16 ms·
A Billionaire Pledges to Fight High Drug Prices, and the Industry Is Rattled
- jseliger 8y agoIt has long puzzled me that we don't have strong political constituencies for price transparency in medicine. Every medical provider ought to have a website that lists every fee and cost; this is not hard to do, yet when I call providers for cash prices, the answer is often, "I don't know" or "I can't tell you."
- dec0dedab0de 8y agoI couldnt even get cvs to tell me the price of something with my insurance. They said it would take a few days.
- maxxxxx 8y agoI saw this with my girlfriend. She needed a procedure where the provider refused to even give a ballpark number, the insurance refused to tell if they would cover it or to what extent. So if you really need it, your only way forward is to get the procedure and hope for the best without even a basic idea about the costs.
- thelasthuman 8y ago"insurance refused to tell if they would cover it" 'Hey boss, I saw the schedule. Not sure I I will be able to cover any of those shifts you gave me. By the way, pay me the same weather I do my job or not. Thanks'
- Old_Thrashbarg 8y agoAgreed, it's so opaque. I feel like I've called a specialist asking what they think my copay will be given my insurance plan and they said they don't know, talk with my insurance firm. I call my insurance firm and they say they don't know, I have to submit the claim first. Any marketplace where the buyer isn't informed of the price until after the transaction is ripe for disruption.
- microcolonel 8y agoFrankly, I don't see how it should be possible to buy something you're not entitled to know the price of; or rather, I don't think it should be possible to bill more for something than the quote.
- rileymat2 8y agoIt is complicated ( don't want to excuse it), but I am not sure I would expect the doctor to know your insurance arrangement (or even how much you would expect to pay because you would need to know how much of your deductible you have already gone through.) And how would the Insurance company know until they are billed for the procedure?
- rland 8y agoThis is what's so strange about the system. There is no "price sheet" because it's all funny money until the consumer gets billed. Perhaps the doctor would not know, but the hospital should have a price sheet for every routine service rendered. Those edge cases that are not routine procedures should have estimates provided in advance. For those edge cases that are so time sensitive that an estimate cannot be provided to the consumer in advance... well, that's what insurance is for.
- shados 8y agoIt's downright barbaric. You have a service for which you basically can't get a quote, can be collected into oblivion if you don't pay, you don't even know WHO will bill you (or even how many bills you'll get!), and you very well might be unconscious or in no position to make this kind of decision. Your life might be on the line! It only gets some level of sanity (though not to reasonable level) if you involve insurance companies, who have some of the information necessary and the leverage to negotiate.
- nickjj 8y agoAlso don't forget that the thought of even asking for a refund on prescription medication will get you laughed at. Right, so I'm supposed to pay $700 for some medication that has a chance of either making my heart stop or cure my condition and if it doesn't cure it, too bad.
- maxxxxx 8y agoI think it was a huge mistake that this didn't get tackled during the Obamacare discussions. Price transparency and the removal of preexisting conditions would be a big step for some sanity in the US medical system. It's also pretty sad that the Republicans who are supposedly for markets don't push for price transparency.
- prostoalex 8y ago> the removal of preexisting conditions That happened under ACA, didn’t it?
- EvanAnderson 8y agoIt did.
- ilove_banh_mi 8y agoActually Trump and the Republicans ran on a platform of price transparency, but Senate Democrats can block and have effectively blocked (assisted by now-deceased McCain) any non-taxation-related changes to Obamacare. Reference: https://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/promises/trumpometer/promise/1393/require-price-transparency-health-care-providers/ https://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/promises/trumpomete...
- Someone1234 8y agoYour claims are simply erroneous and your link doesn't support them. From your own link: > The House GOP bill that has emerged as the leading option to repeal and replace the Affordable Care Act includes no added price transparency provision. So the bill that McCain helped defeat didn't contain improved transparency according to your own source. And the GOP hasn't introduced significant legislation since to address the problem, therefore Democrats supporting (or not supporting) it is all hypotheticals based on no actual legislation.
- ilove_banh_mi 8y ago
- danso 8y agoSounds like there just hasn’t been enough money and support to create a committed movement, not when pharmaceutical companies have the means to push the narrative that it’s an intractable problem. From the article: > Another reason Mr. Arnold got involved: Drug pricing was an issue no other philanthropist had claimed. This makes some intuitive sense. America’s healthcare system manages to hide its costs so well while providing modern treatment that it may not seem like the most compelling humanitarian problem for a billionaire, i.e. a first-world problem compared to providing mosquito nets to prevent malaria.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- prostoalex 8y agoCalifornia requires hospitals to publish chargemasters (price sheets for most common procedures) and makes them available https://oshpd.ca.gov/data-and-reports/cost-transparency/hospital-chargemasters/ https://oshpd.ca.gov/data-and-reports/cost-transparency/hosp...
