4 ms·
I feel like I'm missing some context here; why is FT8 controversial in the first place?
by zokier 8y ago
I feel like I'm missing some context here; why is FT8 controversial in the first place?
- joezydeco 8y agoI'd just like someone to de-jargonize the whole article.
- Custardian 8y agoGlobal communication in amateur radio was previously only been possible using high power transmissions (which requires a full license). FT8 makes global communication achievable for beginner amateur radio folk. Some amateur radio practitioners think if you want global communications without learning radio theory, use your ISP or SIM provider.
- someguydave 8y agoBut knowing “radio theory” isn’t enough to have global SSB conversations on HF. You need a high antenna and reasonably high power, something which most of the population will never be able to have because of how harshly antennas are judged by others in the real estate market.
- VLM 8y agoHam radio is an incredibly large hobby much like model railroading or warhammer40K or photography or RC aircraft or sex or ... computer programming. Similar to every other area of human activity thats ever existed and ever will, tiny sub-group Z will always trash talk everyone doing sub-group A thru Y as not enjoying the model railroading hobby the 'correct' way or not using the 'correct' editor/IDE or not doing the correct thing in the bedroom or whatevs. So its discussing the usual collision of "whoa this new activity (fad?) is becoming super popular outta no where" with the usual "What I've been doing for 50 years is the only correct way to do it" There's nothing inherently wrong or bad or incorrect about SSB analog voice modulation on wavelengths near 80 meters; but you can't expect life long aficionados of that particular sub-group to be excited about some rapidly growing subgroup they're not interested in. So thats the "FT8 is killing ham radio" Now as for why any of this matters, the analog HF SSB crowd has cornered the national USA hobby club such that QST magazine etc promotes 80M SSB operation in the USA as being the "only real ham radio" and then the usual political fallout and drama.