7 ms·
I've come across this problem a few times when running a hedge fund. To what degree does one care where the money came from, aside from following AML rules? I g
by lordnacho 8y ago
I've come across this problem a few times when running a hedge fund. To what degree does one care where the money came from, aside from following AML rules? I get the feeling you only write articles like that if you have more people wanting to invest than you have capacity for.
- A friend called, asking for a recommendation for a job he was applying for. And advice about whether it was worth taking. Turned out, it was the firm that managed Libya's (ie Gaddafi's) wealth. They were making a big push at the time and needed a software developer. Was I going to tell him not to take the job? How complicit are you if you write some exchange connectors for a dictator? He ended up taking it, and they ended up in the news.
- A gulf state sovereign fund called. We didn't even flinch to take it. I think we just assumed they had a lot of oil money and didn't think any further about it. If you read the news, there's some not nice things about the place. Treating manual laborers badly, lack of proper rule of law, that sort of thing. Took the money, didn't think about it much. Not sure I would act differently now, to be honest. Basically the business needed the investment, and there wasn't anything specific and horrible to tell us not to.
- And where do you draw the line? What if a benevolent, enlightened, prosperous but essentially a dictatorship state from the equator wants to invest? And they could well claim to be a democracy. You'd be in endless discussions about which investors to take, which presumably 99% of your competitors would not have a problem with.
- The family office of a guy who'd been in jail called. He was known to have made his money in a seedy way, and tended to have large guys standing around guarding him. I doubt if he actually was a gangster, just seemed to like having a certain tough-guy air about him. Were we going to turn him down? Again, business requirements prevailed. Basically, if it's legal to take his money, most people will do so.
If someone does something horrible like with this journalist, and you are an organisation that is large enough to have a PR footprint, you might care. If you're just a small fish, you are always going to have huge pressure to take the cash. I know what my partners would have done if I'd put up any resistance in these cases; they'd have just ground me down with endless rationalizations, and we'd have ended up doing exactly the same. People always find reasons to do what they have decided to do, and not in that order.
- howlgram 8y agoI just want to mention that Gaddafi brought a lot of development to Libya and his death did nothing for his people. It's easy to say "oh he was a dictator and dictators are bad" but it's not so simple.
- readhn 8y agothe same could be said about a lot of dictators. these guys make it so that there is no other option (by killing opponents) for the country.
- howlgram 8y ago>by killing opponents Gaddafi's rise to power was a bloodless Coup [1], from the little understanding that I have, he was beloved by many Libyans, you should question where these "militias" that took him down came from, his dying words were 'What did I do to you?' [2], and you should question for what reasons should he be considered "tyrannical". Should you look at Libya today, it is ran by territorial gangs, which is antithetical to the idea that they rid themselves of a great evil. Finally I haven't fully educated myself on this, but it's very interesting, just reading the "Background" part of the Libyan Civil War wiki article makes you wonder: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Libyan_Civil_War_(2011)#Background https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Libyan_Civil_War_(2011)#Backgr... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1969_Libyan_coup_d%27%C3%A9tat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1969_Libyan_coup_d%27%C3%A9tat [2] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/oct/23/gaddafi-last-words-begged-mercy https://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/oct/23/gaddafi-last-w...
- lchengify 8y ago"Evidence gathered by Reuters in the provincial town of Khoms shows an organised system of repression with methods including delivering electric shocks to suspects' genitals, keeping them for weeks in baking heat with only a few sips of water a day, and whipping them with an electrical cable while their hands were bound with plastic ties." https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/africaandindianocean/libya/8745164/Libya-Gaddafi-squads-tortured-people-in-shipping-containers.html https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/africaandindianoc...
