5 ms·
Great, another feature that is probably useful for <1% of websites but will likely be used for anti-user functionality like tracking and surveillance more than
by userbinator 8y ago
Great, another feature that is probably useful for <1% of websites but will likely be used for anti-user functionality like tracking and surveillance more than that.
Maybe I'm just old, but I find this trend of exposing more to the outside over the network quite disturbing, and it's also becoming rare for me to be joyful about a new version of software instead of "what did they break or bloat this time"... the Web was far more pleasant when it was about hyperlinked documents and not this cloud-computing-inspired frenzy.
- matt4077 8y agoIf you don't use these capabilities, they probably amount to less than a Megabyte increase in the file size of the binary, and the potential that you could be shown a dialog when a website asks for permission. I fail to see how this might significantly cramp your lifestyle, or what this has to do with cloud computing. (You can even disable these functions globally. Or at least that's what you can currently do with similar APIs like MIDI device access. (And btw: Did MIDI device access ever get you profiled by the CIA?))
- ptero 8y ago> potential that you could be shown a dialog when a website asks for permission First, I suspect that this is in itself annoying to many users (it is to me). Next, even at 1% of accidental clicks it would give out large unintended access. A cynical part of me says that if technology shows tracking benefits it would switch to "accept once, reject every time" and many users would be tempted to click on it just to make those annoying popups go away. The main beneficiaries of this misfeature are advertisers.
- onion2k 8y agothe Web was far more pleasant when it was about hyperlinked documents and not this cloud-computing-inspired frenzy It was also a lot less useful though, as it was mostly about consumption. All of the creating happened elsewhere. People made things on their computer in other apps and then published them to the web. Now though, the web platform is shifting towards being a creative place in itself. People can make and share things entirely within a browser. I'd think that's a significant positive change.
- userbinator 8y agoPeople can make and share things entirely within a browser. I'd think that's a significant positive change. Forums and blogs don't count? Those were present long before this "turn browser into OS" trend started.
- onion2k 8y agoForums and blogs don't count? I've been making web things for a long time. When the grandparent posted "when it was about hyperlinked documents" I took that to mean "When we wrote things for Mosaic". Forums didn't really exist on the web back then. I'd say that comments, forums, etc were one of the first creative tools. We've come a long way since then, but there's much more to do, and it's all very exciting. It's definitely making the web better IMO.
- pdkl95 8y ago> I've been making web things for a long time. I've been making internet things since before the "web" existed. > Forums didn't really exist on the web back then Gopher didn't really have the necessary interactivity, but nobody cared at the time because if you wanted to talk about something in a global forum, you used NNTP (or email lists). The web (HTML+HTTP) had comment/forums/etc from the very beginning, because it was designed with IBM 3270 style form submission features (<form>/<input> tags and HTTP POST). I used these (and other interactive features) regularly in text browsers over my 2400 baud modem. Even if I had better bandwidth, there was no way I could run NCSA Mosaic in the 4MB of RAM installed on my 386DX. Yes, it was slow, but submitting comments only required special support by the server, which then returned a new hypertext document to the client. The feature that arrived later was Javascript, allowing some features to be done directly on the client. However, this was not a necessary required for writing forums software; that always worked as server side software. Shoving everything into the client didn't create many new opportunities; a lot of that existed already in separate software. What did happen is we attached everything to the same single point of failure and created a lot of security problems because risk is transitive.
- blitmap 8y agoI definitely see the potential for harm in this, but I'm excited to program arduinos from a web ide with a statically-served text editor + toolchain. Personally I switched to Firefox. The ideology is only minimally better, but I'd sooner trust Mozilla to ask my permission to use a new web api.
- IshKebab 8y agoThere are already tons of features that are only useful for <1% of websites. You can't deny that this is useful though - this is one of the things that makes the physical web actually plausible. Combined with Android's support for bluetooth beacons you can now have this feature, with no additional software installation required: 1. You walk up to a device. 2. A notification appears on your phone saying you are near it. 3. You tap the notification. It takes you to a website that lets you connect to the device via BLE. 4. You interact with the device via BLE. All without requiring network connectivity for the device (which is always a huge pain). You have to give permission for the website to access BLE. This is cool. You are just old.
- tomp 8y agoWhat are you going to do in a year when you get hundreds of these notifications per day?
- aquabeagle 8y agoI think Google tries to cram all this functionality (WebUSB, now Bluetooth) into Chrome because of the limitations of ChromeOS.
- shwetank 8y ago>the Web was far more pleasant when it was about hyperlinked documents and not this cloud-computing-inspired frenzy. The web was far more useful for you. I, for one, am glad the days of IE6 and the lot are over.
- laumars 8y agoI think the GP is talking about long before IE6 was a thing. Even back in the IE4 days there were web based games, HTML chat rooms, etc. I remember writing vast interactive 3D landscapes in VRML which were embedded into home page even as early as the late 90s (~4 years before IE6 was released). But aside VRML and other browser plugins the web was ostensibly just a network of hyperlinked documents. You'd make an action and get a fresh page. Make another action and get another fresh page. Sure it was primitive by today's standards but it wasn't possibly to do half the "evil" things we complain about today (user tracking, browser mining, etc) and there were still big social hubs like the Yahoo! portal too. What's more, because the barrier for entry as well as people's own expectations were that much lower it meant you saw a hell of a lot more individuality in the content posted. People would literally put a website up about their favourite designs of bridges, the shapes of snail shells, cartoon trivia no normal person should care about, or some local landmark. There were sites dedicated to the most mundane of things yet they were strangely fascinating topics because you get drawn into the topic through the obsession and wonder that drove the sites author to dedicate his on little piece of the web to it. These days the signal to noise ratio is so far tilted the other way with people obsessing too much about contributing what they think people want read or boasting about stuff they feel is boast-worthy that it almost completely drains out the purist content from people who just post stuff that genuinely interests themselves. This is compounded by the fact that the web has been gamified by some big names to encourage the kind of boastful content I described earlier because that feedback loop of posting content then waiting for "likes" and/or means more screen time which, in turn, means more eyeballs on adverts. The fact that everything is so bite-sized hardly helps either; Facebook statuses, Twitter "tweets", Instagram posts - they're all short, direct, "shots" of information. Fewer people engage in the longer process of having a page dedicated to a subject. Which means we lose a lot of detail, creativity and personality. The only good thing about the modern web is that while the barrier for entry writing a website has gone up, inversely the barrier for entry publishing content has gone down dramatically.