7 ms·
It is just insane to me that you have a medical issue and you're calling around for quotes. I know we have had this conversation to death for decades now but it
by Waterluvian 8y ago
It is just insane to me that you have a medical issue and you're calling around for quotes. I know we have had this conversation to death for decades now but it just makes me so angry.
- nostromo 8y agoWhy? The most efficient provider should get his or her business. That way we can treat more people for strep and increase human welfare.
- mrep 8y agoProbably because if we had universal healthcare, you wouldn't have to call any because you would get the same service for free.
- mitchtbaum 8y agoHow would the universe provide healthcare?
- mrep 8y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_health_care https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_health_care
- WoodenChair 8y agoIt's true that you wouldn't have to call around, because you wouldn't have to compare the cost of out-of-pocket providers. It's not true that you wouldn't have to pay. You would pay through taxes, or someone else would pay through taxes. And you would pay in terms of the waiting time, which becomes an alternative form of payment in public systems.
- jimktrains2 8y agoInteresting that everyone makes this argument for things that aren't already covered by taxes. No one sits and argues that you do have to pay for the interstate system in a discussion about the cost of using it as the turnpike. No one thinks that no end user cost (what people usually mean when they say free) <> no money spent.
- TomMarius 8y agoIsn't the interstate system frequently blocked and the roads not really good, the speed limit low, construction way too expensive and slow, etc? I wouldn't really want to have that in my healthcare system... My point: Let's stop comparing healthcare to road construction/maintenance. It's human lives. It works differently.
- jimktrains2 8y agoI wasn't comparing healthcare to roads. I was commenting about how silly people sound when they say "it isn't free, taxes fund it". Also, speed limits can be comparable to turnpike's, the interstates are rarely "blocked" unless you mean congested, which is a different issue and one that more road at that location would actually make worse. Construction costs are comparable to turnpike construction and maintenance costs and are slow because, unlike a turnpike it's most visible and most delaying in areas like cities where you can't move cars to a shoulder, something that isn't an issue for turnpikes..
- monotone666 8y ago>interstate frequently blocked By whom? Traffic is just an argument for mass transit >roads not really good That’s an argument for more government not less. They’re fine where I live. >speed limit low It’s reasonable in cities and towns >construction expensive and slow Also high quality You already have a beurocracy in “your” health care system. It’s just a private one and not a public one. The difference is cost involved in administrative overhead deciding who gets care and for what. A nation needs a good health care system and a good road system to afford productive workers. Both systems when implemented poorly cause human death and disability.
- beatgammit 8y agoYou shouldn't even need to call around, prices for routine procedures like checking for strep should be clearly posted. The bill shouldn't change if you're insured or uninsured, just the payer changes. There's obviously some variation here, and for that an hourly rate makes sense. Health care should be more like car repair: go in for a quote, then pay when you decide on a provider. Obviously emergencies are different, but things like strep or broken bones are pretty common, so they should have a set price.
- HarryHirsch 8y agoThe most efficient provider should get his or her business. That's an assertion, not an argument supported by observations. In the European countries the government sets prices for procedures, and it works well, life expectancy there isn't lower than it is in the US.
- WoodenChair 8y agoLife expectancy is not a simple proxy for quality of health care. Exercise, diet, happiness, genetics, disaster propensity, and many cultural factors have an impact on life expectancy.
- twic 8y agoCompare specifically to the UK then - we get no exercise, have awful diets, are miserable, have a more inbred version of US genetics, fucking love self-inflicted disasters apparently, and are culturally mostly indistinguishable from the US. And yet, despite the fact that we spend a fraction of what you spend on healthcare, have a couple more years' life expectancy.
- Latteland 8y agoAnd by almost any measure we are no better than and frequently behind other western democracies in healthcare.
- nostromo 8y agoEuropean countries are free riders on the American healthcare system. Americans pay out the nose for drug prescriptions, which fund the vast majority of research and development budgets, which then benefit all people, worldwide.
- maxxxxx 8y agoI think this is very self-serving propaganda by the American healthcare system. And even if it's true let's fix this by charging less in the US and see what happens to the rest of the world. .
- TomMckenny 8y ago>The most efficient provider should get his or her business. Given that the US has this system and US healthcare is multiples more expensive with worse or similar outcomes in essentially every field, I suggest we can put that theory to rest now.
- TomMarius 8y agoWhat about Switzerland though? (definitely not defending the US system)
- TomMckenny 8y agoThere must be some additional variable. Be nice to know what it is.
- nostromo 8y ago> Given that the US has this system The US does not have this system.
- TomMckenny 8y agoThe grand parent describes this exact process. Why would we think he was lying?
- TomMarius 8y agoNo lying is necessary, misinformation is common. People generally don't know how much the healthcare industry is regulated and how exactly.
- charlesdm 8y agoThe most efficient provider, however, might not be the best provider. If you have cancer, you want to get the best treatment and survive. But hey, this other guy might be able to do it cheaper!