- rlpb 8y agoPerhaps they should be taxed on their MSRP and not be given a tax rebate on discounts. That would encourage them to keep their published prices matched to what they actually charge.
- bradleyjg 8y agoThey aren’t taxed at all because they register as non-profits even though they act as partnerships.
- mschuster91 8y ago> Perhaps they should be taxed on their MSRP and not be given a tax rebate on discounts. That would encourage them to keep their published prices matched to what they actually charge. The problem is that as there's no mandatory insurance in the US like there is in Germany, there is a very high chance that the patient may not be able to pay the bill, and so the hospital (or practice) is stuck with the costs. Which may go into six, sometimes seven digit sums. And this loss has to be eaten somewhere... in the form of everyone else having to pay way overinflated sums. The only way to fix the US health system is to provide a national mandatory insurance for everyone which covers everything of basic healthcare, and then for the private industry they can offer insurance packages for higher-quality care (single rooms instead of shared ones, for example). Or, if that is not possible due to the insurance companies having bought off half of Congress, at the very least introduce a nationwide pricing list for medical procedures, with as few possibilities for deviation as it can be done (for example, services in the center of Manhattan can be more expensive than somewhere out in the woods because rent and staff are more expensive).
- prostoalex 8y ago
- neonate 8y agohttp://archive.is/ED7g6 http://archive.is/ED7g6
- tfha 8y agoIf you want to fix medicine, increase transparency. Earlier this summer, I had white spots on my throat and needed to go get checked for strep. I called around, and finally settled on a facility that told me they could check for strep for just $59. I go in, get my throat culture, then get my bill. "Well yeah, the throat culture was only $59. But the nurse had to do it and it's $120 to see a nurse. Also, the doctor has to check in before any operation is performed, and that's $200. After all other fees, your total bill is $400". There's no way that should be legal. I was quoted $60.
- microcolonel 8y ago> There's no way that should be legal. I was quoted $60. Well, part of the problem is that the state now assumes that consumers are not qualified to take care of themselves, and that the only people who are qualified are state-approved high-demand professionals. Oddly enough, opioid overdoses were not higher when you could just buy the stuff over the counter; but people have forgotten that people used to be responsible for their own well-being, and are convinced that they should not be trusted to defer to experts when they see fit.
- gbacon 8y agoSome things should simply be left to Our Betters.
- HarryHirsch 8y agoAfter the Alfie Evans circus I'm inclined to agree. You need to be properly trained to be able to recognize what is in the best interest of the patient and that that is the only thing that matters.
- ibeckermayer 8y agoIt’s bizarre that “capitalism” is frequently blamed for the moral atrocity that is the American medical industry when really it’s one of the most clear cut examples of a state-mandated cartel
- maxxxxx 8y agoIt's pretty sad that we have to rely on "billionaires" because the political system is not able or willing to bring even some level of sanity into this totally perverse system.
- jsonne 8y agoThere does seem to be some progress being made: https://www.cnn.com/2018/10/10/politics/drug-prices-legislation-signed-into-law-donald-trump/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2018/10/10/politics/drug-prices-legislat...
- Someone1234 8y agoThat would definitely be a good thing and may help discourage high prices, but let's see if it ever happens. The drug companies are already talking about taking it to court for violating their first amendment rights.
- cimmanom 8y agoOne thing that scares me is seeing how he's putting money into swaying how the media report on things. That one billionaire is willing to do such a thing to support the public good is great. How many are doing so for less laudable ends?
- almostdeadguy 8y agoI’m everyone in this thread talking about price transparency for goods people need to live.
- khuey 8y agoPrice transparency in food seems to work alright.
- jaggederest 8y agoTransportable commodity goods are not really the same as local, nonportable professional services. Imagine if everything you ate had to come from the county you live in. Would it really matter how much they charged? You would have to pay it, right?
- almostdeadguy 8y agoWe're really pretending like price transparency is the primary factor in food prices in the US and that 40 million people don't go hungry in this country?
- jancsika 8y agoI noticed that, too. Free marketeers: how does price transparency improve prices for emergency room visits?
- rland 8y agoPerhaps it doesn't, for those weird edge cases where they have to bring the unconscious patient in and have him assessed 5 different ways. Situations like that are the domain of insurance agencies. But most medical care (the majority of the cost) is not rendered like that. Most of it is routine and predictable, and should be priced transparently as such.
