6 ms·
This article is entirely plausible to me. I have dealt with two relatives with brain tumors. Between disease and treatment, I have seen some incredibly weird st
by wpietri 8y ago
This article is entirely plausible to me. I have dealt with two relatives with brain tumors. Between disease and treatment, I have seen some incredibly weird stuff. It makes me realize how little we understand how minds work.
The best analogy I have is to think of your smartphone from the perspective of a normal user. You're used to it working fine. But suddenly it stops working fine. So a technical friend hooks up a cable and turns on debug logging and all you see is a wall of gobbledygook. [1] You ask what's going on and he starts describing an enormously complicated array of components and systems, and explains that he doesn't really know how most of them work, and that there are a bunch he probably hasn't even found yet. He can try this and that and the problem maybe gets better and maybe gets worse. You're forced to realize that the phone you trusted and thought you understood is beyond your ready comprehension.
Even that analogy fails in that a) minds are much more complicated, b) they aren't designed, so there's no expectation that they should make sense under the hood, and c) you cannot buy a new brain. If it's broken, well, maybe it'll get better and maybe you'll just have to get used to it being kind of broken and be grateful it works at all.
[1] https://logmatic.io/blog/a-how-to-guide-to-debugging-with-android-logcat/ https://logmatic.io/blog/a-how-to-guide-to-debugging-with-an...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bigtones 8y agoAlso brains can remap themselves over time so if pathways are broken, sometimes new pathways can be built.
- sannee 8y agoIt's effectively biological version of fuckit.py [1] [1] - https://github.com/ajalt/fuckitpy https://github.com/ajalt/fuckitpy
- tormeh 8y agoSounds like shellscript.
- cestith 8y agoIANA neuroscientist, but it also seems that the brain has favored pathways and will follow alternates and recall alternate information sometimes if a primary skill or memory is unavailable. This woman was already fluent in both languages and fell back to German. Other cases have had people show greater skill with a foreign language than they had realized they possessed before the injury, and as they healed their primary language came back and their conscious skills with the other faded.
- DelightOne 8y agoThe most important: Theres no documentation saying how it works, its not modularized, whatever bastard got the idea to create such a system... nice, clean, elegant and consistent abstractions and APIs, please!
- epicide 8y agoThe idea of a brain API is both amazing and terrifying.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- meijer 8y agoOne could argue that such an API exists. It even understands natural language!
- Koshkin 8y ago... and then does the opposite of what it’s told.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- RIMR 8y agoIt's an API. Nobody said the purpose was for it to do as it's told. It accepts input and responds according to its own training. Disobedience is a feature.
- DelightOne 8y agoYou can argue everything is a feature since the architect isn‘t around to contradict you. ;)
- sh33mp 8y ago
- hobls 8y agoAbsolutely agreed. Brains are bizarre. My mother-in-law once had what we (and her primary physician) believed was a serious flu. The moment we realized that it was much worse than that was when she started calmly speaking total nonsense. She appeared to think it was normal English, but each word was unintelligible, though it used plausible parts of speech. At that moment I picked her up and drove her to the E.R., after which she spent several days fighting meningitis. She came out of it okay, thankfully, but I still vividly remember how scary it was to watch her "talk."
- post_break 8y agoReminds me of the heavy bertations news caster. She knew what she was trying to say but it was coming out as jibberish and the scary thing is that her brain still recognized the fact that she wasn’t making sense. One of those things that scares me.
- wpietri 8y agoWhich reminds me, I should mention that for anybody with an elderly relative who experiences a sudden decline in the direction of delirium or dementia: make sure they don't have a urinary tract infection. I have no idea how that plumbing is connected, but I have seen it happen myself, and apparently it's a not-uncommon experience for people with Alzheimer's: https://www.alzheimers.net/2014-04-03/connection-between-utis-and-dementia/ https://www.alzheimers.net/2014-04-03/connection-between-uti... And yes, it is entirely freaky when somebody you have known for years starts talking utter gibberish and clearly expects to be understood. It feels deeply unreal.