- rpcastagna 8y agoIt's weird to me you would treat this state of affairs as a static and universally-holding position. I think it's obvious (with several current examples coming to mind) that investors and business partners can be branded as "toxic" in a way that overwhelmingly devalues any money they could actually offer. In the same way the police will take a stolen watch from you after you buy it -- without much recourse on your part! -- you and your company can definitely be torpedoed by taking bad money if public opinion shifts that sharply. These are the risks of working at the national and global scale; they have to be there, otherwise the rewards couldn't (sustainably) be so great. Even ignoring the moral arguments, the fact that anybody is making them changes the game theory perspective as well. The only way to truly stay on top is to make sure most people want you there.
- lordnacho 8y ago> It's weird to me you would treat this state of affairs as a static and universally-holding position. People are going to tend to do what everyone else does. If we were to start hearing that everyone in the fund community had decided not to take money from XYZ kind of investor, we'd probably have done the same. And the arguments would be no different. You'd decide what to do, and then all the reasons that weren't enough before would suddenly be damning and certainly enough. As for moral arguments, I'm surprised (well not really) that people think it's so simple. Anyone who's read a bit of philosophy has come across moral dilemmas that are not clear. I mean fgs there's a guy up the thread who thinks Gaddafi is defensible, and then there are people who think a guy who hires heavies is untouchable.
- statictype 8y ago>And where do you draw the line? What if a benevolent, enlightened, prosperous but essentially a dictatorship state from the equator wants to invest? And they could well claim to be a democracy. I assume you’re talking about Singapore. Its not inaccurate but I think its not really fair to paint them with the same brush as the others.
- tomasien 8y agoThe commentator is specifically asking where you draw the line and is making that the point that this case seems very different but has some of the same characteristics of the ostensibly more clear-cut cases. OP is specifically saying this is not the same brush.
- tomasien 8y agoGood points but "where do you draw the line? It's not clear" is fair observation but not a conclusion. You DO have to draw the line and just because where to draw it isn't clear doesn't absolve you (or anyone!) from drawing it.
- npunt 8y agoYeah exactly - this isn't a minor inconvenience, it's a fundamental part of being in society. I appreciate OP's point about lack of clarity, because yes, the capitalist game has nothing to say about anything except following whatever you can get away with. But that narrow game is being played in a much broader context of society that exists because of a broader social contract and set of values which keeps everything running. The reasonable answer to where you draw the line is: when something is no longer compatible with your value system. And if that's not clear, the issue is that you haven't yet spent enough time defining your values. That's the thing to talk about, research, consider, ask advice on, etc. People having a solid, well-tested personal value system is critical to society's function, because that informs how groups of people like companies then operate, and so forth on up. To make a bit of a broader (and possibly controversial) point on this, we're in a situation right now where software engineering and finance are two fields with the highest leverage in society, yet these fields are some of the least concerned with values/ethics, from the point of view of both the education and experiences people gain in these fields. Small parts of these fields may care a great deal about values/ethics, but broadly speaking the situation we're in is "with great power comes great unawareness of responsibility." It's weird and scary. The result of this lack of concern is that many powerful people have under-developed and unsophisticated personal value systems, and consequently do not know what to do in ethically nuanced, important situations like what OP is bringing up. There's a whole lot of people in tech waking up to this realization nowadays. It'd be nice if we were able to fix this at the source and raise the next generation right, rather than flail around rediscovering this every few years when yet another societal crisis hits.
- altonzheng 8y agoWell said. I’ve just started really thinking about this. Although I would venture that people naturally develop value systems as they get older, whatever field they are in. It’s just that many of our existing institutions set you up to create values based on self interest and wealth. I think it’s unfortunate. But then again, can I really say my values are superior?
- dforrestwilson 8y agoI’m sorry but this is a pathetic cop out. Just because the financial system is global, it does not mean you have to launder money for drug dealers or other people with shady morals. “The business needed the investment” is just code for you desiring an X-figure paycheck. The other corollary of this - should we really be surprised that an anti-globalist like Trump is in power with lax attitudes such as the above?
