13 ms·
67% of workers earning over $100k see themselves quitting in the next 6 months
- aresant 8y agoFixed: “67% of workers earning over $100k see themselves “changing jobs for better pay due to strong labor market” in the next 6 months.”
- Pfhreak 8y agoThis is totally it. Engineers, in particular understand that they have options, they are highly in demand, and they have strong negotiating positions when they interview. It's not uncommon for an engineer to get a boost of 10-25% when changing companies, and other than prepping for the grueling interview process, there really isn't a downside to feeling out what's out there. Especially when your compensation isn't keeping up with the median due to lackluster annual increases.
- hellogoodbyeeee 8y agoDoes this work for your entire career or does it only work until you hit some kind of "salary cap" for your local market? I've had a few good raises in a short period of time, but I'm scared I can realistically only get one or two more in before I reach the top of the market.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sk1pper 8y agoI’ve hit that in my market - or a soft cap, at least, meaning if I want to earn more, I’m going to have to make 2-3x as much effort than I did before. Through working my ass off, and pretty great luck, (working on lots of side projects didn’t hurt either), I recently did some looking just to feel the market out and I’m making like $20k more than I “should” be. Part of this is because my company is based out of Bethesda, MD and I live in Denver, CO - cost of living differences. My company pays really well which allows them to compete with Silicon Valley and everywhere else for the best engineers. No complaints here. I’m making double what I thought I would be making at this point in my career. Anyway, yes, anecdotally, it caps out, but I also like to think that if I really hustled, I could keep raising it. But I’m pretty happy where I’m at and would rather spend my free time doing stuff other than coding and hustling right now.
- molsongolden 8y agoWere your feelers all in Denver? Denver seems to have surprisingly low salaries, especially when accounting for the housing boom of the past 5-6 years.
- iopuy 8y agoWhat would be considered surprisingly low? A level 3 software engineer making $100K? Genuinely curious.
- resolaibohp 8y agoDenver seems to pay very low, considering the cost of living these days. I think they refer to it as the "Denver Discount"
- twblalock 8y agoSalary caps but stock does not. FAANG companies give massive RSU grants to senior people. There is no ceiling at companies that can afford to do that, which gives them a big advantage over startups.
- Pfhreak 8y agoI'd imagine the gains are somewhat asymptotic -- there's definitely a theoretical maximum somewhere out there, and every jump moves you closer to it. The bigger gains (percentage wise) probably come earlier? My first company switch literally doubled my total comp. My second one was a double digit increase as well. I expect any future jumps to be smaller. (Though, who knows where the market will be then, as I'm likely years away from any move.)
- Bombthecat 8y agoThere was a statistic in germany about doctors, diploma and other high income people. Around 40 to 45 the salary capped or even started to decline. (age discrimination is real)
- dba7dba 8y agoStrongly agree that the 67% of workers are not quitting, they are leaving for a new job that pays more. My observation is that the higher you are in the pay bracket, the easier you seem to be abel to get a new job as your skills/experience are also in high demand else where.
- joezydeco 8y agoThey may see themselves changing jobs for higher pay, but what happens if companies are holding tight on salaries? I've been in the market for almost a year now and have had offers, but nothing higher than what I'm currently making. So I stay put. Where is this magic expectation that job offers instantly come with a salary bump? That may have been true before, but at full employment the indicators have all gone weird.
- sjg007 8y agoWell you have replacement rate wages which a company would use to fill positions they can't do without so the wage has to increase. Then you have expansion based wages where the company wants to grow and seize marketshare. Your best bet is to have some kind of leverage. So multiple offers.
- joezydeco 8y agoUnless you're a new grad multiple offers are a very rare thing. Some companies can get from interview to offer in a week or two, some take months. Everyone is a black box in the meantime. Getting 2 to line up at the same time is extremely hard, if not impossible unless you stretch one of them out way too long or simply lie about the situation.
- physcab 8y agoI think there’s also something else at play. Most of my friends also don’t believe for a second that a corporation has their best interests at heart. It’s not just promotions — it’s work life balance, it’s top-down decision making and political empire building, re-orgs every 4-6 months. The growth at all costs style of building companies chews employees up and spits them out.
- stephengillie 8y agoIf a salaried worker doesn't get overtime, then every hour they work past 40 reduces their effective pay by 2.5%.