- jancsika 8y ago> Perhaps it doesn't, for those weird edge cases where they have to bring the unconscious patient in and have him assessed 5 different ways. Does "weird edge cases" cover the 790,000 people who have a heart attack every year[1]? If not, how does price transparency improve their ambulance ride or change which hospital is their destination? [1] https://www.cdc.gov/heartdisease/heart_attack.htm https://www.cdc.gov/heartdisease/heart_attack.htm
- aviv 8y agoWe are looking at the health care problem from the wrong angle. Nobody should be needing most of these drugs to begin with. But we have a food culture and system that feed civilization disease causing foods and that's where the cycle starts.
- jrace 8y agoThere are plenty of people who need medications not because of poor diet.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- endymi0n 8y ago> “Where it is impossible to create the conditions necessary to make competition effective, we should resort to other methods of guiding economic activity.” - Friedrich Hayek, The Road to Serfdom, p.37 Free markets work as expected where the alternative is dying at worst: They fail completely. If you're lying unconcious in the ER and there's zero regulation in the country of unlimited capitalism worship, the hospital can charge whatever the fsck they want. And yet, there are still a few people in the US surprised they actually do so. https://www.forbes.com/sites/chrisladd/2017/03/07/there-is-never-a-free-market-in-health-care/#95025281147f https://www.forbes.com/sites/chrisladd/2017/03/07/there-is-n...
- hexane360 8y agoI'm kind of surprised that quote is from Hayek, considering I know of him as "that Austrian Austrian economist", and mostly see him quoted in defense of radical free market ideology. I guess it just goes to show how far pro-market the Overton window's shifted recently.
- jeffbax 8y agoIt is a myth that the US has a free market in healthcare. It is a web of regulatory hell and perverse incentives.
- wnoise 8y agoWhile that's true, it's a complete non-sequitur to the parent comment.
- hexane360 8y agoIt appears that he's trying to argue that we haven't tried hard enough to deregulate healthcare, and therefore we haven't proven it's "impossible to create the conditions necessary to make competition effective". Which imo shows a startling amount of specious reasoning or delusion.
- bdcs 8y ago
- jorblumesea 8y agoWhy do we talk about "high drug prices" as some kind of mystical force? The cause is simple and very obvious: the medical industry is a for profit institution that puts margins and bottom line above everything else. It's a huge industry with a plethora of middlemen whose only purpose is to squeeze dollars out of the system. Delivering effective care is almost always a secondary consequence to making value for investors. So long as healthcare has quarterly shareholder meetings, we will forever be locked in this battle.
- pcurve 8y agoI've been in healthcare, pharma industry for a long time. Healthcare isn't 'broken'. The high drug and medical prices are by design. That's the way system is designed and it's working as intended by regulators and industry leaders. If they really wanted to 'fix' the healthcare, they can fix it. But there is no money in fixing it at this point. One guy with small amount of funding will do nothing to highly regulated space full of deeply entrenched incumbents. regulators, doctors, pharmacists, pharma, medical device, pbm, medical insurance, hospital systems, lawyers, and IT jobs at those companies.
- raverbashing 8y agoAgreed, though it seems there is a huge window for someone who charges fairly to get in Fixed and transparent/fair costs (and promotion of it) will get a significant line in front of the clinic. If someone's got a huge amount of money to play with this, it will be fun to see the incumbents getting trashed. In a way, it's "dumping" (but not really as it's still above cost)
- pcurve 8y agoI think pricing transparency will help for drugs and commodified services like routine testing and procedures. Historical though, any attempted 'fix' simply results in shifting of profit from one incumbent to another, along with even more creative ways to get around them. Mfr. copay coupons mentioned in the article is a great example. I'm all for change, but to me, American healthcare is mainly regulatory failure.
- gorbachev 8y agoThis, and many, many other similar issues will not be fixed until campaign finance reform gets done.
- chottocharaii 8y agocampaign finance will never be reformed, political movement needs to be able to operate in spite of money contributed I doubt Citizens United will ever be overruled
- booleandilemma 8y agoWhen I was younger and more naive I went to a surgeon to ask how much a minor surgery would cost ahead of time. They couldn’t tell me. I said fine, could you give me a ballpark estimate? And they couldn’t do that either. Imagine going into a grocery store and not being able to check the price of your groceries before you decide to purchase them? Why do we put up with this?