- dcminter 8y agoOr indeed other infections. As it was explained to me, elderly people sometimes can't get a fever so the first sign something is wrong can be confusion and other odd behaviour. In the case of my late mother, it manifested as a fixation on and paranoia about money. Definitely one to bear in mind.
- copperx 8y agoTalking gibberish is also one of the first symptoms of stroke, but that's well-known.
- cestith 8y agoIf you search around the 'net you'll find a number of cases in which a person's principle language has changed after a traumatic brain injury. Some people have even become fluent in a language they only recalled a pidgin vocabulary from before. Perhaps more common, but still quite rare at about one person per year worldwide, is something called foreign accent syndrome. In which a head injury causes someone with one regional accent to speak the same language with a different accent afterward, often resembling the accent of another region. Examples have included from US to British, US to French, an Oregon woman developed an Australian one, etc. Sensory changes, changes in personality, and other things can happen with stroke or accidental brain trauma, too. One particularly interesting case is hinted at in this article, but if you're interested your favorite search engine should turn up many more cases.: https://www.thecut.com/2016/10/the-boy-who-came-out-of-a-coma-speaking-a-whole-new-language.html https://www.thecut.com/2016/10/the-boy-who-came-out-of-a-com...
- zn02 8y ago> Some people have even become fluent in a language they only recalled a pidgin vocabulary from before. I wonder if could use this to learn languages more effectively. This kind of changes after a trauma shows that we remember more than we think.
- posterboy 8y agoWe actively inhibit mixing the different parts of language we know. You can just as well remember actively without destroying another part. What's damaged in most examples here is production, not recollection, anyhow. It helps to talk to people who do not understand your native tongue to actively inhibit production in it.
- jimbobjim 8y agoCorrect me if I’m wrong, but I don’t think there are any cases of people with brain injuries speaking languages they couldn’t speak before. And any foreign accent is a case of someone’s speech becoming distorted and coincidentally sounding similar to another accent.
- Waterluvian 8y agoMy mental model is that the brain is a black box and unlike so many other human components, we can't break it open and learn how it works on a mechanical level. We're left with feeding it inputs and seeing what the outputs are as a way to understand how it works. This means that at best we can have a cause-effect understanding of the brain. Until we can describe the mechanics of the brain with a strong enough model where the resulting behaviours can be predicted, we can't truly understand what the brain is doing.
- posterboy 8y agoThat's a false dilemma. It is the same with any process. On a functional level, input output correlation is defining. On a mechanical level, we may recognize a structure equal to another black box. Indeed, dividing a structure into separate components is the key technique of learning. The problem is just how highly complex the brain is and that the "output" here is rather different from that of a blood cell or a dna strand. In fact, being based on and perhaps even interacting with those and other building blocks, is what makes the brain so abstract. So speech modeled as the output of dna is necessairly higher up the chain of abstraction than a microscopic ribose enzyme or what. But it appears to as us macro precisely because we don't understand all of it. You have effect and cause reversed. If we knew where to look better, it wouldn't be a problem. Chances are experts know way better, but there are really few who know enough to see a bigger picture and can guide the search. I'm trying to say they are breaking it open, inserting probes and imaging it working. But as far as the "output" is concerned, everyone is naturally aspiring to be an expert. A lot of unguided superficial theorizing may be informative as well, to great length as it concerns psychology and related fields.
- gspetr 8y ago> b) they aren't designed It does seem like a reasonable statement, but when you take a bit of time to think about it, billions of people disagree with it. A sobering thought. > so there's no expectation that they should make sense under the hood What doesn't make sense is that at first you deny a religious explanation, then without skipping a beat you ascribe (what can ironically be described as divine) mysteriousness and inscrutability to a body organ. This not only doesn't pass the Occam's razor test, but also assumes a defeatist position that "we might never know for sure". EDIT: I've taken uncharitable tone with this comment, and it may come across as too personal, which wasn't my intention.