- siquick 8y agoCan you explain the logic behind this?
- guu 8y agoIf you work overtime in a week and aren’t paid for it then you have taken a pay cut for that week. You worked more hours but made the same amount of money. Therefore the amount you made per hour is lower than your usual amount.
- Bombthecat 8y agoBingo. That's what a lot of people don't get with there high salaries. On paper they sound amazing. But if you calculate hours worked and salaries. More often then not. There promotion for example made them earn less and less per hour. But as someone wrote on hackernews: if your company is using the emotional path they don't have anything to offer on the rational level. tl;DR: calculate your income per hour, not monthly salary!
- toomuchtodo 8y ago> if your company is using the emotional path they don't have anything to offer on the rational level. Stealing this for my “don’t work for a startup” site!
- captain_perl 8y ago"The reason people are quitting today is because the labor market is so competitive that the only way they can get a significant increase in income is by quitting and going to another job." Well, no, the opposite is true. Employees have to quit because companies stubbornly refuse to be competitive on salary. The reason for that is mismanagement - managers and HR would be personally criticized for "being soft" if they offered raises, regardless of the benefits to the company of doing so.
- swagasaurus-rex 8y agoThis is the real answer. Companies have been stubbornly refusing to grant raises in line with market rates. It makes sense on the balance sheet. A large fraction of employees (33% if we take the article at face value) are unwilling to exercises their market options, and will stay at a company that underpays them. The rest leave for greener pastures, and are replaced with new hires that are paid as much as a promoted position would be paid. But this way, companies can hold on to those 33% that never see a raise that exceeds inflation. Large companies don't factor in things like loss of domain expertise, retraining, or loss of productivity due to hiring in their spreadsheets. So they will continue to do this and the only way to negotiate a true raise will be to leave; or threaten to leave. They hope you'll just be passive.
- 0x445442 8y agoDomain knowledge? Heck, at most of the places I've worked they don't even do a cost benefit analysis on whether or not the dev costs will produce a positive ROI.
- kraftman 8y agoI've seen this so much now that I feel like I must be missing a piece of the puzzle. You work for a company for X amount of time, and you gain domain knowledge of the company, and general industry experience. Some other company looks at your CV, and without knowing you, and probably without caring about your specific company domain knowledge, decides you are worth say 20% more than you are earning. You then go to your current company, and say 'my general skills are worth 20% more on the market, you know how well I work, and you know I have extra domain knowledge specific to this role, I would like more money' - and the company refuses. They then spend time and money finding someone with similar skills to what you have, but without your domain knowledge, and probably at a similar amount you asked for since that's the market rate. How is it not in the companies best interests to just keep you on and give you a raise? How do they justify all that wasted time and money every time? Do they just not measure it?
- samspenc 8y ago"Quitting" -> quitting to move to another job. But this isn't clear until three paragraphs into the article.
- dlhavema 8y agoRight.. kinda clickbaity? One way to try to get a raise at a current job that I've done in the past is get an interview and see if you can get offers for a higher paid job and then use that as leverage for a counter offer. I know there are already many threads about taking counter offers, but its not always a bad thing... in my experience, the manager just needed better justification for the higher ups. It was too large a company for him to just give me a bump.
- GreeniFi 8y agoMy sister works in the advertising industry, where it seems few people spend more than 2-3 years [edit] in a firm before moving on. The big advertising firms tend to be in public ownership and and have apparently systemised the creation of advertising and marketing content, such that it doesn’t matter who is in the job or how long they are there for. I was pretty surprised by that - managers are well paid and grind creativity out of younger employees. Maybe I shouldn’t be surprised - maybe those are just well run businesses, but I’m helluva glad I don’t work for one!
- shostack 8y agoThe average tenure of someone, particularly a junior person, at an ad or media agency is around 1.5 years. The reality is that there's always opportunities at other agencies where they'll pay you a bit more than you're currently making (which is still less than paying someone there already more) and give you an inflated title. Due in part to the nature of the industry, tasks are made to not be dependent on a given individual, and people float around because agency teams are never at equilibrium. They either have too few clients for the team and need to let people go, or too many/too big clients and need to staff up. Source: worked agency side for most of my career and managed a bunch of people. I'm brand side now at a company with a significant percentage of employees at or over the 10yr mark. There's a reason I left the agency world.