- lordnacho 8y agoIn your rush to condemnation, you've missed that I specifically mentioned that we followed anti money-laundering laws. Also none of the people we worked with had been convicted for drug dealing.
- dforrestwilson 8y agoYou are clearly uncomfortable with your own choices in the original post. It's laundering. Legal or not the choices you made were unethical. “We believe there should be a huge area between everything you should do and everything you can do without getting into legal trouble. I don’t think you should come anywhere near that line.” -Charlie Munger Your choices, your life, don't expect me to celebrate or make excuses for it.
- jannes 8y agoHe specifically mentioned that he was adhering to AML rules. Maybe you think that the AML rules of his country should be different?
- dforrestwilson 8y agoNo. I think ethics =/= laws.
- cocacola1 8y agoI can understand why people would take blood money or seedy money (so long as it's legal from their end). I just don't understand why they can't admit to themselves that it's a little evil and go about their business like they'd do anyways. Nothing changes except you feel a little bad about yourself, probably, and the rest of us don't have to hear as many excuses.
- chrisbennet 8y agoI agree. I try to see the best in people so when I hear someone making excuses for doing something wrong [“piracy is not stealing’] I can take some comfort in knowing that they still have that little voice in their heads that tells them rught from wrong - even if they don’t listen to it.
- thebiglebrewski 8y agoSounds like your someone finding reasons and excuses? You definitely can draw the line somewhere, many people do. It's not a binary choice and it sounds like you helped and encouraged some bad people. At least you have tons of money now, presumably, which...makes you more happy?
- megy 8y ago> Was I going to tell him not to take the job? How complicit are you if you write some exchange connectors for a dictator? He ended up taking it, and they ended up in the news. NO, but you should have told him what you knew and let him make the decision.
- grapehut 8y ago> I get the feeling you only write articles like that if you have more people wanting to invest than you have capacity for. I get the opposite feeling. I suspect such virtue signalling is an attempt to attract investors who care about ethics, and perhaps more importantly accept your investment offers.
- paddy_m 8y agoIt's virtue signalling that puts a pinch on your competitors who can't turn down money from bad actors.
- magicbuzz 8y agoIf you don't draw the line at dictatorships that grind up American journalists - where do you draw the line?
- unknownkadath 8y agoThe road to hell is paved with good returns, it seems.
- sjcsjc 8y agoVery good line
- ska 8y agoIf history has anything to say about this, the line is drawn - if it is drawn - considerably further into nasty business.
- unknownkadath 8y agoIt seems to me that this post is distilled evil.
- intended 8y agoThe way I’ve come to define this issue is that Homo sapiens lives in a world built for homo economicus. And homo economicus is busy hacking Homo sapiens to see exactly how much it can be hacked. There’s no “financially or economically” sound choice here. If the marginal utility of taking money from a murderer is higher than not taking it, then you take it. Morals are assumed to be held by people and there’s no adjustment for how weak they are as a slow amorphous force. Our systems are actually designed to be objective and away from soft things like feelings.
- ionised 8y agoThe only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing Your entire post is prevarication in an attempt to justify taking the money of a murderer.
- lordnacho 8y agoWhich example would you say that is?
- Lordarminius 8y agoSince you been involved in the financial world and run a hedge fund, you'll agree with me that if you go high enough, all money is morally tainted. No one ever made a billion dollars by being a boy scout.
- Nursie 8y agoHave you read "Market Forces" by Richard Morgan? Seems like you'd fit right in. Money, business, and taking care to skate just within the line of the law doesn't absolve you from being evil and effectively using your position to help make the world a much worse place.
- chaostheory 8y agoThe same goes for taking Department of Defense (or your own country's equivalent) money. There is so much research and innovation that just wouldn't have been funded if their principals didn't take money from the military.
- oliv__ 8y agoSure, it's easy to rationalize decisions like these, and even find great arguments in favor of them. But, you still have to sleep with yourself a night. I guess in the end it just boils down to how well you can cope with yourself.