- shanusmagnus 8y agoJust as big a problem as the opacity in pricing, is the opacity in figuring out who the best providers even are. There's no Yelp for healthcare because powerful groups won't let it exist.
- bko 8y agoWhat's the alternative? Everyone charges the same price? Who sets this price? Calling around and shopping is what people do on practically every other service or good they buy now.
- jacobush 8y agoAnd on every other service you will get something that at least resembles a straight answer.
- refurb 8y agoMy guess is that this is where healthcare is headed in the US. If things stay on the current trajectory, the govt is simply going to step in set prices. In terms of how they would be set, Medicare already spends a ton of time created a system of DRG codes for every condition along with a set payment (adjusted by COL and other things). Of course Medicare rates are sometimes less than the cost to provide the care. But I see us just getting to the point that the govt will just say “tough shit”.
- lexs 8y agoDo you call around and shop for different fire departments? Seems weird that such a basic need would be treated this way.
- 1123581321 8y agoFire departments are analogous to ambulance response — these services are entirely based on geographic location and, similarly to insurance, need to be arranged in advance by a municipality or county, or an out-of-district annual payment. Most healthcare is not summoned this way although there are an increasing number of medical practices that charge a subscription in exchange for quick access to the office and remote consultations.
- tehwebguy 8y agoIf you think you're angry now you should try actually calling around for quotes. My experience is that most places you call won't even try to give you a straight answer!
- robertAngst 8y ago>It is just insane to me that you have a medical issue and you're calling around for quotes. You dont call around for quotes of $100+ services? Why?
- yodsanklai 8y agoBecause you should be able to show up, get your treatment and go home without paying a dime, like in most developed countries.
- robertAngst 8y agoThat sounds unsustainable and bad capitalism. Free services mean a few people will overuse and abuse.
- Latteland 8y agoSo you are saying poor people should just die I guess. Them and their kids.
- cmyr 8y agoIndeed, ever since I realized I could get medical care without paying for it I've been going out and getting cancer a couple times a week.
- monotone666 8y agoEventually seeking out excessive medical care will be considered a mental illness and it’s practioners hospitalized
- xkcd-sucks 8y ago"Drug seeking behavior" extended to antibiotics and chemotherapy lol
- ionised 8y ago> That sounds unsustainable It is perfectly sustainable if you have a population that isn't ideologically opposed to taxes. You can fix that with education. > and bad capitalism. Good capitalism or bad capitalism, who cares? This sounds like a pointless ideological concern, again. > Free services mean a few people will overuse and abuse. It seems spiteful to me to deny universal healthcare to the majority because a minority might abuse it.
- johnpowell 8y agoI was diagnosed with Oropharyngeal Cancer 39 days ago. Keeping up with the appointments alone has been bad enough. I am not sure how I would deal with this if I had to shop around for the best deal. -I went to urgent care for some swelling on my neck that escalated quickly. 45 minutes later I was getting a MRI. This was on a Friday. They called and said it was cancer. -Monday I was seen by a ear nose throat doctor. Yes, cancer indeed. -Tuesday I saw a oncologist. -At this point I decided to move to Portland since my sister lives up here. So the oncologist referred me to another ENT doctor in Portland. -About a week later I saw a dentist and radiologist on the same day. Everyone agreed that due to the bad shape my teeth are/were in and the location of the cancer my teeth need to come out. -A few days later another oncologist -All my teeth removed (this has been rough) -Tomorrow a "simulation" and PET scan to see if the cancer has spread -Tuesday is something called a swallowing test -Wednesday is a check up with the oral surgeon -Friday is some intake thing for the feeding tube and a meeting with the nutritionist. -Next Monday feeding tube installed. -Next Tuesday another check-up with the G.I doctor. -Next Wednesday radiation and chemo start. So yeah.. I have no clue how much this shit is costing and I don't really care since I have Medicare. I just wish everyone had the same luxury.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mvleming 8y agoGodspeed brother, I wish you the best. You'll be in my thoughts
- chrisweekly 8y agoWelcome to the [Cancer] club noone wants to join. Good luck w/ your treatment.
- monocularvision 8y agoI hope you don’t mind, but praying for you and your treatment going forward.
- dimator 8y agoFight the good fight, internet stranger. Don't give up. Good luck.
- archagon 8y agoWe live in a boring dystopia https://twitter.com/visakanv/status/990570131238473728 https://twitter.com/visakanv/status/990570131238473728
- 1123581321 8y agoCalling for quotes is how buyers (patients) force prices down in the long run. For example, I got a quote this summer for an outpatient MRI that was 20% the cost of a hospital MRI, faster, and would accomplish the same thing. Now I tell everyone I know about this. If enough people do this, the hospital will not be as free to increase the cost and might even lower it (or at least start providing quotes!) This price-shopping process is slowed by all the shenanigans that keep prices and services provided confusing, and demand to improve this is hampered by insistence that patients are never in a state of mind to shop for the best healthcare provider. It’s simply untrue—and there are workarounds in the worst cases like healthcare POAs and family members donating time.