- booleandilemma 8y agoIt’s simply the best way to get a pay raise if you’re a programmer in today’s job market. Want to make 30-50k more? Quit your job and find another. You could ask your current manager for that kind of pay raise but if they do give you the increase, they’re going to expect you to work harder to “earn” it. Of course, all this money being thrown around attracts frauds, and that’s why we have absurd technical interviews.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- commandlinefan 8y ago> Quit your job and find another. Not necessarily in that order, though...
- icotyl 8y agoThe last time I made my case for a promotion, the director said "Sorry, no promotions right now, there's nothing I can do." A couple months later, a coworker gets a job offer elsewhere and threatens to leave, and he's immediately promoted. He happens to be the least experienced engineer, and now he's leading the team. This sends everybody scrambling for job offers, since that's what gets rewarded. Half the engineers have left already, and with any luck, I'll be next out the door.
- nojvek 8y agoThe best way to get a Promo is to get another job. My theory is that in the last couple of years, the market is booming however for most people, salaries haven’t kept up with it. At Microsoft my rate of raise was lower than inflation (so in essence I was getting paid less every year). Jumping ship was a huge jump. I interviewed at a bunch of places and got an idea what the market would pay for me. I negotiated slightly above and been happy.
- wyclif 8y agoI've been saying this for a long time. It's especially true in technology and engineering. I think the reason why the best way to get a promotion and a raise is to get another job is because once you've been working for a company for a few years your salary and benefits are "pinned" or anchored by HR, and you're only going to be able to advance within their acceptable terms, rates, and limits. There's also a lot more negotiation overhead—you have to spend a lot of effort in making your case for a promotion. Whereas with a new job you start fresh and you can negotiate on fundamental terms.
- dorgo 8y agoMy best way to get a raise used to be to quit my contract. Got 50% more for staying. Now I get 33% raises (without asking/negotiation) to prevent me from qutting :-P That said, I started very low, so 50% was not much.
- AllegedAlec 8y agoAs Dilbert said: the company policy is to reward disloyalty. http://dilbert.com/strip/1997-06-29 http://dilbert.com/strip/1997-06-29
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jameslk 8y agoOne of the reasons I choose contracting over employment (I've been contracting for 4.5 years and was employed prior) is that moving from contract to contract is expected and usually comes with an income increase. If I were to change jobs as frequently as I change contracts, this would look bad on my resume. This makes the contract market much more liquid than the job market, which has the consequence of arriving at my current valuation quicker.
- mandeepj 8y agoConsulting is like building a castle and giving it away to someone else to rule and enjoy the fruits. I refuse to do it now. With each new contract, you start from scratch, again. After a while, you'll realize - you are just hitting a reset switch on your career, with each new contract that you pick up. I'm glad I share my thoughts with this very smart man - https://youtu.be/Gk-9Fd2mEnI?t=908 https://youtu.be/Gk-9Fd2mEnI?t=908
- jameslk 8y agoI'd argue contracting has been the best thing for my career. I've learned sales, marketing, accounting, business & legal essentials along the way. I've made great connections from the diverse companies I've worked in and vendors I've worked with. I'm now working on scaling and selling to larger enterprises. I may not own the companies or products I work on, but I own my own company. You can stay stagnant as an employee or as a contractor. It's up to you to make your career.
- onlyrealcuzzo 8y agoIs there any room for income growth in contracting outside of building an agency? A couple of years ago, my career seemed to be dead in the water, so I thought about contracting. It's not clear to me what changed, but in the course of a year, I got two huge promotions and am now making double. I'm currently interviewing for a huge step up that might bump my salary another 25% more. I imagine if I went the contracting route, short term, I could've made much more money per hour, since I am/was pretty productive. But I /really/ doubt I'd get to where I am now on an annual basis (especially considering benefits and vacation). I also seems to have a clear path toward being a VP, CTO doesn't seem unrealstic in a few years, if I want to continue down the career path (I don't, rather start my own business, but nice to have a solid backup). I know there's a lot of money to be made running an agency, but I don't think that's a natural skillset for the vast majority of engineers. Also it seems like a really competitive space. I'd love to hear more from some contractors about this.