- myroon5 8y agoKnew it would be John Arnold. If you find this interesting, he regularly posts content like this on his Twitter: https://twitter.com/JohnArnoldFndtn https://twitter.com/JohnArnoldFndtn
- 40acres 8y agoThere seems to be a pretty simple solution to high drug prices: the Bayh-Dole Act. The background to the law is this: previously if a private institution used federal grants to develop a new drug, the federal government retained patent rights. The federal government isnt particularly good at commercializing products so the Bayh-Doye act allows for private institutions to retain patents for innovations funded via government grants. The government retains certain rights to the patent (this is important). With this situation you have a case where the American tax payer essentially pays twice for certain drugs, their taxes paid for the federal grant that discovered the drug and now they have to pay a private company to actually use the drug. Well, the Bayh-Dole act grants the government "march-in" rights, which basically allows the government to license any patent derived using federal funds to a third party if the original partner “has not taken, or is not expected to take within a reasonable time, effective steps to achieve practical application of the … invention”. The government has NEVER exercised it's march-in rights. I understand the hesitation to drastically change the market for a product by granting a 3rd party a patent that they would otherwise never have, but it's been made clear over the past few years that many pharmaceutical companies are acting in bad faith and abusing their market position by drastically increasing drug prices. I think exercising Bayh-Dole on a high profile drug (EpiPen??) would shake the market back into reasonable price structures. It's a huge hammer the federal government is not wielding.
- WaltPurvis 8y agoDo you happen to know how many drugs are developed with federal grant money? I'm guessing that only a small percentage of high-priced drugs were developed using federal grants, and therefore your solution would be only a very partial solution, but I don't actually know. Do you?
- 40acres 8y agoAccording to Wikipedia from 2010-2016 about 200 new drugs were introduced that were partly funded by the NIH, of these drugs about 80 were significant in the fact that they worked via previously unknown mechanisms.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI'm feeling cranky as hell, so let me go ahead and toss out the wildly unpopular idea that the real solution here is more research etc into dietary and lifestyle changes. But I seriously doubt he's going to go in that direction.
- amanaplanacanal 8y agoThat kind of research is really hard. You pretty much have to lock people up for long periods of time, and make sure they only eat what you give them. The current state of dietary research is pretty much a morass of contradictory associations, with no proof of any causative factors.
- derReineke 8y agoMuch rattled very startle. You'll also be AMAZED what doctors are saying about this new diet thing!
- apo 8y agoHe [Billionaire Arnold] has spent more than $100 million in health-care-related grants since 2014. A million dollars went to Civica Rx, a nonprofit formed by seven U.S. hospital systems to make generic drugs. Up to $5.7 million is pledged to Initiative for Medicines, Access & Knowledge Inc., which files legal challenges to the validity of certain U.S. drug patents, to clear the way for lower-cost generics. He funded research about the relationship between pharmaceutical packaging and drug costs, leading Medicare to pass new rules that took effect in 2017. The state of California, advised by an Arnold-funded group, passed a law in 2017 requiring drugmakers to justify steep price increases. In other words, Arnold is spending money on: - a consortium that will manufacture generics - legal efforts to hasten the expiration of patents to provide more generics - research on packaging - lobbying legislatures to require justifications from drugmakers on price increases None of this sounds like it's addressing the main problems leading to high costs: 1. The customer (patient) doesn't directly pay all costs. The economic incentive to keep prices low lies mostly with the insurance providers. 2. It takes more than a decade of research and hundreds of millions of dollars to develop a drug with a new mode of action. 3. At least 90% of these projects will fail to deliver a marketable product. 4. The amount of money spent on a drug project balloons the longer it remains viable. 5. Failure of a late-stage clinical candidate often leaves a drug company with two options: (1) kill the program; and (2) send yet another candidate through the pipeline. 6. Data on late-stage clinical failures are often tightly held in silos, preventing other companies from learning costly lessons.
- perpetualcrayon 8y ago"there should be 'compensating upside' for the few drugs that do make it to market to ensure investors continue to fund companies’ uncertain R&D efforts" Ok, then open your books so we can see why you're pricing the way you are. Obviously, given all the recent attention this has gotten, the industry is not being very transparent about this. Why has no "outsider" been able to connect these dots and why are you (the industry) preventing them from doing so?
- EGreg 8y agoHere is a full proposal, I’d like some feedback: http://magarshak.com/blog/?p=93 http://magarshak.com/blog/?p=93
- jhabdas 8y agoI'm in Indonesia. There are so many cheap, easy to access drugs here. Need amoxicillin? Get it over the counter for less than $5 US.