- novaleaf 8y agoactually, if you believe in natural evolution, brains are designed. just because there isn't any intelligence involved, doesn't mean that the brain isn't a meticulously crafted piece of perfection.
- RIMR 8y agoOur brains evolved by having the features needed to keep us alive long enough to reproduce. Ultimately we, as a species, designed our own brain.
- Baeocystin 8y agoHydrogen, given long enough, starts to wonder where it came from, and where it is going.
- abstractbeliefs 8y agoIt's probably not, though. Evolution doesn't select for perfection, and many aspects of our evolutionary derived bodies are frankly bizarre. Take the eye as an example. There's no need for us to have a blind spot. Octopus have eyes almost identical in design, but without a blind spot - convergent evolution meant that both species ended up developing very similar eyes but with one crucial difference: in humans, the retina is wired the wrong way round. The retina is like a huge array of light detecting cells. In octopus, these cells are connected to the optic nerve on the back side. In humans, they connect on the front side. The blind spot in humans is because of the need for a hole in the retina for the optic nerve to pass through and split and connect to the retina proper.
- p1esk 8y agominds are much more complicated It's actually not clear if brains are more complicated to understand than modern smartphones. Modern smartphones are designed using numerous abstraction levels - it makes it easier to design, but harder to understand if you don't know those abstractions. Brain, on the other hand, might have fewer fundamental algorithms/methods. In fact, most of the brain complexity could just be evolutionary quirks, some to make to make it's slightly more efficient, others to make some biological functions easier, etc. In the end, it might turn out that the actual human intelligence is not that hard to understand once we got through understanding all those design quirks. This might sound ridiculous - after all a human brain looks so much more complex than an iPhone! But if you didn't know anything about transistors, analog circuit design, digital logic design, computer architecture, OS architecture, and software engineering (not to mention the complexity of cellular protocols), you would have a really hard time reverse engineering a smartphone.
- RIMR 8y agoI think you hit the nail on the head here. The brain is perfectly understandable, it's just that we need to learn to understand more things about it before we get there. We designed everything in a smartphone and can say with confidence that it works a certain way, and even explain why. The brain was designed by evolution, and while we mostly understand what it does, we aren't quite sure of the how and why yet.
- shkkmo 8y ago> The brain is perfectly understandable, it's just that we need to learn to understand more things about it before we get there. Perhaps. While the mobile phone might be more complicated than the human brain (I suspect not), that doesn't mean that the human brain is perfectly understandable. The smartphone was designed by a large number of groups that all built and shared abstractions with the express purpose of these being understandable by other groups. The smart phone's design is purposely built to be comprehensible to the human mind. There is no clear reason to expect that there are clean, human friendly abstractions we can make about all the different layers on which the brain inter-operates. To analogize to software, it may be like the difference between diving into well documented code that has: clean separation of concerns, standard libraries and design patterns, hardware agnostic implementation, a modern programming language vs code that was coded by a self-taught developer using design patterns that they made up, employs no separation of concerns and relies on hardware timing and interference quirks. The former may have far more complicated functionality, but still be easier to understand and reason about than the latter because the former was designed to be easy to understand.
- tcbawo 8y agoSomeone I know had a father-in-law with brain cancer that destroyed his ability to speak -- but he could still sing. So, that's how he communicated up until the end.
- the_clarence 8y agoMakes me think of that buffy episode where they all suddenly sing
- posterboy 8y agoSo, is tonal language a basic layer below ..?
- WalterSear 8y agoSinging recruits different parts of the brain.
- hanniabu 8y agoThis is similar to Ozzy Osbourne where he stutters when speaking normally, but has no issues when singing. I've seen reports of this situation with many people.
- qubax 8y agoIf you are interested in the brain, there are good royal institute lectures on youtube. The Neuroscience of Consciousness – with Anil Seth https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xRel1JKOEbI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xRel1JKOEbI The Neuroscience of Memory - Eleanor Maguire https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gdzmNwTLakg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gdzmNwTLakg Also, any book by oliver sacks is great if you'd rather read books rather than watch lectures.