- rogerdickey 8y agoSo the implication is that 2/3 of workers at this pay level will turn over 2x/year? Why publish these “survey” results when that is obviously false?
- noitsnot 8y agoIt's a survey no one can really fact check? Ladders makes commission when $100k+ workers change jobs, so it benefits them by pushing the idea that everyone's jumping ship to make more money.
- Gustomaximus 8y agoThe wording is workers 'who see themself quitting'. The reality is 1 or 2 in 5 (my guess) will actually do it. People always say this but fewer are willing to fight the inertia
- mrhappyunhappy 8y agoI was working in e-commerce when my company for acquired by a larger one. Since I was 100% remote and had zero face time with anyone I was one of the people to get canned. Actually, most of our company got canned. At first I was furious and a bit depressed and that's when I said enough is enough, I will never let anyone else in a position over me, I'm done being an employee, I will never be let go ever again. A year later I was working insane hours as a freelancer, just learning the ropes with enough pay to get by on. Fast forward to year 3 and I am a consultant making more than I did at the ecommerce company. I am my own boss. I can fire my clients instead of the other way around. Pay is great, hours are insanely good - I work just a couple of hours per week with occasional bursts of power sessions exceeding 3-4 hours. I get to spend most of my time with my kid. The downside is having to always have business lined up but I have been fortunate to never really have any downtime. I'm slowly building out my marketing channels and once everything is in place I can pick and choose really carefully who I work with. Oh, and if I want a raise I just increase my weekly retainer.
- tomp 8y agoWhat kind of consulting do you do? Can you still afford to be remote?
- mrhappyunhappy 8y agoCRO. I am 100% remote working from a non English speaking country. My clients are global.
- barry-cotter 8y agoDo you have a website or do you rely solely on word of mouth/referrals?
- mrhappyunhappy 8y agoMy website is really stale as I am typically busy doing the work. I've tried to improve it but it does not generate any leads yet. So far the bulk of my inquiries comes from dribbble or LinkedIn. I get repeat business from an agency that uses me exclusively in place of their own designer / cro person as they do a lot of a/b testing.
- austincheney 8y agoThe big problem I have is that it’s rare to find a combination of strong leadership with fast stressful work in the corporate world. Historically either my work is slow and easy or my leadership is extremely weak. The only times I have seen strong leadership and fast work is in agency/consultancy work and military.
- Pfhreak 8y agoI throw in strong peers as my third axis. One point in my career I've had strong leadership, strong peers, and challenging fast work. It was amazing. Then we re-org'd, and I'm still looking for that combination somewhere.
- brekelma 8y agoSurvey of users on a job search site shows high proportion of immediate job searchers... selection bias much?
- filmgirlcw 8y agoIn the past, giant stock grants could convince people to stay sans a raise/promotion, but with vesting periods increasing or being staggered and an understandable uncertainty in sustained stock growth (you could do really well or not, depending on when your shares are purchased), it’s totally understandable that someone would leave for another company to get a pay raise or promotion. Boomerang employment is super common too (you don’t get your promotion/level bump so you go to competitor X who hires you at s higher level and salary. You do your 2 years and then return to company Y at a higher level/better salary, in less time than it would take to earn a promotion using the system.). I don’t know if this is sustainable — but I don’t fault anyone who does this or thinks about it. And because it’s so common, it’s not like it looks bad on a resume, because loyalty isn’t valued the same way anyway.
- hateful 8y agoIt's so sad this is the case, but it is the case. In a job I've always gotten 1.5-3% raises, and 10% for promotions. Switching jobs I've gotten up to a 75% increase each time.
