And many fields have courses at the beginning that are designed to weed out people who are not going to be successful in later coursework. And the result of that filter is a certain homogeneity people that make it through that filter and become successful. The internet has done a really fascinating end-run around the university filter, and has been described as an an equalizing mechanism in society. But filters and enforced similarities are things that spontaneously emerge from societies--even anonymous ones on the internet. While it's true that SO doesn't claim to be a learning resource for beginners, most google searches lead there, and that's a real part of its function no matter how much the managers claim it shouldn't be. And the response that beginners get is clear: conform or get out. I think the social tide in the work place is moving against that kind of attitude. Developers are no longer quite the magical group of secretive wizards that they used to be, and the sort of Linus-style kind of treatment of people who aren't completely on it isn't really tenable in business situations anymore. A lot of the jobs that I want to apply for are more and more frequently focusing on being a good colleague, not just a good programmer. I think SO has two obvious directions it can take. The first is to allow the core contributors to continue to lay down the law and remain, shall we say, aloof and concerned primarily with maintaining their fiefdoms while gradually shrinking in relevance and contributions. And the other is to, well, not basically. I don't think either one of those is actively bad. There is value in maintaining the strict order that SO does. But that value comes at a cost. There's a high barrier to entry right now for being an influencer on SO, and that's good if you want to remain the authoritative place to find good answers. It's bad if you want a next generation of leaders to come in and replace the ones who are currently at the top when they wander off to do other things. I remember reading a story about what happens when you listen too much to how people use your product, and the example case was Excel. It was supposed to be a spreadsheet. But Microsoft--ever the leader at market research--figured out very quickly that people were using it for almost everything but spreading sheets! And Microsoft--also the leader at getting product decisions massively wrong--decided to make Excel do pretty much everything instead of developing a separate product to fill those use cases. And now we're at a point where Excel does basically everything, and getting people to not fucking use it for everything is almost impossible. So yeah. They need to keep a tight focus. An interesting counterexample is EvE online. For almost 2 decades now, the games has had a reputation for being hardcore, elite pvp. The weak need not apply. Piracy, scamming . . . being the bad guy in every way is not only allowed, it's encouraged. That community filters itself very effectively. Whining about what's fair or not just makes you more of a target. People farm new player tears as much as they farm space dollars. And it shows. CCP Games has had a tremendously difficult time staying relevant in the MMORPG world and in the last couple of years has been forced to make sudden changes that really disrupted the existing community in an effort to appeal to new players. Nobody really wins there. It will be interesting to see what happens in the next decade. It's a legitimately difficult management challenge, and I'm not convinced that it's possible to avoid what seems to be the inevitable rise and decline cycle of all social networks.
- shady-lady 8y agoI think the 2018 Strange Loop talk "The Hard Parts of Open Source" by Evan Czaplicki hits on some things which SO should adopt. relevant screengrab: https://imgur.com/a/5xMRvtf https://imgur.com/a/5xMRvtf full talk at https://youtu.be/o_4EX4dPppA https://youtu.be/o_4EX4dPppA
- dragontamer 8y agoThere was an online game I used to play called "Utopia" (closely related to Earth: 2025). It was structured in "seasons", where every 3 to 6 months, the game would reset from scratch. I think Stack Overflow would benefit from a similar reset cycle. Perhaps users / badges / moderators can remain the same between seasons, but every 5-years or so, just reset the entirety of StackOverflow. That means: 1. Making "old StackOverflow" read-only. The goal being, these answers may be stale and no longer relevant. 2. Migrate "fresh" stuff over to the next season. Say, everything within the past year is assumed to be fresh-enough to continue to the next season. This is automatic. 3. Users would only have to worry about duplicates within the current season. 4. Referencing an "old season" of StackOverflow is encouraged. If an old answer is still relevant, then you can ask / answer it in the new season. Provide badges for this easy job so that the community can easily push and "renew" the data to ensure it remains relevant. 5. Historical answers can remain archived. There's a lot of answers which are important for history's sake, but changing the text to be relevant for today's programmers may lose the history of some answers. As such: a historical archive of what programmers thought was best in 2013 is best left alone, but "new answers" which reference the old post + updates with new recent developments would provide context. IE: "Don't use std::shared_ptr<> with new[] in C++" (correct in 2013, but incorrect after C++ 2017, which allows shared_ptr<int[]> to use the correct delete[] operator in these cases). Documenting the history and changes of languages is important too! -------- Yes, StackOverflow is a lot like Wikipedia. But unlike Wikipedia, the tech world is incredibly fast paced. Answers for Java 1.4 are likely irrelevant in today's world. I dunno, maybe 5-years is too long, or maybe not often enough. But some "season" cycle would be a good rebirth / renewal period for the website.
- wool_gather 8y agoIntriguing. I like this idea...and I say that as someone who's spent quite a lot of time posting well-recieved answers.
- InclinedPlane 8y agoStack Overflow is still far and away the best site of its kind, but it has stagnated significantly over the last several years. The site runners aren't tackling the big meta problems any longer, and they aren't pursuing innovative solutions either, they're just continuing the status quo into the future.
- eberkund 8y agoYour score on stackoverflow has always been a weak indicator of knowledge/community involvement/any other virtuous attribute. This should be clear to anyone who has browsed upon questions like "How do I perform this common operation in Git?" or "What Bootstrap class do I use?" and seeing the accepted 1 liner answer with 1000s of up-votes while at the same time some in depth answer to a question about operating system internals, database optimization or <insert complex topic here> has maybe 10 upvotes.
- ndnxhs 8y agoThat relates to another point in the post that your questions and answers are scored based on how many other people you helped. I have a super high rep on the blender stack exchange just because I happened to ask all of the noob questions when the site was in beta. I still get almost daily upvotes even though I haven't used blender in years.
- randomsearch 8y ago“SO has probably added billions of dollars of value to the world in increased programmer productivity.” No: the voluntary contributions of many skilled programmers, mediated by a website, has increased programmer productivity. Stack Overflow has captured and exploited some of the value created, and the contributors have not been paid. Skill needed to create SO / Expertise embodied in content provided for free to SO = approx zero. Running a big site like SO is hard, but it’s trivial compared to the expertise required to write the content on SO from scratch.
- codinghorror 8y agoThis is covered in the blog post, search for "I didn't do that"
- mark-r 8y agoI got a free coffee mug. Is that payment?
- mark-r 8y agoI've found that the policies on StackOverflow are at odds with my motivation for providing answers. There are two main motivators for me, working on interesting problems and helping other human beings. The interesting problems are few and far between, so helping others has to do. As you can see from this post, the system has been rigged so that the goal of helping the individual is completely deemphasized to the point where it's actively hostile.
- draw_down 8y agoIf upon hearing that your code is twice as fast due to a removed bottleneck, your reaction is to say “impossible”, go back.
- scarface74 8y agoOn the development side, I try to stay away from the bleeding edge and I do as much research as possible, between the two, I’ve never had to ask a technical question on the Internet. But, I can see the temptation of giving up soon and just posting on SO. I take full advantage of the paid AWS support plan. If I spend more than 30 minutes trying to figure something out, I’ll submit a ticket and wait to chat with someone. So far, AWS support is batting 100. I don’t think any of my questions have been easy even in hindsight.
- petraeus 8y agoPretty obvious answer similar to what google does, show alternative views and account for vote inflation. e.g. if you get 1000 upvotes in position 1 those are worth less than 750 votes in position 2 because its expected that users will lean towards the first answer presented