- Maro 8y agoI've had 3 jobs in the past 6 years (5 in 10). So I spend about 2 years/gig on average. Reasons: 1. Learning. I find that I learn 80-90% of what I will learn at a company in the first 12-18 months. Staying at a job for too long is risky because I will miss out on new things happening in my area. In the long term this is the most important, because this is what will get me more money, and make me competitive/valuable. Example: it's hard for people in traditional data roles to do ML/DL without switching jobs. 2. I prefer dynamic equilibrium over static equilibrium. I very strongly prefer being able to go out and get a good job at any time over having a "cozy job". The only way to be good at getting a job is having practice at it. 3. Impact. I find that I deliver most of my impact on the job in the first 2 years, after that it levels off and I tend to do more maintenance stuff of all the things I've built (both systems and teams). 4. More money. This is almost a side-effect of 1-3. But also in itself: if I want to get more money in my current job, it's partially up to me, but it's also up to my manager and the company/culture. If I get unlucky with my manager/company, I'm not going to get it. Also, sometimes I hit a glass ceiling, and there's simply nowhere to go (eg. I'm already the Head/Director whatever, but the company isn't that successful and/or/but pay levels aren't that high). On the other hand, switching jobs is entirely up to me: if I am good at what I do and have a good track record to prove it, practice interviewing to be good at it, and play the numbers game (apply to lots of companies), I will succeed at finding a higher paying job. Overall: 1. I have to be ruthless and watch out for my own interests. Nobody else will. The world doesn't owe me anything, I have to go out, work for it, make smart decisions and then pluck the rewards myself. 2. I don't think this is unfair towards companies. If a company/org is badly run, people leaving is valuable feedback. Assuming a company can hire good new people, those will deliver new impact, bring new knowledge, etc. Having said that, there are companies where you can work and make more and more money (usually stock options play a big role here), and keep learn more and more (because the company is growing like crazy). These are the startups that are run well and are rocket ships (the FAANGs were like this).
- notyouravgdoge 8y agoDoes switching jobs so often raise any red flags when you interview?
- wordpressdev 8y agoMost companies in my part of the world opt to hire a new employee on higher salary than given raise to existing person. Can't fathom the logic.
- nunobrito 8y agoThe only way to get a proper raise is changing companies. Promotions tend to take years and are often more political than technical. I've seen often that a company prefers to hire someone techie from the outside rather than promoting internally. It is just the way it is. When the already hired engineers see this kind of thing, it is not surprising that morale gets low and churn gets high.
- Gravityloss 8y agoA cynic would assume it's just companies that produce low value, have low value (compared to cost) employees but are VC money pumped. This cycle will continue until there's an economic down turn and a large portion of those companies will go bankrupt.
- menor 8y agoNailed it ;)
- eecsninja 8y agoSo what happens when you stay at your current job because you've just stopped caring for any of the software work out there? It's easier just to stay with your current company than to have to incur the costs of changing to a new environment and having to learn a new way of doing things. I'm not sure if at this point in my career, it really makes a difference in the big picture of my life to get a 20% raise.
- Dowwie 8y agoDon't accept the counter offer.
- ImprovedSilence 8y agocare to explain why?
- ddebernardy 8y agoI'm not the OP, but can offer two reasons: 1. You'll be labeled as disloyal. Which is euphemism for: someone at HR is already looking into replacing you. 2. Whatever problems prompted you to want to go away are still there. Similarly, never offer a counter-offer as a manager. Because: 1. You don't want to send the message to others that it's a valid way to get a raise. 2. Whatever problems prompted them to want to go away are still there. There reportedly are exceptions when things work out on both sides of the fence. But in almost 20 years, I've yet to see one first hand.
- commandlinefan 8y ago> someone at HR is already looking into replacing you. Well, not that I disagree that accepting a counter offer is a bad idea, I'm pretty sure that someone at HR is always looking into replacing you, all the time.
- Latteland 8y agoI don't think that hr is looking to replace people, because it's way too hard to hire. At my company every new hire looks like a magical lucky serendipitous event. Hiring is just that hard. HR grudlingly matches people's other offers. They are too exhausted to look for someone to replace their existing employees.
- Ancalagon 8y agoI used to be the same way, but companies are legitimately having such a hard time hiring they're frantic to keep their employees and, at least at mine, are offering significant raises to stay and keep competitors at bay.
- baby23 8y agoHaving worked at a large corporation I can say that I found the reward system completely random. It’s really difficult, if your not part of the team to figure out how much work and value people are adding. It makes it ripe for gaming the system.
- dawhizkid 8y agoI feel like I've reached a point where I've moved jobs a little too often (avg 1.5 yrs last 3 jobs)
- Latteland 8y ago2 years seems to be the minimum, and it's almost how linked in computes it that matters. In west cost tech companies, 2 years raises no red flags. so if you can get your average to that, or at a minimum your current job is at least 2 years no one will car.